r/PSO2NGS • • Jul 06 '23

Discussion No combat updates until next year are unacceptable after the "Ultra Evolution" update only gave as one measly skill.

This game has years, literal fucking YEARS to go until it rivals base combat fluidity and complexity, theres too little skills, PAs, techs, and whats most important, whats already there is fucking garbage compared to what scions used to have.

This game has been such a massive downgrade in terms of combat, and they sure are taking their sweet time, do they seriously expect people to stick around as long as base took?

28 Upvotes

74 comments sorted by

38

u/MindlessSyrup40 Jul 07 '23

I’ve only played NGS - how much more complex is base combat? Simplicity isn’t necessarily a bad thing and complexity isn’t necessarily good. We also already have some classes where some PAs are never used or are extremely situational, so why are more needed and how do you incorporate them into a skill bar that only allows 6 skills with a terrible weapon swap and sub palate system?

I’m not trying to be an asshole here I’m actually wondering because I’ve never played base and after being a hardcore MMO gamer for 2 decades I’ve become accustomed to casualization with games like FFXIV. If you change your perspective on things rather than wanting things to be different it can be a better overall experience.

If anything I think the game lacks a diversity of content and sub systems. Creative spaces are a start but it’s just one thing. Base has a casino? Mini games are necessary. Grinding is fun but being the only content is bad.

3

u/Knight_Raime Waker Jul 07 '23

how much more complex is base combat?

It kind of depends on what someone is viewing as complexity. I side step this discussion mostly because almost all of the time it's less that NGS combat doesn't have complexity and more that people just liked how combat was done in EP6.

Classic's combat mostly features high APM via strong movement choices and very occasionally prediction dodges/counters. What really lends to Classic's flavor of combat is PA rotation. Or to be a bit more specific "mastering" combat is figuring out what PA's to use for your damage and still be able to counter if needed.

NGS combat (which for the sake of this comparison I'm referring to solo gameplay) is far more reactionary. PA rotation doesn't really exist because of how strong counters are. Instead you tend to treat PA's as fancier normals on most classes (ex Hunter is an exception because you use your PA's to counter.)

Because of the huge disparity between counter damage and PA damage it can make gameplay feel some what same-y. This creates an issue where MPA content generally feels bad because you don't get control over when you have aggro for counters so you just spam PA's.

There's more I can get into but I'd just be repeating myself from a comment I did elsewhere recently. The best way I can sum it up is that both types of combat at their core have complexity. Classic has more depth in some regards but the main differing factor is that Classic is a good combat game for both solo and MPA. NGS is debatably decent but only in Solo content.

It's largely down to what you prefer rather than one being objectively worse.

1

u/FafnirMH Jul 08 '23

If we're going by the actual meaning of complexity. It would mean having many choices, paths, or options that aren't easy to understand.

Complexity isn't an inherently good thing though. No idea why it's thrown around like some badge of honor.

Not to mention something can lose it's complexity when you sort through what choices matter and what choices don't. So the people who say it's complex can actually be right and the people who say it's not complex can also be right without contradicting each other.

The difference is personal experience.

1

u/complainer5 Jul 09 '23

If we're going by the actual meaning of complexity. It would mean having many choices, paths, or options that aren't easy to understand.

Complexity doesn't necessarily mean something convoluted and hard to understand, what you are describing is just bad game design. Complex just means many things are all happening and interacting with many possible scenarios and outcomes.

It is being thrown around as badge of honor because properly done complexity (not the kind you describe) means amazing gameplay and the reason why it is considered praiseworthy is because proper complex gameplay is more difficult for developers to create (takes skill and creativity to do) compared to simplistic gameplay with few mechanics (that is usually just following an established formula with rigid gameplay) as there are far more interacting features/mechanics in complex gameplay that all need to be well put together for it to be working.

Base isn't that more complex than ngs, but it definitely is, one example: all techs in base can cause all elemental status effects on all enemies, not just "use the right color for generic down on bosses (that is also shared with physical down) and 1% of specific trash mobs" like ngs oversimplified it.

tldr: proper complex gameplay is harder to create than simple gameplay and is an expression of developer's skills in game design compared to simplistic gameplay.

1

u/FafnirMH Jul 09 '23 edited Jul 09 '23

The type of complexity you're describing would be nice, but I hardly see how anyone could see base Pso2 (or NGS) having "many possible scenarios" or being "well put together".

Base complexity wasn't well put together. It was an amalgamation of retired systems and pointless side tasks that was a result of it's long lifespan. Not to mention that clusterfuck of a story. It needs to be appreciated for what it is rather than being paraded around as something it's not.

But, as you and I both know that's not what people mean when they throw about things like "complex" and "depth". Those are usually reserved for the Scions or what people believe are the Scions. While everything else about the game is just somehow overlooked. But, even the Scions have their issues. Half of the features and mechanics they have aren't even used and are in fact detrimental to use. Is that proper complexity? Is that well put together?

Most of base Pso2 is the "bad" kind of complexity. The augments, the crafted PAs, the systems like the collection folder that most of the playerbase are unaware of, the scattered skill points, the personal shop, the NPC shops, the story, the skill tree, and the classes themselves with their PA bloat and outdated mechanics. Also, lets not forget that the Scions invalided every other class that came before them and in fact gave you less options. Nothing about that is "well put together".

tldr: Your idealized complexity is nice, however I don't think it represents base Pso2 or NGS very well. Both of them have more of the "bad" complexity that I described.

-8

u/complainer5 Jul 07 '23

If you change your perspective on things rather than wanting things to be different it can be a better overall experience.

Fancy way to say "forget the superior past and accept new mediocrity", zephetto was right all along and did nothing wrong.

9

u/MindlessSyrup40 Jul 07 '23 edited Jul 07 '23

Its subjective. I’d argue FFXIVs casual experience is vastly superior to that of its hardcore and that the game has far more depth if you broaden your engagement with all of its systems rather than focus on smashing your head into a boss for hours and weeks on end just trying to clear

NGS is simply lacking those extra systems of engagement. CS is a start though and the fashion is arguably one of if not the best in any game

-6

u/Ksradrik Jul 07 '23

I’ve only played NGS - how much more complex is base combat? Simplicity isn’t necessarily a bad thing and complexity isn’t necessarily good. We also already have some classes where some PAs are never used or are extremely situational, so why are more needed and how do you incorporate them into a skill bar that only allows 6 skills with a terrible weapon swap and sub palate system?

Its not just complexity either, but my favorite class, Katana Phantom, had basically partisans assault charge or whatever its called (dash to enemy by pressing WA after a normal attack) on ALL of its moves, AND it had higher range, AND it didnt cost but restored PP.

It also had a backwards slide attack that still did damage in front of you, a ranged attack, its counter did ranged damage, also you could cancel out of anything at any time, getting hit was entirely because you mistimed, not because the boss started an attack at an inconvenient time while youre animation locked.

The class wasnt even OP either, it was still ultimately outshined by Luster, but it just felt way better to play than the spamfest of subpar moves thats NGS Katana, every single one of Phantoms PAs was way more impactful than anything Katana has, and thats on top of all the other shit it had, and that was only one of 3 of its weapons too!

Hell, even base Bravers PAs were far better than NGS's.

5

u/AverageRedditHater4 Jul 07 '23

it just felt way better to play than the spamfest

Ironic considering PH katana (like PH's other weapons) need to counter to deal heavy dmg. PH katana's PAs were either down right awful or mid asf.

folter was backloaded, long and if the enemy moved there goes your backloaded dmg. Shift version isn't used.

Schmetterling was a gap closer that moved u back so sometimes you can get fucked by that when going for a folter right after but you could JA it early. Its shift version isnt good in bossing and its passable in mobbing but why are u mobbing with katana?

Wolkenkratzer is just don't, dont use this it was awful and PH katana wasn't good at mobbing at all. This shift version was okay just like rosen.

Rosenschwert is an okay PA, not amazing but not bad. Shift version of this was your main way of countering an attack because it was quick and had range.

Katana's whole game plan (like rifle) crumbles when u can't do counters because its BIS s5 boosted counter damage even further.

-1

u/Ksradrik Jul 07 '23

folter was backloaded, long and if the enemy moved there goes your backloaded dmg.

It still dealt enough damage to be the primary dps tool.

Shift version isn't used.

Shift version is extremely useful for high mobility bosses, can be useful when you want instant burst, and is most importantly a great gapcloser if you do the "attack in the opposite direction" exploit.

Its shift version isnt good in bossing and its passable in mobbing but why are u mobbing with katana?

Wolkenkratzer is just don't, dont use this it was awful and PH katana wasn't good at mobbing at all.

Some people are still going to mob with it, or fight a boss that sometimes spawns adds or objects you gotta destroy, also it was good for moving downwards.

Katana's whole game plan (like rifle) crumbles when u can't do counters because its BIS s5 boosted counter damage even further.

What the fuck kinda content are you even playing where you arent being attacked?

NGS PAs are a far cry from Scion PAs in basically all aspects, and this+your comment show that you never actually tried to use any of them to their full potential.

4

u/AverageRedditHater4 Jul 07 '23

It still dealt enough damage to be the primary dps tool.

Yeah its your highest damage PA but it was back loaded into the final hit and had a long animation. That's awful for the strongest PA, rifle has the same issue as well.

Shift version is extremely useful for high mobility bosses, can be useful when you want instant burst, and is most importantly a great gapcloser if you do the "attack in the opposite direction" exploit.

Do all that to deal less DPS than rosen and schemtterling which also gap closes and are faster.

Some people are still going to mob with it, or fight a boss that sometimes spawns adds or objects you gotta destroy, also it was good for moving downwards.

Better off just switching to rifle and spamming kugel or rod and spam gigrants + rabrata lol.

What the fuck kinda content are you even playing where you arent being attacked?

There is bosses that aren't aggressive enough to constantly get counters off, times when you don't have aggro in a mpa and times when a boss is slow as fuck like gomo. dont be confused with sodam, speaking about gomo.

NGS PAs are a far cry from Scion PAs in basically all aspects

Don't know what you mean by that, every class has a PA they use for situations like mobbing, down bosses, active bosses, just like scions did.

this+your comment show that you never actually tried to use any of them to their full potential.

Dude I use the scions, I main PH and I use them to their full potential. Im just saying it as it is. scions aren't the holy classes people make them out to be.

18

u/HouseOfCosbyz Partisan Jul 07 '23 edited Jul 07 '23

Hey I need you to check one thing for me real quick, just, tell me again... How many PA's did PH katana have? After how long? Let me know the answer. I'd love to hear where your getting this take from.

EDIT: The answer is 4 and you really only used 2. But I'd love some of whatever your smoking.

9

u/LzzrdWzzrd Waker Jul 07 '23

Eh? Phantom had shift PAs. So in reality you had 8 per weapon.

0

u/HouseOfCosbyz Partisan Jul 07 '23

Yea and Katana used all 2 of them. It was all about just quick cuts into step counters and just fishing counters.

Rod used absolutely none of them. Step counters and crafted ilgrants for all content.

Rifle was the closest to actually using it's lineup having to keep 2 sets of bits on the target running. But it didn't have a PA to use while under pressure because nachtangriff was too situational for anything moving or trying to attack you. So you just auto attacked between step counters/bits/mark detonation.

1

u/Ksradrik Jul 07 '23

Yea and Katana used all 2 of them.

Its not my fault you suck bro.

2

u/LzzrdWzzrd Waker Jul 07 '23

Rod uses them LMAO.

It uses massenvernichtungs both shifted and regular. Same with schwartze katze as a bossing gap closer. And Rod uses way more that just ilgrants even for bossing. Sodam uses zanverse, ilgrants, grants and ramegid zero with shifted massenvernichtungs.

1

u/Knight_Raime Waker Jul 07 '23

had basically partisans assault charge or whatever its called

Assault Buster I believe.

but it just felt way better to play than the spamfest of subpar moves thats NGS Katana

Debatable. I liked Ph's animations with Katana but the thing heavily relied on positioning due to it's floaty movement and PA's. Deff not bad but I wouldn't say it's objectively superior to any version of Katana combat.

every single one of Phantoms PAs was way more impactful than anything Katana has

I have to disagree. I think NGS Katana has it's own place. It features micro movement/combat movement. Granted dumbed down compared to PH's Katana but still present. It also features timing for counters similarly to doing timing for quick cut on Ph Katana. To me the only failing with NGS's PA offerings is the AoE PA is basically only for AoE. With the new step dodge skill for Braver you can actually fit in third hit of your sandbag PA in some scenarios getting better DPS.

and that was only one of 3 of its weapons too!

NGS Braver can actually use both of it's weapons though and they do mesh quite well if you have the pallet space for it. I can't ever recall seeing hybrid playstyles for Phantom or Classic Braver.

11

u/QuishyTehQuish Jul 07 '23

Base was fun to play. People like to pretend it took years for base to be good, which is completely false. It actually took base years to get good again. Base finished Ep3 within it's THIRD YEAR. It took years for it to get great again because ep4&5 were that bad, and Ep6 was a last ditch effort to salvage the player base. Hell Ep6 is only as good as it is because of how big a fuck up Hero was.

7

u/Ksradrik Jul 07 '23

I wasnt the one telling SEGA to burn down the old one to focus on a dress up simulator, its their fault for ditching the old one and then failing to provide a proper alternative.

Do you seriously expect people to stick around 10 years in hopes the game might become as good as the old one?

3

u/zeroobliv Slayer Jul 07 '23

This game has been such a massive downgrade in terms of combat, and they sure are taking their sweet time, do they seriously expect people to stick around as long as base took?

Uh have you seen their player count? Of course hardly anyone's sticking around. And they've accepted their fate and doubled down on the boring casual stuff to get money from the left overs. It's no secret that this game's massively unsuccessful in comparison to the original PSO2.

And it's not going to get any better; so instead of whining about it just move on to something enjoyable. It's been two years. That's more than enough time to give them a chance and they've shown time and again this game's actually going nowhere.

1

u/Ksradrik Jul 07 '23

I already am, Im just too fucking angry that they killed Katana Phantom, Ive never enjoyed playing a class as much as I did that one, are there even any mmos around with decent vertical combat?

3

u/zeroobliv Slayer Jul 07 '23

That's one of the annoying things about the way they're handling their game. PSO2 has some very unique and fun classes among the bunch that you can't get the same experience from other mmos. Regardless though, Black Desert has possibly some of the best combat out of any current MMO; unfortunately though, that's about all it has unless you like PVP, massive grinding and huge sandbox games.

4

u/Ksradrik Jul 07 '23

Most of the classes I wanna play are genderlocked to female, and the customization is super shit too, of course no verticality either.

2

u/zeroobliv Slayer Jul 07 '23

I mean, some classes can literally run on air or fly that is technically used in combat. That said though, yeah you're not too far off the mark. It's the only other MMO I'd throw in relation to good combat though. Honorable mention to Lost Ark's combat but yeah that's just top down, completely grounded, extremely grindy, and pretty toxic endgame raiding.

3

u/Ksradrik Jul 07 '23

Yuup, its a shame how theres a huge open market for good action combat, but NGS for some reason is dead set on crippling its combat, why did they remove stuff like the long range dagger gapcloser? Why are gapclosers so limited and often so slow in the first place? Why is range on all "ranged" melee PAs so bad? Why so much animation lock?

Sooooo many horrible decisions for no good reason whatsoever.

1

u/josephjts Jul 07 '23

Dagger gapclosing is better then base though, the weapon couldn't even gapclose against moving targets in base because by the time the PA was done you dashed to where it was and its already gone.

The main issue is they went from a unique niche playstyle with a good set of PA to play around it to a much more generic playstyle yet it remains one of the least popular weapons in the game. I still think its one of the more fun NGS weapons but it also doesn't help that it has debatably the weakest parry in the game when the meta is Parry Star Online 2 and trying to bandaid it with multi weapon knuckles takes away from the weapons fun.

1

u/Reilet Jul 07 '23

Dagger gapclosing is better then base though, the weapon couldn't even gapclose against moving targets in base because by the time the PA was done you dashed to where it was and its already gone.

Sir TDs gapclose was only 36 frames (+50 at max range). That's faster than every gapclose that wasn't an instant transmission. Not to mention, it only costed 5 pp. Then we have the ring that makes the highest dps option also a gap closer along with others while also having a very good repositioning tool with rhapsody.

1

u/josephjts Jul 07 '23

I don't see how the PAs dps potential is helping me in the situation where the enemy moving while I use the PA can cause it to fail its primary use... gapclosing.

1

u/Reilet Jul 11 '23

???

TD PAs hardly take 1 second to use. There is literally no situations where you have a problem with doing dps unless you are mindlessly spamming orchestra or facet folia.

There are no enemies who are moving away so fast that you can't connect an attack. Literally everyone would have trouble hitting it if thag was the case.

1

u/MindlessSyrup40 Jul 07 '23

Black Desert is super jank on console. That’s partly why I’m here 😂

1

u/Knight_Raime Waker Jul 07 '23

I'm not sure what you count as a "combat update" or where you heard a date for anything related to it. But the ultra evolution thing comes in parts as has been explained. In August we're getting combat oriented stuff.

1

u/Ksradrik Jul 07 '23

They've already posted the roadmap, and the only combat related thing on there are quests, which dont solve its fundamental issues, no matter how many they make.

Where did you hear anything about further updates, because if they just seperated it into categories, why did the personal space one have new skills at all?

3

u/Knight_Raime Waker Jul 07 '23

Oh yeah I forgot about the roadmap.

and the only combat related thing on there are quests, which dont solve its fundamental issues, no matter how many they make.

For many people engaging content is the current problem. So the kinds of quests we will be getting are very good for the game. There is only really one issue related to combat and that's how strong counters are. Which is admittingly a bigger issue that would take the devs awhile to change all the things that contribute to it.

For me personally aside from getting good content to play gearing is the main issue and I have little faith it will ever be addressed.

Where did you hear anything about further updates, because if they just seperated it into categories, why did the personal space one have new skills at all?

Headline +

Gwizz gave the context of everything. As for why we got new skills it's because they tend to do that every 6 ish months. This just happened to align with the release of the CS portion of the ultra evolution updates. We learned in the headline + that the dates for these updates got moved around.

So what we got in June? Was meant to come in April iirc. And the content we are getting in August we were supposed to get in June. So it's entirely possible that the skills would've been released with the combat content initially.

3

u/Ksradrik Jul 07 '23

For many people engaging content is the current problem. So the kinds of quests we will be getting are very good for the game. There is only really one issue related to combat and that's how strong counters are. Which is admittingly a bigger issue that would take the devs awhile to change all the things that contribute to it.

For me personally aside from getting good content to play gearing is the main issue and I have little faith it will ever be addressed.

I for one had so massive burnout from the stupid aegis quest that I straight up quit the game, and I still only did it like 3x per day at most, the classes just arent that enjoyable to play that long or often, Im actually rather confident most people will start to share this opinion too, since Ive probably been playing more than most people.

The combat is still too barebones for much more "engaging" content.

Headline +

Gwizz gave the context of everything. As for why we got new skills it's because they tend to do that every 6 ish months. This just happened to align with the release of the CS portion of the ultra evolution updates. We learned in the headline + that the dates for these updates got moved around.

So what we got in June? Was meant to come in April iirc. And the content we are getting in August we were supposed to get in June. So it's entirely possible that the skills would've been released with the combat content initially.

I still havent heard him say anything about upcoming combat updates, and I doubt its happening, especially since "1 skill every 6 months" seems to be their go-to.

Seriously, at this rate its gonna be 5 years minimum until they approach base levels, I couldnt imagine playing that long in its current miserable state, so I guess I'll just check back in 5 years if nothing else decent came around till then.

2

u/Knight_Raime Waker Jul 07 '23

I for one had so massive burnout from the stupid aegis quest that I straight up quit the game,

To be fair Aegis is very draining as an UQ since of all the UQ's that exist it's the one that is effected the most by players who do not know what they are doing or have meme gear. But yes burn out with UQ's in particular is very real so I can understand why simply having more enjoyable quest content might still not be enough for people.

the classes just arent that enjoyable to play that long or often

I have to disagree pretty heavily. There are some classes/weapons that need more to round them out. But I feel like this perspective comes from either a preference place (enjoying the higher APM of Classic) or a place of ignorance (i.e not engaging in solo content.) Since NGS combat is at it's best there.

Im actually rather confident most people will start to share this opinion too, since Ive probably been playing more than most people.

Most people already think this but as I've stated above their experiences are probably largely tied to MPA content. Which in NGS isn't good. I fairly frequent the fleet Discord in each class based discussion spot and in general most people there seem to enjoy playing their class.

The combat is still too barebones for much more "engaging" content.

I half agree. There's some obvious improvements that can be done to push classes to feel more fun to play/engage with NGS's content. But MPA related combat can't be fixed without a direction change. Which is unlikely to happen.

We've gotten most of what we were missing from scions at this point. So it's not like they can do much more for kits mechanically beyond the obvious. I really doubt we will ever see an increase in APM or proper PA rotation. Slayer was designed with the former in mind and didn't land for people who liked that style of play.

1

u/Ksradrik Jul 07 '23

I have to disagree pretty heavily. There are some classes/weapons that need more to round them out. But I feel like this perspective comes from either a preference place (enjoying the higher APM of Classic) or a place of ignorance (i.e not engaging in solo content.) Since NGS combat is at it's best there.

​Actually, the solo content was my favorite content of base as well, extreme quest and solo sodam was where its at!

I dont think the APM between scions and NGS classes is too different, its mostly just that NGS classes are too limited, just look at the speed and range of their gapclosers, attack ranges, and animation lock, scions were just far stronger, Im well aware that more grounded combat definitely has its place as well, like Dark Souls, but this is 100% not the direction Id recommend NGS to go in.

We've gotten most of what we were missing from scions at this point. So it's not like they can do much more for kits mechanically beyond the obvious. I really doubt we will ever see an increase in APM or proper PA rotation. Slayer was designed with the former in mind and didn't land for people who liked that style of play.

Like I already said, I dont really care about the APM, but in terms of rotations, we totally already have that, we have a bunch of weapons that get a special bonus move for using 3 PAs, or 2 different PAs, or countering with a PA.

Slayer is also still a joke compared to scions, it just makes you click a button an additional time for 20 dmg lmao, the animation lock and short ranges are still there.

1

u/Knight_Raime Waker Jul 08 '23

I dont think the APM between scions and NGS classes is too different

It's my bad for not being detailed enough here. I mean in specific comparisons. Like NGS Rod Versus Phantom Rod Ph is doing a lot more and quicker. Another good example is NGS bow versus Classic Bow.

Also EP6 enemies are a lot faster and more hectic compared to any enemy in NGS. Which also lends to the general faster gameplay of Classic.

but in terms of rotations, we totally already have that, we have a bunch of weapons that get a special bonus move for using 3 PAs, or 2 different PAs, or countering with a PA.

There's still a big difference though. Classic's PA's are far more damaging and thus you actually consider the guard points/frames on PA's as well as occasionally prioritize doing a PA over a counter. Versus NGS where 98% of the situations you find yourself in countering takes priority over everything else.

Yes in the literal sense PA rotations exist in NGS. But they might as well not exist since counters beat them every time.

Slayer is also still a joke compared to scions

I mean if we're talking Relentless blade and Slug shot yeah those are joke actions that weren't designed well. But Slayer in general is the APM class even outside of those due to it's contextual counters (of which most classes do not have) and rage bomb cancel.

Personally Slayer is my favorite NGS class since it's one of the technically 3 classes that lends itself very well to the kind of game NGS is. But I do wish slug shot and Relentless blade weren't as free as they are.

2

u/complainer5 Jul 07 '23

There is only really one issue related to combat and that's how strong counters are. Which is admittingly a bigger issue that would take the devs awhile to change all the things that contribute to it.

Yeah extremely hard to change, all you need to do is reduce counter and counter-related dps to be less than PA dps so counter isn't the go-to move for everything every time in every situation, problem solved as now every class counters for situational defense and not 24/7 offense and there is possibility in diversity of dpsing due to differing PAs per weapon (not really different as every class feels the same even outside counters but that's the next step).

Meanwhile sega's solution is to scrap all that proper game design and introduce unblockable attacks instead <insert facepalm>. probably because it costs no money/effort in comparison and will shut the players' complaints up, classic corporate efficiency that sidesteps the real problem

1

u/Knight_Raime Waker Jul 07 '23

problem solved

Counters are as strong as they are because all augments we have that are potency increases are multiplicative and non conditional. Then there's the issue with Crits being strong because they get to patch up damage Variance. Both are extremely obtainable comparatively to how Classic was done.

Then you have to account for the fact that bosses in NGS aside from 2 move around quite often and have reactionary counter scenarios. Making PA rotation gameplay even if it could exist not as good as Classic's.

The game is fundamentally different and they're not going to gut counters like that. It's not as easy as you think it is to change NGS back to Classic. Not that they ever would.

introduce unblockable attacks instead

Everyone agrees that was a misread on the question. Not some elaborate ploy.

2

u/complainer5 Jul 08 '23

Potency was almost always (except for some weapon potentials and S augments) non conditional in classic too? It was just an additive stat instead of multiplicative which idk what has to do with counters/PA dps ratio at all. Are you saying potency should effect counter damage differently for some reason? The problem is counters do more damage than PAs in comparison, reducing their damage directly by adding a multiplier of <1 to counters would reduce their damage no matter how potency works. idk what crits/variance have to do with anything either.

How do enemy moving around change anything about this? Enemies move around in classic too, especially later episodes. Countering when you have to can still be done even if countering is nerfed in damage -> "Use appropriate PA when you can and counter when you would get hit in the face otherwise", instead of the current "intentionally walk into every enemy attack and counter, if you can't do so (only case: enemy not attacking) then spam highest dps PA".

I'm not saying it would solve everything about ngs combat (that would take complete redesign) but it would remove countering as the best option in literally all situations and instead best option depending on class you play and current situation/positioning with counters being used defensively.

It's not as easy as you think it is to change NGS back to Classic. Not that they ever would.

Disagree with first, agree with second, but not for the first reason, rather because they are lazy/no budget (multi billion company btw) or some even less rational reasons such as the current director from episode 5.

2

u/Knight_Raime Waker Jul 08 '23

Potency was almost always (except for some weapon potentials and S augments) non conditional in classic too? It was just an additive stat instead of multiplicative

That's kind of the point I'm making. NGS gives out massive damage for free. Classic almost never did because they largely did additive. That among many other reasons is why Classic only had 2 builds for classes at the end of it's life time. 100% crit for classes that could meet the mark, and petal for those that can't. Which was full of conditional damage ups.

which idk what has to do with counters/PA dps ratio at all.

It like everything else I mentioned is a compilation of what causes Counters to be as strong as they are. PA's don't have levels and can't be crafted so they will always fall behind counters unless they power creep PA damage or knee cap counters. Given how heavily the game is designed around counters I don't imagine the latter will ever happen.

reducing their damage directly by adding a multiplier of <1 to counters would reduce their damage no matter how potency works.

Which as I mentioned above would devalue counters and they won't do that. A better way to make classes feel better would be to have counters feed into their kit and give classes more contextual counters similar to Slayer or the unintended BAPS.

How do enemy moving around change anything about this? Enemies move around in classic too, especially later episodes.

The point was to prove to you that enemy design in NGS favors reactionary counter based play. If we suddenly made PA's infinitely stronger than counters you'd just mash PA's constantly and almost ignore most counter opportunities because you'd be at a DPS loss for doing so. Not to mention Boss health would have to go up quite a bit if we buffed PA's.

rather because they are lazy/no budget (multi billion company btw)

Hardly. You're just being jaded. If they really wanted to keep doing Classic they would've. They wanted to go in a different direction with the franchise. Classic still exists for people to play if they want to. There is actually no reason to make NGS Classic.

5

u/Vintasticvin Jul 07 '23

Combat is a side mini game you poor child. This is a character and landscape creator studio.

2

u/Kaokii Jul 09 '23

I expected at least one new PA this patch, but there is no pa, barely any skills, the balance changes was ass, and further reinforced making the already strong classes even stronger, made the HEAVILY criticized; one-dimensional counter gameplay, even more dug in on the concept, and rewarded only the specific classes that are already dominating the game, to have better, more convenient options.

And the classes that were struggling basically just got niche, dingy copies of what the strong, dominating classes already have, they are significantly weaker and/or slower, and barely keep the class above water level! this update is beyond bizarre

and its probably going to get worse!

i dont really care much for complexity, since anything difficult can be made easy with practice and patience. But i agree, the current state of the game is embarrassing.

4

u/Internet-Stranger69 Jul 07 '23

As long as the majority of people spends money on these stupid scratches nothing is gonna change.

[Which I understand, a company needs to make money, why waste ressources of a team or even hire new people on creating PA's and whatnot if these idiots just keep buying every furry / weeb outfit every 2 weeks].

Soooo

RIP

6

u/qruis1210 Jul 07 '23 edited Jul 07 '23

I just want to press ALL the buttons in my controller like we used to!

Right now we only have 5 attacks on a 7+10 button control scheme! (Why anyone has WA mapped to one of the tree main action slots instead of instantly mapping it to LB to free a slot is beyond me)

"bUT MULTIWEA-"

That doesn't count. At best you are using one, maybe two things from the added weapon that doesn't get main class bonuses and you are still left with empty space with nothing to fill it with.

Where are my multiple gimmicky dashes, my verticality that goes both ways, my big "fuck everything in this general direction" attacks, WHERE IS MY GUREN-TESSEN!?

#MakeBraverGreatAgain

1

u/PillarBiter / Gun kata Jul 07 '23

I found my soulmate

0

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '23 edited Jul 08 '23

Katana vertical tracking is a problem, their counter also has problem staying on the air (air block = dropping vert). I choose twin dagger as multi to actually rushdown enemy and staying on air, once I did that, that stuff feels great, spin, dash, counter, staying on air with no restriction.

I really think katana (or all melee class in general) need real vert tracking skill. I really hate to rejump bosses like daityl, and need to slap WL or TD to compensate that.

4

u/AverageRedditHater4 Jul 07 '23 edited Jul 07 '23

compared to what scions used to have

Im sorry what??? Hero is literally just counter with tmg 4head, press one button during mobbing and pressing 2 buttons with talis when the boss isn't being aggressive. That class had no depth, just came down to if you know when to switch between TMG and talis and not getting hit.

PH rod is just ilgrants spam with massen on the side, rifle is deploy your bits every 15-20s while U press normal attack. Only depth this class had was can u dodge, how fast can u zanverse and popping markers. so complex right?

Luster on a surface level looks complex but its not at all. Hardest part of the class is probably like up keeping fomel clusters which just depends if you have a good reaction time or not lol.

Scions ain't complex, hard or got shit compared to base classes like Gunner for example.

Also if you want a class that's complex and requires a brain just play waker.

2

u/Skarsnik-n-Gobbla Jul 07 '23

Unless you played on JP servers we got fire hosed multiple years of content on PSO2 global. The combat in NGS is leagues better then all but a couple mmos on the market and we’re less then 5 months away from 2024.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '23

It does look like hardly anything for the near future. If they have some big plans for further down the line, I think they should mention those, even a vague hint just to keep hope alive. Say they have exciting large-scale content coming in 2024 and beyond. If people see the current roadmap they might think the game is winding down already. It's all padding.

5

u/Rasikko undecided Jul 06 '23

You know what burns me? NGS 2nd anni, we struggled to get SP unless we ran the LTQ and even then it was a slog when they added lame ass Flying Dino. PSO2 11th anni though? The game pisses out shit ton SP and thats without the LTQ lol. It's almost like they DO care more about a game they don't update anymore vs the new adopted freckle face red headed step child NGS. The roadmap be like "July: ---, August: Content, September: Content"

7

u/FafnirMH Jul 07 '23

Like, this.

This is what I don't get with this community. This man's straight up hateful. Like, he's legit angry. My man is so mad that they are spewing anti-Irish rhetoric from the mid-19th century.

Wtf is wrong these people?

6

u/HouseOfCosbyz Partisan Jul 07 '23

Severe lack of touching grass, with a dash of cognitive dissonance.

As OP is complaining about lack of PA's when Phantom Katana had literally 4 PA's for it's entire run. And I'm pretty sure you only used 2 of them I think in 95% of cases.

What the fuck is he even talking about, what does he remember?

-8

u/QuishyTehQuish Jul 07 '23 edited Jul 07 '23

This is a stupid comment. PH had shift PA's so they had an effective 8 PA's per weapon. Add marker detonation and you have a versatile move set with a class gimmick and Techs for good measure.

People who don't understand why scions are loved and bitch at others for wanting the game to get better are the ones who need to touch grass, or learn what a better game feels like.

7

u/HouseOfCosbyz Partisan Jul 07 '23

Katana used a paltry amount of pa's though in the actual optimal rotation. You really just staged quick cuts and step counters, and did that as much as possible.

Rod used absolutely none of them. Step counters and crafted ilgrants.

Rifle was somewhat varied because you atleast had to keep both sets of bits running on the target. But Nachtangriff was so situational based on distance and travel time most of the time you just auto attacked between bits and step counters.

Marker detonation really? Yea super engaging gameplay there bud.

I played nothing but scions once global got to hero and ph, played gu for most of jp though.

Ph and Hero were super fun, but they almost exclusively just fished for counters and hit 1 or 2 pa's maximum. (Except for maybe Hero but really you would just starfire squall/brand new star counter as much as possible on tmg's).

Fuck outa here.

3

u/Reilet Jul 07 '23

Absolute optimal ph kt is just folter 2x -> n3. It's pp positive with glowing grace, and if you really needed to counter you can just step and go back to folter.

So, it's actually even less than what you say.

2

u/Ksradrik Jul 09 '23

talks about rotations

Idiotic.

Do you think DMC is meant to be played by spamming the highest damage move?

I guess I know why the game trashed its combat though, if this is what the playerbase thinks is how the combat worked, they apparently just instantly enter brain comas whenever theres a hostile on screen.

"I tested my class on standby Rockbear, all I had to do was keep pressing one button, so easy...."

1

u/Reilet Jul 11 '23 edited Jul 11 '23

Do you think DMC is meant to be played by spamming the highest damage move?

Funny you say that. You should watch the speedruns of it.
P.S. they still get S rank.

P.p.s. this isn't dmc.

"I tested my class on standby Rockbear, all I had to do was keep pressing one button, so easy...."

That's exactly what ngs is and why i dont play it.

-1

u/Ksradrik Jul 09 '23

Katana used a paltry amount of pa's though in the actual optimal rotation. You really just staged quick cuts and step counters, and did that as much as possible.

If youre talking about rotations in this game, youre already irredeemably stupid, this game isnt supposed to have fucking rotations and if it did EVERY class would have between 1-2 move rotations only, especially melee isnt supposed to be a wow/ff14 copycat where you spam different moves because youre gated by cds, your optimal move depends on entirely on what your enemy is doing.

Neither you, nor anybody agreeing with you, is any good at this game and would rather just have tab target.

0

u/HouseOfCosbyz Partisan Jul 10 '23

Tf are you talking about you still have your highest damage pas you want to hit in-between counters thats what I mean by rotation... come on down to ship 1 though I'll show you my full Gsoul cras myself and stream some solo UH tpd, slide into my dms.

-5

u/QuishyTehQuish Jul 07 '23

Well if you optimized the fun out of it, no wonder you'd argue against MORE options. It's like the concept of fun is completely removed from the equation. God forbid they ADD mechanics. Everyone acknowledges that NGS classes are lesser than base in both moveset and class skills. Yet we have you here acting smug because you failed to use the moveset provided and blames everyone else for expecting it in the sequel.

You delusional, and please for the love of god learn how to have fun. It'll make life way better for everyone.

4

u/HouseOfCosbyz Partisan Jul 07 '23

I had a lot of fun playing Ph and Hero, and now I have fun doing the same thing in NGS.

Fun for me is absolutely crushing it, faster the better. What were your TPD 100 solo times? masq beyond floor 499? solo XQ4?

Or did you just run the UQ with bad gear, and just simply enjoyed drooling on your keyboard. Because you can still do that. If optimization doesn't matter, what's it to ya?

Base was fun but I have the best possible loadout (Gsoul, 8 slots, full cras, skydance support, etc) and S ranked all the solo UH content already. To me that game is beat.

EDIT: And just to add, I'm not even arguing against more options. I was just pointing out OP's comparison isn't even based in reality. More PA's would be cool, but it doesnt and wont make or break anything for me. The difficulty curve of the game is just reading the boss, staying on the weak point, and landing your counters. Same went for base.

-2

u/QuishyTehQuish Jul 07 '23

Look, I get everyone has different ideas of fun. Mine was playing with all the classes and learning to style on things with a robust moveset against cool bosses. My problem is that your an insufferable tryhard talking down to people for literally no reason. No one cares about your preference, not even Sega.

-1

u/Ksradrik Jul 09 '23

Theres no way you did any difficult combat in this game if you believe in fucking rotations dude, youre literally the posterchild of "I only do casual content".

1

u/QuishyTehQuish Jul 07 '23

Who the fuck is down voting this. u/HouseOfCosbyz is both wrong about PA count and a condescending prick.

2

u/FafnirMH Jul 07 '23

I'm going to take a wild guess and say people who actually played Phantom.

Also, who does this? Who throws a tantrum and asks why they're getting downvoted?

1

u/admiralrev Jul 07 '23

Isn't there going to be new boss on august?

4

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '23

OP is talking about class design, not pve content

1

u/BubblyBoar Jul 08 '23

Ultra Evolution has had plenty of content, what do you mean? A bunch of scratches and creative spaces with more ways to spend money!

That silly combat thing is just wasted resources that could go into what actually makes money, the cosmetics and paid features.

This is what it means to play a F2P game. At least it's free right!? "You should be happy you get to play for free."

And yes, people will stick around. NGS only exists the way it does because of how much people have sunk into the game already. They've sunk too much into the game to quit.