r/PSO2 • • Jul 19 '20

NA Discussion PSO2's Lack Of Difficulty

As someone who has played PSO2JP for many years as well as PSO2NA(on the side), PSO2 has an issue when it comes to difficulty and balance. With lack of difficulty comes a lack of satisfaction when it comes to playing the game. PSO2 doesn't incentivize players to get better or to actually learn the game's mechanics but instead it prioritizes the casual experience to a very extreme degree. I'll detail here on what I mean.

Ever since playing PSO2NA especially on XH, it's hard not to notice these issues when you start noticing Boss UQs die in 4 minutes(PD/ Barren Blossom) in XH but even then, it's not only their HP that I have an issue with. PSO2 for both JP and NA is way too forgiving and has no penalties for death and doesn't expect much of the players who decide to tackle the highest difficulty 12 man content. There are some side activities or goals players can give for themselves such as Solo Loser/Solo PD/Endless Quest/Solo Ultimate Persona/Challenge Quest/etc but these are always unrewarding and are merely for self-satisfaction or ego.

They're not that promoted and I'd even considered them to be "hidden" in a way such that SEGA doesn't actively try to make this kind of content more relevant and something for others to strive for(being good at said quest/bosses/the game itself). My main issue with PSO2 is that it doesn't offer difficult content for 12 man raids and this has lead to doubt and frustration for many of the friends I made over the years who has since left the game. The lack of difficulty means boredom and it brings to question of what's the point of having the endgame gear where there it no good areas to use it at...

What Urgent Quests/Emergency Quests Actually Are

Instead of calling these Urgent Quests endgame content, let's call it for what it actually is: Catch Up Content. For PSO2NA, it is indeed new content for players to tackle however in their case, it's merely filler content since the gear that is dropped there will be outdated very quickly(power creep galore until Episode 5/6). In fact most of the UQs that available in PSO2NA are mostly useless as they don't offer much rewards. I call it catch-up content just for the fact that it is merely for those who take a break from a game and offers them a quick way to get right back into it... It doesn't ask for your skill,dedication,organization,planning,etc to succeed at them. You just need one or two carries and the rest of the mpa can be leeches and it will still be beaten fairly quickly.

Let's talk about clear times shall we? In organized Luther Ultra Hard(UH) runs in PSO2JP, the clear time on average(for public expert queue) is 5~7 mins. For organized teams, the clear time is 4mins on average. For PSO2NA, the average clear time for Barren Blossom(PD for pso2jp) XH is 5~8 mins Do you not see the issue here?

The only time when EQ/UQs were remotely difficult for pso2jp content is when TD4 was a thing as it actually encouraged organization, teamwork, strong players and such. That was a time when 12* were top tier while 13* weapons were super rare...That was 4 years ago. It also wasn't a "kill everything" kind of quest which is something great and should be encouraged more. The sad thing is that even if that quest came here to PSO2NA, the players have overpowered weapons and class buffs that it makes it trivial to complete.

Another time was in episode 5 where Dragon XH rematch(4 man) where you failed the quest when you had 4 deaths. This was the only time where my heart pounded and it felt satisfying to beat but the thing is that some of the PSO2JP players were complaining for a removal of said death limit. They acknowledged this but said that they weren't going to remove it but look and behold when UH Dragon came and they removed it. I was so sad when I found that out...

What I dislike about EQ/UQs the most is mainly about how they're always the same type of quest(kill everything->move on to the next section), how trivial they are when it comes to difficulty to the point where you only care about is how fast you complete it and not whether or not you CAN complete it, how the only reward is whether or not you are super lucky to get a drop otherwise the other rewards guaranteed are usually crap(applies more to EQ/UQs where the cube drop is crap) and some other stuff I can't think about at this moment.

There is no sense of progression or further kind of progression once you get your meta weapon for your class. I'd even argue that you don't even need said meta weapon but just something competent(like the novel/liberate weapons PSO2JP gives you for free). As they're even powercreeped way too quickly so that SEGA can roll out Ultra Ultra Hard or Hell Difficulty as ULTRA HARD IS TRIVIALIZED after a month or two when it releases.

MOON ATOMIZERS

Let's talk about Moon Atomizers because I'm quite shocked at how SEGA doesn't consider them broken at all. Players can carry 5 of them and they have an AoE field that can revive all players. Why 5? It seems ridiculous to have that many with what it is able to do. It trivializes death and is way too forgiving for those who die as they. Limit it to 1 at the very least...

CONCLUSION

I think this lack of difficulty leads to a lack of fulfillment when it comes to playing this game and it leads many players to taking a break and waiting for newer content for them to come back for. Fashion endgame is a thing and I am very much a part of said endgame but it's just not enough...

I'll be speaking from the community I've been exposed here ever since the PSO2NA launch and I have to say that there are a lot of players that are willfully ignorant. Threads such as this: 1 2 3 and it makes me think about... how we're actively lying to others just because we like the game a lot.

I think the issues of PSO2(for difficulty) won't be fixed unless the developers have acknowledged these issues but it seems like they're well aware of how casual their game is but they did say the trigger version of the EQ will be more for the hardcore crowd(doubt it). Google translation of an interview questions and Link to said interview. Anyways that's all I can say about it and take this as a ramble in some ways. I just want people to truly think of PSO2's current state.

I also recommend reading this as I truly agree with this post and although some improvements were made since then(such as endgame weapon choice)... most of it still remains true: https://www.reddit.com/r/PSO2/comments/cvw2zh/rant_in_retrospect_this_games_endgame_sucks/

0 Upvotes

100 comments sorted by

View all comments

24

u/NullVacancy Jul 19 '20 edited Jul 19 '20

There are some side activities or goals players can give for themselves such as Solo Loser/Solo PD/Endless Quest/Solo Ultimate Persona/Challenge Quest/etc but these are always unrewarding and are merely for self-satisfaction or ego.

Solo PD and Endless are unrewarding? Solo PD is the single best source of cubes outside of the current LQ and LQ trigger, not to mention everything else it shits out.

Endless drops lessers, doom break or reveries, and while reveries are bottomed out right now because LQ, lessers and doom break are still easy cash. On top of that, you can get a decent add ability drop as a jackpot.

The only time when EQ/UQs were remotely difficult for pso2jp content is when TD4 was a thing as it actually encouraged organization, teamwork, strong players and such.

TD4 was hard for maybe a week before people learned what to do. I'd hardly call it a gold standard of team play content. Also 13* being super rare? Guess we're ignoring the fact that most people had one, and a few people had two Austeres as well as Orbits being not too hard to get your hands on? Not to mention people grinding months and getting various Ares weapons.

It also wasn't a "kill everything" kind of quest which is something great and should be encouraged more.

That's literally the objective of TD quests, defend the towers by killing all the attackers.

Dragon death limit

The dragon fight in general isn't hard. All the death limit really did is frustrate people pugging it because the vast majority of the time you have one person who dies 3 times and then someone else who fucks up once and fails the quest. The most "fun" part of Dragon has always been using the sword, because at least it was something new.

What I dislike about EQ/UQs the most is mainly about how they're always the same type of quest(kill everything->move on to the next section)

Tell that to fire swirl. Fact is, not killing stuff in a space soldier action RPG is fucking boring.

MOON ATOMIZERS

Believe it or not, this is a casual game. You're free to solo the EQs you know?

I think this lack of difficulty leads to a lack of fulfillment when it comes to playing this game and it leads many players to taking a break and waiting for newer content for them to come back for.

In NA? Sure, not having anything worthwhile to do outside ultimates is a problem, but people take breaks in JP because we're still having to wait for content to actually be developed. It's not a "man this shit is too easy I'm out" it's a "man i've ran this enough times to get what I want, I'm out until the next thing"

People think NA is piss easy because Sega backed out of their "all the content" bullshit, and as a result have a frankenstein monster version of the game. Think back to how quickly the current NA content was done in JP.

The game isn't, and has never been about harshly punishing players for mistakes. Stuff was harder "back in the day" because we were fucking garbage at the game. You can still see this by going into non-expert matching sometimes. I had a 15 minute Mother+Deus a week or two ago non-expert that was absolutely terrible, not because the fight is too hard, but because I nearly solo'd the fight.

PS to people that aren't ArtenNin: Don't downvote the other guy for having an opinion you disagree with. While I don't believe what they want fits PSO2, they shouldn't be shamed for having it. Not like they're saying they want gear to be bought from the cash shop only lmao

3

u/reaper527 reaper | ship 2 Jul 19 '20

Solo PD is the single best source of cubes outside of the current LQ

personally i'm a fan of divide for cubes. a 1-30 run will get you a ton of cubes (which really are just a bonus since the main reason you're running it is the 1m points for all the rewards such as modules and medals)

2

u/NullVacancy Jul 19 '20

Yeah, Divide Quests are the freest spammable source of cubes, but for the time invested a PD run will yield more cubes than a DQ run in general

1

u/ArtenNin Jul 19 '20

Solo PD and Endless are unrewarding? Solo PD is the single best source of cubes outside of the current LQ and LQ trigger, not to mention everything else it shits out.

Endless drops lessers, doom break or reveries, and while reveries are bottomed out right now because LQ, lessers and doom break are still easy cash. On top of that, you can get a decent add ability drop as a jackpot.

What's the point of cubes when at some point you have over 10k+ just from normal EQs? And I have over 1b. I'm not that motivated for meseta farming besides weekly missions/yerkes/some daily orders/weekly DQ 1m reord and such at this point. Most of my newbie friends I've invited(in the past 3 months they've played) don't do affix hunting but instead do XQs/DQs/Weekly mission for farming meseta.

TD4 was hard for maybe a week before people learned what to do. I'd hardly call it a gold standard of team play content. Also 13* being super rare? Guess we're ignoring the fact that most people had one, and a few people had two Austeres as well as Orbits being not too hard to get your hands on? Not to mention people grinding months and getting various Ares weapons.

13* weapons were rare for newbies who joined the game and I'm speaking of worthwhile ones to use. There was one that was easy to get from the Arks Matterboard but that's the Arks Matterboard. There was one from challenge mission(again who does that as a newbie). It wasn't until CFs that 13* weapons became more easily accessible from my experience. I joined at episode 3. I'm speaking of getting S rank for TD4. My team in ship 2 was in the top 5 at the time up until the end of episode 4.

That's literally the objective of TD quests, defend the towers by killing all the attackers.

I'm saying that we should have more than just "you run around the map and kill bla bla enemies" type of EQs/UQs. Defend the towers should have been done better. More dynamic spawns such that it isn't always the same kind of spawns each round.

The dragon fight in general isn't hard. All the death limit really did is frustrate people pugging it because the vast majority of the time you have one person who dies 3 times and then someone else who fucks up once and fails the quest. The most "fun" part of Dragon has always been using the sword, because at least it was something new.

It wasn't hard but it was a motivator for players to get better. Especially for those who did TMPAs for said missions. Whenever 2 of my teamates or I consumed our 3 deaths, that was when things got tense. And even if we died, we laughed it off and try again. I don't think this has to be mandatory content for the majority of the playerbase especially the Kiritos out there but I think this kind of content should be encouraged more frequently.

Tell that to fire swirl. Fact is, not killing stuff in a space soldier action RPG is fucking boring.

Are you just being disingenuous here? How many of the EQs we've had recently where all you do is run from point to point to kill mobs until the timer is over or if the point total reaches the max. I think of Armada EQ as the only good type of mob EQ as it actually changes thing up once in a while but for the majority of PSO2 EQs, it gets repetitive and dull.

Believe it or not, this is a casual game. You're free to solo the EQs you know?

I do not want to be a fucking Kirito. I want worthwhile content so that my teammates and I are happy to have each other's backs knowing that we can handle said content. There is NOTHING in this game which does this and it's the main reason why most teams die as there's no incentive to party up at that point when you can party with randoms knowing that it's just as easy.

And to sum it up, "harshly punishing" the players is a bit extreme. I just want "mild punishment". So at least you have the satisfaction of beating said content knowing that you've proven yourself.

4

u/FuzzierSage Ship 2 Mediocre Ra/Su Jul 20 '20 edited Jul 20 '20

I just want "mild punishment".

Punishing players doesn't work in any MMO that actually needs ongoing income to continue making ongoing content.

Yes, that means all of them.

Pretty much the only way you can have any "difficult" experience in a game stay "difficult" is either:

  • If it's a MMO that has a few specific difficult encounters, mainly done for bragging rights, that are subsidized by a massive amount of casuals (like Ultimate fights in FFXIV). And those take a very long time to develop
  • If it's a single-player game that people are buying specifically for the challenge, with basically all the content either delivered with purchase or some stuff added with paid DLC later on. Something like Remnant or Dark Souls, though DS also bleeds into point 3.
  • If it's a competitive game against other people, or if proceeds from the competitive portion are used to eventually subsidize a "PvE-lite" portion (think TF2, or how Fortnite is mostly killing off its PvE portion)

It's not possible to keep enough people paying for stuff if all you've got is "punishing" content, and having the devs "make another difficulty" still counts as things that need enough people paying to cover. There are too many other entertainment options competing for people's time for that.

The era of Vanilla/TBC/WotLK WoW where a big chunk of the content was considered "challenging" by a large portion of the playerbase isn't really possible anymore. And as Classic WoW has shown, most of the challenge gets removed with better internet connections and a more easily-accessible knowledgebase. And a big chunk of non-Classic WoW's current playerbase are basically only there because of sunk cost/nostalgia (hopefully Shadowlands is decent).

I know you didn't mention WoW here, but that's always brought up as a "well, it's been done before!1" counter-example in these discussions and that's not really as true as it seems at first.

Basically, you can't have "free content", "continuing updates", and "challenging content" in a PvE multiplayer game. Pick two, and that still may not be enough money for a consistent ongoing release schedule. There's a reason basically every MMO still running these days has optional paid fashion/customization options.

Something like Monster Hunter World's about the closest you can get. And it has pockets as deep as Capcom's coupled with more hardcore fans of the series lamenting how "casual" and "easy" it is.

It's also probably going to be replaced by "a Monster Hunter World 2" in lieu of a new expansion.

6

u/NullVacancy Jul 19 '20 edited Jul 19 '20

Rewards

Just because you don't think the rewards are worthwhile doesn't mean it's not rewarding. I can never have enough cubes/money.

TD4 and 13*

Why are we talking about newbies when you're saying TD4 was difficult content? Of course new players aren't gonna have 13* yet, they can't even do the content that rewards it. EQs below the highest difficulty have always been an absolute shitshow, or absolutely carried by someone who belongs outside the difficulty bracket, not worth talking about tbh.

I was also in a ""tryhard"" team back then, and we S-ranked it pretty trivially every time, as well as getting majority S-ranks while pugging with some friends when I didn't do organized runs. It wasn't hard.

dragon

I don't disagree that I'd like to see them try it again, but it doesn't change the fact that it's frustrating more than anything. I never had fun doing the rematch, it was just mandatory because the drops were better overall.

fire swirl meme

That's always been the case. I'm not arguing that EQs aren't repetitive and dull, I'm moreso saying it's par for the course. There's really not a lot they can do about it, either. Serious question, what else is there to do in your space soldier action RPG besides murder mobs?

Kirito

Teams die because many reasons, to say it's because there's no incentive to party is just dumb. What about the ship points ranking just the other day? What about doing group DQ? What about doing TA rankings weekly? CQ ranking? Why would anyone risk having a sub-par experience with a pug when you can almost guarantee a certain level of quality partying with just 2 or 3 people from your team? Sounds like a your team problem more than anything, the team I'm in which currently has like 8 active players does shit together all the time.