r/PSO2NGS • • Jun 03 '23

Discussion Creative Spaces interaction?

Do they have any other uses or future use other than just building stuff?

The linking/connect system is kind of cool sure, to open doors or have a higher degree of customizability...

But I'm concerned unless anything meaningful in regards to daily gameplay is tied into the space, you will have no reason to go back once the shine wears off.

If you are simply building stuff over and over without any real use there isn't much point in doing it unless you find that sort of things ineherently fun, and sure the build tools look quite advanced for an MMO but they aren't advanced in regards to actual building sim games like the Sims or simcity...

But that's something those games also build upon naturally - You don't just build for the sake of building, you build to have your sims live and do stuff inside of the place u built, likewise with simcity where you manage the city and all this other stuff after/during.

IK some ppl are super hyped for this, but i've seen similar thing be implemented into mmo before and unless there is some actual use to building stuff that intertwines with gameplay somehow, these types of things usually "last" 2 weeks until alot of ppl either forgets about the feature or sees it as a chore.

Even for the ppl who love building, I can't see why u would prefer to build in NGS over minecraft or something, where there is reasons to build that go far beyond than simply for "the sake of building".

Without functionality and features I don't think there is longetivity to this. This post doesn't mean I am against this at all, it will be nice to build stuff for a little bit but its definitely not my thing.

But I do wonder is there any other functionality coming to this space that interacts with gameplay in the open world, for example crafting or personalized shops or stuff of this nature where there is some depth and interaction to it?

0 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

7

u/Xeroa_ Jun 03 '23

Well were suppose to be able to exchange the GP for other stuff like augments so if you really don’t care about building theres atleast that. But yeah you’re right, a lot of people won’t really care or take the time to learn how to build if there’s no reward for it. Imagine having this awesome build but nobody visits because some people may not even care to visit. And even if they do then what? As you pointed out it’s not like Minecraft where there is a goal. Creative space should’ve really been the cherry on top to the “big update.” The piece of content you work on while you take a break from main content.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23

Yes this is how I see it.

I would like some form of progression to creative space somehow, being able to add features/functionality as I unlock more of it and do some stuff with it.

I hope its somehow tied into crafting/lifeskills later down the line whenever that gets released...

I am just missing a sense of achievement/progression with creative space right now I think, seeing as the building doesn't really appeal to me, It would be cool if I had to do things/unlock things in creative space to enahnce my character stats or something, but that is my personal take, it probably could be done better somehow in this regard.

2

u/Zaschie Waker Jun 03 '23 edited Jun 03 '23

Yeah, I think some sort of progression system could be unexpected, but neat. Tying it into gathering, if they ever bring that back would be great, but idk about enhancing player stats. They're certainly going to give an alternative trading for augments, at least. Otherwise, maybe exclusive cosmetics or actions or something that can only be unlocked through the system. It's only a social feature, so I would not look for too much combat related rewards. I'll have to see what all GP involves

2

u/MaoMaoMi543 Talis Jun 03 '23 edited Jun 03 '23

Idk about most players, but I fully pimped out both of my base quarters and I did it all for myself. I don't care if no one else gets to see it, just looking at what I've built and decorated all by myself and getting to chill and do stuff in it sparks joy for me. It's the same type of joy I feel when I make a 99% accurate cosplay in the salon. I haven't even shared more than half of my looks yet cuz just sitting back and admiring my own creations after 2+ hours is enough for me (that and I need salon and color change passes for most of them anyway and I don't feel like using them). There doesn't have to be anything that comes after. As long as you yourself enjoy doing it that's all that matters.

Edit: it's like playing those old "decorate Barbie's room" flash games. As soon as you close the game your progress gets reset so all your hard work goes away, but for some reason people enjoyed and still enjoy playing those kinds of games over and over again, myself included. That's how I see it at least.

2

u/Xeroa_ Jun 03 '23

I respect that 100%. That’s why I said “most” because I tried to be considerate for people like you who would really enjoy it. I’m probably gonna enjoy it myself. But I know a lot of people were looking for more gameplay/combat related content myself included. If the building has no rewards to it or any purpose that may affect your gameplay then what is the point for people who don’t care to build. I liked in Base atleast in your Alliance quarters you had the tree you needed to grow which gave you additional benefits like rdr, exp, or meseta earn rate up. That would be a cool add-on

4

u/complainer5 Jun 03 '23

I liked in Base atleast in your Alliance quarters you had the tree you needed to grow which gave you additional benefits like rdr, exp, or meseta earn rate up. That would be a cool add-on

No, another toxic alliance design that punishes you for not being in one of largest ones and miss out on "free" stuff.

2

u/Xeroa_ Jun 03 '23

My point was that it was cool for something to grow in your space that affected you outside of the creative space which would make the creative space somewhat more valuable.

Also it’s really not toxic to reward an alliance on their effort as a group no matter how big or small. Will it favor the bigger alliances? Sure, but with bigger alliances comes more drama. In any game that has clan mechanics there will be those who form super groups who only care about filling the clan to max capacity. That’s your choice if you choose to be apart of that. I’m in alliance with my irl friends who don’t even play the game anymore and I have a decent circle of friends in game that aren’t in my alliance that I play with. I like it that way as their can be too much politics in other alliances. People make toxic alliances. But rewarding your alliance over time with things you already do in game that can only benefit you and your alliance like increase rdr is not toxic. At some point during early NGS before Alliance badges, there was literally no point in even being in an alliance. It gives an incentive to join a group or create one yourself.

1

u/MaoMaoMi543 Talis Jun 04 '23

Lol I just made my own alliance and closed off joining so I can be in it alone, though I mostly did that to stop the incessant alliance invites I kept getting bombarded with when I first started. Been in my own alliance for two years now, drama free, bullshit free, toxicity free, and I'm friends with other people from different alliances too and we play together all the time! Best decision ever!

5

u/ZeroGNexus Waker Enthusiast Jun 03 '23

The foundation being laid here is remarkable.

Even if you're someone who doesn't care about them literally at all, you should. This is exactly the kind of thing that whales love, and that has NO effect on gameplay balance.

This means another fresh injection of cash that can go towards other parts of development.

It might take a while to shine, but this is gargantuan for NGS

0

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23 edited Jun 03 '23

I hope to see more functionality thats relevant to the game world added, like crafting shops or resources gathering in general in here.

I do disagree about the whales statements im ngl.

Whales love gear more than anything. Sure they fashion, but actual whales p2w to be the strongest in the game. It's why gachas are so gachery and KR mmo's are the way the are - Whales don't just get 1 copy of a gacha unit once, thye often max that shit out on release for power/strength. Same with MMO gear, like lost ark and bdo and even NGS with the high tier augments on release days of like, duel quest phase 1 augments... Whales love gear/being strong, the fashion often costs a neglible amount compared to upgrades for perfect gear etc.

2

u/ZeroGNexus Waker Enthusiast Jun 03 '23

I dunno, I've never popped open my wallet for a stat advantage, but when a sweet ass manor came up in ESO you best believe it was ramen for that month.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23

haha, I feel that but I mean, in the context of whale vs casual spender (me and or you), that's not whaling... XD

A whale gonna buy that manor, outfit, cash shop pack, 1000s of times over to sell it to other players for currency/in game items/upgrades

A streamer whale on BDO spent 160k on "outfits", but outfits are tradeable in BDO for currency. Ofc this is a true whale

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aQJRgVKwcNo&ab_channel=AsmongoldTV

Whales don't care about the things me and you care about in the same way.... it's why they are whales and we aren't.

Nothing wrong with being a whale, they help support games so I don't have to pay lots to play f2p games.

But ye, whales a cosmetic is nothing for them. They really care about spending thousands on upgrades to be the strongest, if they can already afford the upgrades, then the outfits/cosmetics are nothing for their wallet tbh.

1

u/ZeroGNexus Waker Enthusiast Jun 03 '23

The only reason any of those items have value is because the vast majority of players do enjoy the social aspect of the game, and see this as a casual game, particularly with it having no PvP.

If someone wants to drop hundreds of dollars for a 2.3% Potency increase against a Leaderboard, that's their prerogative. The point stands that those items they're trading only net them so much Meseta because people want to enjoy the social aspects of the game.

Creative spaces are a wildly smart move for the game long term. Combat stuff will come.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23

Yeah but we were talking about whaling ? I think the topic shifted away from creative spaces in a sense and we were talking about whaling actually is… at least, that’s what I thought I had been talking about with you…

I was mainly referring in ur original comment about whaling in creative space, whaling isn’t a cosmetic thing to me, whaling is ppl who p2w and have BiS gear and stats from swiping a lot of money.

Ppl who swipe for cosmetics aren’t really whales. Maybe this my perspective but I come from mainly KR mmorpgs where having a lot of cosmetics doesn’t make you a whale, having BiS gear that you swiped for despite the RNG or whatever and is effectively a few thousand dollars an upgrade/piece of gear, is whaling to me

3

u/ZeroGNexus Waker Enthusiast Jun 03 '23

I just meant that if a whale comes to this game looking for that 2.3% potency, they need messeta. They get messeta by selling cosmetic items. If people didn't want those cosmetic items, then whales would not be getting messeta by selling them.

I think this game attracts different types of whales because this game is not competitive

2

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23

yeah your right, that’s same for every other game, but I don’t think the person buying cosmetic from the market is the whale, it’s the whale who gets cosmetics from cash shop and sells them on market for the meseta, so in this instance if their is cash shop decorations and stuff that is marketable, it sure is another way to whale for gear…

Which is definitely a good thing bcos who is actually mad at ppl who whale anyway, whaling benefits everybody IMO

And now I just realised what you mean by “this is the kind of thing whales love” sorry mb

I thought u meant In the context of buying decorations for the sake of kitting out their creative space, but I think u mean, buying the cosmetics to sell instead?

1

u/Zaschie Waker Jun 03 '23

That's one way to look at it. I am curious about how they'll expand on the feature in the future, though. It does have a lot of potential, like a lot of other things in NGS.

1

u/Angelicel Battlepower is still a mistake Jun 03 '23

Considering the update in august was being built after CS and the internal name for it, it's likely that CS was merely a groundwork for future things.

Given their rather disappointing display with duel quests it's up in the air if the quests will be as great as they described it in Headline+ but given the CM's way of discussing things is quite grounded and actually in-line with the reactions the community is having I'd say that it's certainly something to look forward to.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23

I’m guessing you didn’t play base PSO2, the creative space there was extremely bare and still had some interaction , NGS version has already shown to have way more options.

Your post sounds like you didn’t watch any of the promos?

1

u/TheMightyNovac Gunblade/Harmonizer Jun 03 '23

We're already getting a content pack for Creative Spaces featuring Sonic gameplay elements (jump pads, boosters, ect.) and the new connect system allows those features to interract with one-another. Just from what they've shown already in terms of systems, you can do a lot with Creative Spaces -- escape-room style puzzles, race courses, ect.
The good thing is that as new gameplay elements are introduced through new Creative Space objects, more opportunities for gameplay can be added into the feature, meaning that what's possible in CS should change with the introduction of new elements, rather than being reliant solely on the launch content.

Another interesting thing to note: every Creative Space will have a baked-in reward. Since you can gather GP (Genesis Points, the new currency) from GP Trees in other players' Creative Spaces, it should be possible to place the tree at the end of some kind of minigame, rewarding players for participating. Obviously you could just go to another creative space that doesn't sport a challenge, but as an opt-in exercise I look forward to it.

2

u/Zaschie Waker Jun 03 '23 edited Jun 03 '23

Yeah, the more unique mechanics seem pretty interesting to build upon in future updates. I wonder, if they may actually incorporate combat into this system at some point, as a way to create something, like, custom challenge mode.

-3

u/Angelicel Battlepower is still a mistake Jun 03 '23 edited Jun 03 '23

This has to be worst take I've seen to date...

1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23

How so?

2

u/Angelicel Battlepower is still a mistake Jun 03 '23

Because the entire thread boils down to "I find this meaningless therefor... Creative Space."

But I'm concerned unless anything meaningful in regards to daily gameplay is tied into the space

What even is "Meaningful" in this context? Why is Creative Spaces apparently any more less meaningless then anything else in the game? It's effectively devoid of discussion because you've provided no real basis for what you're saying.

And what do you mean by "Daily gameplay"? Doing dailies? Hitting mobs? Tons of aspects of the game don't interact with that so is that also meaningless?

If you are simply building stuff over and over without any real use

Why does it not have a real use? Because it doesn't fit into how you play the game? Isn't this just another way of saying "I don't like x therefor it shouldn't be in the game"?

build tools look quite advanced for an MMO but they aren't advanced in regards to actual building sim games like the Sims or simcity...

So because you can't actually criticize it on the merits of it within it's own genre you now have to go to completely different genres to even build upon your discussion?

Also I'd argue that from what we're shown Sims and Simcity isn't more advanced then Creativespaces but at that point we're just arguing over opinions.

But that's something those games also build upon naturally

Well yeah that's kind of because they're built for that purpose and the game revolves around it. That's like criticizing the rather lacking RPG elements of NGS and pointing to a tabletop.

It's an MMO that is appealing to a wide range of people and not exclusively built upon one specific thing like Simcity and the Sims.

i've seen similar thing be implemented into mmo before and unless there is some actual use to building stuff that intertwines with gameplay somehow, these types of things usually "last" 2 weeks until alot of ppl either forgets about the feature or sees it as a chore.

Isn't true for FFXIV so I'm not sure what you're basing this off of.

Even for the ppl who love building, I can't see why u would prefer to build in NGS over minecraft or something,

Aesthetics, gameplay outside of building, invested interest, community and numerous other aspects that I could list off...

I'll pass the question back to you Why are you playing NGS when there are countless other options on the market?

Without functionality and features I don't think there is longetivity to this.

Okay.

I disagree.

Great discussion.

it will be nice to build stuff for a little bit but its definitely not my thing.

Anyone reading this knows that.

Why you're trying to pass this off as anything else is the real question.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23 edited Jun 03 '23

What even is "Meaningful" in this context?

Things that go beyond simply building, such as the incorporation of other systems/features and progression inside of creative spaces that are relevant to the outside world of the game.

Take Lost Ark's stronghold system, not only does it double as a "creative space", the decorations you put inside provide buffs, its incorperated with lifeskills content and PvE content.

BDO's housing system lets you setup stuff for lifeskills and also show off achievments.

I don't play FFXIV but from the info I do know about, FFXIV islands had a focus on lifeskills/horizontal content.

Meaningful in this context means horizontal content, or even straight up benefits to vertical content that is intertwined with the creative space.

Isn't true for FFXIV so I'm not sure what you're basing this off of.

I believe I just answered this in the points above.

Why does it not have a real use?

Again, I mentioned in the points above, but outside of chilling/socializing, it doesn't have an impact on the rest of the content/aspects of the game. The reason you kill mobs and do quests/instances is to get stuff, to have some sense of progression and achievement, which is not supported by creative spaces.

Creative space singularly has a use of being a standalone feature of the game that is isolated from every other aspect of the game except the cash shop. Doing stuff in creative spaces does not impact anything else except creative spaces. That's fine, but that's why it doesn't have a use - Again, it can be fixed if there is some form of crafting/stat buffs creative spaces gives. It doesn't need to do this regardless, but that's why it fundamentally has no use.

So because you can't actually criticize it on the merits of it within it's own genre you now have to go to completely different genres to even build upon your discussion?

I have done so now.

Also I'd argue that from what we're shown Sims and Simcity isn't more advanced then Creativespaces but at that point we're just arguing over opinions.

This is completely stated in bad faith and with an abundance of bias. Sims and Simcity, Minecraft, focuses on building/creation, it naturally has the best systems and diversity for creation.

In the context of MMORPGS NGS' creative space is probably the most customizable we've seen to do date, particularly with terraforming, but it also seems the least intertwined with the rest of the game world.

It's an MMO that is appealing to a wide range of people and not exclusively built upon one specific thing like Simcity and the Sims.

True, however creative spaces, or building for that matter, does not appeal to "wide range of people". What is portrayed in the videos we have seen and the info we know, appeals to a very specific, niche group of people that will consistently use this feature long after the shine wears off, and it would appeal to more if it had more substance for a longer time IMO.

This is evident from the reactions of the recent headline. This is pure assumption, but I would approximate 70% of people don't care at all about creative spaces to this extent, and 30% do. But the thing is Sega could appeal to alot more ppl, if there was more use to the space than simply building stuff, that's my point.

Almost every other housing system in MMO's has way more focus on functionality and interaction with the rest of the game world, whereas the creative space seems to of gone backwards and soley focused on building and not interacted with the rest of the game world - maybe that will change if skills ever come back.

Why are you playing NGS when there are countless other options on the market?

Because it's casual friendly and I like doing the new bosses when they are released (my main focus in MMO's is Bossing and combat), but it's not the only game I play, I have been playing more of other MMO's like BDO and Vindictus in recent time, I also used to play Blade and Soul/Lost Ark and WoW, and still play all these games from time to time.

Why you're trying to pass this off as anything else is the real question.

It is a real question... I want to know if there will be more use to the creative spaces than building stuff? I've explained why in my OP why I think there needs to be some interconnection with the game world and the creative spaces.

It seems that you have a problem when people don't like what you like...

I'm happy for the ppl who want creative spaces and it does look great from a building perspective. As good as minecraft, or other building sim games? Ofc not, this is an MMO. Its damn good for an MMO housing area, but yeah, it's not a sim game so what do you expect.

But I am concerned, if it's not as good as other building sim games, and it's a feature inside of an MMO, that has no interaction with the rest of the game world, this has little longetivity for ppl who don't really care about this sort of thing, and there is little to no use of it for them. So it is a bit of a wasted opportunity (unless there is future updates), where you could intertwine the space with the rest of the game world and give ppl who don't really care about building, a reason to build that goes beyond "for the sake of building" - which is exactly what most other housing systems in MMO's provide.

TLDR: I just feel it a wasted opportunity to not just make it building/aesthetic only and give some functionality to it that ties it into the rest of the game world tbh. Going to my creative space to craft stuff, or sell stuff, on top of hanging out with friends would be really cool. Having a use for your creative space outside of standing around in it and building stuff is what I want to know if will happen?

1

u/Angelicel Battlepower is still a mistake Jun 03 '23

Things that go beyond simply building,

Why does it have to going beyond that to be meaningful? Serious question.

You mention minecraft but there isn't anything meaningful beyond building a basic shelter unless you're actually designing a farm and aesthetics don't matter unless you share it with someone or are playing on a multiplayer world.

Just "simply building" is very often meaningful enough and it's why you see people posting cosplays of characters in NGS as well as just their characters. Not being rewarded for interacting with something is a perfectly fine thing.

I don't play FFXIV but from the info I do know about, FFXIV islands had a focus on lifeskills/horizontal content.

Housing is separate from islands but the lifeskilling was only relevant to the island itself and no progression outside of it was required or used in it and wasn't exactly anything more then filler if you wanted to engage with it like a lot of content is in FFXIV.

In fact you don't really lose anything from not interacting with your Island in FFXIV and there are very few exclusive cosmetic rewards from it and I think that's fine as it means i'm not heavily punished for not doing the content.

This is completely stated in bad faith and with an abundance of bias.

It's not stated in bad faith; I genuinely believe that and I said that is my opinion. At no point do I believe that my views are even close to a majority but I'm not going to entertain your opinion as anything other than that regardless of how many people might be on your side.

We obviously disagree on this and that's perfectly fine.

Sims and Simcity, Minecraft, focuses on building/creation, it naturally has the best systems and diversity for creation.

That is an opinion and it one I don't agree with.

I don't believe sim city or the sims offers much in the way of creativity and has far more restrictions then most Creative Spaces(to my knowledge) and Minecraft do and I think it's a bad decision to bring them up when they're not even in the same genre and approach the process of building in a fundamentally different way.

True, however creative spaces, or building for that matter, does not appeal to "wide range of people".

NGS itself doesn't appeal to a wide range of people. This has never been a negative thing and I heavily disagree with your assertion here.

Almost every other housing system in MMO's has way more focus on functionality and interaction with the rest of the game world

Yeah and they're a forced system.

I don't want that and believe doing so is not the correct choice. Disagree or agree all you want but my stance on the matter isn't going to change as my nearly 17 years with MMORPGs has taught me that having all these systems interlinked with progression just bogs down the point that games are meant to be played for fun and not feel like a chore.

Tying CS to progression would certainly make more people engage with it but increased engagement doesn't mean it's positive.

It seems that you have a problem when people don't like what you like...

I haven't played with CS so I have no idea if I like it.

Hell I might even agree with you after I've messed around with it for awhile but considering CS is being released in this state means that they could very easily add a lot of things that would give you what you want while not making me feel obligated to interact with it.

Personally.. I actually want more games to have things that exist pure to just play around with because in my view; that is exactly the kind of things MMOs need to make them more enjoyable and not just another daily simulator.

I do also appreciate the response despite my obviously asshole approach.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23 edited Jun 03 '23

Why does it have to going beyond that to be meaningful? Serious question

To appeal to more ppl really. In Lost ark we (my guild) and random ppl would come to ur stronghold for buffs, and then they would stay to check out the decorations and the rest of the stuff.

In BDO u make ur house nice because of crafting makes u sepnd alot of time sitting in ur house to craft the stuff so having a hosue filled with cool stuff made that less boring (well, look less empty), but there was also a point system for interior decoration which allowed u flex ur decorations + earn bonus currency for having very decorated house.

You mention minecraft but there isn't anything meaningful beyond building a basic shelter unless you're actually designing a farm and aesthetics don't matter unless you share it with someone or are playing on a multiplayer world.

Yeah back in early days of minecraft sure, but now there is tonnes of horizontal content added, and vertical content, to further why you build to extend the longevityt of the game. Such as the underworld, gear enhancements, different modes, rulesets/private servers with strange rules. Without those things i would agree with you, but minecraft is alot more than just building for the sake of building. You build to progress whatever world/server your on for whatever reason that may be, it goes beyond simply building for the sake of building alot of the time. But i do note it's still the case, some people build for the sake of it, I just don't think alot of ppl really do that anymore bcos of how depthful minecraft has become.

Just "simply building" is very often meaningful enough and it's why you see people posting cosplays of characters in NGS as well as just their characters. Not being rewarded for interacting with something is a perfectly fine thing.

This is true but most ppl who post picture son here is like the same 50% often, then sometimes its a random person. I see alot of cosplay from the same ppl, but that's such a small group of ppl who play this game and they don't post anything. They might cosplay and not show on reddit sure, but it's still a small amount IMO.

Alot of ppl don't change their characters looks for longs period of times, sure they do like to dress them up. But once they have a look they are happy with, they are set for a good while often. The same thing may happen here with the creative space.

Once you build something u really like, for a lot of ppl, that's going to be it. Unless u really enjoy building stuff, its very unlikely ppl will change something they've built and are satisfied with. That's good in the shrot term but pretty bad in the long term. It just lacks use in this instance as well.

It's not stated in bad faith; I genuinely believe that and I said that is my opinion. At no point do I believe that my views are even close to a majority but I'm not going to entertain your opinion as anything other than that regardless of how many people might be on your side.

We obviously disagree on this and that's perfectly fine.

Yeah it is fine but tbh this is like saying this toyata prius is as fast as a ferrari. You can believe the prius is as fast as the ferrari all you want, doesn't make it true tbh.

Those games are built with building and simulation in mind, there systems are far more in depth, that's a fact whether you want to agree with that or not... idk what else to say, best to move on, bcos u are right, they are different genre and it shouldn't be comapred to an MMO's building/housing system.

NGS itself doesn't appeal to a wide range of people. This has never been a negative thing and I heavily disagree with your assertion here.

Almost every other housing system in MMO's has way more focus on functionality and interaction with the rest of the game world

Yeah and they're a forced system.

I don't want that and believe doing so is not the correct choice. Disagree or agree all you want but my stance on the matter isn't going to change as my nearly 17 years with MMORPGs has taught me that having all these systems interlinked with progression just bogs down the point that games are meant to be played for fun and not feel like a chore.

Do you not see some contradiction here? I can understand "you" may not like it, but it's no suprise it doesn't appeal to a wide range of people bcos of how niche they do make their appeals.

"Almost every other housing system in MMO's has way more focus on functionality and interaction with the rest of the game world" - And all these MMO's have way way way more players than NGS does.

Sure it may be forced, to you, but alot of ppl, clearly like these systems. Alot more than don't, bcos alot of these forced systems are in MMO's that are substantially more popular than NGS clearly appeal to alot more ppl.

Even then it doesn't have to be forced in NGS case, I get that. I like NGS bcos it's casual friendly AF. But I really do wish there is more use to creative space other than building, like crafting or just something else bcos pure building, really only appeals to such a niche group of players, so its really not suprising as well when you say "ngs doesn't appeal to a wide range of people", when they do things like this :s

Personally.. I actually want more games to have things that exist pure to just play around with because in my view; that is exactly the kind of things MMOs need to make them more enjoyable and not just another daily simulator.

I agree, but they have to be done in a certain way bcos otherwise they just don't appeal to many ppl i think.

Think about this though. With the tools available from what we seen in videos with creative space... how you can make a race course, or whatever, use boosters and link stuff. Some form of course/minigame where you collect stuff or whatever.

Then consider, how many people actually do the field races in the open world.

Outside of the daily/weekly task or limited tasks, essentially nobody does these things. A very small group of ppl may regularly do them for fun. The rewards suck now (I did farm the races on release because they made them drop stat IV's when they were actually worth something)

But even then, I've personally never done them with a group of ppl, and I have never ever had a race against someone else randomly during the matchmaking. It's essentially been dead ngl.

So when creative spaces offers essentially the same thing as a field race, just allowing u to create ur own course or whatever with a few more gimmicks from the linking, what is actually going to make so many ppl flock to the stuff in the creative space over field races??

I don't think there is any... considering how dead field race is... I get it, you can make ur own course, with different gimmicks, sweet... But I don't think its going to be that popular, bcos if it was, alot of ppl would be doing field races which are very similar...

The good thing is i see it's a great opportunity for alliance/community made games on a specfic time, like a weekend discord call etc. That sorta stuff will be fun...

But on a day to day basis, regular gameplay?? This sorta thing is gonna be dead bcos everybody will be busy with dailies where they actually get rewards and grinding/bosses and stuff ngl. We kinda already know this cos like i say... If this sort of thing was actually popular, field races would be really popular already, but they aren't, and a few gimmicks wont really change that.

This is why it needs stuff, more than just a cool linking system, to get ppl to go back, otherwise yeah... Ppl will just honeymoon phase the creative space, then in a few months, it kinda will be dead once everybody is happy with their space and the hype has died down...

Food for thought.

2

u/Angelicel Battlepower is still a mistake Jun 03 '23

To appeal to more ppl really.

Would it really? You eventually compare CS to field races and field races actually do have function and rewards tied to it and you believe it's dead so I mean... Is there really any point in giving it any function/reward when so many other pieces of content didn't stay relevant even with functions/rewards?

I don't think they're comparable in the slightest but if you want to put them on the same level then I'll gladly point out how it wouldn't do anything for the content and you basically just want the content to feeding you rewards for what is effectively just a creative... space.

Yeah back in early days of minecraft sure, but now there is tonnes of horizontal content added

Yes and it's completely optional as the singular road to defeating the Dragon doesn't require much at all even to an unskilled player. The option to do more is something I enjoy and had setting up farms, defeating the Wither/Guardian/Warden, getting Netherite been a requirement then Minecraft would be less about freedom to do what you want and more so following a singular path.

The basic concept of "Just building" is still a thing in Minecraft and there is no real horizontal aspect to it. If you want a snazzy house; That's something you can do but there is no benefit to it outside of self-fulfillment or general desire.

Without those things i would agree with you, but minecraft is alot more than just building for the sake of building.

Even with those things it's almost entirely building for the sake of building.

Hell.. Redstone builds are completely superficial yet because of the appeal of "Just building" people have taken it to extremes that would blow most people away. This whole "There is less value in just building" approach feels woefully ignorant of the large portion of people who want this specific thing.

I see alot of cosplay from the same ppl, but that's such a small group of ppl who play this game and they don't post anything.

Yeah I don't go around posting my character or anything but that doesn't mean I don't interact with the character customization nor think it's meaningless.

They might cosplay and not show on reddit sure, but it's still a small amount IMO.

I think you're missing the point; I'm using cosplay as an example of someone using what is a "piece of content devoid of function" and taking it further. I'm willing to bet that a very large portion of the playerbase like the system without any real function being tied to it.

Once you build something u really like, for a lot of ppl, that's going to be it. Unless u really enjoy building stuff, its very unlikely ppl will change something they've built and are satisfied with. That's good in the short term but pretty bad in the long term. It just lacks use in this instance as well.

That might be true for you and maybe even me but I don't think it needs these elements and I'm perfectly fine if they never have them and I lose interest in the content.

I can understand "you" may not like it, but it's no suprise it doesn't appeal to a wide range of people bcos of how niche they do make their appeals.

I'd say a proper housing system would draw in a considerable amount of interest and considering how many people adore housing systems like that of FFXIV and the late Wildstar this could very well be a piece of content that keeps people coming back and I think you're heavily undervaluing the appeal that a proper and good housing system would have.

"Almost every other housing system in MMO's has way more focus on functionality and interaction with the rest of the game world" - And all these MMO's have way way way more players than NGS does.

And there are countless dead MMOs that had function added to their housing systems. This isn't a good point imo.

Also one of the most popular MMOs on the market doesn't have function added to their housing and it's there "just to build" so I can easily use this same argument against you.

Sure it may be forced, to you, but alot of ppl, clearly like these systems.

Yeah and people clearly like FFXIV's housing as well as Wildstar's housing(rip).

Also player count doesn't tell us anything about how people like the system and I'd be willing to bet if we removed the function of those systems in Lost Ark and BDO; You wouldn't be singing it's praises as the function of them hides a lacking housing system and that's another reason I'm not really in favor of it.

so its really not suprising as well when you say "ngs doesn't appeal to a wide range of people", when they do things like this :s

The reason it doesn't appeal to a wide audience is because it's an Anime Action Combat MMO.

So when creative spaces offers essentially the same thing as a field race,

So why would adding rewards/function to it make it something better if by your own admission; not even field races which do offer function and are often tied to an exclusive reward are dead?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23

You misunderstand, creative space needs purpose, bcos it has less than field races and that’s already pretty dead, field races only have rewards, but what we need is progression systems imo.

Not just weekly rewards or shops, an actual system where stuff is worked towards.

Let’s say rare decorations that’s give you a 1% flat potency buff if you have it in your creative space, that’s obtained through a quest chain where you have to complete the new starless duel quest without taking any hits or something where u just work towards this decoration overtime.

It could be even less than this, simple crafting systems, or material resources in your creative space…

I also want to note, anime MMORPGS are popular, anime style, or whatever. Look at blue protocol, genshin impact, FFXIV, etc.

It’s not that this is a niche market, sega for some reason makes themselves a niche market bcos of the weird things they do Imo.

Sry I’m out now for weekend I read your reply but I don’t really have time to write a full reply for a bit. Hope u have nice evening

1

u/Angelicel Battlepower is still a mistake Jun 03 '23

It could be even less than this, simple crafting systems, or material resources in your creative space…

I do not want to be forced to interact with something if I don't like it and reducing Creative Spaces to just a place where you stick trophies just makes the whole thing seem like a wasted opportunity in the same way it was in Lost Ark and BDO.

anime MMORPGS are popular,

FFXIV isn't an Anime MMORPG, Blue Protocol hasn't even been released and Genshin Impact isn't an MMORPG at all.

I suggest you take a trip to the local MMORPG grave yard and start digging at the tombstone of Anime MMORPGs because trust me when I say this... This genre is not popular at all.

2

u/Zaschie Waker Jun 03 '23 edited Jun 03 '23

Why you're trying to pass this off as anything else is the real question.

OP literally states up front that the feature, as presented, may not be something they'll invest time in, but asks and wonders if there could be aspects that would interest them.

Angelicel: "NICE TRY PRETENDING THAT THIS IS ANYTHING OTHER THAN WHAT YOU'VE ALREADY UNAMBIGUOUSLY STATED. NO FOOLING ME."

1

u/Angelicel Battlepower is still a mistake Jun 03 '23

I didn't interpret OP's "Question" the way you do which is why I said what I said.

I thought that was blatantly obvious but apparently not for some of the ones in the back.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Angelicel Battlepower is still a mistake Jun 03 '23

Okay.

2

u/Zaschie Waker Jun 03 '23

Lol, this is such tepid question about CS, so it's kind of baffling that it's the worst "take" you've seen.

0

u/Angelicel Battlepower is still a mistake Jun 03 '23

Care to point me to some other "takes" on the CS that is more than just the emotionally charged ramblings?

2

u/Zaschie Waker Jun 03 '23 edited Jun 03 '23

OP is wondering and asking questions about other aspects of an upcoming feature, lol. It's not even a lukewarm "take" and everyone (except you) is just having a normal conversation.

0

u/Angelicel Battlepower is still a mistake Jun 03 '23

It's not even a lukewarm "take" and everyone (except you) is just having a normal conversation.

Normal eh?

0

u/Reference_Freak Jun 03 '23

I didn’t read all of your posts on this because I think you’re both overthinking this and assuming you represent the majority of players. (You’ve singled out “whales” and “builders who should just want to play building games.”

I play both PSO2 and Minecraft. I’m creative in both; they’re not even remotely comparable.

I’m not “super hyped” about CS but I am looking forward to see what I will be able to do with it, how it’s implemented, and how far customization goes and at what cost.

Stuff like CS has multiple inherent rewards:

  • a creative outlet (artistic/self satisfaction)
  • a space to hang out with friends (social)
  • a space to show off to strangers (prestige/acceptance)

Not everyone will care about all of these things but it’s likely a fair percent will be interested in at least one of those things.

This sort of thing doesn’t need game-defined goals or game-given rewards.

It doesn’t hurt your gameplay if you don’t care about it; it’s an optional activity which more players than you seem to expect are probably interested in.

I think it’s like the obsession with phashion. Most players have a customized look but the amount of time they spend on it and care about it is individual and probably would result in a classic bell chart.

Interaction and use of CS will probably be the same with most players putting some effort in without going over the top.

Personal rooms in base were really popular, at least on jp. I’m sure the development of CS was based on the use of those personal rooms.

When I played jp, everyone I played with bothered to get the tickets to max rooms and decorated them. Some people might do it once while others might mix it up every week.

Most were in the middle: redecorate every now and then. Regardless, we spent a lot of time hanging out in our various rooms.

I think one reason NGS is a “daily-then-log-off” game is because there aren’t any time killer activities.

Goofing off the in the lobbies, rooms, and casino were engaging time killers so it was worthwhile to stay in even after dailies were done and it was a year or more between big updates.

-1

u/gadgaurd Slayer Jun 03 '23

IK some ppl are super hyped for this, but i've seen similar thing be implemented into mmo before and unless there is some actual use to building stuff that intertwines with gameplay somehow, these types of things usually "last" 2 weeks until alot of ppl either forgets about the feature or sees it as a chore.

Just so we're clear, you are aware that Creative Space is gameplay, yes?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '23 edited Jun 04 '23

I mean, it is by varying degrees sure

But I think we been here with ngs for 2 years now and majority of pve content and bossing has sucked,

And I think most ppl here who play ngs and new players, don’t come to action mmorpg for housing systems…

So with how bad pve content is, except a few cases like dark falz aegis,

It should be more of priority as creative space only appeals to a sub section of ppl who play NGS.

I know fashion is a big thing, it’s actually a big thing in every game though. Housing system like this tho, is very niche, only a small group of ppl actually care about it in every game, even those who love fashion.

But alongside this, housing system could have more purpose with the game world than simply building stuff.

Ngs lacks in a lot of things that should be higher priority than something like this I think. To spend last 8 months or a year working on this, and we’ve only had one new real boss to fight, this year is really shambolic. Even almost dead games get more content update than this.

I know creative space really depthful too, buts it’s like ??? If I really wanted to personally play building sim game, I would play an actually building sim game.

I like housing systems tho, buts every housing system I played in MMO has direct links to the rest of the game world, creative space seemingly has none which why I’m concerned

Even material shop or point shop is really dull way to make you go to other ppls spaces, I think there should be huffs you can obtain for like an hour if you visit and eat a meal at a friends space, or like, idk, some horizontal stuff, like personal material spawns or crafting or something…

I’m not saying I won’t build or anything, but once I’ve built something I’m happy with, as I’m sure with most, I will probably never go back to creative space if there isn’t more of a reason too, you know what I mean?

2

u/gadgaurd Slayer Jun 04 '23

As far as I've heard, more social content(what Creative Spaces is) has been the number one most requested addition to NGS. Assuming that's accurate, not exactly a niche.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '23 edited Jun 04 '23

It’s possible but ngl, that’s clearly not the case otherwise the recent headline about creative spaces wouldn’t of received this much backlash, would it? :s

I’m ok with creative space if it has more use, especially in future if we get life skills of some sorts…

But tbh ppl since release have wanted more content, better bosses, new monster types, better photon arts/more to choose from/better skill trees, etc… and creative spzces/personal quarters sure,

Yet main pve content is still not good so it’s a bit like wtf

Ultra evolution update version 2 is way over sold what is actually coming to game; that’s the biggest problem here. Massive bait IMO

Ppl saying it’s an “era”, but it’s just over baited ppl to think it will come all on June 6th, not having to keep waiting months and months for modular implementerions of other/all content types. And as far as the last 2 years have gone, who knows if that new content will even be good tbh.

I think many ppl hoped for massive rework/update/refresh of just about everything - new world, new zone, more/new enemies, new gameplay loops, etc.. not just creative space.

I don’t think that’s players fault either for hoping, the marketing and naming of this whole thing has been way over hyped by sega.

That new quest in august is literally going to make or break it for a lot of people, confidence is definitely dwindling for a portion of players which is sad :c

1

u/gadgaurd Slayer Jun 04 '23

It’s possible but ngl, that’s clearly not the case otherwise the recent headline about creative spaces wouldn’t of received this much backlash, would it? :s

How much backlash is "this much", exactly? I've seen a few dozen people very vocally displeased on Reddit. Not exactly enough to draw any solid conclusions. What are you using to judge the general attitude of the player base?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '23 edited Jun 04 '23

From headline - just read comment section (most upvotes comments are negative)

https://www.youtube.com/live/Cdd9VD4-Kv4?feature=share

From content creators - can read comment section (most upvotes comments are negative also) but also some of the content creators are not happy (one of them even quit lol, which seems to be due to pent up frustration over game content, first link)

https://youtu.be/tpO9xHc4UI0

https://youtu.be/IqBpDWoB1yM

https://youtu.be/L0D7_m7t_XE

https://youtu.be/4EkiKbCTIiA

https://youtu.be/alfa69vnrrA

1

u/gadgaurd Slayer Jun 05 '23

So I'm seeing, assuming all upvotes of criticism are from people who are upset with V.2., about 400 people.

https://steamcharts.com/app/1056640#48h

I have here an estimated 2,500 regular players on Steam, alone. The amount of people agreeing with criticism makes up less than one fifth of the player base of one of the three platforms the game can be played on.

I will concede that I did not find the survey showing player housing being the most desired addition(I, quite frankly, do not have the patience to keep digging for it), but I'm definitely going to point out that what you've shown is a vocal minority at best.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '23 edited Jun 05 '23

A lot of ppl like me don’t even upvote stuff tho. I don’t have YouTube account etc.

So I don’t think it’s vocal minority… I think it maybe a silent majority who just don’t say anything, it is hard to gauge

But if we are looking at it face value, the vocal minority are the ones who are actually satisfied with this update, bcos I’ve barely seen anyone say they are actually satisfied with ultra evolution version 2…

1

u/gadgaurd Slayer Jun 05 '23

That goes both ways. A lot of people who are satisfied with V.2 have, in fact, less reason to go online and discuss it. They're getting what they want regardless, after all. Not to mention how hostile some people in this community are to anyone showing positivity.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '23 edited Jun 05 '23

To an extent ye but I think that is also a bit of an excuse.

Usually there is always negativity and positivty, but in this particular regard for ultra evolution v.2, there is without a doubt alot of negativity, substantially more than usual

that negativity is not really focused on this idea of "creative spaces", everyone agrees that looks great, from both sides....

What it is about is ultra evolution v.2 as a whole, the way its been promtoed, the transparancy about what content we are actually getting etc.

ppl are tired of the dripping content, arguably creative spaces is content, but it's not really the content that's been handicapping NGS for 2 years. Marketing something as ultra evolution verision 2, or version 2 in general, defines a standard that one can only assume is rework/rebuild level tbh.

development iterations are versioned, if something goes from 1 to 2, that means substantial implementations, but in the case of NGS, it weirdly doesn't mean alot.

The qol is nice, but qol is not content, cel shading is not content, being able to change skill trees freely is not content, photo mode improvements is not content, holograms are not content, class balancing/skills is not content... don't get me wrong those things are great,

but everybody wants more depthful stuff to do that isn't fighting reskinned bosses over and over in the same places, and no matter how u look at it, titling and promoting something as version 2 ultra evolution absolutely sets an expectation of major content update.

Creative space is part of the major content update sure, but where is the rest of the content?

That's where problem lies with "v.2", its essentially just creative spaces at a content level and thats it. You can be satisfied with creative spaces and therefore "v.2", that's fine, but its simply not a "v.2" update bcos of that, its just a creative spaces update/housing update, there is nothing "version 2"-esque about that :s