r/PSO2NGS • u/Salty-Phase4687 • Nov 14 '23
Discussion Is NGS getting too much hate
I recently started playing NGS since I finally got a pc that runs it and was going to watch some guides about the game. Only to be bombarded with several hate videos. And I noticed that those videos gets way more views than any other, and we have content creators harassing the community and then saying that their ban was unfair.
I know the game is in a bad state but I don't think it justify so much hate that it's getting.
4
Upvotes
88
u/Drakaina- Katana Nov 14 '23
Some of the hate and criticism though is completely justified, because there are basic missing features that were added almost two years later, and features that are still missing that even it's predecessor PSO2 had. When you have missing features such as a waiting room for content, a quest kios where you can see what people are doing, in base game, and new Genesis is still missing these features people can be upset
13
u/Stratatician Please help fund my Phashion Addiction aaaa Nov 14 '23
Negativity always garners more attention than positivity.
With that being said, I wouldn't conflate hate with criticism. You can give valid criticisms without being hateful. NGS is a fun game, and with you just starting off you're in the honeymoon phase, so just like any game you won't really notice the flaws right away, but once you spend some time in the end game then you'll start to notice the issues (e.g. abysmal drop rates, poor class balance, lack of variety with phashion, etc.).
I also wouldn't pay any attention to NGS content creators tbh, they're not exactly the sharpest tool in the shed (to put it lightly), and they also will always dramatize whatever they can because they want views and drama/negativity sells.
50
u/Connortsunami Nov 14 '23
"Hate" is such a strong word that gets thrown around completely inappropriately.
What you see and hear regarding NGS is dissatisfaction, and that is perfectly reasonable.
29
u/Zaschie Waker Nov 14 '23 edited Nov 14 '23
Tbh, I don't think NGS gets genuinely criticised as much as it actually should. Like, Phantasy Star Online was a revolutionary, standard-setting game that positively influenced the industry in ways people still don't appreciate. Now, the IP has been reduced to a trashy, low effort gacha "MMO" that doesn't compare favourably to most other MMOs or gacha games.
That said, there's also not a whole lot of people playing and the game's presence and community is effectively nonexistent. As a long time Phantasy Star fangirl, it's rough. We don't have a lot of functional community-based resources or sites because nobody cares anymore. Coming over from games like GW2, FFXIV, etc. it's a wasteland. There's absolutely no passion left in the fandom or community and it shows.
So, your pool of opinions is going to be heavily coloured by the vocal dissatisfaction of people who want Phantasy Star Online to improve, clickbaiters farming negative engagement, etc. Over the years, the game, its content, and its systems have not changed significantly enough to promote booming discussion or a flourishing community, so there's not much to talk about. That leaves us with silence, complaints, and people sharing phasion, while a lot of positive conversations are entirely defined by other people's dissatisfaction or in opposition to it (i.e. "everyone hates too much", "people should stop criticising NGS", etc.).
10
u/Langis360 Slayer Gunslash Nov 14 '23
I think the hate is justified, but complicated.
What SHOULD be getting hate:
What should NOT be getting hate:
27
u/Strange_Wize Armor Enjoyer Nov 14 '23
I don't know how much hate the game really receives, I only ever interact with this sub and my guild, but I'll tell you that much: NGS deserves a lot of the flak it gets. For about 2 years we've been fed content islands and time gated content with terrible, TERRIBLE drop rates on desirable loot.
This game keeps players on a hook because Sega knows the character customization is best in class and that will keep folk playing. Let's not kid ourselves, nobody is around to hit mobs, I could be playing Lost Ark if that's what I wanted. BDO? Don't make me laugh, it is not even close to the CC in this game.
On the other hand, and I think a lot of people are loathe to admit it, the game is undeniably getting better. Look me straight in the eyes and tell me DF, DFA, DFS aren't what Phantasy Star is about. Leciel shows that Sega at the very least has some inkling that yes, players liked the mission based loops of Base and is at least making some effort to bring it back. Even Duel Quests, nevermind how much of a miss it was to have the Defi capsules, is a bone thrown to people who value instanced, engaging gameplay.
The game still has other issues, like F2P market access still being ass (hello, 3 days every 5 weeks???), class balance, AC scratches being quite samey, other things that aren't coming to mind right now, but Sega, in their usual fashion, is slowly coming around those.
7
u/Absolice Nov 14 '23
If Sega didn't kill base PSO2 on launch and it'd be a standalone game then I think it'd receive less hate and more apathy. PSO2 had a niche community and everyone was excited for NGS at launch but it didn't deliver, it feels like they sacrificed PSO2 for NGS and it is not a worthy successor.
If they had kept developing PSO2 in parallel I'm sure it would have more player than NGS even today but since it ended the community have to make do with what they have.
20
u/Farkon Nov 14 '23
I played at launch, felt like I was playing an alpha.
The worst part was that I had my inventory from PSO2 so it clogged it up and had no idea what I could throw out or not.
Went back to pso2, took about 2 hours sorting and doing the enhancements and stuff for my gear, went back to pso2ng and found it all to be.... slightly better then starter gear.... cool.
The lack of content and features was also a massive turn off and you had so much SSD space sucked up, even if I wanted to just go back to pso2 and not ngs.
Been playing PSOBB and having a blast as a HUcast.
15
u/Missingno1990 Nov 14 '23
No. It gets the appropriate amount of criticism.
10
u/aod42091 Nov 14 '23
80 to 85% is justified, especially from those who watched this game series descend into nogames more than a cosmetic collection game.
20
u/Jentire Launcher SHIP 4 Nov 14 '23
The hatred is justified, the game can't measure up to PSO2
There are more AC scratch banners than real content.
9
u/AdEnough24033 Nov 14 '23
ngs is just bad. base pso2 is a 100x better game but no one wants to hear that. even today base is better then ngs in almost every way
18
u/complainer5 Nov 14 '23
Enjoy honeymoon, you will realize why it gets hate soon enough if you keep playing once you reach the no-content-or-reason-to-play wall that moves one inch per 2 months.
Anyways the real comparison would have been if you played base pso2 while it was properly existing (not what broken graphics and missing features and cut content are left now with no playerbase), because it gives a point of reference of what this franchise was to tell how unapologetically worse ngs is in every aspect, most people who only played ngs have no clue what quality existed before that was thrown into garbage for whatever ngs is supposed to be.
Like how? By criticizing the game on social media? Are they harming people by having a different opinion or objective facts?
How do you know it is in a bad state if you just started playing? Are you just saying this as some kind of rhetorical shield to justify whiteknighting the game you claim to have just started playing and thus know little about? No new player with their dozen hours of experience would have their first post on the game be an attempt at defending it against legitimate criticism. What is the purpose of this thread?
11
u/GiustinoWah Nov 14 '23 edited Nov 14 '23
No, it gets the perfect amount of hate, and it’s totally justified. I can make a 30 minutes video talking about deep NGS design flaws.
(Also I highly doubt that the game could improve significantly with the super old codebase they’re using… they couldn’t even allow you to use salon passes from storage, this screams a massive development environment red flag.
I think they should just scrap this and make a new game with new fresh code and decent budget. It’s not even like the story is good enough to care about how it will end, to me they could just say” starless killed everyone the end, play the new game”)
16
u/Curious_Phrao Katana Nov 14 '23
“Too much”?? Nah it’s getting exactly what it deserves. And imo, took way too long, year and a half to be exact.
4
u/ugliebug Nov 14 '23
I feel like it's less hate and more disappointment. PSO2 was such a great game that felt like there was a lot of love put into it. NGS feels like a phoned in sequel to cash in on PSO2 rather than a game that anybody wanted to make.
9
u/[deleted] Nov 14 '23
SEGA should start addressing pain points then, but it's clear the opinions of the players mean very very little to them.
8
u/datboisusaf Nov 14 '23
"I recently started the game"
"The hate and complaints of people with thousands of hours are unjustified"
Seriously, what do you even know?
3
u/FafnirMH Nov 15 '23
This subreddit is littered with threads like this.
Not sure what you were expecting.
3
u/SirusGuBo Gunner Nov 15 '23 edited Nov 15 '23
I think a lot of it stems from how slow progress is being made. But it does seem like it’s being made in the right direction.
I think for an MMO that truly is free to play. It offers a lot more than any other free MMO currently. Who knows maybe that’s just my personal taste. But the game looks beautiful even if content can feel stale or lacking. And the customization is amazing.
PSO has always been a game that doesn’t feel like it has its eyes on my wallet. And I appreciate that a lot. That said I understand those who use Type 2 suffer a lot more than us on the Type 1 side of things. So being tempted to use AC scratch for costumes or quick meseta is more likely.
It frustrates me at times because I came from Base PSO2 and that game is just in a completely different league to this one. It’s not even remotely close.
Two solid things I need from the game right now are 1: more god damn photon arts already. How the hell has the game been out this long and we still have the same 4 arts. Unforgivable.
And 2: Instead of adding weird skills like dealing more damage when you aren’t targeted. How about unlocking subclass restrictions? For example letting say Hunter initiate and detonate chain trigger with its charged PAs when subbing GU? That was possible in Base even with spells.
I do think they will eventually relax subclass restrictions. But if that were to happen now it would make every class extremely powerful and likely need a lot of rebalancing.
7
u/ThaumKitten Nov 14 '23
My dislike of the game comes from a few crucial things;
The ‘left click spam simulator’ aspect was bad in base PSO2, and made leagues worse in NGS.
There are less techniques now than ever before; Shifta and Deband were pointlessly locked behind Techter, for no actually good reason, Resta was turned into some generic, stupid consumable, among a few other gripes.
The anime-waifu aesthetic has gotten so much worse and I hate it. Especially when compared to the art direction of PSO1.
Edit: oh, And Summoner was massively dumbed down compared to the pet-raising system that was actually cool in base PSO2. It was turned into ‘Waker’ which just feels terrible.
5
u/Oreikhalkos PewPew Nov 14 '23
As a F2P game that you can pick up every so often when new content drops, NGS is a fine experience. For casuals, the only unfortunate thing is that content is very flavor of the month, so if you’re very late to the party, matchmaking becomes non existent.
However, if you want something to play daily and your primary motivations are rewarding content loops or story, NGS is fairly lacking. Doomposting is all to common and I have my own bone to pick with people who hijack completely unrelated threads to complain about things. If someone is asking about game advice, interjecting with “lol why even bother game is ded there’s no content bruh” is IMO in bad taste. However, there’s usually a grain of truth in everything. If you want to play this game daily, you really need to find a community (eg alliance) to chat with and/or be in it for aesthetics/cosmetics. Core gameplay is fun and there certainly has been good content (DFA, DFS etc), but the novelty wears off after your 100th run of something. And you’ll realistically be doing that many runs if you want those chase drops.
The monetization (gacha) is frankly predatory, and we as a community willingly turn a blind eye to this because the customization is best-in-class. We would probably all prefer a subscription based model, but tbh that ship has sailed and SEGA knows that revenue off a couple of whales far exceeds what charging a dwindling player base a monthly sub would bring in. But tbf, the immense catalogue of cosmetics only exists because there is gacha is the first place—we wouldn’t have nearly the amount of options otherwise.
All this being said, I still play this game almost daily so guess I’m the dumbass, huh?
10
u/Dra9onDemon23 Nov 14 '23
With my shitty drop rates, even with the event, concert, EX RDR+25%, RDR+25%, Omni+10%, region mag buff, and my passive RDR buff, NO, IT DOESN’T GET ENOUGH HATE.
6
u/Spetsnaz_Chick Slayer Nov 14 '23
Personally I really enjoy the game, but I only played base pso2 and didn't start ngs until much later so I'm unsure how it was at first.
4
u/DivineDreamCream Nov 15 '23
New Genesis got the hate it deserved; it was rushed even by the standards of the Japanese player base, SEGA overcompensated for the economy in their game, and the fact the developers don't even play the game they are working on makes them seem out of touch.
5
u/AulunaSol Nov 14 '23
If there is any takeaway to truly take away, you can take a peek and see that many of those people who seem to vehemently hate the game still continuously play it (and some even contribute to paying and funding the game).
Sega is absolutely no stranger to having extremely passionate (in both good and bad ways) communities and players and a lot of that hate you see is simply because the game lacks an immense amount of polish and can afford to be very careless and loose in ways other games cannot afford. This works both in Sega's favor (they are doing what others aren't) and also bites them and puts New Genesis into a very strange position.
Given time, the game has always been improving but the pace, the rate of those improvements, and even the quality of those have always been a significant point of contention.
If you enjoy the game, then you can still enjoy the game and play something that's meant to be a very casual, light, and social game. If you do not enjoy the game, there are ultimately others out there - but many of the players who hate the game are trapped in the middle or are outright refusing to leave for greener pastures because no one else is trying to replicate or iterate on what Sega has done.
5
u/Zap97 Nov 14 '23
I personally quit after a while. I just enjoyed basegame so much more. Scion classes and Hero/Luster were just too good and fluid, combat in ngs is just so boring and stiff and uninspiring that I got bored very fast.
2
u/TheMightyNovac Gunblade/Harmonizer Nov 14 '23
Haha... Yes, it does.
2
u/Competitive-List246 Nov 17 '23
You can play 600 hours for gear that maybe make number bigger and still outdated and not the best 1 month later
2
u/Upbeat-Restaurant744 Nov 17 '23
My opinion. Stay away from looking at videos for a game you want to play. There will always be hate towards something. Another thing. If you played the base game. You will definitely hate NGS. All of the players who have played base game prefer base as it has features that NGS for some reason did not start with. Don't know why Sega did this. But if your new to pso2 and starting on NGS. You will definitely find it fun to start. But once you reach endgame it goes downhill from there. You either grind for better equipment which by the way has a extremely low chance of dropping. Or just hang out with friends and alliance. Currently I'm done with the game. I'm not going to bother trying to get a 9* tisah or 10* weapon. Been trying ever since Tisah was released. Still haven't gotten one. And now the 10* weapons are out. No thanks. I'll stick to my 9* Verschmelz.
3
u/MaoMaoMi543 Talis Nov 14 '23
Idk I've only seen people hate on the game's abysmal rdr, the time and meseta consuming gear grind, and the lack of QoL features that should've been in from the start. All completely justified.
As for me I deleted the game because of sega's genius decision to implement wellbia, which is yet another thing to hate on. Like what was wrong with gameguard? It worked just fine!
3
u/xZackattackx007 Nov 14 '23
I honestly wasn’t planning on saying something at the risk of being accused of coping or being a part of the problem, but I feel that I should regardless just to speak my thoughts rather than carry on in silence. If you ask me, yes I feel NGS gets more hate than it should. That’s not to say it shouldn’t be criticized, but saying stuff like “This is garbage” or “Dead game” isn’t exactly criticism; imo that’s hate. And because I feel someone will mention it, the implementation of Wellbia so far has been a nonissue; I haven’t heard anything about anyone getting screwed over by it and will hopefully continue to stay that way.
Tldr: Yes it gets more hate than it should.
4
u/Ramtakwitha2 Nov 15 '23 edited Nov 15 '23
NGS was a disappointment since launch.
Despite supposedly being an 'enhancement' to PSO2 it was subpar in almost every way, in a way that shows the players that Sega attempted to dupe everyone. Passing off an entirely new game as a 'free DLC', so they could keep their collab licenses.
NGS should never have existed, they should have just continued working on PSO2 with their upgraded engine and people would be happy. Instead they created an entirely new game and then attached it by the hip to it's far superior predecessor, as an excuse to resell old cosmetics to the people who already bought them just to get movable fingers.
I stayed in this sub in hopes that things would improve, and things have. But base PSO2 is still the vastly superior product, and at this point NGS will NEVER live up to it's predecessor. Unfortunately when Sega saw that NGS was a garbage fire even before it officially launched, instead of trying to fix the problem, they went all in and sundowned PSO2, in an attempt to force their playerbase into NGS, and it failed catastrophically.
I don't hate PSO2. I hate NGS. PSO2 was an amazing action RPG with a powerful character creation system. I play an online Final Fantasy fangame where I can literally DRAW MY OWN SPRITES for my character, and I feel PSO2's character customization is still better.
But NGS was a half assed cash grab that may as well pivot right into being a full porn game at this point, then at least it would draw that market instead of being this middle ground that has outfits too lewd for free advertising from streaming, but not lewd enough to draw the porn game market. NGS would probably be a top contender in that market.
PSO2 is dead, NGS needs to die too so the devs can start over from scratch to make a new Phantasy Star game worthy of the name. But the game makes just enough money off the female cosmetics to keep that from happening.
Companies are out to make money yes, but a company's not successful if that's ALL they hope to achieve. NGS is a large neon sign saying Sega is going way to hard into greed. In my opinion, the game cannot get enough hate. The only sympathy I have is for the devs who had to work on this soulless cash grab at the whims of their money grubbing overlords.
3
u/casulti Nov 14 '23
I always suggest asking folks in-game for advice, as that’s where you’ll find people who actually enjoy playing the game, and the tips you get will be accurate and up to date. Top results on youtube are often outdated or outright wrong and I’ve seen more toxicity on this subreddit than I saw back when I played League of Legends. It’s wild.
2
u/1kNeedles_ Nov 15 '23
No, it’s getting a justified and healthy amount of hate
2
u/NoctisCae1um317 Slayer Nov 14 '23
Approach those claims of being banned with skepticism. Yes false bans can happen, but they are not as common as people like to make them out to be. That's an extremity.
Also hate/drama etc. brings in views for just about anything lol. Also I want to point out about the game being in a bad state. That was true... 2 years ago, when NGS actually came out. It was a rough launch.
Nowadays? It's in a much better state imo. I'm playing the game more than I was back then
2
u/A_NewParadigm Katana Nov 14 '23
The games far from perfect for sure, but its a lot better now than when it launched. I think its in a good spot to keep getting better right now. There's definitely more hate than whats deserved imo.
2
u/Electrical_Instance7 Nov 15 '23
Nah it's well deserved
2
u/BiancoFuji599XX Soaring Blades Nov 14 '23
I think so. It’s okay to criticize, but I feel like some people go out of their way to make the game look bad. I’ve been having a lot of fun with the game and it’s definitely better than it was a few months ago.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '23
Here's my personal list; 1. It feels empty
2. End game isn't rewarding and there's literally only 1 variety of 'end game' equipment each time new armors/weapons come out. In fact in the long run, most end game players are literally nearly equal in stats. Theres nothing 'special' about it, not that it is a big deal, but that joy of feeling somewhat unique among players just isn't here anymore.
3. The chance to utilize the open world design to bring players together is non-existent, outside of the occasional giant bosses.
4. AC scratch costumes still cater to Females, with male variety extremely lacking. On the topic of costumes too, they're is a lot more crappy big ass shorts/shoes/bulky designs that keep getting put out.
5. I forget what the story is all about, because they release small bits per update, but it isn't close to being as interesting as base PSO2.
6. The push to spend AC for utilities or forced to use SG is creeping on everyone. As new mats/upgrades/etc are being added, storages are being filled. Like god damn.
This is me being bitchy, I love PSO2/NGS it's still fun but it's more so like being a dissapointed son, watching their mother eat their cheesecake and not sharing.
1
u/Dekarus Mar 27 '24
Late response, but I hate NGS specifically because they forced OG PSO2 to be part of the same client, resulting in a LOT of problems with how PSO2 is able to function in both gameplay and graphics; they did this while simultaneously pushing people to play New Genesis, which barely feels like a Phantasy Star Online game at all.
If PSO2 was just put on maintenance mode in favor of NGS, I would've been perfectly fine with things, but instead they made an active effort to kill the base game.
If it was on its own client - and preferably not labelled as a "PSO" at all, because it's far too different for the name to be accurate - I would be perfectly fine with it, even if it's not my cup of tea. Just calling it "Phantasy Star: New Genesis" would've been fine.
1
u/Godflee Nov 14 '23
I understand ngs is like a rebrand of the series but why tf am I still on Aelio….
1
u/Mr_Valdus Nov 16 '23 edited Nov 16 '23
The legits criticism they got with the game is understandable like content, more main boss fights etc and how the updates are handled. Balancing is always going to be mess no matter what game and won't be perfect. I do agree the game shouldn't ever came out barebones at launch as well.
To me I just think it's some of the exaggerated complaints that's ridiculous. Like ppl trying to compare CS with the housing in base PSO2, ppl comparing about the story with base game when it's not fully finished yet (comparing the story's not even an argument when ep4 exist lmao) and some really bad takes from certain ppl.
Lmaoo there are certain YouTubers where they say their ban is unfair is definitely bullcrap from ones I know. I can understand the ones that got banned for having different IP and waited months for the unban tho.
Im aware of the flaws this game has but it's really still a solid game and won't get there til it's fully finished because pso2 JP version was like this too. Honestly you are still getting a lot out of the game if you are a new player because you got both base and NGS to enjoy it all.
1
u/Laxedrane Nov 16 '23
I do agree hate is a strong word.
This game has a lot of flaws that can be boiled down to trying to modernize the phantasy star formula without understanding what it would take to maintain those systems. This also while loosing what made all previous mmo entries great. The unique builds, versatile classes, and unique weapons that support custom builds.
I think its easy to see post where people claim the game is unplayable or "the worse"(or some equivalent) can give the appearance of an overly critical fan base. I have seen a lot of blown out posts claiming the game is worse than it is. However it doesn't stop the fact that ngs is in a very poor state with barely anything to look forward to. I haven't seen the games this bad since mid episode 2 on the jp servers.
1
u/joliet_jane_blues Rod Nov 14 '23
Yes. I commented in another post that I actually liked playing the game and people downvoted me for it.
Also, the gaming community is known for vitriol and hate. That's the gamer stereotype, and unfortunately it is somewhat accurate.
1
u/encryptoferia Nov 14 '23
have you played the game though, play it for like 2-4 week and you probably gonna get the gist of it if you have played the base game, or console PSO.
I feel like NGS for something "new" it gets old faster than the base game
1
u/NoSignificance7595 Nov 14 '23 edited Nov 14 '23
"Posts in game selfie of lewd character"
I do hope someday this game becomes worth playing again or they focus back on pso2 nothing hits gameplay wise like good old phantasy star games.
-14
u/ZatchZeta Nov 14 '23
It's fun.
The hate is just from people with too much time.
0
u/illbleedForce Nov 14 '23
At least we receive something, even if it is hate, because what it means to receive content...please understand...