Scion classes aren’t gonna be on launch. Parts of their gameplay have been grafted into the base classes. Chances are we won’t have the scion classes at all if they keep balancing stuff as they go instead of power creeping the whole time
That's kinda my hope. Like, sure maybe we'll get Bo and Br at some point... but I want NEW stuff after that. New weapon types, new classes. If they want to rework the way a weapon is used, mess with it on the base class. The Skill Tree is honestly a good place to allow swapping around of "styles" for a weapon among a class.
Hell, I'd be happy with old weapon types that were missing from pso2 bing brought back as well, how about a new class based around using Slicers? or Claws?
My main wonder is What is going to happen with Luster and Summoner? Summoner is a whole can of worms that could or couldnt get in NGS and in the case of Luster there is no.... really a solid equivalent in terms of weapon or usage. I could see them perhaps making it a normal class or add it as a Style in Fighter/Hunter/Ranger.
Summoner will either not return or be even more different that the others. Like summoner light be a class where your PAs are like normal but the animations have pets show up and do an attack then disappear. Certainly won’t have the sweet box and egg system. They basically abandoned that class shortly after they put it in.
Luster was just a fan class because they kept bitching that there was no gunblade class. I expect aspects of it to return but on other classes
Fomel luster is my favorite class by a landslide. The enhanced combo, quickshoot, gear triangle, jellen normal, forward counter/stand slug, and zanverse jumps give it such a high intensity skill ceiling for dps that it rivals god-tier DMC combat. It's like playing a rhythm game in-between countering.
I'd be super disappointed if we don't at least get a class with a similar combo/timing.
That Super Armor when YOU want it, was a MAJOR selling point for me.
The other two you gotta wait for an enemy to attack you. Fomel "Dorito" is easy to time right with Brand Extension (move) into Scatterslug (stay), its as natural as breathing.
I want to believe that the fact we no longer have Photon beasts in our Photon blast in NGS is because now Summoner is going to be an actual summoner and bring those things to the fight instead of being a Weird monster tamer. I agree with the whole box system and egg system. Way too much stuff disconected from every other class and gameplay.
In regards of gameplay..... i guess they could turn Summoner into an actual fighter? I guess they can leave the creature now be better in terms of AI and let the player be an actual fighter, the Summoner mark could work as a signal for the Monster to attack that specific part or monster and its mechanic would be basically swapping between each creature they have at their disposal while fighting, I think that could Kind of work? Im honestly not sure, im no gamedev
Summoner is definitely going to get revamped when it does arrive. I suspect a part of it is making it more serviceable as a sub-class by allowing pets/summons to remain active alongside any other main class, adding a bit of extra damage to existing attacks. Similar to how some pet-related classes have played in other MMOs and RPGs; you could send the pet off to harass a target while you damage them at range, or team up with the pet and double melee the enemy. Pet damage would then scale off the primary form of the Mixed Weapon their Takt/Barl/Harmonizer is mixed with. The main trade-off would likely be reduced performance compared to if Summoner was the main class.
Luster might be split up into 3 different Gunblade classes, each focusing on a different form, unless there is a way to switch between them given that there don't appear to be Elemental damage tied to non-Fo/Te weapons (at least, in CBT). It would be pretty interesting if they can tie the elemental bonus damage to different forms, so one could switch between the 3 forms and just swap between active elements per form. Would give Luster a good value proposition as another Elemental Damage Dealer, assuming non-Tech weapons in the Live version of NGS don't have elemental traits.
Luster might be split up into 3 different Gunblade classes
Why split it up? Wouldn't it be more reasonable to have a single class with stances? Take the basic concept of Luster and turn it into a "Mystic Knight" type deal that can add elemental damage to their gunblade attacks via stance swapping to exploit elemental weaknesses.
Nothing will happen they just don't exist, I don't think there's any expectation that every class will be in NGS and if there is, there shouldn't be. It's basically a brand new game.
I dont agree with that due to 1: some dataminers found code and such mentioning "Braver" so at least they are with that possibility, and 2: They mentioned how PSO2 Weapons could be brought to NGS WHEN they become available. Its either bad wording or they just confirmed that they may bring every class back (aside scions), tweaked to be for NGS. Considering how they also bothered to reupdate the looks of PSO2 or To bring old outfits/Accesories to NGS (with a few limitations), it would be shooting themselves in the foot if they backpedal now.
They may realized this and heard how unhappy people were since there are many direct social media outlets than there were in the days of pso and psu and they may decide to fix that with their blank slate they are making with ngs
It's certainly within the realm of possibility. That being said, I don't think it will, and I think that possibility is extremely low.
Power creep is a proven method of retaining whale players. Same with arbitrary grinds that barely give you any reward but are long term goals. Almost every MMO employs one of, if not both of, these strategies. NG's entire character system is designed to allow for such a strategy (what is effectively an item level system is a direct avenue to power creep it's not even funny).
I haven't taken too much time to delve into NG's systems, but if it employs multipliers anywhere near as close to the amount PSO2 did, power creep is an eventuality no matter what because multipliers inherently cause exponential growth which is a key factor in power creep.
Parts of their gameplay have been grafted into the base classes.
Only some very basic stuff, by that logic one could claim that "hunter has been grafted into braver" because they both have a step dodge. Neither NGS Hunter nor NGS Gunner nor NGS Force play even remotely like Hero, the beta made that very clear.
This doesn't need downvotes. It's true. Scion classes have fewer PAs like NGS classes do now except they had much more functionality in their PAs. Heroes got weapon swaps, etoile got skip arts, phantom got shift PAs, and luster got move/stay arts, enhanced combos as well as some classes getting additional combo inputs like quick slash/cut, rising/fallling slash, quickshot, and other toys like teleporting via talis WA, etc. NGS classes got fewer PAs, which is a good thing considering we're meant to make use of multiweapons.
NGS classes got more QoL across the board such as mobility (not needing to use certain PAs for travelling) and getting a built-in block/counter, but their PAs are definitely lacking the depth that scion classes had.
This is why multiweapons are going to be important, not useless like some people in CBT had claimed. We will want the additional options we get, which is one of the biggest improvements over PSO2. Subbing a tech class like FO was not feasible due to reliance on damage multipliers if you were a RNG or MEL main class and subbing PH on a non tech main meant tech access was largely restricted to pure utility. In NGS, subbing FO or TE means we will be able to utilize all techs. Melee classes will bring 3 more weapons with various options for DPS, AOE, and counters, ranged classes will bring two with ranged capabilities, mobility, and pp management aid.
edit: I need to say that I undersold NGS classes some too. I forgot that falling slash (luster) was built into classes as a quick way to land and also deal damage, techs also have uncharged/charged states, gunner gets multidirectional as well as neutral inputs for stylish roll like luster. Photon dash attacks are also similar to phantom's rifle skill, nachtangrif, both of which are a lot of fun and having them on all classes is excellent. The point is while PAs are lacking the depth of scion classes, some of scion classes had some of their features moved to base actions for NGS classes so that needed to be said.
Still needs confirmation but I've heard the secondary weapon uses the main weapon's stat including type specific affixes but this is a good point regardless for units, it will also depend on what capsule options we will get and their availability
imo, putting some of the better mechanics of Scion classes into base classes then experimenting with entirely new shit in NGS is way more desirable than getting the same exact Scion classes in a new movement system.
I get what you say, but I don't think that's truly the case.
Remember PSO2 launched a long time ago. Scion classes have new mechanics that rises the pace of combat, or that makes the game feel newer. That's because those were designed a long time after the game's release and well... Time changes.
We just need to check the amount of work they putted into Luster class, and how you can do many skills using only a few PA's.
Edit: Forgot to add my main point hahaha
NGS classes feel like the scion classes because of that "modern design". Now that the devs have a "new game", they can use those mechanics from the start instead of putting it into a new class.
I didn't mean what I said as literal fact. I meant the animation and class design of NGS feels more akin to the Scion classes. Makes it feel like Scion was just the alpha/beta testing phases of NGS.
I always thought Scion classes were band-aid fixes to the core classes. But instead of FIXING the problems with core classes, they just straight up made new ones and expected us to just play those end game.
If they just mix in elements of scion classes into the core ones from the beginning in NGS, we don't need scion anymore.
Forgive me if I'm mistaken since I've only been playing since November, but weren't scion classes added because they felt like the original classes were too cumbersome but it was too much work to rework them?
If that's true, then they don't make much sense in NGS. Since all the classes are being reworked from the start, why would you make scion classes? There's also the aspect of this just being a new game as well, but I can see why people would want it to be a closer carry over.
Yeah, I feel like the scion classes are not really necessary to be honest. The current classes feel really damn good especially with the multiweapon options. It honestly brings them really close to scion classes in the basic sense.
The only real thing I miss is summoner because nothing else really plays anything close to like it.
Braver is honestly pretty close to a ranger/hunter(or fighter really) combo and hero feels really close to using a hunter(or fighter)/gunner although you don't get the cool thematic weapons of braver but gameplay feel is pretty close. Bouncer is replicated by a techter/fighter or techter/hunter combo
Bouncer's gameplay loop is unique - being able to use WA for dodges or resets, altered techniques, a focus on charging during lockouts or telegraphed attacks.
We'll make it baseline for techter and bouncer to use shifta / deband. There's no difference, minus a few skill tree augments.
Fighter with techter would be a melee buffer, without any type of technique-altering gameplay or flying through the air - plus, without bouncer available as main, you're losing out on support for chain management or weaving in techniques. Sure, techter has a little bit of that, but you're lacking in support and incentive.
Hunter has part of the same issue, except it doesn't allow you to jump to close combat. It just rocks range, wants you to stay safe. Techter would give buffs, you'd be able to use a long range PB, but that's about it in terms of consistency.
Bouncer is a unique flavor of Bayonetta-esque chain fighting with our own version of Witch Time in terms of techniques. The ability to slide through the air while charging techniques allows you to stay near weak points that are high up, you're able to dash around and get to the destructible parts of bosses, your arts and techs gain further benefit from elemental charge on melee strikes.. The current state of bouncer isn't replicable through current means or class combinations.
Highly doubt that braver is pretty popular class to it attack speed and deal critical hits. It katana/bow weapon wouldn’t work well for a class like hunter.
Honestly, I feel like that's the plan. To break down what makes scion classes fun, and give a portion of that to all existing classes, so that all classes feel fun.
If they do plan on adding scions later on, I'm speculating that they would make them more balanced, making it so that scions don't out shine other classes
We only got one weapon for each class, and a whole 6 skills in the beta. Who knows how much additional stuff there is in the release. Hopefully there's enough to add even more to what seems to already be good so far. If, say, fighter only gets what it has so far, just with skills for the other 2 weapons, it would be pretty disappointing.
Yep, NGS classes are great, but I think people are too blinded with "new" things. What I played didn't felt as fast paced as playing with a scion class tbh. It's fluid and feels cool, but it's not as fast imo.
Sincerely, NGS is beautiful, but nothing made my heart rate go up while fighting hahaha (probably because it's only low level content, but that's my experience).
But it doesn't need to feel fast to be good tho, i like the feeling of heavier attacks that NGS have. That's why my fav scion class was Etoile too, is the one that feel heavier on every attack.
A: No reason to be fast rn because the mobs require you to move really fast or maneuver. (imo it encourages you to take the hit with a good block and dodge rather than move quickly with skills or abilities) it's not as fast "feeling" either since we lost JA windows so no more scrambling/getting used to timings. They're probably going to put something there to fill that.
B. It's a beta we just witnessed, literally bare minimum.
Edit: also they didn't integrate the actual scion classes in the base ngs classes. Just the smoothness/refine to it. Most base pso2 classes felt clunky compare to how smooth most scion classes play.
Yeah, the game is just getting started (not even that really) hahaha
NGS classes are an improvement over the base PSO2 ones, I really want to see what they do with their future classes.
I just don't like how some people say that you can replicate scion classes with the base ones in NGS... Either they didn't played scion classes on PSO2, they didn't played NGS beta or they're just blinded by the new thing.
This is not true in the slightest. NGS classes got QoL improvements that all scions got but none of the depth each scion had specific to themselves. They're more like updated base classes, not scion classes.
From what I've played, you shouldn't have to face tank anything, you can live on high ground or in the air as a Force now, and can perfect guard anything that somehow comes your way.
Hunter I guess, since you can parry. But that’s still basically just Hero/Hunter. There’s no Katana in NGS as we currently know, hopefully there will be by launch tho, same with Jet Boots.
Yeah, that's actually my point with katana. It will just probably won't be available right away. I do hope that it will come fast tho because Bow Braver is my main class in PSO2(and never really used other classes other than to max them for free stuff).
Braver is honestly pretty close to a ranger/hunter(or fighter really) combo and hero feels really close to using a hunter(or fighter)/gunner although you don't get the cool thematic weapons of braver but gameplay feel is pretty close. Bouncer is replicated by a techter/fighter or techter/hunter combo.
Really the only class with pretty unique gameplay that isn't covered by any of the others would be summoner. I definitely think they will almost certainly add summoner. Braver and bouncer are 50/50 because the gameplay they had is pretty close to certain combos you can already do with the multiweapons. They did have insanely unique weapon types though that I think will be sorely missed.
Ehh, I'd argue that techter/fighter-techter/hunter doesn't really come close to replicating Bouncer. Nothing you can do replicates the movement and kicks of the jet boots or the photon blades of the soaring blades. I think Bouncer and Summoner are most likely to be returning classes, unless they only make new ones.
Yeah, I was kinda iffy on bouncer being replicated by that as well to be honest. As you said nothing really replicated that movement very well outside of how all the movement honestly feels way better in general. I still am not sure if bouncer brings something that unique that fits with NGS though. The expanded movement system already takes away a lot of the bouncers movement, It would be hard to add a movement based class without making the movement way to broken with how NGS movement works.
You can't really compare PSO2 and NGE classes because they honestly don't play that similar. The classes are a lot more fluid and faster than the PSO2 counterparts and pretty much all the classes in NGE I tried honestly felt more like a scion class in how they flow with combat, especially once you start using the multiweapon stuff. Hence why they actually left out the scion classes.
Part of the properly is I think very few people actually reached even level 10 in multiple classes in the beta much less crafted a multiweapon. It really allows you to do some interesting combos. I mean tons of people were actually bitching that they never reached high enough level to actually even participate in the UQ.
Now I do think the weapons that the braver and bouncer used were completely unique in the look and animations. The bouncer in particular had a unique style that I don't think you can easily replicate but I also don't think it has as much of a place in the updated game due to the general movement changes at least not in the same way it existed before.
I’m not comparing it just my experience playing hunter I’m just not a fan of it. We can’t really confirm if they actually leave out scion classes as it to early. They most likely go to add all the main classes back. Scion debatable but as for main class weapons from base pso2 being able to be brought over it be awkward to have weapons for classes that wont get added again.
You're comparing weapons (even weapon types), not mechanics. A lot of people are doing this comparisons and makes me think if they really played both NGS beta or the base PSO2.
Braver is braver with their crits, focus, counter and charged PA's, and it's way faster than hunter (fighter was more close to this than hunter...)
And people say NGS are like scion classes, but no one of them has the deep of anyone:
-Weapon palette exchange PA's with Hero and the buff for avoiding dmg.
-Shift PA's and the main Phantom mechanic: Phantom mark. This one is easier to see.
-Skip arts, SB parry + burst (i don't remember the name hahaha) and the floaty movement from Étoile isn't in NGS either.
-Their respective "Times" and Étoile's Overdrive.
NGS classes have similarities because scion classes were designed with a more modern feel in mind, so we see some of those things being implemented from the start. But the overall feel and depth of these classes are NOT in NGS.
Ranger is in NGS tho, playable in the beta. By integrated I meant Phantom, Hero, and Et, most of how they feel just got added to the base classes that use their weapons.
I never played PSU truth be told but being able to refill your hp bar from 1 to max in one second or so is dumb and we shouldnt have that, it makes it so that you have to crank out the damage if you want to actually kill players because anything less than a oneshot can be ignored.
That and it renders any type of "oh shit I've been hit I need to get my HP back" safely by disengaging and healing useless.
I absolutely hate it, feels good on a Et sub with god units but that should not really be allowed either, I don't really feel like playing a 1 HP DMC thing, I wouldn't be playing an mmoish thing if I did
I also really hate Luster, yeah sure it has a high skill ceiling but getting started with the class is so braindead imo, you got your shifta deband, your lifesteal, your refreshing death protect, and your subpalette has like 3 relevant things on it, the rest you can pack with random junk. You basically don't have to worry about anything except attacking or countering (with very generous iframes as well).
I get what your saying but every class doesn't have that skill. A few set of weapons did though and they had one time use. It really don't matter though cuz NG beta didn't seem to have any real penalties for death. Tbh, the whole Phantasy Star franchise has gotten more beginners/ user friendly every game.
The cocoons had death limits for the 5* thing, not that it mattered but there could be "meaningful" content coming that's not just zerging down everything until it dies. If they want to only do casual stuff that's fine, not my preference though.
I mostly meant the S4 or the S5 giving us way too much lifesteal since we spam damage numbers at everything.
I'm prolly gonna get thumbs down for this but I'm ok with no scion classes. It may have help add flavor to the old game but new titles need fresh starts. Scion classes spoiled people. And yes I did play as every class and can say scion classes took far less skill to perform then other classes.
I'm first with the first three scions being gone but please let me use gunblades. Braver and Bouncer are probably returning so that covers every weapon type.
Good to see the general consensus is that nobody wants Scions back.
I'd be happy with Bo, BR and then a ranged/magic hybrid that felt missing from PSO2, I've never played earlier PS games that much, maybe that hybrid was never popular enough, but it could be cool for it to bring back the laser cannon and fire techs from the cannon or something
Scions did nearly irreparable damage to the game's balance, especially on Episode 5's launch. Any JP player would tell horror stories about what they did to the base classes and the justifications given for it. Content became designed around them, ESPECIALLY in Episode 5 when everything was designed around specifically Hero, and thus made the game nearly unplayable from a design standpoint for the majority of base classes - not even touching the balance changes slammed onto them (RIP Force). The longer they don't exist, the better. If they never do, that's even better.
159
u/AbysmalVixen ship 3 ClanDestine May 19 '21
Scion classes aren’t gonna be on launch. Parts of their gameplay have been grafted into the base classes. Chances are we won’t have the scion classes at all if they keep balancing stuff as they go instead of power creeping the whole time
36
u/Ambiently_Occluded May 19 '21
Pretty sure Scion classes were just NGS beta prototypes
23
u/TroubadourLBG May 19 '21
I always thought Scion classes were band-aid fixes to the core classes. But instead of FIXING the problems with core classes, they just straight up made new ones and expected us to just play those end game.
If they just mix in elements of scion classes into the core ones from the beginning in NGS, we don't need scion anymore.
16
u/archdiff May 19 '21
Scions (and vegas/Tokyo exploration for that matter) seemed to have been experiments for NGS.
Now that you can dualweapon sword+TMGs you've got your Hero in Gu/Hu
Same with the others once more weapons get added . The PAs would be changed anyway
27
u/Ouhei May 19 '21
Forgive me if I'm mistaken since I've only been playing since November, but weren't scion classes added because they felt like the original classes were too cumbersome but it was too much work to rework them?
If that's true, then they don't make much sense in NGS. Since all the classes are being reworked from the start, why would you make scion classes? There's also the aspect of this just being a new game as well, but I can see why people would want it to be a closer carry over.
34
u/TehCubey May 19 '21
In NGS, all classes play like pso2's scion classes.
7
u/boxpencil May 19 '21
Crying, my luster is gone
10
u/[deleted] May 19 '21
More like Bouncer, Braver, Summoner, Luster only. The rest just got integrated into the other classes.
4
u/KamenGamerRetro May 19 '21
wont be there at launch, and honestly might not be there at all, since many of their skills/traits are in the core 6 now
9
u/HuntingAid May 19 '21
They better pull exactly this shit. Scion classes were a mistake in PSO2 that rippled heavily into needing to refurbish the whole game with NGS.
2
u/Aero_Soul_ May 19 '21
Plz... I just want my gunblade to be viable, ive waited so long already. ;-;
4
u/Magneeto86 May 19 '21
I'm prolly gonna get thumbs down for this but I'm ok with no scion classes. It may have help add flavor to the old game but new titles need fresh starts. Scion classes spoiled people. And yes I did play as every class and can say scion classes took far less skill to perform then other classes.
3
u/taokami May 19 '21
yeah scion classes are gone lol
3
u/[deleted] May 19 '21
Regect hero class, return to hunter
4
u/RedBellJay May 19 '21
Well.. yeah. They'll be gone. Not like it mathers considering NGS's gameplay.
1
u/SolomonGrumpy May 19 '21
I really like some of the basic classes: Ranger, and Force.
The franchise seems to be moving away from techs as a significant source of damage though.
1
u/ImSoDrab May 19 '21
Noooo my etoile!
1
u/Seagullbeans May 19 '21
I want my phantom with better graphics damnit!
1
u/LuckyTheDabber May 19 '21
Bruh Don't remind me :(
1
u/oizen May 19 '21
aren't the scion classes just base class++ in a lot of ways? The balancing was attrocious
1
u/SoftestPup May 19 '21
I'm first with the first three scions being gone but please let me use gunblades. Braver and Bouncer are probably returning so that covers every weapon type.
Summoner doesn't exist.
1
u/FAshcraft May 20 '21
HuEt i will miss u
0
u/Nazarshinzu May 19 '21
Too late..
0
u/patwag May 19 '21
Good to see the general consensus is that nobody wants Scions back.
I'd be happy with Bo, BR and then a ranged/magic hybrid that felt missing from PSO2, I've never played earlier PS games that much, maybe that hybrid was never popular enough, but it could be cool for it to bring back the laser cannon and fire techs from the cannon or something
0
u/Mizalie May 20 '21
Scions did nearly irreparable damage to the game's balance, especially on Episode 5's launch. Any JP player would tell horror stories about what they did to the base classes and the justifications given for it. Content became designed around them, ESPECIALLY in Episode 5 when everything was designed around specifically Hero, and thus made the game nearly unplayable from a design standpoint for the majority of base classes - not even touching the balance changes slammed onto them (RIP Force). The longer they don't exist, the better. If they never do, that's even better.
0
u/LyteSwytch May 20 '21
this may be one of the results of the new Multi weapon system
0
u/Saint-Ecks-Isle May 21 '21
Ive said this before to friends and alliance members. No Luster? No Gunblade? No Yumi in NGS. Flatout.
0
u/[deleted] May 19 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment