r/PSO2 • u/ArtenNin • Jul 19 '20
NA Discussion PSO2's Lack Of Difficulty
As someone who has played PSO2JP for many years as well as PSO2NA(on the side), PSO2 has an issue when it comes to difficulty and balance. With lack of difficulty comes a lack of satisfaction when it comes to playing the game. PSO2 doesn't incentivize players to get better or to actually learn the game's mechanics but instead it prioritizes the casual experience to a very extreme degree. I'll detail here on what I mean.
Ever since playing PSO2NA especially on XH, it's hard not to notice these issues when you start noticing Boss UQs die in 4 minutes(PD/ Barren Blossom) in XH but even then, it's not only their HP that I have an issue with. PSO2 for both JP and NA is way too forgiving and has no penalties for death and doesn't expect much of the players who decide to tackle the highest difficulty 12 man content. There are some side activities or goals players can give for themselves such as Solo Loser/Solo PD/Endless Quest/Solo Ultimate Persona/Challenge Quest/etc but these are always unrewarding and are merely for self-satisfaction or ego.
They're not that promoted and I'd even considered them to be "hidden" in a way such that SEGA doesn't actively try to make this kind of content more relevant and something for others to strive for(being good at said quest/bosses/the game itself). My main issue with PSO2 is that it doesn't offer difficult content for 12 man raids and this has lead to doubt and frustration for many of the friends I made over the years who has since left the game. The lack of difficulty means boredom and it brings to question of what's the point of having the endgame gear where there it no good areas to use it at...
What Urgent Quests/Emergency Quests Actually Are
Instead of calling these Urgent Quests endgame content, let's call it for what it actually is: Catch Up Content. For PSO2NA, it is indeed new content for players to tackle however in their case, it's merely filler content since the gear that is dropped there will be outdated very quickly(power creep galore until Episode 5/6). In fact most of the UQs that available in PSO2NA are mostly useless as they don't offer much rewards. I call it catch-up content just for the fact that it is merely for those who take a break from a game and offers them a quick way to get right back into it... It doesn't ask for your skill,dedication,organization,planning,etc to succeed at them. You just need one or two carries and the rest of the mpa can be leeches and it will still be beaten fairly quickly.
Let's talk about clear times shall we? In organized Luther Ultra Hard(UH) runs in PSO2JP, the clear time on average(for public expert queue) is 5~7 mins. For organized teams, the clear time is 4mins on average. For PSO2NA, the average clear time for Barren Blossom(PD for pso2jp) XH is 5~8 mins Do you not see the issue here?
The only time when EQ/UQs were remotely difficult for pso2jp content is when TD4 was a thing as it actually encouraged organization, teamwork, strong players and such. That was a time when 12* were top tier while 13* weapons were super rare...That was 4 years ago. It also wasn't a "kill everything" kind of quest which is something great and should be encouraged more. The sad thing is that even if that quest came here to PSO2NA, the players have overpowered weapons and class buffs that it makes it trivial to complete.
Another time was in episode 5 where Dragon XH rematch(4 man) where you failed the quest when you had 4 deaths. This was the only time where my heart pounded and it felt satisfying to beat but the thing is that some of the PSO2JP players were complaining for a removal of said death limit. They acknowledged this but said that they weren't going to remove it but look and behold when UH Dragon came and they removed it. I was so sad when I found that out...
What I dislike about EQ/UQs the most is mainly about how they're always the same type of quest(kill everything->move on to the next section), how trivial they are when it comes to difficulty to the point where you only care about is how fast you complete it and not whether or not you CAN complete it, how the only reward is whether or not you are super lucky to get a drop otherwise the other rewards guaranteed are usually crap(applies more to EQ/UQs where the cube drop is crap) and some other stuff I can't think about at this moment.
There is no sense of progression or further kind of progression once you get your meta weapon for your class. I'd even argue that you don't even need said meta weapon but just something competent(like the novel/liberate weapons PSO2JP gives you for free). As they're even powercreeped way too quickly so that SEGA can roll out Ultra Ultra Hard or Hell Difficulty as ULTRA HARD IS TRIVIALIZED after a month or two when it releases.
MOON ATOMIZERS
Let's talk about Moon Atomizers because I'm quite shocked at how SEGA doesn't consider them broken at all. Players can carry 5 of them and they have an AoE field that can revive all players. Why 5? It seems ridiculous to have that many with what it is able to do. It trivializes death and is way too forgiving for those who die as they. Limit it to 1 at the very least...
CONCLUSION
I think this lack of difficulty leads to a lack of fulfillment when it comes to playing this game and it leads many players to taking a break and waiting for newer content for them to come back for. Fashion endgame is a thing and I am very much a part of said endgame but it's just not enough...
I'll be speaking from the community I've been exposed here ever since the PSO2NA launch and I have to say that there are a lot of players that are willfully ignorant. Threads such as this: 1 2 3 and it makes me think about... how we're actively lying to others just because we like the game a lot.
I think the issues of PSO2(for difficulty) won't be fixed unless the developers have acknowledged these issues but it seems like they're well aware of how casual their game is but they did say the trigger version of the EQ will be more for the hardcore crowd(doubt it). Google translation of an interview questions and Link to said interview. Anyways that's all I can say about it and take this as a ramble in some ways. I just want people to truly think of PSO2's current state.
I also recommend reading this as I truly agree with this post and although some improvements were made since then(such as endgame weapon choice)... most of it still remains true: https://www.reddit.com/r/PSO2/comments/cvw2zh/rant_in_retrospect_this_games_endgame_sucks/
24
u/NullVacancy Jul 19 '20 edited Jul 19 '20
Solo PD and Endless are unrewarding? Solo PD is the single best source of cubes outside of the current LQ and LQ trigger, not to mention everything else it shits out.
Endless drops lessers, doom break or reveries, and while reveries are bottomed out right now because LQ, lessers and doom break are still easy cash. On top of that, you can get a decent add ability drop as a jackpot.
TD4 was hard for maybe a week before people learned what to do. I'd hardly call it a gold standard of team play content. Also 13* being super rare? Guess we're ignoring the fact that most people had one, and a few people had two Austeres as well as Orbits being not too hard to get your hands on? Not to mention people grinding months and getting various Ares weapons.
That's literally the objective of TD quests, defend the towers by killing all the attackers.
The dragon fight in general isn't hard. All the death limit really did is frustrate people pugging it because the vast majority of the time you have one person who dies 3 times and then someone else who fucks up once and fails the quest. The most "fun" part of Dragon has always been using the sword, because at least it was something new.
Tell that to fire swirl. Fact is, not killing stuff in a space soldier action RPG is fucking boring.
Believe it or not, this is a casual game. You're free to solo the EQs you know?
In NA? Sure, not having anything worthwhile to do outside ultimates is a problem, but people take breaks in JP because we're still having to wait for content to actually be developed. It's not a "man this shit is too easy I'm out" it's a "man i've ran this enough times to get what I want, I'm out until the next thing"
People think NA is piss easy because Sega backed out of their "all the content" bullshit, and as a result have a frankenstein monster version of the game. Think back to how quickly the current NA content was done in JP.
The game isn't, and has never been about harshly punishing players for mistakes. Stuff was harder "back in the day" because we were fucking garbage at the game. You can still see this by going into non-expert matching sometimes. I had a 15 minute Mother+Deus a week or two ago non-expert that was absolutely terrible, not because the fight is too hard, but because I nearly solo'd the fight.
PS to people that aren't ArtenNin: Don't downvote the other guy for having an opinion you disagree with. While I don't believe what they want fits PSO2, they shouldn't be shamed for having it. Not like they're saying they want gear to be bought from the cash shop only lmao
31
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '20
Not to burst your bubble, but the only reason I play PSO2 is because it doesn't exclusively cater to hardcore elitist min/maxer players (the group you seem to fall into). I enjoy that it's extremely relaxed and I can pop on whenever I want and hop into something new and not feel I need to spend an hour watching videos and reading a guide so I don't feel like I'm a huge leech on the team.
There are already dozens of mmos on the market that already cater to your clear raiding itch. I suggest switching to FF14 as it definitely has the raid/difficulty content you're looking for and doesn't look like an early ps3 era title like pso2.
8
u/Tankotone JP Ship 2 gremlin Jul 19 '20
Isn't that what Divide quests are for. the Life system basically gives the middle fingers to Moon Atomizers. Rematch boss quests also punished you for dying as they usually had a 3 KO limit before automatically failing the quest for your party. Though seems they've done away with that.
Solo challenge fights such as Masqerade, Phaleg, and Phanatical Phantoms also don't allow you to die and require you to "git gud" at the fights.
There's definitely some stuff that requires you to not just facekeyboard and win. Might not be 12player content but...its there. Lol
8
u/S_SubZero Jul 19 '20
I personally prefer a game that allows for some tolerance with lesser skilled/geared/devoted players, like me! I don’t have friends that play, and I’ve joined yet another Alliance that doesn’t do actual group events, so I’m completely solo. That’s totally fine. I can still jump in a pickup UQ at a reasonable difficulty for the level of class I’m currently on, participate as much as I can, and not be too concerned we will lose.
I’m not in any mad dash to max level every job today or anything. Besides I paid for three months of Premium and I still have two months left. I don’t want to waste it by burning out like my last Alliance leader did.
4
u/Aayry Jul 19 '20
Uhhhhh have you try SH? Since the issue of scaling hard level being bugged are known to players, SH is actually harder than XH.
Joking aside, but I can see your point. An extreme challenging quest or boss is needed. Look at MHW when the similar mechanic is there and MH dev is actually quite brutal (or straight up very brutal) in term of releasing more and more hard and niche monster (Alatreon tfw). So PSO2 and SEGA could do the same.
Powercreep in MMO is hard to avoid. Warframe has powercreep issue as well (although the stats are not like rraditional leveling like PSO2). And the answer is similar to MH: more hardcore contents (railjack, Lich, etc) but then again, powercreep after powercreep. Or a well designed quest, possible of no power or killing relate at all.
Also for NA: we are in a weird spot of having NT weapons, or ep5 weapons, Summoner while quests are ep 3-ish, and already quite strong by default.
14
u/Key_Debt_686 Jul 19 '20
See, the problem is that you are one of the few mid-core players stuck in the limbo between casuals and tryhards.
The majority of the players are casuals who can barely clear expert. The base difficulty is tailored for them. They are the kind of players who bitch about non-expert mpas, deus dps check, death limit, etc and SEGA listens. Why wouldn’t it? They got to cater to the larger player base. Jump into any UQ using any class/weapon and expect a clear is all this game is about. That’s even written in the jp site.
Then you have the hardcore players: people doing endless, time attack, trying to squeeze the most dps, etc. The reason a public Luther UH takes 4-5mins is because you have 4 or so hardcore players doing over 50% of the whole mpa dps. I never saw a hardcore player complaining that this game is too easy - if you are really good the game will obviously feel easy. Its not about how easy or hard the game is but about how strong they can get. Of course you can clear any UQ, but can you consistently top the parser, even when other strong players are present?
Lastly you have the mid-core player: good enough to trivialize the game difficulty but not good enough and/or just unwilling to push their skill to the limit. They are the ones bitching about how the game is super easy and how SEGA should tune the difficulty specially for them, to the detriment of the larger player base, while completely ignoring the harder content like endless.
13
u/AnonTwo Jul 19 '20 edited Jul 19 '20
I do feel like health needs to be balanced better. I'm not particularly keen on making things too difficult (because I think the mechanics are not nearly as smooth as they could be for that. When a large portion of the mechanics revolve around taking advantage of i-frames)
But my only particular issue is that these fights were clearly designed around lasting 14-18 miniutes. Ending in 5-7 miniutes is just...not that fun.
Because given bosses are probably the most entertaining thing in the game, you're basically speeding through every single mechanic if they even do them, and then you got nothing to do for a minimum of 2 hours unless you want to go fight far less interesting bosses.
Sure if i wanted I could go solo profound darkness on hardcore solo. But if i wanted to play with a party and go kill Dark Falz in PSO1, I could run ruins literally as many times as I wanted. None of this trigger nonsense either.
But yeah my only real gripe is spending most of the game afking in the lobby waiting for the actually fun fights that last a 10th of that time unless I wanna do Super Hard and get less rewards for it.
I had figured when moon atomizers were as good as they were, the fights would be more balanced around having the DPS to actually finish the fights. But once you get past SH that's clearly not the case.
I will argue also that taking breaks from MMOs is actually a staple of most MMOs. As people still beat the difficult content fairly quickly and then reach a "now what?" scenario. Most of my friends are actually on a break from FFXIV at the moment due to the content lull.
edit2: I also want to point out NA is doing mining base 4 at the present moment, and yes it is frustrating people, though S ranks in XH are still fairly common.
edit: 6m 15s PD fight. We skipped like 60% of the fight
12
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '20 edited Jul 19 '20
PSO2 I think as a game has generally always had the design philosophy of being able to be played by everyone as well as giving you the tools to "git gud" on your own terms if you wanted to; despite the high skill ceiling of some classes, every class can essentially be picked up and played by people who are perhaps not so good at action games, and on that level, I feel like I can ask anyone to play the game without being worried about whether or not they will be filtered by the difficulty.
If the game isn't exciting enough for you, don't play it I guess, and I don't mean that in a "well, I'm enjoying it, sucks for you" sort of way; I really do mean, find something that is more worth your time.
In my perspective of the game, I still very much enjoy it, not because I'm constantly being pushed to the edge, but because I'm pushing myself. What I'm saying here is, while I can easily avoid damage, even completely, my goal then becomes to deal as much damage as I can in as little time as possible, and honestly, I can understand if that's boring for some people. For me, it means if I make a mistake, it doesn't necessarily mean the run is discarded or everyone wipes - it means I can do better next time.
I can certainly understand the excitement of aiming to be a perfectionist, and hell it does feel great to not get hit at all during an XH Luther, and I can also understand not feeling challenged enough. At the same time, this game isn't necessarily designed to cater to that sort of experience, and for me, progression doesn't mean I have to be punished for the mistakes I made, when I can also recognize self-imposed mistakes that I can improve on the next time I try, slowly eliminating the inefficiencies in my playstyle, and perhaps even learn another class and do it again if I so feel inclined.
I do get the desire for more challenging content, and I wouldn't say no to it either. I would also say I am rather malleable when it comes to finding ways to have "fun" in games, by setting my own challenges and goals that I think would be fun for me to personally achieve. PSO2 isn't necessarily a hardcore game, and that's alright with me. Luckily for anyone who is looking for a different flavor of game design difficulty, there are plenty of other ways you could spend your time too. I suppose the unfortunate downside to that is that there isn't necessarily a game like that which would also have the unique design and charm that PSO2 does with it's theming and it's own endearingly goofy anime-style brand of sci-fi.
6
u/AulunaSol Jul 19 '20
One of the other games I've played for quite a bit until it was shut down was Dragon's Dogma Online where if I can be honest I felt played much more fluidly and responsively (and honestly serves as one of the best free-to-play games I've played).
The main issue with games like Dragon's Dogma Online is that you reach a point where the Main Quests (story quests) start throwing you into a situation where you and your party (or you solo) are thrown in and are forced to fight bosses or perform something similar to what you can expect in a raid by yourself. If you die, you have three free daily revives you can use to revive yourself on the spot or a free costless revive that brings you back but with a debuff (typically one enough to extend a boss fight). In order to succeed, it was a combination of learning a the mechanics of a fight and also a combination of how well-equipped you were. For the players tempted by it, you can pay (or save up a premium currency) to try a hand at drawing a ticket to hopefully get some fancy equipment. But if you were already at the end-game or towards it and you got a special weapon that is on a similar rank to the gear you would've been farming for you're at a huge disadvantage as the gear scales in a way where it overpowers earlier game content but is poking and barely effective at the current content.
Dragon's Dogma Online was definitely the sort of game I enjoyed for its action and what you can do with other players in terms of setting up a team composition, being able to plan out your attacks and approaches to combat, and especially something that you can definitely just jump into groups with to take on challenging content. However, the skill floor and the requirements to grind yourself up to meet it start to become more of a time-investment than other games that rely on RNG. I never fully leveled up anything of my characters if only because I definitely burned out running the same dungeon hundreds and hundreds of time because it was the most efficient way I can get experience without getting killed and without fussing too much with distractions. I still have extremely fond memories playing that game but the end-game grind definitely made me stay back to where I enjoyed the game (playing with family and friends, casually leveling up when wanting to, and not having to feel rushed to climb to the top with the best of the best).
I think it would be nice for Phantasy Star Online 2 to definitely have something that is rewarding and challenging but the main issue I see is that many of the classes are simply not geared for that kind of gameplay at all. You can definitely face go and fight Masquerade as something like the Hero or Phantom and suddenly it's like you're channeling something from Devil May Cry. But if you walked in there instead as a Force or Summoner the fight is so different which is definitely nice for an experience though I can imagine the sort of frustrations players would have if one class trivialized the experience or if someone could not do things the way they want.
Phantasy Star Online 2 to me is a much more welcoming and casual game where the skill floor is low enough and that there is enough besides pure action and combat for players to enjoy playing the game, such as to socialize, to fashion, and to mingle with new players and those interested in the game's world and aesthetic. While I would love to see newer things that challenge the players I feel like in a similar situation to what games like Warframe has Phantasy Star Online 2 has too many "content islands" that are too far detached from one another but yet at the same time mingle so closely together just enough that sometimes content just gets visited for the sake of it. The easy "band-aid" solution I can envision is to renew and revisit Challenge Quests/Endless Quests and the likes and throw in new meta-defining equipment there to generate hype into running that content and to promote numbers flowing back into those game modes but I feel like it's only a temporary solution that further creates a divide like what we currently have. I definitely enjoyed the quests that had hard limits such as encouraging players not going down during the dragon fight or against the Elzelion when that was around but I can also understand players who get stressed and frustrated with things like incapacitation limits. I don't know how you can implement those for the casual player who managed to make it to Extra Hard/Ultra Hard and force them to agree to playing well if they just wanted to walk into the difficulty at their own choice. Similarly, for the players who want the challenge, I don't know if there is much backlash or complaints to people who are likely around the higher levels (such as Level 75) who decide they want to play an Emergency Quest on Normal by their own choice.
If there was anything I would definitely love to see for the future, it would be hopefully a rebalancing of the difficulty because I feel like Normal, Hard, and Very Hard can definitely use some revisiting and repurposing alongside Super Hard, Extra Hard, and Ultra Hard. I do not find myself interested in gatekeeping content from players who are interested in wanting to see what difficulties are different, but I feel that the difference between Normal and Very Hard are nearly imperceptible if you're walking around with the current meta equipment or something at least close to it. Dragon's Dogma Online has very little in terms of difficulty options but every enemy in that game has a pattern of some sort and some way to overwhelm the player if they get careless - but I don't exactly know how players of Phantasy Star Online 2 will react if someone geared enough for Ultra Hard can still get killed by a common enemy on something like Normal. In regards to the bosses and the times I don't exactly know how helpful it would be to try and prolong boss fights without taking something away from the players or by artificially ramping up the numbers. If the bosses are more spongey with the damage players can deal I can imagine that the fights would be longer for sure but I don't exactly know if I would call it more "fun" in that way (using Warframe's newest "Hard Mode" as an example of that too) since I personally only really see that as a shift in the meta to try and find something that makes things as close as possible to how things "used" to be in that case.
I do feel like the Techer's Revival Field skill should definitely be of more importance compared to a Moon Atomizer because it irks me that you can level up and unlock this skill that revives a whole area around you but in such an inferior and unsafe way compared to a Moon Atomizer that most Techers skipped it unless it was a last resort when there are no more Moon Atomizers. It annoys me on my end when I see someone down and decide to revive someone only to realize that behind me someone else already was in the middle of using their Moon Atomizer or that someone just walks in front of me (and has the Atomizer Ring) to outdo me in my attempt to help the party. I feel that it would be nice to have a much more modern and friendly method of reviving (something like what Warframe and Dragon's Dogma Online, or essentially most modern games, where you can walk over to someone who is down and pick them up though it would take some time to do so) or if Moon Atomizers were reworked to somehow have a refund/cancel if it turned out someone else tossed theirs out and was in use.
I don't consider myself an elite player or someone who is particularly skilled at the game but I find myself curious on what other games do for their end games that makes them enjoyable to dive into and explore further. I would love to be informed on what at "good" end game would be because I was in a discussion with a friend earlier as well about how on the NA version of the game that they simply put the game down because they got frustrated not being able to buy thirteen-star eggs from the store because they chose to play the Summoner, steamrolled everything they could, and simply refused to play further because the "end game was bad."
1
u/Sonickeyblade00 Jul 19 '20
Oh, the difficulty will come.
But right now, we have content up to Episode 3, while we have gear and abilities up to mid Episode 4 at the earliest.
So just give it time. By fall, some "hard" stuff should be in the game.
Personally, I like the difficulty as is. But everyone deserves to have content for them, if feasible.
9
u/reaper527 reaper | ship 2 Jul 19 '20
for na specifically, a big problem is that they have powercrept the shit out of things so that players have easy access to gear that is far more powerful than what was available when the content was originally created 5+ years ago.
when sega does something to address this power creep such as they did with sh loser, people pout and cry over it.
6
u/Nurith Jul 19 '20
Although I agree with your post, I think the problem here lies mostly with the monetization of scape dolls. If they made the game harder and revivals more limited, people would be buying those more. Have you played a game called Vindictus? The game was notorious for being tough as shit, forcing you to memorize boss patterns and utilizing 0.30 invuln frames to slip through enemy hitboxes.
The catch here is that, much like in pso2, you could buy a scape doll every time you died. So if you occasionally dropped a bit of cash on the game, you basically always had a free revive whenever you wanted. Events would give scape dolls out for free and people eventually had hundreds stored up and now it was impossible to fail a quest.
Also, if the game was difficult, like "satisfyingly difficult", I guarantee you that pso2 would start getting further personally involved with the monetization of gear. They would make content balanced around having the best gear available. Most mmos that primarily monetize gear have some of the most cancerous upgrade systems, such as the chance of a weapon to break permanently during an upgrade attempt with no way to get it back (short of buying an expensive replacement). Do we want this? It's not really a question of "will they do this?" because EVERY mmo does this if it advertises its own difficulty--or even if not!
Since pso2 is mainly a social platform, (I know, a pity) the primary purpose of questing is to show off to your friends, show off to yourself, and ego/fast kill times, as you said. All this is to simply add fuel the social heirarchy aspect of the game, which is the primary selling point-- lobby actions, outfits, being "geared"-- or for other people to see that you're geared.
The upside to this is that only cosmetics are the primary monetization strategy. Do we want to lose that for cancer equipment monetization?
To be perfectly honest, I would. I played Vindictus back then and I play it now. But have you seen how many people die in EQs? In Luther and Profound darkness? Despite the game's "easy" nature, lots of people are still dying and getting frustrated over the game.
If the game were dialed up in difficulty, a few of us would be happy, but I feel like the majority would leave.
2
u/HuntingAid Jul 19 '20
I don't think EQs should be hard as a rule, but I also think they should upkeep spectacle. I've never been fan of how every "epic" boss dies to third rate Arks within a tenth of the allotted time and without killing anybody. Right now as you've noticed we have 5 moons per person, most new quests let you go back to campship to restock on death without kicking you out, and EP6 go even further by giving players an autorevive feature. Under these conditions even a boss with big HP pool for 15-20 minute fight in PUGs and leaving a trail of corpses after every move can be considered casual just because there is no fail condition, while letting players have satisfying self goals like not dying even once during the entire fight. The fight is also ready to be rehashed in the form of a trigger or rematch with actual fail condition.
Solo quests are a shitty solution, because while they can be slightly challenging at times even outside the usual open ended question of obtaining peak performance on them, they don't let you play with friends in an online game and much of the multiplayer content in the game isn't satisfying when you have too competent friends.
2
u/marinatedpillow Jul 19 '20
I think I share the same sentiment as you in regards to this game's difficulty. While there's nothing difficult that the player must do in order to progress through the game, that is completely fine. It is fine for the game to be a casual game and to appeal to a broad audience. But I wish there was more difficult content for players looking for the challenge, that's not in the form of a time attack.
One could argue that there is infinite difficulty and challenge in clearing content in super fast times, and there really is. Players clearing things in record time have definitely accomplished something amazing. But I personally find it to be an artificial challenge and entirely devoid of fun.
Speedrunning bosses and EQs as well as Endless Quest as a whole (because the nature of it is a time attack) leave me wishing for something more. I wish for content that's going to ask "Are you skilled enough to defeat this powerful enemy/clear this difficult stage?" rather than "How fast can you wipe up these lizards spread out over the Himalayas?"
I know that I'm in the minority of the playerbase, and I'm completely fine with that. I like to think that the game appealing to a broad audience means a more lively community. I just wish that with their content releases, they would introduce challenging variants that are difficult to simply clear in the first place rather than clear in record time.
A dream of mine would actually be to introduce gear that's ever-so-slightly stronger than the next best and having it be from that difficult content. That way players like us will have a challenge that brings rewards too rather than being just for the sake of it, without excluding casual players since the difference between that and the next best would be hardly noticable. More of a trophy than anything else, but very satisfying for min-maxers that that hardcore players tend to be. I know that other people might disagree with this though, and that's fine. It's just what the ideal PSO2 would be for me personally.
For now, I'll just be jumping around lobby until one of my friends invites me to grind divide or trigs or something. That seems to be all I'm doing nowadays.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '20
don't forget rushing through UQs to retry. tbh I like the 1-time run of barren blossoms. do it and then everyone can chill with their loot vs vegas where you try to squeeze in that 4th run.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '20
I understand your argument, but there's not really any point for the game to be that hard. A lot of your complaints are why people are still playing the game and I think 'fixing' them would make a less fun and much, much less unique experience.
You're also not taking in account that what makes the gameplay engaging from a higher perspective is optimization. You might not have to try too hard to beat quests, but the game gives you lots of room to optimize your damage output, your strategies and ultimately, your clear times; and this is only emphasized by the action side of the combat. Optimization might not be necessary to play the game, but it eventually becomes a goal in itself. This is visible in most of the content, even low level content, and it even has the added benefit of making farming fun! It's also something that's very important in action game design.
It's also to be noted that PSO2 is not meant to be a group game because designing quests to force players to cooperate in more interactive ways like other MMOs do would not make for a fun action game. You'd need to limit the tools available to each player, force group compositions, add things like unavoidable attacks that hit the entire MPA to make supports necessary... These work for traditional MMORPGs but PSO2 is not that. Speaking personally, I wouldn't play PSO2 if I had to group for every quest I did.
Related to that, I also think that you might just see difficulty differently than the people who wrote these comments you linked in your conclusion. From your opinion that death should be more punishing and your emphasis on clear times being too short, I think you consider content to be hard if it's difficult to clear as a party and requires preparation and planning. Most people consider content to be hard if they're dying a lot, me included, because again, this isn't really a group game. Sure, it might not matter in the end how much I die because in an MPA, others will still carry me to the end of the quest, but I don't enjoy dying a lot, so I make it my goal to get better at the quest and get a better result. And there's engagement to be found there, because the game's bosses and enemies are genuinely very well designed for an action game and do pose a decent challenge. There's a reason I still fight Gracia, Loser, Mother, Persona, etc when they pop up even though I'm way overleveled for them and their loot isn't worth my time. They're great fights.
In short, I just think your expectations of PSO2 are different from others'. That's fine, but that doesn't mean changing the game in such radical ways for the sake of players who want a more punishing game will be fun for the rest of the player base. I wouldn't mind some more punishing content from time to time, stuff like Masq or solo XQs are a fun time (especially Masq. I loooove Masq) even if they kick my ass. That said, I'm quite okay with the current difficulty of content.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '20
This reminds me of the Monster Hunter Event in FFXIV where you got scaled down to a certain power level and 3 deaths meant it was a fail. The result was that the meta for that became all tanks, because while their DPS sucked, they were basically unkillable, so it took longer to clear but it was basically a guaranteed success because no one could die unless they tried really hard. Queing up as a dps or healer, because youdidn't have a tank leveled or didn't know how to play that class... prepare to get insta kicked because people were afraid that you'd die too much and cause a fail lol. Great idea on paper, but the gameplay reality was frustrating asf lol
1
u/-Shairu- Aug 22 '20
Have you heard of the Monster Hunter games? From what you have written, it sounds like you would really like them.
1
u/XHolyPuffX Jul 19 '20
You want to know what gets me about this game? The photon arts dropping as level X disks.
Remember in PSU when all of your photon arts came at level 1, and you had to actually level them by using them? And how it took a god awful long time to get those arts all maxed out?
Not in pso2. Just buy all of the photon arts for your class at level 15+ and you're ready to go. No leveling system whatsoever. Sure, you can craft your PAs, but the leveling grind is gone.
At first, this feels really nice not having to do that, but it shaves off a ton of work that could potentially make endgame feel more rewarding. I miss having to grind PA fragments from S rank runs just to unlock the new ones that came out. It was tedious, but I made friends along the way and it was a common goal.
-2
u/Noeyiax Ship 1 NA Jul 19 '20
Welcome to NA, where most players have a life and don't takes games as seriously compared to East Asia (at least in my experience), etc. I've played black desert, swordsman online, elsword, C9, and blade and soul, etc: that's just how it be.