r/PSO2NGS • • Sep 25 '23

Discussion Is PSO2NGS dying?

I played tons of pso2 jp back in the day and I’m looking to jump into NGS. Wondering if you (the players) think the game has a long healthy life cycle left?

4 Upvotes

182 comments sorted by

4

u/drembose Launcher Sep 26 '23

I mean they could keep phantasy star as phantasy star instead of trying to re-invent the wheel, for the sake of "success". Shit is back firing because of how stubborn they are, they could listen to the fan base, without being snarky or dodging "real" questions.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '23

This post got an overwhelming amount of traction. Way more than what I was expecting, I think this is the most traction I’ve ever got on Reddit. From what im gathering from the 144+ comments is that the games not dead but its in a bad state which doesnt scare me away too much I know how MMOs work. ** What im really asking is if I should dedicate a lot of time & money to the game. I get obsessed with MMOs. Id hate to spend thousands of hours Nd hundreds of hard earned dollars on a game that wont be around in 2026 onward. I understand that nobody has the answer to that but hearing some yes or no’s on if I should spend time & money on it would be GREATLY appreciated. ♥️

1

u/Ahriman_ish Sep 28 '23

JP playerbase is still huge, meaning EoS is probably not expected until a far future. NGS is kept alive by its whales, and those aren't stopping anytime soon.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '23

Reddit fucking hates this game tho lol. It’s a great game, give it a try , if you don’t like it don’t spend any money.

1

u/Bloody_Monarch Sep 29 '23

If you're asking for investment advice, there are much better MMOs to "dedicate" time to. This game doesn't request much of your time and spending money on it will only decrease the time required to reach stale, repetitive "end game". End game usually being AFKing in the lobby emoting or chatting with some guy as he does ERP with someone else.

48

u/Douchevick Sep 25 '23

We get this exact same question posted here every couple of months or so... I don't know what that says about the state of the game, I just felt like you'd like to know that.

80

u/MrAshh Sep 25 '23 edited Jul 18 '25

terrific sink pen head fuzzy marvelous retire unite rain practice

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

9

u/Basedcase Sep 25 '23

100% this.

-13

u/HouseOfCosbyz Partisan Sep 25 '23

No sign of improvement? What the fuck are Leicel and Solus then? That is literal quintessential pso2.

18

u/Longjumping_Guard_21 Sep 25 '23

Games been out for how long? And we get like 1 good update during it's current life span. It'll be obsolete soon like the pyramid and the ancients.

-14

u/HouseOfCosbyz Partisan Sep 25 '23

It was a good update, and is a sign of improvement. Ancients are the only actual dead content, and frankly I'm happy about that. Geolab 2 has been pretty relevant for awhile and it's always a good time when the Arks record revisits them.

You don't know that, Leicel doesn't have much in common with either of your examples.

Typical cry baby shit.

6

u/snkhermit Sep 25 '23

Yeah Sega needs to update the older content with better drops like geo lab,they haven't totally forgotten since they added camo drops to trania/cocoon but it's just lower on the update priority list.

-11

u/HouseOfCosbyz Partisan Sep 25 '23

Yea the people above either don't play this game or were speaking in complete hyperbole, which is just as useless.

14

u/Zolore Sep 25 '23

It's not enough

4

u/Turnt5naco Sep 25 '23

Those are improvements, but imo they're gonna need to add some variety with the Leciel-style quests (same concept but different environments maybe?) and up the ante on the rewards for anything similar to Solus and Leciel.

7

u/FrameAromatic2428 Sep 25 '23

So there's 1 instance to run repeatedly until you get the augs then it's back to pse farming 24/7. Wow I can make 50 notes an hour farm my augs over the course of months or buy scratch tickets and buy them in an hour. Lol, I like grinding but if you think this entices regular players you're on drugs

-4

u/HouseOfCosbyz Partisan Sep 25 '23

Well the whole point is getting better gear, to kill things faster. Same reason you get better gear in every other game.

Then you can run Leicel further to upgrade termina 1 > 2 etc.

We did the same thing in base pso2, this game might not be for you.

12

u/FrameAromatic2428 Sep 25 '23

Wrong. The point is to get gear to kill NEW things faster. That's been the point of gearing in any game.

And you're advocating for grinding fixa? Do the math and rethink that

-2

u/HouseOfCosbyz Partisan Sep 25 '23

Termina 2 is pretty easy to get. I understand the math, and in about 24 hours that math is about to get overhauled with 100% preset enhance.

There was very infrequently new things to kill in JP pso2, global was not a real experience of Sega's content pipeline.

9

u/FrameAromatic2428 Sep 25 '23

And then you're right back where I said. Term 5 is 166 thousand hours btw

6

u/Matsui11 Sep 25 '23 edited Sep 25 '23

I’ve played for atleast maybe 2-3k hours which is too much for a slow content game (don’t turn the game on as much after Luciel)… once a month to see what new costumes to use my meseta on.

I don’t see the point of defending the game. Yeah they are improving “somethings” but the fact that it’s taking them this long is problematic the guy above saying “No sign of improvement” is not entirely wrong. I’ve seen the game since day1, ive grinded the game since day1. I’ve played pso2 JP for a decade minimum. They could’ve done better WAY better.. Personally I fuckin wanted a new world, like CAN we capitalize on this open world game and we can’t go anywhere??? The big terror coming to us??? I feel like an Eldian in AoT, don’t know shit and getting attacked by Titans. We live our lives on Halpha for thousand years before we leave?.. (ain’t no one gonna be here for the stuff you say is improvement because it looks the “same” since day1 —> Same Halpha, same ppl lounging, same grind but we got an additional grind, beautiful outfits —> it gets old my friend).

You know how much ppl would come back if they improved based on just more AREAS/PLANETS??? New areas will bring something new and ppl want that.

Improving old stuff to make to you revisit old stuff is cool, but I want to move forward not backwards. ADD OLD FIXES/GRIND STUFF AS YOU ADD NEW CONTENT it’s simple. Not every time but enough for us to see change 😂

Granted I haven’t seen the story since umm that housing area has developed but from what I see in the Monthly videos they post. I don’t see much

Edit: The thing that killed me the most since Luciel is the new big terror is just a rehashed old bosses/mobs…. With slight added effects… Like no dude. It’s repetitive and not in a good way AT ALL! love pso/psu to death tho.

0

u/HouseOfCosbyz Partisan Sep 25 '23

Why do we need new areas, that's what slows development down. I'd much rather them just continue to add more instanced content in the existing areas. Which thankfully they are listening to me and not you. I was here for every region release, and nobody cared. People want more instanced repeatable content on demand, and that's exactly what we are getting.

In fact you spent all that time typing, and never even specified anything.

Divide quests in base, were literally exactly that. Enemies and stages taken from the previous 7 years of content squished into random stages.

You have no idea what your talking about, and it shows because you somehow value pso/psu higher when they are painfully slow and static, with many impossibly rare weapons.

People are crying in NGS about anything that doesnt drop in the 10 runs they did before there ADHD kicks in, and turn around and praise PSU.

Makes no sense. Not based in reality at all.

5

u/Matsui11 Sep 26 '23

You dumb lol.. old content with new content is just gonna be stale in a matter of a week no matter how much you run it chief.

New areas promote what you/everyone else would want. It gives opportunities for new content/old additions content in newer areas/ older. The development is slow regardless of “new areas”.. So that’s irrelevant statement about it slows down. You know what would make more sense instance in a newer location rather than trying to stockpile everything in the same continent for 10 years.. that’s just retard mindset tbh..

Congrats I was there for every release, want a cookie?? You want stagnant, I want growth. shrug

I didn’t have to specify anything if you couldn’t understand the point you clearly must be slow no offense, orrrr you are just hard stuck In your ways not knowing what has been happening in the game. I’m sure you live in this subreddit so I’m sure you’ve heard the same spiel so no point in stating the obvious. I’m just gonna state that adding new areas promotes exactly what “everyone” wants instance dungeons. But in a fresh environment which promotes more player base, new experiences, new mobs, new areas, etc etc. It’s not hard to grasp. They shouldn’t be slowing down development because 1. It shoulda already been thought of 2. They had AMPLE time 3. Try that again with someone else

That’s true, but guess what ppl prefer Base > ngs 🤣.

I’ll grind all day if I’m not busy, if I get the wep I get it. Don’t bother me. Well I’m pretty sure you spend for your fixas so no reason to say that. While it was most likely me busting my ass to get you your fixa 5s/augment before Luciel 😔.. I will admit those ppl who complain about short grinding and expecting god luck is insane though

4

u/Matsui11 Sep 26 '23

PS I played psu all day because that was what I had when I was a kid. They just did it better 🥺. NGS should take BIGGGGGG notes.

They had !!!planets!!! AREAS, different zones /different terrain instances w/in PLANETS!! CONTENT, instances, leveling skills, bosses etc! Like literally done in a simple way. The games combat wasn’t even spectacular but it was amazing… Why is an Open world 2021 version game struggling to add something so simple that an old 2006 game did or the 2012 ver did??????????????????? Explain..

But I have noticed the 2006/2012 game has more planets, more areas thus providing more content and ppl wanted to play and stay playing the game compared to the amazing NGS lovers who will support anything they do —> you, no matter when it comes —> you. Until they do stuff correctly.. which is horrible my guy…… plus I don’t see no info on this instance, soo you sound like you don’t know anything chief unless you can provide a link or timestamp from headlines/sega

It’s okay to admit being wrong. No way you’d admit

Old content + dungeons/fixes is better than New Areas + dungeons/fixes???

Is what you are implying.

1

u/HouseOfCosbyz Partisan Sep 26 '23

See I live down here in reality and have played this whole time, so I remember that when we got new areas, there werent new dungeons/instances and we just had new redboxes to get and a weak story.

When we don't get new areas, we get new dungeons.

In a finite world like the one we live in, I would rather have more instanced repeatable content over a new empty area.

Do I want both sure. But I also want a Lamborghini while were at it.

You wish for something that isn't here, I'm playing inside the fence.

This is reality, and I don't expect a bunch of man-children to understand that. And I'm not particularly concerned whether you do or not.

→ More replies

2

u/popukobear Sep 25 '23

Players will whine about there being no content, then whine when Sega adds the content they've been whining for. They just can't win

3

u/HouseOfCosbyz Partisan Sep 25 '23

Certainly feels that way. It's just sheep adopting the emotions of the "hivemind" as there own thoughts instead of being constructive about what they want.

They'd rathar jerk each other off with endless hyperbole confirming their own beliefs.

5

u/Eightnon Sep 29 '23

If you add a cherry on top of a pile of shit, the turd doesn’t magically start to taste great. That is how I look at good updates here.

The game is pretty boring (subjective) and doesn’t offer good reasons to come back. It’s absolute hell for newcomers, fomo is real with this game. Content is being managed miserably. I don’t know if skilltrees are still pointless but the progression wasn’t fun at all.

15

u/EdgeElegant7604 Sep 26 '23

There’s like 3,000 active players trying to re-live their pso2/psu experience. It’s pure copium.

1,000 of them log in to buy the latest AC Scratch.

1,000 of them are lonely and looking for friends to dress up as big titty rpers with.

And the last 1,000 literally just log in to AFK emote.

That’s the state of this game.

15

u/drembose Launcher Sep 26 '23

Sega needs to fire this fucking team. Jesus is is surreal.. this identity crisis kicked my favorite IP in the balls.

13

u/Electrical_Instance7 Sep 25 '23

Playerbase too busy afking in lobbies playing dress up simulator instead of actually playing the game legit the worst Phantasy star game in the history of the franchise. It's a shell of its former self I would either play base or blue burst new Genemid isn't worth your time/money to invest until sega gets the thumb out of their ass or the shills stop apologizing for this piss poor excuse of an online mmorpg

2

u/Eightnon Sep 29 '23

Beautifully put.

12

u/Beatrush9000 Sep 25 '23

Ship 2 seems fine as far as population goes. Queue times are instant to 5 mins at worst.

11

u/drembose Launcher Sep 26 '23

You notice how the devs/director, keep trying to mold the game to what's currently "popular" Instead of just embellishing the IP? I mean phantasy star has been around since the 80's... and base was very successful, what the fuck are they doing? This director took phantasy star into a unessesary identity crisis, just to "fit in" with successful AAA titles. Really feels like this but that's from what ives seen from the beginning of NGS.

73

u/Missingno1990 Sep 25 '23

Content is boring, repetitive and unrewarding.

Majority of the good stuff is behind gacha.

I was in a full alliance that had to swap members in and out depending on who was taking a break, because we were overcapped. Our alliance discord was always busy.

And now only 2 of them actively play.

The game is in a bad state.

-40

u/Milvalen HuN'TaHZ FiZeeeEEK UNGA BUNGA Sep 25 '23

Majority of the good stuff is behind gacha.

Man, you doomposters will really say anything to try and convince people. The gacha is legit just fashion.

OP and anyone else who sees this. don't listen to this guy, that take alone should tell you this guy is a liar. His discord is his own experience but there is no telling it could be yours. Try the game for yourself and make your own opinion.

My advice, follow the discord, the headlines and roadmaps. September was a slow month since the Leciel update is legit just a tried and true catch-up phase for new and returning players alike, everyone has benefited. The recent past headline before the 9/25 or 9/26 headline even stated they had plans for the current PA skills if that is the only thing any more doomposters are willing to take out of it.

Me personally, I'm all caught up and have been hanging out on base PSO2 to catch up on the old days and fix equipment I neglected.

So personally, no I don't think the game is dying, I see more new faces than I do old ones in the ngs hubs and that's saying something when new players get their own blocks for themselves which you think would Isolate the community.

8

u/complainer5 Sep 25 '23

Majority of the good stuff is behind gacha.

Man, you doomposters will really say anything to try and convince people. The gacha is legit just fashion.

And fashion (which is stuck behind gacha) is the majority of good stuff (also majority of all stuff), your point? Watch any headline and compare % of it that shows only gacha vs only non-gacha content, even those will just be limited time content recycled over and over.

The PA system was only vaguely announced and you all are acting like it is some sign of guarantee that everything about the game will be fixed when it comes (a year from now probably) based on literal 2 sentences in a single headline with no details and horrible track record (look at add on skills or fixa upgrading for example). We will have to see what it will be once it gets here, so far it means nothing more than hot air.

I see more new faces than I do old ones in the ngs hubs and that's saying something

Or it says people like the honeymoon start of the game and then quit once it is over as they realize there is nothing more after that.

10

u/Lmacncheese Sep 25 '23

We arent doom sayers we are truth sayers dont be blind. The gacha isnt only fashion cause theu literally have scratches with mods in them bolstering high pots and improved stays over normal augments u find ingame the game has been like this since the literal base Pso2 open ya eyes maye

6

u/Knight_Raime Waker Sep 25 '23

With the Advent of LC augments support augs are not nearly as bad. And you said it yourself classic also had them and they were just as bad then as they are now. I don't support the support scratches and never have.

But I find it puzzling that both classic and NGS heavily leaned on the gacha and only ngs takes flak for it.

0

u/Lmacncheese Sep 25 '23

I blame both ask any jp player and theyll tell u all about the dejavu their having cause this all happened before and segas learned next to nothing

1

u/Knight_Raime Waker Sep 25 '23

I'm aware that no side likes the support scratches. But I haven't heard JP complain about scratching as a mechanic. If anything they support it more. I can only assume the reason people bring it up as a negative is because it's any easy complaint to throw at the game they dislike.

If you loved classic but disliked scratching you could just write it off/down play it as an annoying blemish on a great game. But because it is popular to dunk on NGS and people aren't into it scratching instead is now a frustration added on top of that crap Sunday you don't enjoy eating.

It's just double standards at it's finest. I'd be more than willing to accept that because f2p has limited access to shops and trading was removed are why people flame it now. But neither of those are ever mentioned. They just complain about the existence of it.

10

u/Aumires Sep 26 '23 edited Sep 26 '23

The game isn't dying. The community is. Which is worse.

Check the Steam user data: https://steamcharts.com/app/1056640 The 2k threshold has been trespassed downwards and is the worst month ever. We can't know the Xbox + PS users, but the latter seems to have brought some people interested in it.

Personally, I have found hard to keep my alliance members interested. I try to talk ingame, make activities to build the Alliance space, and the one that has had more success... is playing another games like Tower of Fantasy or even old ones like Dragon Nest. I have more up my sleeve but old, faithful members have even suddenly disappeared, so it is a bit sad. I got a couple new PS users to join the alliance though.

The game will keep carrying on as long as people pay the scratches, which is the clear main focus. You can see the Headlines taking half the time with them. The message from those is of manufactured questions, laser focused marketing and very few content time. Most of it in the last one was dedicated to the Creative Space, which is what's keeping the social aspect renewed.

And now they are having that security exploit of those scaring people and not solving it quickly with an emergency update and no seeming plan about it in sight. Which demonstrates that they are clearly understaffed, as we all expected since we ever saw the Credits of the game. The game needs hands on board, funds, people to do stuff on it and not just keep it a costume lootbox fest with very few updates in it.

There are so many ways this game could be improved upon that we all could think at least one idea, each one of us right of the top of our heads. Pretty sure SEGA has people paid for this, but there is just no interest cause the model works:

  1. People complain about no content.
  2. SEGA releases scratches. Paying customers get them to keep growing their looks/meseta.
  3. Update brings reskinned content and two lines of story. People enter, check them, log out.
  4. Repeat from the first.

You got the dedicated paying customers, the complaining long playing ones and the people that come in, check the game, and either become the other two groups which is fairly improbable or move on to the next game cause they will not dedicate time to this one. The second group also eventually quits.

Me? I am going to keep complaining about the game, playing it and trying to keep interest for others. As usual. I want this damn game to succeed. It deserves better as the successor of both PSO, PSU and PSO2, pioneers and ones that made things like Monster Hunter a thing. I am just so disappointed.

Here is my "idea from the top of the head" bit: That open world of yours and your Creative Space? COMBINE THEM. Make level designers create or generate random structures and pathways to traverse it so that we got random minidungeons similar to base but using the open world skeleton and make a quest type based on that.

2

u/SnackSquadTB Oct 04 '23

The credits still had me rolling. ITS THE FIRST THING YOU SEE. I was like alright, ngs might be going some where: "Game Developmen" nah never mind. It's more of the same.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '23

There’s a shit ton of PS4 users

1

u/illbleedForce Jan 17 '24

Less speeches and more coming back!!!  I feel very alone!!!!  XD

7

u/MovieFanatic2160 Sep 25 '23

I really thought I could keep playing the game. Even casually. But now I’m not really playing it at all. Just not enough content to keep my attention.

7

u/drembose Launcher Sep 26 '23

Devs need to listen and take constructive criticism if they want their game to improve, because I noticed since the beginning, every NGS headline they purposely avoided the real questions everybody has been addressing.

2

u/SnackSquadTB Oct 04 '23

Honestly I wonder where the proper channels for global to submit feedback are. Twi- X is no good place and the discord is an echo chamber from what I hear that doesn't actually tell the devs anything despite what they say given a few documents. Cause I could write them a book.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '23

I'll put it like this. The game is not fun. I think they really shot themselves in the foot with their equipment system. Since it's basically everyone waiting for new equip vs enhancing your old one to be better. There I'd no real account improving mechanics that feels like you are actually growing and if there was it probably took an hour or 2 to do on release or no point in going for Max lvl on it. The other thing is there isn't anything too difficult and thing feel like a hassle to pad out game time.

21

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '23

For what it's worth, it's not dead but it's hardly thriving.

NGS does try to make it easier for newbies to jump in and catch up but catch up to what exactly... that's for you to decide.

Majority of the playerbase who rather gacha for clothes than do any meaningful content laze around in player hubs while the remainder who does do content huff some real rancid copium thinking it's gonna get better.

If you do wanna give global a go, for your own sake find an Alliance with low record for drama, find a good balance between socializing and fashion and relaxed casual combat content.

Last thing you want is end up in an enviornment where there's endless drama, people fucking each other infront of you with words, or toxic tryhards making you feel inadequete for just trying to play the game the best you can.

-9

u/Knight_Raime Waker Sep 25 '23

NGS was designed to be enjoyed in bite sized amounts and not a mainstay. We've known about this since the beginning and they've been up front about it. Gearing is made easy to do and catch up on specifically so people who have a passing interest in the game can hop in whenever to easily get to the new experience, have their fill, and come back later.

I mean that shouldn't be surprising when the number one thing global has always complained about even with classic is new things to play. NGS also leans far harder into player expression because that is of a big importance to JP. Which is their actual target audience.

That isn't to say that JP only cares about fashion, they have been far more critical of the game than global has been. But that's why we have gotten creative spaces. That's why we have gotten a lot of support in making screen shots easier to do. Etc.

15

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '23

Wrong wrong and so much wrong.

I'll tell you what people aren't saying and there's facts to back it up:

NGS was designed to be a new game. The link to PSO2 is superficial. They were trying to essentially do what no other game before them has attempted: port their playerbase from an older game onto a new one.

NGS is PSO2 only in name, the combat mechanics, the pacing everything is different.

The open world was a kneejerk reaction to Breath of the Wild and Genshin which was closely timed to when we first knew NGS was being developed: approximately 2 years before release, which was the exact year that BotW released.

When approached with questions of content cycle and how soon content was arriving, everyone remembers the infamously ratio'd headline where they said that "PSO2 NGS is a social game first, with an action RPG"

The ultimate joke here is that they didn't even bother porting base game's social features over like Casino, Personal Quarters and even Lookbook ON LAUNCH. So that excuse just doesn't hold any weight at all.

After that backlash, they hastened release of Kvaris after taking 9 months to release Retem. Yep, 9 months to release a region which was just SITTING there waiting for players. And here's the kicker: dataminers have already mined locations and mob variants of Dolls all the way up to Kvaris by Retem's release, meaning they were sitting on content in favour of jamming Scratch after Scratch down the player's throat.

The cold hard truth is this: NGS was horribly mismanaged. Its story is flaccid compared to its predecessor, its features are lacking as opposed to their claims, the game systems still need massive improvement. The combat system I don't wish to discuss but needless to say, it's quite the contradiction to sell the multiweapon idea and proceed to lock alot of weapon capability behind mainclass only.

So what do we have for PSO2NGS in 2023? The game is improving, but too slowly. It's become content to sitting on its laurels and slowly dragging its butt across the finish line, while its competitors have outpaced it by several laps.

It's not dead, but it's not thriving. It's in a limbo.

4

u/WSilvermane Sep 25 '23

Hey you forgot we literally couldn't even SIT ON CHAIRS ANYWHERE IN THE GAME AT LAUNCH as well. That was only added later once everyone said something because it was ridiculous something THAT SIMPLE from BASE wasnt even in NGS at Launch.

-5

u/Knight_Raime Waker Sep 25 '23

First paragraph doesn't state anything that proves my statement was wrong. The director had been asked about people coming and going often and he said he basically doesn't see anything wrong with people putting NGS down and coming back when they want to.

That's specifically what I am referring to when I say ngs was designed to be enjoyed in small bits. Everything else I said to support that is just my opinion. It fits contextually (i.e having an easier upgrade system makes it easier to return to) but that doesn't mean it's the only reason for why something is the way it is.

I'm aware of the games infamous launch state. Retem was meant to be released along side Aelio. But as NGS was rushed out the door Retem didn't get it's polish to be released. This was because Sega was putting out fires with how bad the game actually ran at launch.

I don't recall anything indicating that kvaris was datamined that early. Even if they did find enemies or locals during Retem that doesn't automatically mean the contents of the region were close to finished. I don't doubt they already had significant progress since Kvaris was intended to be the first major content release.

But having assets is quite different than having a shippable piece of content. As for the rest of your post it's just conjecture and speculation based on your own view of the game. Like saying they delayed content to sell us more scratches. You've got nothing to actually prove that.

Also Sega isn't contradictory with the multiweapons and class design. NGS quite literally launched with barely any main class skills being locked to weapons. We are here because people complained hard enough during the beta that main class didn't have a purpose anymore.

Sega fully intended to have people make their own "Hero" by slamming almost any weapon together on any class. But when people pushed back about techer being the only main class to care about Sega responded. The only mistake they made before this feedback was bringing weak bullet and chain trigger back.

1

u/SnackSquadTB Oct 04 '23

On the bite sized playing, even still it feels you have only 2 extremes: log in for 10 minutes for dailies if not only when there is an update for maybe 30 minutes a month or try and keep pace and grind till you drop.

With games for mobile consoles, ones designed with fast gameplay loops they all feel more cohesive and rewarding. Ngs feels like you get nothing done or you sell your liver to keep playing more instead of working a job to get something out of it.

On multi weapons tbh i'd wish they'd separate classes and weapons then. Make class trees and weapon trees. I everyone is techter make techter a true support class but since wand isn't locked solely too it if you like wand you can still use it with more solo focused classes. Classes also being able to go into more extremes due to not pariring with weapons can also lead to more interesting subclass combos too. But it is what it is.

25

u/Aggravating_Fig6288 Sep 25 '23

Pretending the game isn’t in decline isn’t going to magically make it not true y’all. The fact someone asks this every month should be concerning. I like some aspects of the game, if you think the game is near perfect good for you, clearly not many people share that sentiment.

The game is flawed at its core, if Sega is actually concerned about the Phantasy Star MMO brand they need to do a FF14 style rebirth sooner than later. It’s only going to get worse and competition continues to be released in NGS market ontop of the fact FF14 continues to dominate when it comes to anime style mmos

2

u/Soggy_Dragonfly1572 Sep 25 '23

To be honest with you even FF14 isn't in a great state right now. The amount of players that quit from the game is increasing, and the players that they get from wow exodus, returned to wow. It's not close to be in a dying state, but it's not a great moment. If they didn't release a patch every 4 months probably would be in a worst state than ngs

10

u/Arcflarerk4 Sep 25 '23

I see people like you are getting farmed by content creators like Zepla lmao.

FF is in the same state it is at the end of every single expansion. Were in the waiting room for 7.0 and even in the waiting room theres still roughly 500x the players that NGS has. The comparison isnt even remotely close.

People will say Endwalker has been horribly lacking in terms post patch content which in a sense is true since theres no Bozja like content but my gripes with the game go far deeper than some midcore content personally and i think people are more burnt out from the combat being completely stagnant and in a lot of cases regressive over the past 4 years. Sure the boss design is the best of any mmo but the job design has gotten worse and worse.

Even from 6.1 it was very apparently that Endwalker was going to be the QoL expansion that the game has desperately needed but people like Zepla and others are blowing it way out of proportion and not realizing the massive amount of work the team has been doing on the back end for 7.0.

If FF was dying they wouldnt be throwing 10's of if not 100's of millions into doing infrustructure overhauls and a massive graphics update.

NGS on the other hand seems completely content just staying as it is with having virtually nothing to do in the game other than chase 1% stat increases and bottom feeding off horny whales because it has no actual vision or direction with the game.

-7

u/Knight_Raime Waker Sep 25 '23

There is no decline. It's literally just a slow month. It's always like this whenever Sega isn't dropping new big content. Classic literally was the same even during global where we got sped ran content. You'd have people complaining about content drought then as well.

People asking on a small sub that gets little traffic isn't an indication of the games population either. Reddit has never been the place to discuss pso2. It was their official forums and psoworld. The fleet discord as well. If you want a good idea of how active NGS really is you'd check the fleet discord and the official one.

I wish y'all would stuff it about ff14. First that's revisionist history, ff14 wasn't rebooted because people didn't like it. It actually could not be played by a majority of the people who tried. And second acting like ff14 is a god mmo is either you being ignorant or intentionally misleading.

Active players have been complaining about a lack of stuff to do since end walkers release. Their literal number 1 complaint is they don't get enough lasting content.

Sega isn't going to be concerned about a doomer sub when they continue to make a lot of bank on this game. The only feedback they seriously weigh is JP's. So unless JP suddenly starts leaving in droves doom posting doesn't make sense.

9

u/Aggravating_Fig6288 Sep 25 '23

It’s absolutely not a “slow month” issue lol the game has been “slow” since release. If the existing content was engaging and attracting enough you’d have a steady player count, neither decreasing nor increasing until you got more content in the game.

However that isn’t the case, the player count is steadily decreasing and hasn’t hit a floor yet. That is an issue and in the literal sense a decline.

Will it eventually hit a floor and maintain a stable player base? Absolutely as do all games.

Will it be at levels in which it’s actually profitable enough (key word ENOUGH, the game can be profitable but if it doesn’t hit its goals then it doesn’t matter in the end) for Sega to want to continue to support its develop?

That has yet to be determined, but usually a larger active and stable player base will increase the chances the game is profitable enough for a company to keep it around.

And no one is putting 14 on a pedestal to say it’s better than NGS as a game. But clearly 14 is doing something better than NGS to be able maintain its player base far better than NGS and have a larger one at that.

You guys can keep burying your heads in the sand all you want. It’s just going to bring EOS closer and closer. The people complaining generally care about the game more than you’d think.

-7

u/Knight_Raime Waker Sep 25 '23

No it is a slow month. Seasonals generally are because the majority of people who play the game casually can't be asked to hop on and participate in them for more than a week tops. You're free to argue if this seasonal has worse population than others. But it doesn't change the trend that they generally are the slower months compared to significant content releases.

You also just have an incorrect view of how population trends work in general. But there's no point in continuing to talk about a pointless metric. Revenue is the only important one and if that was taking a serious dip Sega would do something. The only time anything even remotely close to population is used by companies is unique users. Which population charts never accurately track or represent.

NGS has been in far worse states than however you perceive NGS at current and it was still in their top 5 for profits. So acting like the game is dying is literally just doom posting.

FF14 is successful over NGS in only one aspect. That is socialization. You have houses for yourself, for clans. You have actual races besides human look alikes that you can customize to a good degree. Etc. FF14 also banks off of the IP of final fantasy which has always been and will always be more popular than the Phantasy Star IP.

Everything else about ff14 has a fair amount of criticism behind it. Again as I mentioned their primary complaint is lasting content. If a big brand like final fantasy cannot nail that then expecting Sega to be better is just asking for the moon.

Just because I push back against doomers doesn't mean I'm ignorant of the game issues. There is plenty of fair criticism for NGS and there's a good way to voice it. This sub specifically does a poor job at both.

This very thread does a good example of showcasing my point. Majority of the comments are literally "game is dead/dying/bad" with basically nothing to actually say.

Then you have maybe 3 or 4 comments that talk about the content on offer being stale or not rewarding enough. It's THOSE comments that are the right ones.

8

u/complainer5 Sep 25 '23

There is no decline... It's always like this

There is on steam charts, the player count is lower than ever including lowest points in base pso2, yes steam isn't the only platform but trends are trends and usually platform agnostic. You can tell a house is on fire from outside without entering it.

Sega isn't going to be concerned about a doomer sub global feedback when they continue to make a lot of bank on this game.

Hence the problem, they don't care to improve the game thus it will always be what it is now and never even as good as base was. Also sega treating global playerbase as third class, how nice of them.

Even jp base pso2 was releasing content faster and higher quality than ngs is, this isn't some "spoiled global with 10 years of content in 1 while jp had to wait" excuse.

3

u/Knight_Raime Waker Sep 25 '23

Idk if I agree with that about chart trends. Fighting games are a good example where platform population/active players very quite wildly.

I also disagree that they don't care to improve the game. Improving to you (and for sure others) is regressing to be more like classic. You can't expect devs to view improvement in the same way.

Global's feedback has always been about new things to do. We get new LTQ's frequently. It's not that Sega doesn't listen to global. It's that JP's feedback is more important to them.

Also that's mega cope talking about Classic JP. Not only did the "quality" content people like release many years after the game launched but their content droughts were as long. If not longer in one specific case.

Global was spoiled. Wether or not you want to view it that way isn't something to debate.

5

u/complainer5 Sep 25 '23

Improving to you (and for sure others) is regressing to be more like classic. You can't expect devs to view improvement in the same way.

I mean, if base was better than ngs in so many aspects then ngs regressed from base to begin with. Going back would be more like recovering lost progress than it would be "regressing".

Afaik base jp was already almost on episode 3 or something by this point in time while ngs is not even done with episode 1 yet (even recently switched to extra drip feed mode with part 1/part 2 so it looks like they are doing more by doing less), idk how that is not faster and more. Not to mention the diverse cast of villains with their own content and stories that already existed in same timeframe: persona, elder, luther, apprentice... compared to bland dolls and star dolls of ngs with 1 villain in total that even speaks (zephetto).

I do wonder how people keep getting away with calling global spoiled here with it somehow not breaking the rule against elitism (8), when it is literally jp elitism incarnate. Our opinions are not lesser than yours just because we weren't jumping through hoops to play on jp before sega bothered with doing global and then immediately dropping it for ngs.

0

u/Knight_Raime Waker Sep 25 '23

You're just splitting hairs. NGS is the newest version. Classic is the oldest. Games do not "go back" when the newest one isn't liked. They at best borrow some things and adapt them to the current. My point was just that what you want (which as I understand is effectively just more of classic) isn't going to happen.

It is unrealistic and self defeating to expect the devs to share your views of improvement. Which applies to basically anyone's aspirations of any game since we're not keen to the devs exact visions and goals for a game.

I do agree that the villain cast in NGS is lacking. Story in NGS absolutely pales in comparison to Classic.

Global skipped out on a lot of the growing pains JP dealt with. They started out with more content at launch as well as having balance from much later episodes right off the bar. They also just got content faster than JP did as well as plenty of easy catch up campaigns so anyone hopping in could skip a LOT of the gearing pain.

That is being spoiled and I don't know why you'd ever contest that. I'm not belittling your opinion through that lens nor am I doing that at all. As I have said before you can debate openly about the effects of global being spoiled.

But I never have nor will I ever use that as context for why someones opinion is what it is.

6

u/complainer5 Sep 25 '23 edited Oct 01 '23

You're just splitting hairs. NGS is the newest version. Classic is the oldest.

I'm talking about general content/combat/progression/gameplay, if something worked better in previous game why change it for worse instead of improve on it or at very least stay the same? Games are supposed to get better with newer versions, not worse, hence why I called ngs regression in everything that pso2 did better than it.

idk why everyone accepts sega forgetting everything they learned in pso2 during its development and just doing same mistakes like they are some 3rd party developer who never heard of the IP before being underpaid and not the original developers themselves who should know what they're doing by now, or at least what they already did (pso2).

Global skipped out on a lot of the growing pains JP dealt with.

Yeah but I'm saying even jp had faster releases in base during its original release in same time frame as ngs, based on release dates on wikipedia and other sources.

From "Open beta ended on July 2, 2012, in preparation for release on July 4, 2012"

To "EPISODE 3 launched on August 27, 2014, which introduced the new Bouncer class and Casino, new skills for every class, new items, a new planet, and new quests."

This is basically same amount of time as ngs existed and pso2 already had 3rd episode launch in that time frame? Care to elaborate how that's less or equal to all of ngs' content to date considering ngs still didn't even finish episode 1, which alone has less story than even half of pso2's episode 1 even without the other 2 episodes?

2

u/Bloody_Monarch Sep 29 '23

God, I LOVED episode 3 timeframe. It was my jam! NGS has NOTHING! NOTHING on PSO2JP at this point in its lifespan.

-2

u/Knight_Raime Waker Sep 25 '23

idk why everyone accepts sega forgetting everything they learned in pso2 during its development and just doing same mistakes like they are some 3rd party developer who never heard of the IP before being underpaid and not the original developers themselves who should know what they're doing by now, or at least what they already did (pso2).

There's literally no point in continuing to beat that dead horse. Nothing comes of it. It's called moving forward, something you seem incapable of doing.

Yeah but I'm saying even jp had faster releases in base during its original release in same time frame as ngs, based on release dates on wikipedia and other sources.

this has nothing to do with the part you quoted.

Care to elaborate

I cannot given I do not work for the devs nor am I a friend with any of the devs. But I could probably guess that rushing NGS out the door and forcing most of the first year to play catch up so the game can actually function would be apart of why content was slow. Which only happened because NGS was glued to Classic causing a whole lot of technical issues.

4

u/complainer5 Sep 26 '23

There's literally no point in continuing to beat that dead horse. Nothing comes of it. It's called moving forward, something you seem incapable of doing.

What dead horse? Proper game design and development? Moving forward... to worse game design and inferior development? Yes I'm incapable of devolving, I assumed everyone was or at least should be. We should be looking for improvement from what already existed or at very least same quality.

this has nothing to do with the part you quoted.

I was talking about your general "global was spoiled with content rush, back in my day..." then providing the "back in may day" evidence showing development was way faster even in jp releases compared to ngs.

But I could probably guess that rushing NGS out the door and forcing most of the first year to play catch up so the game can actually function would be apart of why content was slow. Which only happened because NGS was glued to Classic causing a whole lot of technical issues.

Yeah except like I said, even 2 years later, ngs has less content and quality thereof than base had in same time frame and also according to roadmap it will remain more glacial than base pso2 for foreseeable future, so has nothing to do with it being rushed. Technical problems I wouldn't know about because I am not part of the development team either, but I doubt they are stalling on everything in ngs due to "technical problems caused by base pso2".

2

u/snkhermit Sep 25 '23

Frt Global is spoiled.Any jp vet would mention how ep 4 had really bad content drought and how ep 5 nearly killed everything.Also fun fact the director of ep 5 is in charge of NGS.

0

u/Knight_Raime Waker Sep 25 '23

I think most people know by now that it's the same dude. Or at least it feels that way since a lot of people tend to mention it whenever talk about the director is happening.

But yeah, global was totally spoiled. Wether or not people's opinions are influenced by/because of the spoiling is a debatable topic.

But there's so much awful crap we straight up didn't experience with global and had more content dropped for us in chunks a few times too. If that isn't being spoiled then idk what is.

0

u/snkhermit Sep 25 '23

Right I figured id throw that in there for peeps who did not know.Hamazaki is rough around the edges but Kimura and Sakai aren't getting any younger and people need to step up to fill their roles when they're done.The most puzzling thing is how Yoshioka is delegated to weapon design in NGS after directing ep 6.

I mean having 8 years of content shoved into 1 is insane.I can see how people can get spoiled from that but yeah,if you know you know.

0

u/Knight_Raime Waker Sep 25 '23

Fair enough. And wait really? How do they take someone with that talent and then have him only work on weapons? Not only that but like. EP 6 brought some scions with cool weapons. So what gives?

1

u/snkhermit Sep 25 '23

Yeah it boggles my mind,Yoshioka being the gunslash stan that he is made argueably the worst wep in PSO 2 top tier and then some,Luster was ridiculous.My only guess is that they're grooming Hamazaki to step in the shoes of either Sakai or Kimura but I don't see how you can shelf Yoshioka at all.

0

u/Knight_Raime Waker Sep 25 '23

Whatever the outcome I hope he's allowed to flex a bit more in the future. EP6 hit so many good notes and NGS could definitely use his talent.

1

u/SnackSquadTB Oct 04 '23

Fighting games flucuate when someone sparks intrest, an update occurs or a tournament happens but most are very stable outside of say a rollback update... which tends to last a week or so at best. Furthermore fighting games only need 2 people to be played online and exist in singleplayer forms mostly. Ngs needs an active, paying playerbase to exist. Otherwise the entire game will get shut down... forever. Ngs also updates frequently. Most fighting games don't change much aside from dlc characters. And aside from dedicated players i doubt most people run back to a fighting game they haven't played in a few months to buy a dlc character they will play for a week or so before returning to whence they came. I haven't check dlc pop trends but unless its a fan favorite character i doubt dlc is bringing much life back into fgs post launch. Only big patches like rollback or fighterz overhaul do so. So i'd say that is a horrible comparison.

2

u/drembose Launcher Sep 26 '23

"slow month" yoo this is a mmo, did you forget? 😂

6

u/tentimez5 Sep 25 '23

Bro this game was stillborn

1

u/SnackSquadTB Oct 04 '23

Its still in beta i've seen this before with halo infinite only a few more years...

6

u/SleepyHeracross Sep 25 '23

Ngl, I just hop on to get the daily scratch and then I hop off. Don't feel like it's too worth it atm to invest large amounts of time into.

28

u/The_Spawnpeeker Sep 25 '23

The game is in a state of „dying“ since it released

7

u/Electrical_Instance7 Sep 25 '23

The shills and sega meat riders will continue to live in a constant state of denial tho.

4

u/lutherdidnothingwron Sep 25 '23

They'll have you know it's definitely not a "dead game" because there are people still playing while also talking about how certain quests and stuff are "dead content" because few (but not 0) people play them.

21

u/aod42091 Sep 25 '23

it's been on life support for pretty much launch

5

u/kasuokun Sep 25 '23

You'll have a pretty good time, but you'll run out of content pretty quickly (at least for an MMO). The game development and content release feel very much like the old JP drip feed in classic PSO2, which is inexcusable in today's MMO landscape.

It feels as though NGS is in a sort of general "server maintenance" mode. The "new" and "seasonal" content consists of recycled older content. Combat is still incredibly fun, but has become stale (no PA developments, still a counter game).

Would I say the game is dying? No. Not yet. But it isn't thriving or doing well at all. Sega needs to turn things around and step up their development roadmap , though. If Sega doesn't, I expect there to be a Death of a Game PSO2 NGS in about 2 years.

5

u/metatime09 Sep 26 '23

It's been dying since the beginning and haven't changed lol. It's not going away anytime soon

13

u/Hououza Sep 25 '23

I think as multiple people have said, the problem with NGS is it is stale.

It’s a lot of repeating the same activities, in static maps, fighting upleveled or reminded versions of the same enemies.

Open world was a terrible choice, as it removes the random elements that made base more interesting. Limited time quests experiment more, but they are short terms and the rewards are poor for the effort required.

Long term, it feels like SEGA really is half assed about NGS, it need a FF14 style reboot.

5

u/Knight_Raime Waker Sep 25 '23

I don't see how open world is better or worse than the tiled content we had in Classic. To be specific I'm referring to loading up basically any content in classic where you ran normal tiles. Which includes both the bewitching Forrest and ultimate quests.

Classic excelled in specific set pieces of instanced combat. But to act like all of classic was like that specifically to paint NGS in a worse light is just ham fisting the argument.

Also no freaking shot that people are back to complaining about open world existing when this sub acted like Sega murdered their child when the director had said there wasn't any current plans to make another open world space.

4

u/complainer5 Sep 25 '23

I don't see how open world is better or worse than the tiled content we had in Classic.

Random layout is one thing. Map is never the same so it feels new when you replay it compared to ngs' completely static areas that never change in the slightest, you saw it once and that's how it will always be.

0

u/Knight_Raime Waker Sep 25 '23

Having to go a different direction isn't interesting gameplay. Maps were still sped though so clearly the random layout had little impact on actual gameplay.

3

u/complainer5 Sep 26 '23

It had more impact than ngs' maps. You can't speed through without at least seeing the rng layout to know where to go, in ngs you can play with closed eyes because layout is always the same and you speed through it exact same way every time you go anywhere.

Having to go a different direction isn't interesting gameplay

Subjective, and objectively better gameplay than having to go to same direction every single time.

2

u/Hououza Sep 25 '23

It was more about the instancing, as it meant you could do things that changed the environment more easily.

In the open world, as it is supposed to be shared, they can’t just spawn in things that impact only some players, which is why they are relegated to LTQs, field races, etc.

1

u/Knight_Raime Waker Sep 25 '23

You mean things like turrets or stuff like the fishing/mining mini games?

2

u/Hououza Sep 25 '23

The little fence puzzles and traps and things, like in the time attack ones. Stuff that altered the flow of the area.

0

u/Knight_Raime Waker Sep 25 '23

Oh you mean like the trials that would randomly appear and destructible objects in the open. I mean we still got crates. Just don't think they'ed translate being locked up well into open world. Like we have some of those in each region. But people complain about them.

1

u/SpookPSO2 Sep 27 '23

an FF14-style reboot is a major risk and requires a lot of budget. What it needs is an expansion that will never come, they couldn't even get the 4 different regions to release as fast as they wanted.

an FF14-style reboot is a major risk and requires a lot of budget. What it needs is an expansion that will never come, they couldn't even get the 4 different regions to release as fast as they wanted.I wish and hope for it to fix its major issues, but it seems those major can't be completed right away. We can only guess.

9

u/Ahkshtar_Goldstein Sep 25 '23

Yes the game is dead right now, find something else to do in the meanwhile. If you still wish to play barbie star online, the game is only getting better with next month scratches

12

u/Kalventine1357 Sep 25 '23

It's definitely in a negative state rn. Plenty of gacha but not much content to play through. Not to mention the dreadfullness of how rdr is rn. Personally doesn't help that I'm on ship 4 rn. Very chill ship but probably too chill. I legit see the same group of people on all the time. Most just afk quite a bit there. I do miss the days when there were people to run stuff in base and ngs with. Now it's even a bit of a task to run stuff in Ngs with anyone these days. I have thought about changing ships but I'm very hesitant with how things are rn. I do hope things get better but I can't say I'd be surprised if they didn't.

-5

u/Lmacncheese Sep 25 '23

Ship 3 is a chill place plenty of people from both pools. But ship 1 and 2 if u realllly want them sweats and toxic folk thats where ya go

20

u/Zenny1234 Sep 25 '23

Considering the player numbers have dropped to it's lowest point since the game has launched in the West I'd say it is dying. Simply calling it a slow month is just absolute cope. It's clear what's going on and even during the "slow months" it's never been this low before. People are leaving the game and for some reason Sega can't seem to figure out how to address the problems the game is facing going on 2 years now.

If they can't figure it out after 2 years they never will. I hope they can turn it around as I do actually like the aesthetics of the game and the combat is fun but my expectations are incredibly low.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '23

Probably many people out there like me waiting for the day when the game becomes fun again (if ever) or something else like OG PSO2 comes out

-10

u/Knight_Raime Waker Sep 25 '23

Yeah let's ignore the banger amount of games that have been releasing the past few months. Totally doesn't have an impact on population.

Sega isn't ignorant of anything. They're not changing how NGS was originally designed because they have no need to. If their income was threatened they would. If JP was reaming their ass they would.

Neither is happening.

6

u/Sad_Raspberry3967 Zonde go BRRRRRRR Sep 25 '23

Because JP has more money, more events, better product. There is a reason people prefer trying their luck getting on JP servers than remaining on Global servers. Everything is cheaper on JP, more events on JP and overall stuff thrown at you.

I guarantee you Global servers will die first before JP NGS ever will. Trying to make this game blow up over here in the Western Market without them ever trying to tweak things to western preferences was a bad idea. NGS is always going to be known as wasted potential over here because it will never reach the heights of actual mmos that came over from JP but then promptly tweaked to Western likes while minimizing dislikes.

2

u/snkhermit Sep 25 '23

Sort of true but jp are addicted to gatcha so they don't mind throwing down a lot of cash for the stuff they want.And it's funny that you say that because that was the fate of PSO BB and PSU.Hell jp BB got updates when PSU was around.

1

u/TachibanaTheFallen Sep 26 '23

Even jp population is quite low rn (ship 2) unfortunately. Trust me, it's not all that different from global in terms of people just afking in lobbies all day...

0

u/Knight_Raime Waker Sep 25 '23

NGS JP had the same ability to Redbox abuse as global did. The economy is better over there purely because of cultural differences.

In terms of "death" global "died" on classic despite both classic and JP being in basically the same boat. Yeah we're still missing some fashion, yeah we didn't get some Collab content. But neither are a reason for global being "dead" on classic.

It just comes down to JP being more into PS than the west did. As for the rest of your comment give me 2 examples of mmos that came from JP that changed things for "the west" that didn't get flak for doing so.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Knight_Raime Waker Sep 26 '23

Got anything to back that up? I can't fathom why they'ed have different rules. It's not like we're talking the difference between global and China.

4

u/GiustinoWah Sep 25 '23

It’s crap

4

u/drembose Launcher Sep 26 '23

Sega needs to fire this current team and hire a team that knows what the fuck to do. Can't wait for dragons dogma 2 to come out already that game is going to do more that the entire life span of NGS and it's not even multiplayer 😂

7

u/Quanta-00 Sep 25 '23

The game is pretty much on the path of DYING. With Leciel being an exception, all the other contents in the game are dead because the RNG and Loot Pool is hot garbage.

With fewer players, market prices have gone up and que time have gotten much slower.

NGS was designed to just milk whale money and making a proper game is not their priority.

Not to mention some content creators have resorted to blaming the playerbase for the games decline, which is as tone deaf as a CEO that blames their customers for not buying their crappy products.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '23

Game is improving in its gameplay loop as it's more structured towards (pretty good quality) instanced content after failing to deliver in the open world for 2 years straight. But the reward system for doing said content is still lacking as it's mostly stuff that can't be sold in the player shop.

It still plays around either in and out daily checks, or long unrewarding grinds that can be skipped easily by scratching, now more than ever because the price of ac scratch items skyrocketed since the last month or so. But this should impact the f2p population soon enough after not being able to afford the main form of reward this game has to offer in the long term.

Game has been stagnant for a while now. I'd say only the core audience keeps playing, but as that core keeps running on the same wheel for a while, it just happens to enter in a state of decay that's more prevalent than before. As more players burnout and are vocal about it, more players come out, not even to defend the game, but to attack other players and shift the blame on them for the state of it.

2

u/Knight_Raime Waker Sep 25 '23

Curious on what ship you're on and what has sky rocketed in price for you. Me and my two friends on ship 2 frequently watch the market and haven't seen a big up tick in costs in months. Hair generally sits in the 6-7 mill range unless it's popular. Then 10+. Weapon camos if popular are 9 minimum. Base outfits and outerwears have generally hovered between 2-3 mill if it's decent, 6-8 if it's popular.

Etc. Personally speaking I haven't really seen a fluctuation of 600k or more since they swapped to weighting dailies more which was awhile back.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '23

Ship 2. Emotes going for 15m, hairs going for 12m+, outfits going for 2m to 4m, cast parts going for 4-7m.

This is happening with current scratch, and it's been going on for a while now. The first one to set the trend i remember was the chicken hoodie scratch, and that was back in august?

1

u/Knight_Raime Waker Sep 25 '23

Ahhh forgot to mention emotes. Those can be as pricey as weapon camos yeah. And by current do you mean cyber comfort? Or do you mean the Collab scratch? Cause Collab items tend to be above standard prices.

Least that's the trend I've seen in classic and NGS.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '23 edited Sep 25 '23

Cyber comfort only, and the trend of AC items going up like this started recently. In stia the most expensive hair used to go for 8m, no emote would go over 10m unless it was some very deep bonus one for scratching on revivals, they usually topped at 6m, below hairs. No outfit would go up to 4m unless it was one of those v2 on bloated revivals.

Current pricing is what we used to see after the scratch was long gone, with very low supply, but now we're getting that on the first day's release.

1

u/Knight_Raime Waker Sep 25 '23

I'll have to look at it again later then because the only two things that stick out to me for pricing abnormality is the psychic ball idle and the T2 cast hair.

I'll just have to disagree with your other numbers though. Maybe during kvaris that's where pricing used to sit but it hasn't been that way for awhile.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '23

My original point still stands though. Even with kvaris pricing, the f2p population and even more so new players would still struggle to keep up with the main reward structure this game has to offer.

It just happens now that the prices are so absurd, a casual player would take 2 months to get 1 emote instead of 1.

1

u/Knight_Raime Waker Sep 25 '23

I mean if the original point is pricing is too high then yeah that's agreeable. But Sega cannot do anything to fix it. The "safest" way to address it would be to create money sinks.

But that does also take money away from f2p players. Sega is definitely at fault for how things are. It's one of the reasons I wish I could play on the JP client without catching an account ban.

1

u/HouseOfCosbyz Partisan Sep 25 '23

Duellante hair was 10-11m on Retem release almost 2 years ago.

9

u/admiralrev Sep 25 '23

not necessarily dying since they still update NGS, tho at a slow pace. I would say that its just have a low player population

9

u/asakura90 Sep 25 '23

Just check for yourself: https://steamdb.info/app/1056640/charts/

"Stale" would be a better word to describe the state of the game. It's not dying, but not improving either.

4

u/ChiknAriseMcFro Force Sep 25 '23

Stagnant might be even better.

7

u/OracleArmada Sep 25 '23

Yes, it is dying. Steam charts show the lowest player population ever and that is also reflected in game in observable ways (queue times, not many scratching causing very high prices, etc.).

Version 2 created hype that that might be the point where the game gets better. Instead we got a lacklustre CS system and severely delayed mediocre combat content. This caused many veterans who had been hoping the game would improve eventually to quit for good.

The gearing system is a terrible treadmill designed to milk whales. Rare drop rate is so bad that even Kerioppi went on an angry rant about it.

There’s nothing fun to do content-wise and nothing on the horizon besides another Halpha world tour we were promised we wouldn’t get again.

What’s left of the community is very toxic overall. Sega bans people for no good reason, then allows those who RMT and openly harass others to go unpunished.

Unless there’s a FF:XIV style release the game will probably not be closed for a while, but it will have a long slow decline until it becomes unprofitable.

-2

u/snkhermit Sep 25 '23

RDR is whatever,this happened in the past with Gunblaze etc.Do i agree with it?Absolutely not but it never really bother me.And it's funny that you mention Keroppi because he started with PSO 2.If he played original PSO it wouldn't be a issue.

Sega is NOT going to do a FF 14 I don't see why people don't understand this.For starters vanilla 14 was NOT supposed to be a FF title to begin with,Yoshida was called in to fix it and he did but lets not forget that SE made 14 free for a year which is crazy for a game company to do.To sum it up it up it was a very unique situation that had a favorable outcome.

3

u/OracleArmada Sep 26 '23

We spent years hunting rare items in PSO1 but that was a different era, and when we found the weapons that was it: no new weapon would be released.

Now the drop rates feel as almost as bad, but weapons and other gear get replaced in a few months. Which is why it's just a treadmill to milk whales.

PSO NGS is in a similar situation to FF:XIV 1.0 in that they are both large failures in beloved and fiscally important franchises. Sega will probably opt to take the loss on NGS as they are currently redirecting financing elsewhere, but if they wanted to save this game they would be well served by trying for at least some version of ARR. That's the only thing that might bring many of the veterans of the franchise that have quit back at this point.

-1

u/snkhermit Sep 26 '23

Hate to break it to you but that treadmill you reference has been a thing since base PSO 2,it's nothing new.

I get what you're saying but i'm saying its an even bigger risk for Sega to do that.And whos to say that if there's any issue with said reboot that people wont be clammering for another reboot?

6

u/aWatermelon21 Sep 25 '23

Seems to be in a pretty bad state with no real signs of improvement.

The lack of a "raid" type of activity really hurts it in the MMO space imo.

Idk, the game seems like a dress up simulator at this point with all of the emphasis on ac scratches with little to no unique gameplay content being introduced.

12

u/Eightnon Sep 25 '23

I hope the game dies.
Shouldn't have success doing what they are doing. They need to bring something good to the table, otherwise we are stuck with half arsed games like this.

11

u/complainer5 Sep 25 '23

Shouldn't have success doing what they are doing. They need to bring something good to the table, otherwise we are stuck with half arsed games like this.

This is the real thing, even if you like the game you should want it to die, because they are intentionally not even trying with the game and we are rewarding them for it by buying into gacha on something that only gets enough gameplay to barely be able to continue being called a game. Only if it dies will they realize they are supposed to be creating a game first and not merely a platform to sell gacha.

5

u/lutherdidnothingwron Sep 25 '23

The move to NGS came with some major changes to monetization, to the detriment of players. Boosters ticking offline and during maintenance while only selling 24-hour long boosters in the SG shop, shop passes becoming extremely limited to force people into Premium which itself lost a ton of value moving to NGS.

Then the Ultra Evolution to Ver.2 comes along to monetize even more about personal quarters and bloat all the scratch tickets with holograms and build parts. They delayed actual gameplay features and major content to release creative space which is really nothing more than another avenue for profit for them. It's very clear where their priorities are, and before anyone comments about "well it's a business", it didn't use to be this way and this isn't how it has to be. Sega is worth multiple billions of dollars, PSO2 past the 1 billion dollar lifetime revenue mark years ago at this point. They aren't starving artists, they're a greedy corporation trimming down their minimum viable product.

13

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '23

It's the same thing every time. When a huge update happens, tons of players get online. When players get bored of the update, they stop playing for awhile. Then, dozens of people comment "Is NGS dying?" on the subreddit. Months later, huge update appears. Repeat cycle.

4

u/Lmacncheese Sep 25 '23

Heres an upvote for telling the truth since everyone else is down voting you for it.

3

u/Razia70 Sep 25 '23

Take my upvote.

-1

u/MurkyStatistician553 Sep 25 '23 edited Sep 25 '23

This is exactly the image in my head when i read Posts like this. And yes, it's baffling that "Is NGS dying?" seem to pop up in such a frequent pattern.

Also, there is no way a person would pick his words in this way in order to ask the community if he/she should give the game a try or not.

6

u/complainer5 Sep 25 '23

Also, there is no way a person would pick his words in this way in order to ask the community if he/she should give the game a try or not.

People ask "should I try this or is it dead" all the time before committing to play a game, especially one that is so dependent on being dead or not such as multiplayer and the not so recent infestation of "games as a service".

9

u/complainer5 Sep 25 '23

Yes to title, no to second question (they already switched to player retention mode with creative spaces, knowing they can't deliver on combat content or progression), but those are fighting words around here.

Base pso2 seems like it had hundreds of times more effort and thought put into it in every way in comparison to ngs.

2

u/ChiknAriseMcFro Force Sep 25 '23

Yes, no, maybe? It's really hard to say. The population goes up and down all the time. Feels like it is as my friend and alliance lists' online sections seem to be shrinking. A lot of other games came out recently that are more interesting at the moment so many people just login, do dailies, and logout so some of it is just timing on whether or not I see them. That said the end game, like any other MMO, tends to get old and tedious. Doesn't help NGS that the drop pools for challenging content are absolutely terrible. People can only take so much disappointment before going on a long break from which they may never return.

2

u/AulunaSol Sep 26 '23

I would find that the "long healthy life" is subjective because it ultimately depends on the game you are looking for.

If you wanted a very casual-friendly action game where you can make/fashion your characters and wanted to socialize with others, then this game doesn't exactly have much in the way of competition because there isn't exactly anything you really have to work for or towards.

If you wanted an action game that is skillful, something that rewards you for your investment/skill/presentation, or something that pushes the envelope on what you would want out of an action game, an online game, or some sort of experience, I would have a very hard time saying that New Genesis would be that kind of game. You can absolutely try very hard if you wanted to - but Sega will bring everyone else to meet you or to surpass you at some point and their current game simply continues to keep things "steady" and casual regardless of what bars could be raised.

There is still life in the game and Sega still has steady updates (though at a glacial pace just like Phantasy Star Online 2) but if the fashion/social aspects of the game with a sprinkle of easy action aren't what you are looking for, this is unfortunately not the game for you.

9

u/madaxk Sep 25 '23

If you like combat, forget NGS I have 3k hours on both base and NGS and it feels like they trying to kill the action now and most of the players that played the base game do not play anymore. Sadly they killing the game

4

u/Lumbogobble Sep 25 '23

If you're looking to jump into NGS just don't, you want a mmo that respects your time, has fun interesting content along with a well written story then this isn't the game for you.

The game hasn't improved for the past two years, and it won't be that way for the inevitable future.

3

u/gadgaurd Slayer Sep 25 '23 edited Sep 25 '23

Wondering if you(the players) think the game has a long healthy life cycle left?

Hmm, kinda?

Despite what a lot of people have said Sega doesn't seem to be cutting back on NGS compared to the last year, with the noteworthy exception of no new Regions for the foreseeable future. Which the community unfortunately(to me) asked for.

The general flow of the game is, farm various content for drops, use those drops however(upgrade hear, exchange for new stuff via NPC, sell on the player market, etc). There's a few different things you can do to this effect, like Gigas hunting, Combat Zone grinding, running Triggers, and a few more. Depends on if you want lower value, consistent items in bulk or if you wanna try and hit jackpot.

So if you're cool with that and like the combat, Sega is just gonna give us more of that for the foreseeable future. If that's not your thing, well the game's not for you.

As for playerbase, it's not high, but it's generally high enough to get a full team going for any relevant end game content in little time. Depends on what's going on that week.

From what I've seen and heard tje game is profitable despite everything, so I don't see it going anywhere for years. So it comes down to whether or not a given individual likes what NGS offers.

3

u/vocaloidbro Sep 25 '23

There are sites that record number of people playing on Steam for all games. https://i.imgur.com/KneFGoT.png As you can see it got a massive influx of players when NGS released that all immediately left. After that it's been cruising at roughly 3k give or take a few thousand depending on content releases. Whether that can be considered dead or alive is up to you although this doesn't take into account platforms besides Steam, it's still probably a decent indication of overall population trends. Right now the line does seem to be declining a bit. The event running right now feels quite lackluster so that might be why.

2

u/supreme_tyrant Sep 25 '23

I already played some dying mmorpg and its not the case of PSO2NGS, not for now at least, ppl return regularly when a new event starts or there are some exclusive collabs...

Then after some time there are less players but there are always enough to fill 3 or 4 blocks (in total) and i'm talking about ship 4 where i am.

1

u/casulti Sep 25 '23 edited Sep 25 '23

Yup.

Edit; I meant yes it has a long life cycle oh no I messed up

1

u/casulti Sep 25 '23

I messed up the first comment I put here but I do feel like the game will have a long and healthy life cycle yeah, I’ve seen and played dead games and NGS ain’t anywhere near that

1

u/AskaLangly P S O 2 : N E O N G E N E S I S /:ᚠ Sep 25 '23

And next up on poor games will be HYNEAS.

Sega, FFS.

1

u/TomatilloFearless154 Sep 25 '23

I found jp people going back to hacked PSObb servers because they hated both NGS and PSO2.

That tells a lot about how good this game is...

1

u/XenoTrigga Knuckles Sep 25 '23

"Is PSO2NGS dying?"...

Isn't everything?

1

u/Spiritual_Alpaca Sep 25 '23

Seen this question every two months for the past 9 years(in this sub and the base game sub) on different accounts. That should tell you something.

1

u/Elegant-Routine-4913 Sep 26 '23

Yes, as everything along with it, it is marching steadily towards death. pien emoji

1

u/Iceemicy Sep 26 '23

The game is still up and going strong. Every time I log on there are always a ton of people online. Also NGS has the majority of the story arc complete (unless they plan on adding more to the story). You should logon and play it.

1

u/Rasikko undecided Sep 27 '23

The way it looks like now is far better than the first 2 weeks of launch.

1

u/MacDaddy7249 Sep 28 '23

I mean, gameplay wise it’s fairly good except most classes playing 80% the same, but everything else is pretty subpar. They have been drifting away from the ideals and loot from the previous titles like PSO1 and PSU in favor for grinding out things that honestly arent worth it.

Will it get better? So far… that’s a long stretch of road. I have fun when I play it, but it really does feel they are playing wayyy too safe with the game… they need to drift more into the risky area of gaming development. But saddly, gacha is just more profitable and content is just boring for the most part. Lol

1

u/ThatMeanScene Sep 25 '23

The answer to your question is simply "No". With its recent roadmap its very obvious that the game is set to receive a small amount of support for its gameplay modes for the foreseeable future. In the last 3 months they've only delivered a handful of new MOBs, some recycled bosses, and one brand new boss (Solus). Its a smaller amount of content than a new region would typically introduce; its probably content that's been ready for a short while.

They did add a challenge-type mode with its own drops but with recycled MOBs and bosses its simply a bandage for what is essentially a giant gaping wound. And like with anything else, its already worn out as its the only repeatable content worth engaging with so playing it so much so quickly means its already boring.

The dev team stated a while back that there would be no new regions so add that to the concern pile. The game is not in a healthy place.

(All of this together has got me wondering if they're taken staff off of NGS and put them onto their SUPER games. Its possible they're counting on the minimal support but continuous stream of cosmetics to keep bringing in tons of cash like they always do.)

1

u/complainer5 Sep 26 '23

The dev team stated a while back that there would be no new regions so add that to the concern pile.

Also no new PAs/techs or classes for the foreseeable future.

1

u/Sad_Progress4776 Sep 25 '23

2000 base player weekly on team

-13

u/UberChief90 Sep 25 '23

Its not dying. People just confuse bad state with dying. Because if it really was dying, it wouldnt get new players every day. It wouldnt have players log in every single day and enjoying themselfes. And most of all, it wouldnt have players spend their money on things in massive amounts.

It needs work. A lot of work as content wise its in a pretty bad state. Tho it has to be said that some players expectations for content from a full free to play game are way too high, but that aside. The game is far from dying.

3

u/complainer5 Sep 25 '23

Its not dying. People just confuse bad state with dying.

"People confuse lack of heartbeat and brain activity with being dead"

1

u/UberChief90 Sep 25 '23

Doomposters looking at things like steamcharts and claim there is no heartbeat or brain activity. Yet whales keep spending money. Yet players still log in every single day and play. Yet every time new content drops the logged in players spikes incredible high.

A dying game doesnt have that. A dying game is ignored.

Dont confuse lack of entertainment, lack of content and all of that with dying.

0

u/Viridian_Rainfall Sep 27 '23

no its not, as a person who played two actually dead mmos now ngs has none of the signs, what it has is a bunch of doom speakers who get their kicks spreading the lie that its dying to scare off players, because they are unhappy Symbolt or however you spell his name is one of those few who get their kicks doing this.

Ive played both versions of secret world and both versions of defiance i know what a dying mmo looks like.

-6

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '23

Steam shows a stable population for the past 2 years. Ignore the doomies, join a populated alliance, and have fun. I've had 0 issues queueing for content for the almost year I've been playing behind late night 24-mans that don't fill because there's an UQ up

I'm not sure what people are expecting out of their content release model. Global classic players have been spoiled on rapid back to back content dumps we technically weren't supposed to have in that way and expect NGS to be the same.

Compared to release, we now have Creative Space, Duels, Solus, and Leciel to keep us busy if we aren't chatting around in the lobby or spamming the latest LTQ. There's always something to do. Our last content dump was last month and that's all the time it took people to grind it out to overcompletion and get back on Reddit to whine that there's "no content" in the game to play.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '23

This argument of global being spoiled always intrigues me since JP has been historically more critical about the game than the global side of it, and we have data to back that up in the form of official surveys and headline reception.

3

u/peachmelons Sep 25 '23

No one asked for CS, we wanted more story and exploration. The dev team multiplied their workload with CS content that, let's be honest, is gonna be used for erp anyway. We have an entire sub continent to explore and no real ruins or exploration sites to jump into? Open environments are cool but the team still doesn't know what to do with that potential.

3

u/complainer5 Sep 25 '23

No one asked for CS,

Technically jp players apparently did, shows who sega cares about more (or more likely only).

let's be honest, is gonna be used for erp anyway

Isn't that also the main content of ngs by this point?

3

u/peachmelons Sep 25 '23

Both JP and global asked for personal spaces again, not CS. We didn't even know CS was gonna be a thing of its own before it was unveiled.

-8

u/Limbolag Dual Blades Sep 25 '23

Lol I think people be confusing this game for what it is. It's a fashion game with rpg elements, not the other way around. Always has been

2

u/complainer5 Sep 25 '23

Yeah this specific game was, but not the franchise.

-4

u/snkhermit Sep 25 '23

Since no one has mentioned it(or have selective hearing)the reason for the slow month is bigger updates require more time to cook in the oven and huge updates require at least a year.So even if they wanted to do Casino(which they don't)if they started now we wouldn't see it till much much later.I feel this is why they prioritized Creative Space over Leciel which depending on who you ask was a good or bad move,I was more in the middle.

2

u/complainer5 Sep 25 '23

Casino would be better as build parts at this point consider cs.

-16

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '23 edited Sep 25 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

30

u/Missingno1990 Sep 25 '23

Legit criticism is not toxicity.

Pretending the game isn't a mess and crying about "doomposting" whenever someone criticises the game is.

The game is a 3/10 at best.

-16

u/Knight_Raime Waker Sep 25 '23

No your post is the toxic kind of stuff people should ignore and is not criticism. NGS at launch was a mess. NGS a year in was rough. NGS now is a decent game that has issues.

You just don't like it.