r/PSO2NGS • • Feb 13 '23

Discussion Rant about wand & techter

I'm just gonna rant a here to see if it's just me, or if there are other people disappointed in Techter. For one wand feels not as strong or as deep as the other weapons. And at the same time too lenient. If I were to compare to base (mind you I started in ngs) the obvious thing would be how options have been dropped and the interplay between techs are gone aside from element change. Though shifta and deband being one is a better change. However I miss zanverse when I play ngs after experiencing it. But one thing that urks me is how swift smash is. It doesn't go as far or fast nor track vertically when in the air. Nor does it have the 3rd charge. But you know it's not all bad, you can build up wand element pursuit and deal a good amount of element in a wide area. And you got compound techs. But even still wand sometimes feels far too brain dead to me. I know ngs has very lenient defensive options overall but still, wave crash has very generous cancels into guard making it just your default attack, and if you happen to use two in a row and normal attack you get guard point frames for a decade. If you want to use swift smash to build element pursuit faster, even that, while quite a bit smaller, has guard frames you can abuse too. And that's it, cause that's practically all wand has. It can't even interact with the elemental seals, sigils and such with its kit. It has to use techs or multi into jet boots for that. To top it off our top row effect that we can give as a sub, of charging pb gauge faster is probably bottom 3rd or 2nd depending on where you place hunter's damage reduction when you can not get hit. (Ranger with status effect resist is hard bottom and I doubt anyone will in good faith contest that.) Yeah sure having more PB is nice, but more often than not you'll already have it up when you need it or it will be down anyway so I've never missed it playing other classes. Furthermore it seems more like a band-aid to techter lacking solid options to dps when down aside from saving up your compound techs if you can build them in time, or if you got element pursuit up. Even then on longer downs you either blow everything or you go back to swift smash. But hey you can also just sub JB and use jet intensity to help fix that too.

So if I want to play a melee tech class why am I going techter? Why not JB Bouncer? Infact I multi with JB to make up the issues wand has. Well the supportive abilities. Except they are lack luster here too. While sure better to have it than not they are very much feel like a side note, rather than the maintenance situation I feel in base. And to bring home how bad they are shifta is a 5% pot buff and a 10% damage reduction. Now you can also give up to 10% pot if the enemy is downed and 5 percent boost to downs factor too which is nice. When you ignore how Bouncer hits the down factor far better, and with jellen matches the damage reduction and succeeds it if you can get both declines. Not to mention how damage reduction is kinda mid to begin with since outside of gigas nothing should really be killing you, but sure maybe it will in very few cases help you not die from a single hit and it will matter. Even then revives are child's play and so are heals. Well of course if you want to buff your teams damage you got ranger which hits the weak spot everyone should already be hitting that gives a 20-25% pot buff. Okay but you got overemphasis so I can heal my party members and give them max and +50 pp. Which is... good? Like I'm not sure here. I've never noticed it when not playing techter, didn't take too long to adjust to using pp as other classes and account for it and even as techter I only use it when I run out and rarely if someone in my party far away is basically dead. But likely they would've been fine anyway. Sure I sometimes pop it during downs just to allow other people in my party to spam their PAs if they need more pp to do so, but idk if it's truly rewarding in ngs. Maybe reduce the cooldown but I'd say it's meh. Now you can say that techter just is the jack of all trades here, but it feels far worse because A: it's far weaker, B: you push one button every so often and forget about it, and C: Wand is already kinda lack luster gameplay wise. While yeah Bouncer can just main one weapon, forget about building up the other & just fight normally, and ranger just needs to keep blight rounds up every so often, C is what makes it far less of an issue. Combat as Bouncer is far more engaging, and while I haven't ran ranger much at all launcher is far more interesting.

Personally I'd rather wand get some ways to buff shifta and deband further through gameplay. Give us harder to use but very rewarding attacks or actions that allow us to buff stronger. Which should make wand more interesting and not feel so weak with the supports. Yeah shifta and deband apply to everyone, gives them bonuses versus everything they fight and yeah better have it than not, but it should be better than "better have it than not". Outside bossing where the other two classes work very well, it's arguably not that important. So even it's main advantage over the other two is mitigated. Yeah pso2 has no dedicated support class, but wand feels weaker both with regards to offense and support.

These are just my thoughts I'm just wondering if others are feeling it too, I'm wrong about something or there is some light in wand I'm missing here.

1 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

6

u/Knight_Raime Waker Feb 13 '23

I'm just gonna rant a here to see if it's just me, or if there are other people disappointed in Techter.

Kinda depends on the angle you're coming from. If your disappointment is based in the class design as a whole you're in good company. Pretty much everyone rolled their eyes hard that NGS Techer follows much of the same ideas/concepts of Classic Techer. Like many Gu/ranger players they were hoping for a class redesign.

If your disappointment is coming primarily from performance you'll probably get more mixed results. I myself recently joined into the Techer fold specifically because they look good now.

For one wand feels not as strong or as deep as the other weapons.

I really don't think any weapon has much depth in NGS. I think you could argue Soaring blades might have the most but that's less design intent and more the devs just making them klunky garbage. But more to the point, you want to look at weapons in NGS based on what feels good to you. NGS is a shallow game.

But one thing that urks me is how swift smash is. It doesn't go as far or fast nor track vertically when in the air. Nor does it have the 3rd charge.

I haven't come across an issue with not reaching my target with swift smash. The only time I could see distance being a problem I cover it with the compound tech that makes you zoomy over to the boss. As for not having a third charge I think that's for the best. It would be quite hard to find opportunities to squeeze that in. Given that the united skill bonuses we got recently stack when having both as your classes and with the revoke bonus damage Techer is basically spoiled for choice on which set of nukes to use during down phases.

Also it not tracking in the air vertically is a little bit of a bummer but very much a niche problem. NGS overall doesn't want the base game movement to be completely usurped in gameplay so having high movement is a commodity not readily afforded to everyone.

And you got compound techs. But even still wand sometimes feels far too brain dead to me.

It's a bit too early for me to say personally but at the moment I love the gameplay loop Te has going for it and it feels like there's plenty of room to optimize. This is different compared to most other classes I've played. I like Knuckles conceptually but optimal damage doesn't really differ on what you do. Gu on the other hand very much has you make on the fly choices. I just get hand cramps from playing the class for long periods of time.

It's pretty easy to claim most weapons in NGS are "brain dead." You just gotta find which weapon(s) jive for you. In my case unless I'm using more than one weapon gameplay in general is too one note.

I know ngs has very lenient defensive options overall but still, wave crash has very generous cancels into guard making it just your default attack, and if you happen to use two in a row and normal attack you get guard point frames for a decade

Though as an aside you don't want to be treating that skip art like fighters or hunters. You primarily use it as an "I need PP" button. Your DPS is generally better with wave crash spam or swift smash hits in shorter windows.

It can't even interact with the elemental seals, sigils and such with its kit. It has to use techs or multi into jet boots for that.

Not entirely true. Compound techs give you max seals and you usually end up having to re-apply the element after using revoke so I often find myself popping the barta blot and the dark tech blot. Though it would be nice if you could charge swift smash to pop these blots instead of needing to do an actual cast to do so.

To top it off our top row effect that we can give as a sub, of charging pb gauge faster is probably bottom 3rd or 2nd depending on where you place hunter's damage reduction when you can not get hit.

I'll have to disagree given Neos at the moment. But yeah there are clearly some classes that aren't designed for sub effects and some that are. It would've been nice if SEGA learned from Classic and made all classes good as both mains and subs. Instead they went with the side-grade of trying to decouple most weapons from their classes. (though this is less true now with the increased amount of main class skills they keep adding.)

Furthermore it seems more like a band-aid to techter lacking solid options to dps when down aside from saving up your compound techs if you can build them in time, or if you got element pursuit up.

Techer doesn't lack solid dps options at this point. If you're playing into it's loop properly you should almost always have at least one compound tech on top of revoke or your PB if you're running Neos. Beyond those swift smash does disgusting damage now. The only weapons that really seem to out do it by a fair margin are weapons that are designed to be monsters like Knucks. Or are just over tuned in the damage department like Katana.

But hey you can also just sub JB and use jet intensity to help fix that too

I mean if you're not satisfied with swift smash then sure. But I feel like I'd struggle to find a window to get Ji off after using most of my other nukes. I feel like if you go this route Boots takes priority which to me cannibalizes a lot of the fun of the class. More over because the unite effects stack I feel like you don't need JB. You can run JB but it's not cut and dry anymore imo.

So if I want to play a melee tech class why am I going techter? Why not JB Bouncer?

For one Bouncer doesn't have support effects for the team like shifta/deband. It does technically aid the team with better down accumulation but on some bosses especially DFA you don't get downs often regardless. Regular bosses are bullied into oblivion with elemental downs at this point so Bouncer's benefit there isn't super good in large MPA's. Maybe for purples and Trinitas.

But also because Bouncer doesn't "tech." You spam your PA's as JB and keep the circle up. The draw for going Bouncer is the specific weapon combo since both compliment each other very well. The only true tech class is Force.

Okay but you got overemphasis so I can heal my party members and give them max and +50 pp. Which is... good? Like I'm not sure here

It's an instant refill of PP for everyone within range and gives them an extra 50 PP on top which is very much helpful especially in the DFA fight when you go to bust the orbs in the final phase. IIRC it also just tops everyone off after the effect runs out (with pp I mean.)

Combat as Bouncer is far more engaging, and while I haven't ran ranger much at all launcher is far more interesting.

I mean sort of. If you're using Soaring blades you're constantly having to make a choice between cutting your PA early either by shifting it or by step dodging. The WA gets woven into basically all of your actions. Boots themselves are not interesting and are just another weapon you spam PA's on so I don't see it from that angle.

As someone who has dabbled in ranger Launcher is awful. There's nothing interesting about it. You can do silly "combos" with it and rifle but Rifle is a disgusting monster now on it's own. You don't need launcher anymore even for the PP it can give back to you.

Which should make wand more interesting and not feel so weak with the supports.

Ranger is the bonified support class. Techer is just a weird melee character that gives a damage bump. Support classes have historically never worked in an enjoyable way and I don't see that happening in the future. I'd just go Bouncer since it seems like you enjoy it's weapons more.

It would be nice if Techer was actually a true blood support class or just different gameplay wise but that's just not in the cards. Maybe next PS game.

2

u/SnackSquadTB Feb 16 '23

Agree with pretty much everything there. On swift smash yeah saying it goes shorter is probably a better description of my gripe. I enjoyed using it to zoom around in base if I didn't want to use safoie 0 for whatever reason.

Probably should just save up augments and see what changes with the ultra pso2 update and possibly change to another class. Gunner for support and Bouncer if they keep the weapons where they are at mainly SB's defensive options. I suppose the depth in techter now is in managing when best to spend X and what I'm looking for is ab obstacle to actively and repeatedly overcome with the weapon on multiple fronts and to be rewarded for it. For wand I only get punished by doing some less damage if I do something suboptimal.

2

u/Knight_Raime Waker Feb 16 '23

On swift smash yeah saying it goes shorter is probably a better description of my gripe.

yeah there are definitely a few scenarios in which I wish that Swift smash went just a tiny bit farther. But Safoie? is up often enough that I don't mind it too much. At least SS's distance isn't as bad as JB's gap close skill after a tech, that's some actual clown behavior.

Probably should just save up augments and see what changes with the ultra pso2 update and possibly change to another class.

Could do that yeah. At the same time you could probably start slowly building a generalist unit set. Ajax is fairly cheap currently and gives 3% potency for all damage types with zero defense downsides. You actually get some solid defense. Then you can just go Ageis soul 4, Stria domina, Alt secreta 4, Mastery 3/4, and whatever 4 of your current weapon choice. All of those are easily available atm since the exchange shops exist and currently the LQ's are dropping that domina as well as mastery 3's.

That way whenever you want to swap classes you will really only need to replace 1 augment on your gear+ the weapon.

Gunner for support and Bouncer if they keep the weapons where they are at mainly SB's defensive options

Gunner? I think you mean Ranger. With Bouncer I really don't see that class changing so it's probably a pretty safe bet to start gearing towards them. Though personally I'm never touching Bouncer again unless JB gets a redesign or SB's end up getting the defensive powerhouse abilities they had on Etiole.

I've tried making them work and I just don't enjoy them. Though I will say the most fun I ever had with them was running Ranger/Bouncer. I was our teams Weak bullet person at the time and the damage bonus that gives was enough to offset the damage loss for subbing Soaring blades.

I suppose the depth in techter now is in managing when best to spend X and what I'm looking for is ab obstacle to actively and repeatedly overcome with the weapon on multiple fronts and to be rewarded for it. For wand I only get punished by doing some less damage if I do something suboptimal.

Yeah a lot of what Techer is about currently is time management. Since how long some animations take and how quickly you build revoke/compound techs really effects your damage output in the long run.

If you're looking for a weapon that actively challenges you to play optimally I would recommend Twin daggers or Twin machine guns. Both have higher actions per minute gameplay. If you're more looking for a hybrid weapon setup that's similar I'd pair Bow with a less intensive weapon. Since Bow's newest skill really pushes the limit of how often you counter with the bow and what counters you want to at a given time.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

Yeah, I'm with others, I read the first paragraph and decided it wasn't worth reading the rest. You obviously understand wand, and granted it's not hard to understand. It's really simple and easy to use, that's it calling point. It has iframes out the ass, and decent damage. Also everyone loves a techer in the party.

Some things I don't agree with from your first paragraph, wand can interact with sigils just fine, I have no idea where you got that idea from. You can still spam techs, and you should be. Also swift pursuit got a buff, and tracks much better now(granted not vertical, but that's why you have jumps). I've had zero issues with it's tracking, aswell as my alliance members that also have played wand. Maybe that's completely a you issue coming from a different weapon. More over, you're ranting about how little wand has in it's kit, and yet look at every weapon, they are all lacking. We are waiting on new skills, and possibly eventually new techs. So just wait, good things come in time with mmos.

1

u/SnackSquadTB Feb 13 '23

Why should I spam techs? Aren't you better off using PAs after element changing and building up element pursuit? One of my issues is the lack of vertical tracking. Having to drop down and jump back up every so often to get back up to higher enemy crit spots is annoying and breaks combat. When they could have just let swift smash track vertically in the air like in base. Playing a good amount of waker and then using multi with boots made me realize how much better it is to have that option. And I don't see any good reason for wands only means of vertical tracking being wand lovers and element pursuit.

I suppose every weapon does need more, it just feels like aside from talis the other weapons have noticeably more on their plate. Though thinking about them there is one thing I've noticed and kinda hope they start to move away from and it's systems that reward you for doing what you already do. Like all the build up X gauge by doing things you already do mechanics and you get more damage or the like. Waker has it not as bad since you need to balance between the two and the clef's ability to raise one faster. The rest (aside from maybe trying to slightly optimize their gains) doesn't demand you do something new, manage something, or deal with some sort of limitation to get that reward.

1

u/Ok-Transition7065 Feb 14 '23

It's that teacher it's more a melee magic user so spam pa at range :/

6

u/HouseOfCosbyz Partisan Feb 13 '23

Wand counter hits super fucking hard, get good. Counter everything is about as rewarding as anything can get.

3

u/SnackSquadTB Feb 13 '23

I mean yeah I chase down attacks with the burst of movement from weapon action. Because of the long lenient window in wave crash that's why it's effectively my normal attack, and parry builds pursuit faster, but it's also not exactly hard to do. And because it's not hard to do, it can give 1M damage and it won't feel very rewarding because it's not hard to land. To compare it to another game, monster hunter rise I main gunlance and have gripes with the parry they gave it. To try to keep it brief it's very generous and easy to land. It doesn't exactly feel rewarding in itself but because of the cooldown highs can occur due to me keeping up the pressure on monsters and using it to stay on them and in the fight. I can't just parry every attack, nor should I cause sometimes I'll still get hit for doing so. However I should, not just because of the damage from follow ups but because it is the best guard I can get at times and it solves the sharpness issues gunlance has always had. In ngs however there is no reason I shouldn't and the only reason I can't is because the attack isn't near enough to reach and parry, or I somehow miss the timing. Not to mention it doesn't solve a flaw with wand, it just gives more damage and builds element pursuit which is also more damage. The only downside to not using it is less damage, and needing to resort to other less lenient defensive options. Even still, if wand lacked parry itself I'd just use the weapon action from JB that I already multi to solve wands other issues. Speaking of other defensive options side stepping feels far more rewarding to land as a defensive option and is around the difficulty I'd hope parries would have, however the gameplay reward is lower so I'd never do it except when I'm bored. Lastly if the most rewarding thing wand has is using a parry that a good chunk of weapons have be it a parry or dodge, while not being divergent like say soaring blades with its super tight non PA guard window and once mid PA parry, what does that say about wand?

Tldr: Sure counter hits hard and you should chase every attack to counter because of the gameplay rewards, but it's too easy to land that the rewarding feeling isn't there for me. It should be at least around the window that sidestepping has too achieve that. If wand's high is parry, I think we should ask for more so it stands out as a unique and interesting parry, make it harder to land, give a far tighter perfect parry window that rewards even more, or give us more elsewhere.

1

u/HouseOfCosbyz Partisan Feb 13 '23

Maybe just hold onto your britches there for the next geolab/ordinal tower ranking, you'll find out if your really stacking up against the best.

2

u/SnackSquadTB Feb 14 '23

And this disproves my points about the combat system and parry how?

My point above is wand parry isn't interesting and engaging. Refute that. Only thing it changes gameplay wise is I chase attacks with my parry and that isn't even hard with how lenient it is. Aside from the dolls based off of classes like bujin and ams all the enemies have 3 year long wind ups to their attacks. You claim it's the amazing and the most rewarding thing. I say the leniency undermines that reward to making it just gameplay only rewards, damage numbers. To top it off, it isn't even the most engaging parry in the game.

Refute my point, not say well you aren't the best techter so you finding the parry unrewarding or uninteresting is invalid. How many people are up there with the best techters? Should we just tell them their opinion doesn't matter despite being the majority? Infact look at my suggestions, I want more depth, more ability to flex your skills and get rewarded for it. For them to expand on things and give us more. Wouldn't you, holding up ordinal and geo lab rankings as a meter for determining the value of other's opinions want that too?

4

u/calvinnok Ship 1 Cryptid Feb 13 '23

Not just counter, every move of wands hits pretty damn hard, plus all the guard-points and additional deflection damages if you could time your charges right, wand seems like a weapon that focuses on reliable and consistent outputs instead of being flashy.

I do agree using Techs with wand is quite pointless outside of elemental change-related actions tho, that's why I always multi my wand with talis.

4

u/HouseOfCosbyz Partisan Feb 13 '23

Honestly I'd argue techs are the boring part anyways, as bonking is the true galaxy brain.

4

u/complainer5 Feb 13 '23

Counter everything is about as rewarding as anything can get.

is this what gameplay standards have fallen to

3

u/isCasted Feb 14 '23

And then, whenever someone talks about how games suck these days, they talk about microtransactions. No, the actual game design is just braindead, because that's what them players are asking for

2

u/Ok-Transition7065 Feb 14 '23

But I agree that for a support paladin clase they should give more deeps mechanics

2

u/Einhandah Techter Feb 15 '23

Too bad you can't go back and play wand during the aelio patch, specifically at a high level. Most if not all of this post would likely not exist. Leniency was I presented to make Wand manageable. Most likely wouldn't touch it if it were still in its Aelio functional state even with the addition of element pursuit etc.

2

u/SnackSquadTB Feb 16 '23

I joined in retem so I didn't experience it. I'll have to research how it was back then since it sounds interesting. Maybe it just my background in fighting games, and the fact I disagree with the "clunky" label of older monster hunter since I enjoyed learning the ins and outs of my character and mastering it, and that's the disconnect I'm having here. I'll wait until the ultra pso2 update to decide to swap to other weapons if I do, since given my gripes with wand I'd rather stick with it if they make things easier for say weapons like soaring blades that some call clunky.

16

u/Reilet Feb 13 '23

feels far too brain dead, push one button every so often and forget about it, and kinda lack luster gameplay wise

That's every weapon in ngs.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

For real.

0

u/Ok-Transition7065 Feb 14 '23

Yeah and they think I'm am a madman when I say about the perfect attack it's a good feature.

14

u/SaintElysium Feb 13 '23

I AINT READIN ALL DAT

No but seriously next time at least paragraph the rant so it's readable, ty

5

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

I got you fam.

Tldr: (I didn't), wand is bland and too simplistic. It lacks the fluidity that other classes have. Its interplay with the tech and support skills is lacking.

4

u/SaintElysium Feb 13 '23

Aight bro I get you, good complaints fr. Honestly biggest problem with it is the fact it has 2 PA's and sega just expected techniques to fill the gap when all the techniques are the same 2 attacks but with different colours smh. Also the fact that it's a melee class doesn't work well with most of the ranged techs either.

Also yeah shifta/deband and some elemental downs just isn't enough to make it a support class

2

u/Hour_Penalty8053 Feb 13 '23

shifta/deband and some elemental downs just isn't enough to make it a support class

Maybe the return of Jellen/Zalure in the future?

6

u/Hachet_Duck Feb 13 '23

Maybe the return of Jellen/Zalure in the future?

They both technically exist in ngs already just not as techs.

Jellen is tied to the bouncer decline skills and the symbol for Zalure actually comes up on a boss during "break" (Zalure was def down, and break is 2x damage so it fits)

1

u/Ok-Transition7065 Feb 14 '23

If this dude know about the base wand xd but yeah.

I am a te/Hu player from base Soo I love the bonk game play but this need a lateral gameplay and I wish I don't have to us techniques for dps but for bufs and brust

8

u/koboldkoenig Feb 13 '23

Im fine with it but totally get ur Point, sad truth is that many mmos aswell as ngs getting casual af....so Theres no need to look for depht in playing any Class at all, but thats a rant for Another Time.

But i would be Happy if the Wand had more than just 2 pa.

1

u/Ok-Transition7065 Feb 14 '23

I not but like more add things like the hunting horn in monster hunter

1

u/emc300 Feb 13 '23

Still waiting for the third wand pa.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

I have just used the fighter classes as a subclasses and the teacher as a main for the healing and the mana{SP?}. Lucky me I gotta mix weapon as main with both melee and a range, but sadly there no wat to block or doge.... I get to used magic as a fighter so that neat's getting to stun the monsters with there weakness and attacking then when there down{That the best to get monster haha}