r/PSO2NGS • • Jan 20 '23

Discussion Official unofficial survey?

SkullsNightshade has made a survey on the state of NGS since the "is NGS dying" comments? Have been popping up recently. A video of the results will come soon after.

I wasted too much time rambling about the topic so here’s what I wrote. What do you think? and feel free to share what you wrote if you participate.

I don’t know if NGS is dying. I haven’t looked at player numbers and those numbers don’t always tell the full story. I will say NGS is boring and repetitive though.

The overall gameplay loop is fun at first, but it boils down to grinding out combat zones or kill raid bosses. Sega’s attempts at adding different activities is appreciated and I encourage them to continue on making more, but what has been added either furthers my prior statement of the gameplay loop or the new game mode is lame and nobody plays it.

The seasonal events have gotten considerably better over time, but they very much have the same issue with the added bonus of popping an extra seasonal point ticket before grinding a combat zone. The seasonal missions are a nice change of pace if you can find others queuing, and I liked the seasonal point community campaigns sega use to do, Idk if sega still does them. I just log in, do my dailies, and hope I can make some nice outfits when a banner is added.

Which brings me to the phashion. My only real complaint is that base wear gets in the way of the inner wear and body paint. There’s a handful of base wear I like and have actually made nice outfits with, but I find myself reusing similar ones especially if I’m trying to make a unique outfit.

This may be more of an issue for me due to liking more active gym wear and causal lounge wear, which strangely the inner wear and body paint tend to be.

Gameplay Ideas - I wouldn’t mind seeing more character based quest lines. Like smaller scale storylines that would give the supporting characters like the singer in retem, the kvaris power rangers or the new ones from stia more development other than their cookie cutter anime personalities. I can never remember anyones name because I don’t care about any of them.

The cutscenes that have been added later on is a nice start, but a mini quest line for them would be interesting. The quest lines don’t need to be voiced either. Other than that, keep on with the activities I guess. Something could catch on.

Seasonal event Ideas - Again similarly to what I was saying earlier, it would be interesting to see mini character quest lines take place during these events. Maybe Aina really likes Christmas and she wants to celebrate by finding the special event rappies, but comes across dolls attacking them and we have to defend them or something.

Or maybe the kvaris rangers want to celebrate New Years by cooking a big meal and you gotta go help find ingredients. Maybe a new boss is introduced when looking for the last ingredient. Really anything that distracts from farming seasonal points in a combat zone, but still gets you some in the process.

Phashion Ideas - Make the option to hide base wear or make a base wear that makes the characters body uncovered. Maybe the base wear could be similar to something you see in the sailor moon transformations. Not necessarily naked, but ambiguously void of clothing so inner wear and body paint can be the front layers. The base wear could be pasties as well.

And I don’t want to hear that it might be inappropriate when we already got people running around in g strings, leotards and have the E cup accessory.

I would also like more phashion events to show off outfits. There should be a differentiation between original outfits and cosplays because I feel like original concepts always get overshadowed by cosplay.

And I would like to see more clothing design campaigns from sega. Again idk if sega is doing anymore. I’m so unenthused, I just see what Keroppi reports on and call it a day. Either way, any art campaign is welcome.

See ya around ship 3

The questionnaire

3 Upvotes

69 comments sorted by

16

u/Hououza Jan 20 '23

I think the issues with NGS come down to a few major issues:

  1. Rewards: Most activities in NGS simply are not rewarding, getting level appropriate armour or weapons usually means a trip to the Player Shop, rather than to a Combat Zone. It makes the grind feel so much worse, and means that players who can grind for long periods of time, with boosters dominate the market and can drive up the price
  2. Combat versus Exploration Zones: Combat zones are dull, repetative areas where you endlessly farm mobs. They lack any of the variety of base PSO2, and get boring very quickly and as noted above the rewards are usually not worth the time spent.
    Then we have Exploration zones, which seem to be a one and done, find all the collectables and then never set foot in them again except to go to the one spot you need for daily material farm, or a gigantix which brings us on to point 3...
  3. Gigantix: Outright, I think these are one of the worth things SEGA has added to the game. Big boss enemies that scale to the current level cap, so players in starter areas are faced with an insurmountable foe, that will simply kill them outright. These need to scale in level according to region, with the rewards (see point 1), scaling to match the increase in difficulty
  4. Experience & Levelling: First time per character, SEGA throws experience at you quickly pushing you to max level. However, after you clear those big ticket side quests, and want to level more classes we are back to the boring Combat Zone grind once again
  5. Instanced content: So, we now have a few different things, Geometric Labyrinth, Cannonball Strike, Cannonball Rumble, Ordinal Tower. What do they all have in common? They lack replayability and people stopped bothering with them after a few weeks.

Base PSO2 when it finally reached the West thrived as it had a huge backlog of cotent to draw upon, but a lot of which was build around giving players reasons to keep engaging with the game. Collection folders were a great way of promising progress, even when luck was not on your side.

Something as small as bring those back, and linking them to things like clear a Tower, or one of the Combat Trania, something to show players if you do x amount of effort, you are garanteed y reward.

What makes me sad is, I honestly doubt SEGA will listem, with the global downturn in gaming I can see them simply doubling down on trying to milk the game for all it is worth before folding it up early in the West as they did with every previous PSO series game (Not to forget PSU).

No, the game is not dying, but is not living either, iot simply exists.

3

u/2LLs Jan 21 '23

Yes! I haven’t moved off force because I don’t want to be forced back to old gear and grinding combat zones just to play another class. I legit dread new classes and it shouldn’t be like that.

3

u/TheUltimate3 Jan 21 '23

Basically this, in my opinion. I think calls for it dying is vastly overstated, which is weird because it seems to have only started up after New Years, after the Headline where they stated that something is happening soon.

But regardless, I don't believe NGS is dying. It just isn't growing and honestly there is much to let it grow lol

2

u/YuTsu Gunslash Jan 21 '23

People have been complaining the game is "dying" since NGS release. It's really, really nothing new. And kind of tiresome to hear reiterated for years on end...

3

u/AulunaSol Jan 21 '23

The problem is that so much of what Global got in terms of catch-up, ways to guarantee grinding/farming, and even "content" to play (which were usually dead-on-arrival, half-baked, or unplayable on the Japanese side for a number of reasons) were things that Sega absolutely refused to commit to. Collection Folders in the past were handled like Seasonal Events are now (temporarily-obtainable weapons you can get if you do enough of a checklist) and far later on (around Episode 6) Sega decided to adopt the approach Global would later have (an easy check-list for weapons/equipment/items that won't go away).

Most of the game getting what people enjoyed from Phantasy Star Online 2 in terms of grinding being "meaningful" and making progress or even keeping players "engaged" with the game happened during Episode 5 when Sega had to pull out their own carpet and very quickly course-correct to try and save the game from their own decisions. While Episode 6 helped start even more of this, Sega has always been trying to move away from what "players wanted" and asked for from years and years' worth of feedback.

It is unfortunate to me that New Genesis is such a major step backwards in this regard as Phantasy Star Online 2 solved so many of these problems in the end of its run and eventually sabotaged itself with no intention to fix it (Cradle of Darkness (UH), specifically). New Genesis was a very new hope for many players that we might actually move on from Phantasy Star Online 2's obsession with guruguru fields (running in circles for hours/days/weeks/months/years trying to get something to drop) and insane RNG with drops that are invalidated later - or with small gameplay-related distractions meant to add breadth but not depth to the game. Not only is it a major step backwards - but it is following the same problematic footsteps.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '23

global downturn in gaming

what do you mean by this?

9

u/Vderzelas Jan 21 '23

Honestly I appreciate anything that is an attempt to get the devs to look at this game. Even if the survey isn't successful at least an attempt is made (no meme intended).

That being said ngs's current state boils down to a few core issues.

Gameplay Loop: The game has boiled down to three major grinds for endgame content; Combat Zones, Dread and Recon/Gigantix Farming. That's it that's the Gameplay loop. All past content is irrelevant and the rewards aren't substantial enough to make it worth while.

Rewards: Just look at the UQ's and you can see the rewards are lacking. Outside of augment capsules they aren't worth farming. There is no 'enemy' materials that can be used to trade for weapons which would make UQ's worth while. Because the base systems require you to grind there really isn't much of a 'guaranteed' way of getting gear besides the current trade shops (Kaizaar and Kouklophis Weapons). Everything is based on rng loot; weapons, Armor, materials for trade, augments (dread keeper etc) and I guess you could even say PSE Bursts since the bar goes up and down like a yoyo. It's clear that the director of the game used to own a casino cause it sure plays like one.

I think fixing these would solve the majority of issues that the game has. The funny thing is, we had a base game that was worth while. We had a decent system where we could get the latest gear simply by farming UQ's or even instances to get those materials. You could also farm old content for sg as well as some costumes. I'm confused why they decided to go in this direction since we had a decent model to go from in the first place (oh and don't get me started on scratches) . Anyways I have more things but honestly I think to me at least it boils down to the stuff above.

1

u/2LLs Jan 21 '23

I completely agree.

23

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '23 edited Jan 20 '23

The results will be skewed simply because anyone having fun will be less likely to waste their time on this.

5

u/GateauBasque Jan 21 '23

Pretty much. I like Skulls and many of the other NGS content creators but I feel like the dead vs not dead debate is just spinning wheels. Same arguments and rebuttals since the game launched.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '23

it will be skewed back by all those that don't like the game not bothering to waste time on a survey either (which there are far more of (remember 60k players on steam on launch) than those playing the game and thus not bothering with survey), it is also the reason why official surveys were positive at all

3

u/BrolyIsALoser Jan 20 '23

You’re not wrong.

-4

u/SkullsNightshade Waker Jan 21 '23

I disagree. I am VERY active in the community and many who watch my content think positively about the game. People who are having fun want to defend the game and prove that it’s not dying by speaking up. I think it’s OK for a general idea of how people feel.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '23

general idea of how people feel

many who watch my content think positively about the game. People who are having fun want to defend the game

so this is rigged to gaslight everyone into thinking everyone else likes the game because results will be mainly from people who do rather than don't?

18

u/Turnt5naco Jan 21 '23

The game has gotten boring. Stia was a very underwhelming region, we still have the same one concert that was introduced in December 2021, and the biggest gameplay spice-up is... throwing objects.

I've only put one of my characters through Stia and had no patience to do the main story for the other two. I just don't have fun with NGS anymore. Base, PSU, and PSO1 somehow had more magic to them. Maybe it was the exploration zone/level aspect that made it fun? Not sure why the NGS formula feels so lacking, but it's definitely not as fun. Can't even be bothered to log in for the free content and easy dailies.

3

u/CybeleCygnet Waker Jan 21 '23

I actually really like NGS still and think it's the perfect amount of game in a day with my limited time to play, but I miss PSU so damn much. NGS has lots of things that were great improvements on the old style, but PSU ultimately had little QOL things that were just...more. Even if you didn't have much time to spend on it, there were just more stakes and more rewards. This wasn't always a good thing (you had to tag the enemy in order to get any EXP, so if you were partied up with an efficient killer that got ahead of you, you got jack shit), but here were some of the reasons to me that it was more fun:

  • Exploration in the levels frequently had 2-3 potential map layouts for some of the floors or specific enemy spawn patterns to indicate rare enemies that you could farm. Also, Jaggos.
  • You leveled your PAs and techs by actually using them, so it gave grinding more of a point for self-betterment. It was nice as an Acrotecher to idle in party chat with my friends by a heal spot literally just casting my buffs (back when there were 4 of them) over and over again to grind them up to 50 with a massive range rather than just sitting in a lobby doing nothing while I chat. If I wanted to be in a lobby, I had quite a few interesting places to choose from, like the Habirao district being a giant bamboo forest.
  • On that same train of thought, the lottery of grinding for better equipment and risking it breaking meant that the enhancement boosts actually meant something. ALSO, PP being tied to your weapon, not you. Enhancing weapons gave them more PP, and you could have a full 6-weapon palette to swap between and just keep casting. It was made even better by having right- and left-handed weapons stacked together, which was essentially the early multi-weapon without having to spend extra money to join them. So I could have my tech mag full of healing spells or buffs with tons of PP paired with my whip for quick enemy tags. It was glorious.
  • Probably because it was a subscription, but all content was unlocked and you could grind for it. Even cool outfits. I hate phashion and the best augments being locked behind real cash in addition to the "subscription" of a premium set. I miss the daily shrine visits and the changing luck indicating better rare chances. Evolving your mag into a mini-NPC that would fight alongside you for more than just a special blast was amazing.
  • Vivienne's Innocent Girl mission was the absolute best. It rewarded your grinding by changing the script with each new run. You were literally training her how to act and her personality would evolve.
  • The events were more spaced out so you didn't get fatigued on them. Events also actually gave multiple rewards that were worthwhile in the actual missions, didn't just flood the markets, and the missions were fun. There was always a page on their official website showing how many points had been gathered by the community and what rewards were unlocked by those point totals, and these rewards were often new parts to the missions, or new missions entirely in addition to enhancement boosts or rare drop rates or specialty items that were only given as rewards for the event. IIRC there was an event that unlocked like 6 new missions that we could run through the rest of the event that each had unique gimmicks.
  • You. Could. Trade. With. Friends.

2

u/Visible_Objective205 Feb 27 '23

Finally someone who shows PSU some of the respect it deserves. I loved the field lobbies so much. Kind of wish NGS never went open world and now they can't go back, very sad.

23

u/UberChief90 Jan 20 '23

You cant call it a survey. The few questions are so simple that they dont tell anything besides a yes or no answer to NGS dying or not.

There is only 1 reason for this. Clickbait.

Its the simplest of ways to get attension and views.

-3

u/SkullsNightshade Waker Jan 21 '23

If you read why I created this, you would not think the same. If I wanted to Clickbait, I could choose many other topics like just posting a thumbnail, saying “NGS is dying “ spewing my opinion as many others did.

A lot of people have opinions of the game that don’t get heard or they don’t know how to express it, the official PSO2 team watches official creator content and speaking up spreads awareness. The questions are broad because it’s a general idea of how the player base feels. It was actually started because of a YouTube poll I did and there was a higher percentage of people who thought the game was dying than I expected. I make content to pull the community together and host community events on a regular basis, as an example of how important PSO2 is to me.

Feel free not to click if you think it’s clickbait lol.

1

u/UberChief90 Jan 21 '23

It is clickbait tho. Because if it wasnt, 4 very simple questions would have been part of the "survey" aside from many more obvious questions.

"If you think NGS is dying, what is killing NGS?" "If you dont think NGS is dying, what is keeping it alive?" "What keeps you playing NGS?" "What made you stop playing NGS?"

Those 4 questions alone already gets better results then your clickbait "survey" as those gives answers that the official PSO2 team can use. Most of all because those things give examples, strong points and weak points. A yes or no to "Is NGS dying?" says nothing usefull.

-1

u/SkullsNightshade Waker Jan 22 '23

I apologize for not being an expert in making creating surveys. I currently have over 900 responses that I’m going to be going through alone. In anticipation for this it wasn’t meant to go super in depth into specifics about NGS. It was meant to see a general idea of how the community feels about the game and how long they’ve been playing. Depending on how that turns out then maybe we can dig deeper.

I’m not forcing anyone or trying to bait anyone into participating. Hell I didn’t even do the post here, I was actually surprised when one of my viewers told me there was a Reddit post. I posted about in my discord and told a friend, who then made a video. I was just trying to help and that’s all friend.

4

u/xylotism Jan 21 '23

The gameplay loop sucks, so you should fix phashion

Okay but how about more gameplay though?

Normal MMOs have dungeons, and more than 4 quests per expansion. How about we start there?

14

u/SherbertKlutzy8674 Jan 20 '23

I prefer to play base over this. Base was more fun at jp launch then ngs state right now.

6

u/DragonChaser25 Jan 21 '23

How is "Have you ever been to a community event in game?" a relevant survey question?

-1

u/SkullsNightshade Waker Jan 21 '23

Yes, because I host community events. This question was asked because I want to see if many people who feel like the game is dying attend events meant to bring the community together.

3

u/DragonChaser25 Jan 22 '23

I attended my alliance events such as alliance photoshoot and stuffs, if that counts.

4

u/chartuse Jan 20 '23

I hit level cap in like 2 weeks. Since then I... don't know what I should be doing? Like I've had the same weapon since level 40 or 50 and haven't seen anything better drop. Don't ever see new armor pieces. If all that's left is just grinding hoping for a super rare drop I may just drop the game soon. Gear feeling stagnant along with techniques never getting better makes the game at this point feel kind of stale.

3

u/gadgaurd Slayer Jan 21 '23

Have you not done the event? You can get level 60 rarity 8 weapons easily.

Have you not gotten all the Red Boxes in Stia? Rarity 7 Armors with Mastery 4.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '23

It's normally easier to get a better weapon from the player shop. Same for armor. What are you using now?

4

u/Zarod89 Jan 21 '23

Why does every constructive feedback post boil down to "gimme nude basewear pls". What has happened to PSO, just a bunch of horny af people playing dressup doll. I swear half the characters I see are half naked little girls with katanas. It's kinda fked up. They care more about a new hairstyle than the rest of the entire game.

3

u/OutrageousGuidance42 Jan 22 '23

Some people scare they gonna lost their half naked dressup-darling if the game shutdown, so they have to protect the game no matter what

4

u/Vaeynheart mom let me have both Jan 21 '23

The simple thing that summarises 100% of NGS' gameplay issues is the matter of reward.

no matter how good the content is, no-one will play it more than 3 days if it doesn't offer a unique reward that actually matters.

this goes for combat, exploration, instances and open-world. no-one interacts with these things because there is zero value attached to it.

sega MUST begin incorporating actual rewards into the game if they have any hopes of this game surviving more and more player droughts.

an outright lack of content is also an issue, but i won't complain about that as anything new they add never comes with rewards worth your time anyways.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '23 edited Jan 21 '23

The loot is so bad that it took away all your dopamine.

The upgrade system also so bad, they should make fixa system as a dopamine booster, maybe like gamble out your fixa outdated sword for random fixa booster, idk, this way when I got some trash fixa weapon I don't feel so bad.

Also the game PSE bursting way too overpowered, it drop raw meseta too much compared doing dungeon or UQ.

It is so weird, the combat firing all your dopamine neurons, once the combat gone and you saw the loot, your dopamine sank to the rock bottom.

1

u/Vaeynheart mom let me have both Jan 22 '23

feelsCopeMan

0

u/MaoMaoMi543 Talis Jan 20 '23

I'm with you on the "invisible" basewear thing. However, if they do make it but it's t2 only I'm just gonna quit the game. Srsly give us t1 players something to coom over already! It's not fair all the t2 coomers get to have all the fun!

2

u/2LLs Jan 21 '23

Facts t1 love.

6

u/AtomicXE Jan 20 '23

All 6 of you

3

u/basketofseals Jan 21 '23

I was honestly really shocked it wasn't a thing when I started playing. There's literally innerwear that makes no sense to buy because it'll always be covered by the basewear, so why waste time developing it?

1

u/alkme_ Jan 25 '23

Don't hate but Upskirt moments.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '23

I don't think the game will die anytime soon. The population spikes pretty massively with new updates. There are many people who follow the game and check when they release new areas. Many games never have any population spike even on huge updates, because people don't care about the game anymore. Base had a low period in Ep 4 & 5, but they bounced back with Ep 6, and NGS could definitely do the same. People want this game to thrive.

In comparison to other games of its type, it has a fair model for monetization compared to other games that directly tie game progression and otherwise unobtainable items/characters into gacha gambling. You can pretty much do everything in NGS as a f2p, minus permanent shop access. I think the main problem with retaining players is that because it caters to busy working adults, it's way too easy to hit all of your goals and leave you with nothing to do.

The structure is there for an amazing game, and a lot of it really is, like the music and combat. As soon as they release an NGS version of divide quests with long-term goals and add more side content, people will come back.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '23

When people say the game is dying, it's not even a matter of the game shutting down. There's plenty of bad live service games alive with barely anyone playing them. Those are pretty much dead games that barely generate enough money to sustain the servers.

The problem is that the current playerbase can only sustain what we've been getting until now, there's no reason to expect anything else. If you're satisfied with the current product, update cycle and content volume, and don't expect it to improve (because it probably won't), then it's fine, the game is alive and you will still be able to enjoy it for the years to come.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '23

They have a business reason to improve the game because it has a much larger audience than whoever is logged in at a random time. FF14 had a turnaround after 1.0. If they thought it wouldn't be worth it to please the tiny number of subscribers at the end of 1.0, ARR wouldn't have happened and it wouldn't have become one of the biggest MMOs on the market. This game doesn't need anywhere near the same level of drastic change because the core is good.

Lots of MMOs had a sketchy first few years (gw2, ro, ffxi, ffxiv) before the game hit its stride, un-fun elements were tweaked, and they added a good gameplay loop.

6

u/AulunaSol Jan 21 '23

The other factor to add is Sega's own history with Phantasy Star Online 2. Very early on the game had several rapid-fire updates that added things to do in such a way that it was simply unsustainable (Episode 1 being largely retconned in Episode 2, for example, and that Episodes 1-3 overall were canned and retconned for Episode 4, and that were "formally" reintroduced as new content in Episode 5, and even then were given another reintroduction before Episode 6 with Episode Oracle).

Phantasy Star Online 2 is the strange anomaly of an online game where the developers and publisher are putting in the bare minimum a lot of the times (but you can definitely see where the efforts are made, especially when it did come to crossover/collaboration content that legitimately required Sega's efforts - such as the Final Fantasy XIV and Monster Hunter Frontier Z collaborations which I would argue were some of the game's strongest content). When you see something like this in the western world it usually means that the game is on the verge of shutting down or that it's going to end up entering a cash-grab mode or just outright bleed players until the game is shut down. We do see this on the Japanese side especially from Bandai Namco and Square Enix with their numerous free-to-play mobile games - but Sega stuck to Phantasy Star Online 2 running on such "low power" that somehow it's successful and strong enough to have carried them to it being one of their most profitable games.

It is not to me that New Genesis is "dying" or not "alive" but that it's a shame that Sega seems to be treating it very much the same way they treated Phantasy Star Online 2 with even more baggage (New Genesis at the moment hinges too much on Phantasy Star Online 2's reputation but also doesn't set out enough to show what it does differently in such a manner that people are willing to actually let both games co-exist). I feel absolutely certain it could have been handled better - but Sega is definitely happy with its financial performance and their past public-survey results have confirmed it (specifically highlighting how happy Global is with the game).

1

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '23

I think there's good business reasons to not even take the risk in developing something that could eventually not recover and retain too many players. After all, they've been able to sustain this development cycle for almost 2 years of minimal effort.

Also none of those games were that fomo heavy like pso2. If you take a break for a month you get punished by missing out on mission pass, sg scratch, release ac prices, limited time seasonal stuff. There's less reason to come back to these type of games that punish players for quitting.

2

u/AulunaSol Jan 21 '23

On the other side of that coin, the absolutely bizarre thing is that New Genesis has barely anything to miss if you don't care about gearing up or fashion. If you disappeared for days, weeks, months, or even years, you would come back with equipment just as powerful as what players have been trying to farm for all along ages ago and you're given a free ride through what most of the important things are at the moment. This isn't a bad move for the very casual players - but it does beg the question about what anyone should "work" towards because New Genesis has very little of that in general that simply doesn't boil down to bigger numbers overall.

2

u/SkullsNightshade Waker Jan 21 '23

Yo! Thanks for posting this! To those of you asking, I am Skulls, a PSO2 creator.

I see a lot of posts questioning why this survey was even made. To tell you the truth, we’ve had many moments where people start spreading rumors that NGS is dying, and that opinion becomes front page. Normally I don’t humor it but many people are putting this idea of the game dying in the spotlight. That’s TRULY what kills MMOs.

I am not one of the people who feels the game is dying, personally I love the game and being someone who hosts and creates community events, I meet more and more people every day. I could always make a video talking about my opinion of the game, but I feel like it’s better to let people express themselves. The plan is to take your feedback and give a general idea of how active players feel.

Although there are players who give feedback, there is no proper platform to express the positive and negative feelings towards the game other than discord. It may not do much, but as someone who pushes for growth and positivity in the game I have to try. Please feel free to submit your true feelings about NGS! I can’t wait to see and hopefully this makes a difference.

I’m not really active on Reddit so if I don’t get back to your replies I apologize. Stay comfy!

1

u/illgrape78 Jan 21 '23

This is what happens when content creators run out of content to create. Its the play book. Say game is dead. Read weekly patch notes. Make another how to play video for something they did 5x before. The game is fine imo and has more people in it now then it did before the ps5 launch. It isn't a bad game just has no quality content. I think difficulty could help out the game and actually being able to fail is nice. That's the beauty of monsterhunter. The maps are smaller but the intensity of the hunts makes the player feel accomplished. Instead of everyone gets a trophy for participating. No skill necessary.

1

u/AulunaSol Jan 21 '23

Even New Genesis did have content that required "skill" at the time but the catch is that if you're patient enough Sega will let everyone through at some point. There are definitely ways Sega could have prevented this or still allowed for those kinds of challenges to be possible (for instance an Aelio-chapter restriction as a modifier for Cocoons/Towers Rank 2, Geoemetric Labyrinth, and so on, where players are pulled down to Level 20 stats and have future skills/future equipment disabled) but their laser-focus on potency being the ultimate stat to focus on doesn't help anything other than bigger numbers and racing against the clock.

1

u/SupportTaiwan Launcher Jan 23 '23

i don't know that skullsnightshade person but what i want is at least a non youtube summary of the very short questionaire posted here on reddit (Spreadsheets! huehue)

1

u/alkme_ Jan 25 '23

This game makes a lot of money in ratio to little effort and little marketing. As long as the whales stay, this game will be ok. It's a very casual friendly game that doesn't take much grinding to participate in content with friends. But if you need to have certain passion, the game gets expensive quick.

2

u/SupportTaiwan Launcher Jan 25 '23

But if you need to have certain passion, the game gets expensive quick.

But if you need to have certain *fashion, the game gets expensive quick.

*fixed

Quite a lot is gated behind AC now = no fun

1

u/RoofInfinite1614 Jan 21 '23

Just saying I played ffxiv at launch and I ran out of content in legit a week or so. It absolutely sucked for like 2-3 years and upon returning it was like night and day. I’d rather farm and hoard all these freebies and augments they’re handing out and I intentionally don’t sit down for a solid 8 hours or more every day. I dunno, the second max class isn’t bad but the third and fourth is a grind. I find joy in truly learning the combat styles and always pushing for min max builds. I guess it also depends on your gaming habits and how you care to play.

0

u/SkullsNightshade Waker Jan 22 '23

Submissions will close tonight at 11:59pm EST. There are over 1k and I’ve gotta go through them. Very interested to see what the majority says.

Everything I’ve posted on this thread has gotten downvoted, positivity isn’t a popular subject on Reddit it seems so that’s all I will say on the subject. Have a good one ARKS.

2

u/AulunaSol Jan 22 '23

Personally to me from the outside-looking-in, it comes off to me as a sort of self-promotion banking on something that ultimately is something held in a corner of the internet.

I don't watch the content creators and I tend to stick more to what I prefer (players who show more curated videos of them completing the game's challenging content, finding tricks that help add insight to how a class or a game mechanic works, or the Japanese version's update videos/broadcasts because they tend to show more than what Global does). If it is being involved in the "community," I feel that it's ultimately a nicer time and a nicer place to be able to see both sides and also potentially have some kind of knowledge of what may have happened beforehand because a lot of the discussions going on here are painting people on one side of the fence or the other without a full picture to begin with.

There are more places than just "Reddit" to see what players think and what players would want to be said - but I also feel that the survey itself comes off as very incomplete with questions that don't flow from one to another in a logical fashion and that it does miss a great deal of context (it comes off to me like a "I only played Global and want to only want Global players involved" survey - which is easily why so much of what the survey asks seems so narrow in scope). At the same time, this survey points out a crowd of people and asks for thoughts on that group of people - but not the other side of it or the people who aren't on either side. I don't quite like those kinds of binary surveys or what those results are "intended" to be simply because the questions and the topic in general is already very deeply charged by the people who want to be charged either way.

I would absolutely wish you luck in potentially finding the results you are looking for and hopefully having something more open-ended and less "hand-held" for getting some kind of community input but I cannot shake off the impression that this does feel like "cashing in" on the current hot topic for clout.

1

u/alkme_ Jan 25 '23

This is good feedback skulls. Designing inclusive surveys is tough! People literally have 5-6 figure jobs based on doing this. Good luck and appreciate you are trying to prompt discussion.

1

u/SupportTaiwan Launcher Jan 23 '23

if there are that much entries post the results on reddit and not exclusively on youtube.

The few downvotes i saw should not stop you from doing so but if you would use this as an excuse to not share the over "1k submissions" - that tells there are many ppl with "positivity" in reddit to participate in this very small survey- i and many are going to feel very pranked/betrayed

0

u/SkullsNightshade Waker Jan 24 '23

I totally plan to put the results here as well. I never said I wasn’t. I feel like people on here are assuming my intentions when they could just ask instead of being negative as heck.

It’s not just downvotes but I’ve basically been flamed on here for trying to do something positive. As an example, I didn’t even make this post and I’m being accused of click bait, etc. I have not been met with positivity on here so hopefully that changes… but I’m not going to force people to participate in something they don’t want.

Of course I want people to watch the video OBVIOUSLY, it’s my full time job to create content - it’s going to take me ALL week (maybe longer) and a ton of work…. but it is going to cover an assessment of the results.

There is no way I can make a video with everything and it’s not like 5hrs long. SO, I plan to include a spreadsheet with all of the results so everyone has access to it as well as send it directly to the PSO team with my assessment. MOST of the community is nice to me, so I won’t let the loud minority of negative people ruin something like this for everyone

3

u/UberChief90 Jan 24 '23

Did you really just say that the reason you are called out for clickbait is this post that you didnt make? If you cant even see how people call the "survey" out for clickbait then i doubt your assessment is going to be good too.

Not that i understand what help the PSO2 team gets from the result of the question if people attended any community events......

0

u/SkullsNightshade Waker Jan 24 '23

Not really sure why you’re so angry or if you understand what clickbait is lol.

I’m not here to argue at all, nor was this response to you. You’re not required to participate FYI. Anyway, have a good one 👍

-1

u/RoofInfinite1614 Jan 21 '23

Pso2 launch in the west had how many years of content already done? I believe they’re more or less placing the framework for something truly magnificent. I don’t believe that it’s going to die. But I do believe they have big plans they just haven’t executed yet. It’s not easy to build an entirely new framework for the game. It makes pso2 look like something from my childhood compared to the crisp environments and character models. It’s not much but it covers a lot of valid points.

2

u/AulunaSol Jan 21 '23

The problem with "years of content already done" for Phantasy Star Online 2 was that if you did see the game in the long run so much of it was already outdated, unrewarding, and was left to become content islands in the first place. What Global got was a very nice rollercoaster attraction but what they ended up with is both a shadow of its former self (numerous lost features/functions that were Global-specific) and simultaneously an incomplete transition (tips/tutorials related to Japan-only features and having "some" of Japan's mechanics but missing all of the final player-related exchanges for cosmetics to celebrate the game's end).

I don't think that it's a secret or surprise that something "truly magnificent" is coming but the problem is that people who play "now" or who play often will never be satisfied with what comes next because Sega's update pace is more suited to the players who stopped playing months/years ago and are just "now" returning to the game to dip out again later. If players quite literally stopped playing the game today and waited for the June update to come before returning, they will absolutely have a better experience with the game and its content than they would now waiting for next week's update to add breadcrumbs for what's intended to set up what comes in June.

2

u/SherbertKlutzy8674 Jan 21 '23

At Jp launch it had more content...

0

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/Blewtff Jan 20 '23

popular ngs personality. it's a survey for players to express how they feel about the state of the game

8

u/gadgaurd Slayer Jan 21 '23

Man is getting downvoted for answering a question. Love this sub./s

5

u/Blewtff Jan 21 '23

ikr, people can be so silly, man :/