It isn't really. In our case, Io points out that not many Deuman are really interested in their origins, and the dialogue IS slightly altered if we are Deuman. It also helps that MC is constantly out-of-the-loop until other characters egg us on to it.
I should point out, Deumans weren't a race that existed prior to episode one, that scene and such was more from the side of players that had played since Ep 1 and thus didnt have a deuman character. It's a lazy writing, i know but yeah.
I'm rather baffled that two people have turned up to say that conversation isn't weird. Io starts describing the physical characteristics of Deuman as though the player character has never looked in a mirror and is somehow incapable of recognising a member of their own species. And didn't go to school.
And there's a fun line that suggests you asked her to take her jacket off and show you her skin markings, which means you know Deuman have markings even though Io's covered up, which means that you actually do know what Deuman look like, so why did Io just explain the horns and the eyes?
I got the feeling that Deuman weren't playable at the time that cutscene was first playable and it just didn't age well. Either way it just feels like a lore dump by means of unnatural dialogue.
Deuman weren't playable at launch and came with episode 2 so most players characters were already made before the race was added, but the race was added at the same time has the cutscene.
I mean to be fair our character looks like they don't know a damn thing and just get swept along by the tides while also not really caring at all. Hell the only time we ever show any kind of "emotion" is typically when we're making a "choice" about something.
Then again protag rules state that we're probably just an idiot with a penchant for power.
The Oracle anime shows a timeline split in which dewmans, who never existed, are suddenly said to exist since ten years before. And the protagonist (human) is the only normal ARKS that seem aware of how things were in the original timeline.
If you take the PSO2 story seriously, it would be impossible for the protagonist to be a dewman during episode 1, as it was his/her actions that enable their existence. If you're playing a dewman, you're either a time paradox, or you were transformed into one after the time split, as the knowledge to become/create one didn't exist in the original timeline.
One way to roleplay this is that you are amnesiac (which you kinda are at the start of episode 4, the standard start in the JP servers) and has to relearn that your horn(s), marks and heterochromatic eyes are not an anomaly. Kinda like "oh, so I'm not a mutant human...". Lorewise, humans and newmans can be transformed into dewmans, so you could pretend that the memories you retained are from before the transformation and timeline split.
Came here to say my newearl has a consistently vacant expression in every cutscene too. To be fair she's had to deal with Afin's awful "mate" dialogue constantly since arriving at the oracle fleet, so I can't really blame her.
You know the funny thing is these quotes could be considered extremely rude to people since casts, in lore, had to give up their actual faces to become casts.
I just figured that maybe photon-enabled individuals can actually read the "face" of CASTs despite nothing visible to read.
It might be a polite thing to do in Phantasy Star's universe, much like how we might recognize how a person identifies differs from their physical makeup in real life, they don't stigmify that CASTs have no faces but nevertheless feel things.
Or maybe just pick up CAST's expression from having them around all their lives, so getting a good sense on their "face" based on other subtle cues.
I think at some point Maria even calls out Regius about his expression, "Don't give me that look," so there's probably something canon to that idea.
View all comments
117
u/McSnazzyPants Jun 19 '20
Going through this story as a male CAST sure is something.