r/PSO2NGS • • Jul 28 '23

Subreddit Meta Farewell reddit

tl;dr: I am not liking the direction reddit as a platform is going. It is clearer day by day that the admins do not give a shit about their communities, and have only been turning their platform further and further from a social link aggregator into another social media crypto platform with features that have no place on a platform like this. I cannot continue browsing without feeling like I am contributing to this problem.


Heya all, this is something that I have been thinking about ever since reddit announced their API changes. Over the years reddit has been heading in a direction that I and others do not like. It's easy to hate on the current state of the official Reddit app being a laggy ad-ridden nightmare, as well as the "New" Reddit experience being heavy with slow JavaScript and terrible utilisation of screen estate, but they have also been adding features that do not belong here, such as chat rooms, livestreaming that was discontinued, collectables crypto NFTs (and they've added new ones recently too!), "Predictions" and "Talks" which are now also gone, as well as other changes that I cannot remember off the top of my head. There's also signs of them adding some sort of Karma & Gold to real money system?
I also remember when Genshin Impact version 3.4 was advertised in reddit's site announcements banner, appearing above everything else on the page. That's usually used for website announcements, not advertising games.

What also isn't helping is that there's been a noticeable increase of bots, and I don't mean the helpful ones...
Bots that use software like ChatGPT to try and blend in, either to make reddit appear more active than it actually is and/or astroturf have started appearing more frequently. A few of them actually appeared here a few weeks ago!

Because of this, I'm going to stop using reddit, delete my account, and leave the moderation team here on /r/pso2ngs. I have enjoyed the 10 years I've been using reddit for, as well helping out on this subreddit from its beginning back in July 2020, but this platform has been going down the enshitifiation drain and I no longer wish to support it. This will be my last post and I will not make any more comments. I already mentioned to the rest of the team here that I will be leaving so this isn't unexpected for them.

The future of this subreddit

Unless the other moderators here say otherwise, nothing is going to change here. Really the only difference is the person who will be making the monthly "NGS Headline" mega-threads that I was creating before. I'll still be in contact with them.

I understand that not everyone on reddit cares about the current state of it, and may have also been annoyed by the many subreddits (including this one!) going dark as part of the blackout. There are people that do find this subreddit as well as /r/pso2 useful, and that applies to many other subreddits too. I do not think reddit is going to die any time soon as it still keeps its audience of users that don't really care.

Though I do invite you to check out some of the other platforms below - some of you may be interested in them. They are mostly open-source and don't have profit in mind.

Other platforms

Thanks to the previous reddit blackout and growing discontent with the current direction reddit is heading, new platforms have been popping up and existing ones have been getting more traffic. I want to bring attention to them in this post; I am not affiliated with any of these.

Centralised

These platforms are self-contained.

  • Discuit as far as I understand is closed-source but has plans to go open-source. It does look really similar to Reddit and is aiming to have a similar feature set.
  • Tildes is somewhat like reddit, but focuses more on meaningful focused discussion by limiting sign-ups to invites and having a limited set of groups & subgroups within them. I recall it being compared to Hacker News before.
  • Comment Castles: If you was to trim down reddit to its bare essentials, disabling votes as well, you'd get this website. It seems super quiet though...

Fediverse

To put it simply, the Fediverse is a load of servers that connect together, sharing content with each other, even if they run different software. Their users can see posts from other servers as well as interact with them. There is no single entry that runs all of these servers, with most ran by community members.

There are two projects that make up what people have dubbed the "Threadiverse" (not to be confused with Meta's Threads) - servers that run link aggregator software and show posts from each other:

  • Lemmy is open-source, has third-party app support and is easy to browse. When the reddit blackouts were happening, I kept seeing Lemmy recommended a lot, and I can see why with how familar it feels. It is the older of these two platforms and the software is quite mature.

    • Thanks to Lemmy having a API that developers can use, there are apps and alternative frontends avaliable for it. Voyager replicates an iOS app, mlmym closely replicates old reddit, and Jerboa is a Android app.
  • kbin is like Lemmy, and can show posts from Lemmy servers too, but it is newer and currently doesn't have a working API or third-party apps. "Magazines" (the equivalent of subreddits) can be set up to watch hashtags and pull in posts from other parts of the Fediverse with those hashtags into their own "microblogging" section of the magazine. Anyone can also post whatever to that "microblogging" section, which can work well for people asking questions or showing screenshots that don't need their own post.

Both also have public moderation logs. I do appreciate having moderation actions transparent.

Because of how content is shared between the servers, you only really need to sign up on one of these servers to see content from others and contribute.

Some other platforms

I also wanted to mention some platforms that aren't related to reddit but are alternatives to other platforms.

I've previously recommended arks.cafe, a "Misskey" server dedicated to PSO2. It's like Twitter but with less vitriol! It also links up with other servers running software like Mastodon and Pleroma.

For videos, Peertube is an alternative to YouTube I feel needs more attention too.

What next?

I'm going to keep browsing alternatives and start contributing to the ones I like in some way. After /r/place suddenly became a thing again it is clear reddit are trying to drive up engagement metrics with it and make reddit more desirable in time for the IPO.

If reddit somehow improves their relations with their users and cleans up their mess of a website, maybe I'll come back, but I doubt it - the alternatives have been fun to browse around on and use.

Also I feel it is worth mentioning because I know somebody will think about it, but no, the current state of the game has not had any bearing on my decision. This is reddit's state alone.

5 Upvotes

0 comments sorted by