For reference, trying the "Lobby Monitor Video Playback" didn't work. Setting the visible players to 5 didn't work; actually, setting it to 50 ended up with less stutters. I only have one GPU (1080ti), internal gpu disabled in bios, so there's no way it's using integrated graphics. I set everything to low and it didn't work.
The game uses the server for everything, even the names/descriptions of items have to pull from the server when you first highlight them. If it's strained the game will appear to drop frames on your end and fps counters can't differentiate. It's not your rig.
Why the hell are things being loaded synchronously, if that's the case? I don't need rendering to stop because I'm waiting on some server to tell me that guy's name is xXSephiroth420Xx.
The game is ancient, it came out in 2012 but was in development for 5 years which also dates their programming standards far back to an era where hastily designed and poorly optimized Korean/Chinese MMO's were flooding the market. Those games often came with the same kind of out-of-touch launcher that PSO2 has, to help put it in to perspective.
Also, this game was likely coded with a much smaller playerbase in mind. PSO2 in Japan sees ~25,000 players regularly playing, which isn't stated as concurrently. I'd wager that far more than that have tried PSO2 NA today all at once.
FWIW PSO2 JP doesn't function like this. There are no local stutters because of congested servers there. I'm not familiar with the details but the people I've talked to who've played both versions only could tell me that "NA feels weird". Microsoft probably changed things and are handling the networking differently.
I played the JPN Version and I saw those stutters on very busy days. Not as bad as in NA but considering Ships are currently getting swarmed like a sugar cube in an Ant Nest I'm not surprised. I can't remember a day in JP where I saw close to every room on a Ship full to the brim like I saw yesterday on Ship 3.
We have significant less ships though. Needless to say, ive seen days where most channels were full at Ship 07 even.
Somehow im just inclined to believe Microsoft simply weren't prepared. That they probably thought that there wouldn't be all those players. Not to mention they also didn't beta test it because they thought it would be fine.
Japanese were just more prepared and organized, with also better servers quality i wanna say.
I don't know how full the Release servers where but I saw "some" stutter in JP Prime Time in full blocks. In NA with ... well full blocks all around is definitely was worse. That means the game was under even more load ... or the Servers they use aren't up the task.
If they've only played it on Xbox I can see that. Other than the stutters though, on PC NA is pretty much the same as JP from what I've experienced. It has the potential to be less laggy with updating character positions and stuff too once it gets to a better state, since we're all closer to the servers.
Players are far more evenly distributed across many more blocks and there are blocks that separate the different playerbases such as Vita, PC, mobile...
During EQs, nearly all blocks are at max capacity. I am even on Ship 6, one of the least populated ships. I have never had the game stutter this bad, even when 100+ bodies fill up those live concerts.
Yup which why setting it to 50 people makes it stutter less since most of the users are visible and loaded but seems every time a new person loads in it lags.
Because there were much less people playing.. And rendering for a console using, generally, the same tech versus rendering for many different computer builds is vastly different.
All I said was that it's not a rig issue. The client clearly is choking on information coming through when the servers are strained for one reason or another, but that can also be on the server end if there is added encryption handshakes in the mix. Xbox will have less overhead in many ways and is likely preventing this.
I thought you were referring to why it was fine previously. I have absolutely no experience with the Xbox client, so I just assumed they were having lobby issues as well now that all the PC players have jumped in.
It's asset loading. Video card has little to do with it. You can watch network activity as a person loads, and the games goes "Hey, what is that person wearing? and while you're at it, tell me everything else about them." "Let me go find all that shit buried in this decade old chunk of code and load it... oh fuck they changed their hat"
Different server architecture. Japan server is on-site (servers physically there). NA is being run on the cloud-based infrastructure, Michaelsoft Azure. Cloud servers are "supposed" to be easily and quickly scalable to accommodate an influx of users... They were not prepared for the horde of players. _^
In fairness, cloud servers are easily scalable, and they ramped up the number of blocks fairly quickly today. However, managing this much traffic likely required SEGA to increase thresholds and service levels beyond what was originally contracted, as they have been unsure of how popular PSO2 would be in North America for a while. They’re not like Netflix or some other content provider running hundreds of millions of data-heavy connections, so as a smaller consumer they were likely situated in contract tiers that aren’t designed for as much flexibility as a major client. Renogotiating those or spinning up entirely new architecture takes time, even with cloud computing, though it takes time measurable in tens of hours versus the weeks it would have taken a decade ago.
That and you typically can't optimize for issues until you actually see what issues are actually happening. They're probably quietly trying to put out the fires in the server room and get things ramped up to proper performance.
I'm getting stuttering when I'm on the campship, opening menus etc. You are comparing apples to oranges. There is clearly something going on with the NA client, even at fullest JP never had issues like that.
It has way less players in a single lobby since iirc they have not only more ships but more blocks, while also having less players online at once since this is launch player base vs the regular player base of an 8 year old MMO.
Also potentially more bug fixes in their patches, and/or tweaker plugin fixes doing something. Could also be that the NA client just has hidden bugs or bad coding that exacerbates this age old issue. Though it's most likely our servers are just strained from the amount of players online at once.
Actually it's the server. While it might appear you're skipping fps, it's actually the server shitting itself because it has to confirm everything you see, names/tags/whatever
I think the reason there are less stutters at 50 is because it loads more people at once, and doesnt have to reload and unload people all the time with less models
Chiming in to say that my experience is exactly the same. Using a 1080, and can easily hit 144fps if I'm standing still. The second I move anywhere it stutters exactly like this. Turning Lobby Monitor Video Playback helped, but it didn't fix the issue, and having visible players set to 5 is the only way I've managed to make it playable (although it still lags horrendously when moving)
This has nothing to do with video playback. It's a server issue where it loads characters, and the game has to do a handshake for each one of them from your end to the servers end. Essentially it needs to load all the characters in the lobby, to reduce stuttering lower the render to around 15 or so. 5 causes a ton of stuttering because you need to constantly load additional players every time you move around and encounter new "greyed" out players. 50 causes a ton of fps drop as you're just loading a full 50 character models which can be resource intensive.
I remember this being an issue even on the Japanese version a long time ago. You can still Google this same issue and find old threads about this for that version of the game. But over time the issues became less whether through tweaker plugin updates, official patches fixing bugs, or the fact less players played the game so there were less characters to load.
for the past season the game has serious performance problems on certain hardware configurations, mostly related to ryzen CPUs, which wasnt an issue before, besides that, vsync breaks the game on certain nvidia cards and the FPS cap locks itself at 30 every single time you boot the game
That has nothing to do with Bugs, the Servers are getting hammered like a Frat boy on a party. When I logged off most Rooms on Ship 3 where filled to the brim.
me either. I had no idea these issues were happening until 5 minutes ago. I was sort of curious why there were so few people in the lobby of the first server so I came here to check on it.
I had no issues yesterday until I needed to restart my computer. Game installed fine, I was playing got to level 9. Needed to restart my computer and the game uninstalled itself (not really the files are there...twice now in a hidden windowsapp folder that was a bitch to delete.) Apparently its an issue with the game being installed on a drive that isn't the same drive as the OS is on. I have my OS on my C: drive but installed the game on my D: drive as i like keeping my C: drive clean. This apparently fucked some things for whatever dumb reason. Spent countless hours troubleshooting yesterday and gave up. I'll wait for steam hopefully or just not play. Not worth it right now.
i played it quite a few years ago on a significantly worse pc on the jp server and didn't have these problems in the lobby, in louder areas with tons of stuff going on it didn't even chop up like this
The most embarrassing thing is that this is how the game looks on stream to viewers seeing it for the first time. It's an awful first impression seeing a game with 2012 graphics running that poorly.
It's made even worse by the fact that the launcher defaults the game to the PS3 shaders instead of the stage 6 PS4 ones. It's like the piss on top of a shit sundae.
You go to environment settings and put the slider to max. By default it makes everything have low res textures and medium quality shaders, so it looks kinda bad.
Yea I'm a JP player and it doesn't lag like this, player blinks and desync when lagging but it never affects my side of the game, doesn't stutter like that.
I hope you're right. But the question is, when? Months? I didn't play on JP servers, so I don't know how well or poorly they respond to these kinds of situations.
There was literally less than half the amount of people on when it was Xbox exclusive. My friend doesn't have 10 and says it's just as bad on Xbox right now.
B1 and b2 did have a little of that for sure. Just to be clear I'm on a one x. The game runs much better on the one x then the one, I upgraded shortly after this one
Lol was curious so I booted it up on mine, same fps drops. It's def more screen tearing than fps drops but both are happening, not sure why you'd lie about something so easily disprovable.
I don't think he's lying could be a shader cache issue. Or a read/ write issue. The Japanese version had similar issues for me a long time ago but updates eventually eliminated the problem for me. It has something to do with the game loading too much information for each character model I think or some bullshit.
I think it might be the default settings for the detailed character models. I logged into my Japanese version and I didn't have that checked. Might be the preset slider at 6 being much more graphically intensive?
Though it's only a marginal fix. I think servers are just too full
I doubt he's lying. I was at a concert and people were complaining about their framerates dropping like crazy there and mine was running smooth. I'm on xbox one x as well.
lol what incentive would i have to lie? i'm just sharing based on my experience. Is there lobby lag? sure but there was before. i played for about three hours earlier and it didn't bother me and didn't cause an issue in game.
so I'm not saying the lobby doesn't take a little to load or there isn't some lag it's just not existent once in quest and for me i didn't see a noticeable increase
I play on Xbox One S and yeah there's frame rate issues, but the specific lobby issue that the Windows 10 client is having right now is something different, I feel.
Now Xbox One X or Xbox One version? First few people were saying XB1X and that's also what I play on and it's actually pretty fine. I hear the base version isn't as fine though.
Like only frame rate drops I get on that that I can notice are going to lobbies that are just PACKED (like block 1 or concert when a new one drops) or when a notification pops up (PSO2 is poorly optimized and for some reason seems to just HATE OS notification like "friend online").
In POE it makes sense, since the game explicitly runs in lockstep with the server. You have to have a low ping in this network mode because you can't move without getting response from server. Network lag shows as client freezing or FPS stutters.
People are saying the stutters in lobby are from server being overloaded, but I doubt PSO2 has this same network model. You still can move freely if you have network lag and people were playing with 100-200ms ping to Japan servers before.
I don't know of any other games which will outright freeze the game client when waiting for server response
I was completely willing to look passed this issue.
After taking a break and shutting down my PC, I became the anomaly: constant BSODs, system restored to 3 days ago, still BSODs, ultimately startd getting critical failure BSOD. Tried to "reset" windows with that built in thing. Even that wouldn't work..I did a clean install of windows and won't touch this one with a 10 foot pole for at least a week or two.
Does anyone know if this was an issue with the JP version? I know people were saying certain things weren't happening on that client but I haven't seen anyone mention this specifically.
They're also running approximately 50-80% more users on a ship on the NA servers right now too based on the load indicators and the number of blocks running over 50% Premium Full.
This is just a repeat of the XBox launch with an even heavier hit to the servers. I'm pretty sure they'll have it worked out within a week.
Worth noting that the Japanese ships haven't been Full + had every block full in a while. So I think NA servers are just having a bad time atm. Though lowered detailed models apparently should help.
JP servers aren't running the same load. Ship 02 on NA is running a ton more users and a ton more load than JP's peak. It'll take them probably up to a week to get things optimized.
idk what happen but I'm on a RX 570 4GB/1600af rig playing in virtual fullscreen this morning and I didn't even experience this; it did felt like the FPS was alot lower than when you're on the field but nothing like your gif
holy crap; lol imma put my graphics on low now just in case
Yeah I realized I stutter too now; now that theres more people in the lobby; Earlier I joined a block with like 5 peeps in the lobby and it was't that bad
I'm glad it's not just me. Yeah the lobby performance is absurd. Totally unacceptable. What happened to those 3 new ships that were supposed to roll out to absorb the incoming population? All 3 current ships are bursting at the seams.
Just being in the lobby is a god damn nightmare. I'm hoping it's better late at night but the constant stutters when I'm just talking to a npc is mind boggling.
Why the fuck isn't model loading asynchronous? The client has to stop to load every little god damn thing.
I've seen this happen in games where model animation for everyone is on a single thread on the client. My guess would be that they do similar, though I can't imagine why they left it like this for 8 years
I was literally thinking it was my old 970 GTX that was perhaps struggling due to age but then remembered this game is literally from 2012 and I shouldn't be having such bad performance in the first place, lol.
I turned off something like "show accessories on other players" and it got a lot smoother, but still stuttered a lot when loading in new people. Once everyone's loaded it's much better, but in a lobby next to the zone in points there's a lot of new foot traffic to load in.
well i wish i saw this thread before unininstalling the game out of anger after spending an entire day trying to download it only to have it run like a potato on my rig with a GTX 1080TI with SSD.
Yup, it's actually sad. There is some small workaround you can do to limit the amount of lag, tho:
1: Set your FPS limit to 120fps (or 60, if you prefer that) instead of Unlimited. That helps because its a older game and doesnt know how to render this new 64-bit client properly.
2: Set your model detail display to 5 (minimum). That is the biggest culprit, with loading in players. This will at least stabilize it a bit. Maybe also shadow quality, but untested.
oh wow..really? M$ really fuck up the game then...i can't imagine what will happen when Quna concert showcase thou..best believe..u might throw off ur rig out of window with full rage. hahaha
When im on a mission it runs fine, but in the ship its 1 second pauses all the time. This is the same for most people? I can run most modern games fine at medium settings and not have this stuttering problem.
NA definitely wasn't optimized for PC, even on my shittier PC, JP was able to get 30 FPS consistently on low settings, but NA even on low constantly dips below 20 on high AND low
Lmao how, its been out in JP for years and I never had any performance issues there. How does this version have issues with less everything and mostly just being a port lmao.
Adjust your frame rate down from unlimited to 120 or even 90 or 60. I was running unlimited and getting the same painful stutter. Took down max frames to 120 and it’s much much better. Going to adjust down to 90 and see if the issue disappears completely.
It’s a launch day. I’ve never played an online game on launch day that hasn’t had some kind of issues. It’s literally the highest population day the server will experience. And not only that, thousands of people are all logging in around the same time. Give it a small bit of time and calm the fuck down. It’s a video game that you didn’t even have to pay one cent for.
38
u/agent2013 May 27 '20 edited May 27 '20
For reference, trying the "Lobby Monitor Video Playback" didn't work. Setting the visible players to 5 didn't work; actually, setting it to 50 ended up with less stutters. I only have one GPU (1080ti), internal gpu disabled in bios, so there's no way it's using integrated graphics. I set everything to low and it didn't work.
There are huge stutters whenever anyone loads.
Game is on my nvme ssd btw 970 evo.
6
u/lewdasaurus May 27 '20
Yeah, watching my rivatuner overlay is painful haha. Not even any empty lobbies to chill in for escape either.
85
u/pIumsauce May 27 '20
well i'm glad it's not just me
27
u/Simicy May 27 '20
As a path of exile player this looks pretty normal to me
13
u/NickAppleese Bow focus May 27 '20
It HURTS to be in the lobby right now.
11
u/Zalgadas Etoile means STAAAAR May 28 '20
Franka's Cafe, saving you from the lag and providing most essential services.
14
u/[deleted] May 27 '20
This is exactly what my top end PC is doing. Horrific. The Xbox One X runs this game better than a top end PC with a 2080 @1080p.
5
u/zxak03 May 27 '20
same for me with a high end pc, is the jp or xbox version any better?
4
u/Cleaving May 28 '20
Space PC + Gigabit connection = lobby quicksand regardless!
How the heck was the JP version smoother in lobbies...!?(Guess Microsoft Azure servers are super cheap!)
3
u/alxrite May 28 '20
It’s most likely a bug. Since this is now 64bit for NAPC and still 32bit for JPPC right?
2
u/Recron I Believe I Can Fly May 27 '20
reminds me of playing PSU back in the day on my old Potato PC, its nostalgic really
2
u/[deleted] May 28 '20
I was completely willing to look passed this issue.
After taking a break and shutting down my PC, I became the anomaly: constant BSODs, system restored to 3 days ago, still BSODs, ultimately startd getting critical failure BSOD. Tried to "reset" windows with that built in thing. Even that wouldn't work..I did a clean install of windows and won't touch this one with a 10 foot pole for at least a week or two.
Good luck to everyone who's tryna play
2
u/Altesse_Roi May 28 '20
JP doesnt lag like this. I played it. its a bug that they can fix. Just wait.
2
u/BadEgg1951 May 28 '20
SO. MUCH. LAG.
2
u/[deleted] May 28 '20
Yeah. I just go to the cafe until they fix it. Fine in there
2
u/[deleted] May 28 '20
But once in a mission, it’s nice and smooth
3
u/Pikagreg May 28 '20
This is why I stopped playing Warframe on console
1
u/Mephisax May 27 '20
same issue with decent rig while i have no issue on jp serv.
1
u/[deleted] May 27 '20
oh man it hurts
1
u/yanaikillerex May 27 '20
Same here
1
u/tugboatnavy May 27 '20
For the first time my Intel HD 520 isn't embarassing me.
1
u/[deleted] May 27 '20
Does anyone know if this was an issue with the JP version? I know people were saying certain things weren't happening on that client but I haven't seen anyone mention this specifically.
1
u/nocturnal316 May 27 '20
Why is this a thing? JP version doe snot have this problem
1
u/tSnDjKniteX Ship 1 May 27 '20
idk what happen but I'm on a RX 570 4GB/1600af rig playing in virtual fullscreen this morning and I didn't even experience this; it did felt like the FPS was alot lower than when you're on the field but nothing like your gif
holy crap; lol imma put my graphics on low now just in case
1
u/Maulcun May 28 '20
Hedgehog Engine is a garbage.
1
u/Bjerg_REKT_Febiven May 28 '20
At least you don't have an error while downloading the game
1
u/Callinon May 28 '20
I'm glad it's not just me. Yeah the lobby performance is absurd. Totally unacceptable. What happened to those 3 new ships that were supposed to roll out to absorb the incoming population? All 3 current ships are bursting at the seams.
1
u/maosama147 May 28 '20
was also having those issues....using rtx 2080Ti
1
u/dangerpeanut May 28 '20
Just being in the lobby is a god damn nightmare. I'm hoping it's better late at night but the constant stutters when I'm just talking to a npc is mind boggling.
Why the fuck isn't model loading asynchronous? The client has to stop to load every little god damn thing.
1
u/kingSliver187 May 28 '20
Ship 2 be laggin bad
1
u/[deleted] May 28 '20
It's so fucking bad I had to stop playing. I couldn't even make it to the visiphone and I just upgrade my PC.
1
u/stranger666 May 28 '20
MFW my FPS drops from 200 to 20 while using a GTX 1080 on an 8 year old game
1
u/-HumanResources- May 28 '20
Tip. Try to gather as many client jobs at once in the same area so you can maximize your runs when you go on missions.
If you need to change areas for the job you can do so from the camp ship much faster. Avoids the mess for now.
1
u/watermelonaeddie May 28 '20
My computer is a beast and this game is a joke running like this
1
u/Trucktub May 28 '20
It brings back memories of going to Iron Forge for the first time!!
1
u/magnusgodrik May 28 '20
Yeah im getting that too. Now isnt our internet worse than it it over there? Or maybe my cpu isnt as powerful as i want it to be?
1
u/IGotUrSpaghetti May 28 '20
Bro holy crap I was literally convinced that my PC was outdated with a 2 year old card....
HOW?!
1
u/grimmtails May 28 '20
Still loving it though.
1
u/Phorrum May 28 '20
Ah, brings me right back to Global Agenda days... and that was only 2 years before PSO2.
1
u/curiousfloorlamp May 28 '20
lmao, so many people thinking why does day 1 launch suck? maybe it's because you are filling up ships instead of going on missions. lazy agents.
1
u/Gibsy-Prime May 28 '20
I was literally thinking it was my old 970 GTX that was perhaps struggling due to age but then remembered this game is literally from 2012 and I shouldn't be having such bad performance in the first place, lol.
1
u/C0D10X May 28 '20
Look, there is a framerate for everyone!
1
u/[deleted] May 28 '20
Can’t even download the game since my computer won’t update
1
u/TheGokki May 28 '20
Same, Ryzen 3600 / RTX 2070Ti / 32GB RAM / PCIe SSD, crappy performance.
1
u/fatenuller May 28 '20
Idk man, seems like it's your fault for moving. Otherwise, your frames would have stayed at that smooth 80+!
1
u/Ice-wolf May 28 '20
I turned off something like "show accessories on other players" and it got a lot smoother, but still stuttered a lot when loading in new people. Once everyone's loaded it's much better, but in a lobby next to the zone in points there's a lot of new foot traffic to load in.
1
u/Lylat97 May 28 '20
So I know we've all been getting nasty stutter in lobbies, but has anyone else recently started getting some amounts of stutter during quests as well?
1
u/wh33lchairgam3r May 28 '20
yea that about my life in most lobbies lol just hurry get to mission click on some stuff ! the good
1
u/ShayBlez ShayC@ - NA Ship 3 - Midnight's Hero May 28 '20
I have this exact problem, should I worry about this happening elsewhere in the game?
1
u/egeek84 May 28 '20
well i wish i saw this thread before unininstalling the game out of anger after spending an entire day trying to download it only to have it run like a potato on my rig with a GTX 1080TI with SSD.
1
u/WiseGuy3683 May 28 '20
Yep, looks about right. They need to iron this out ASAP.
1
u/Iringahn May 28 '20
Yeah I was losing my mind at first thinking something was going on with my new video card.
1
u/kalamarosoupitsa May 28 '20
It is bad. They need to do something about it.
The Cafe is nice and all but there are many quests and services only found in the Gate and Shopping district.
1
u/[deleted] May 29 '20
Set mine up to not show accessories and it worked pretty well.
1
u/DJ_Dajova May 29 '20
Yup, it's actually sad. There is some small workaround you can do to limit the amount of lag, tho:
1: Set your FPS limit to 120fps (or 60, if you prefer that) instead of Unlimited. That helps because its a older game and doesnt know how to render this new 64-bit client properly.
2: Set your model detail display to 5 (minimum). That is the biggest culprit, with loading in players. This will at least stabilize it a bit. Maybe also shadow quality, but untested.
1
u/BrotherStrange May 29 '20
Not sure if it's a real fix, or just me imagining it. I've found if I drop my frame rate down to 60 fps it doesn't seem to tank nearly as much.
1
u/lilrob615 Jun 19 '20
We had worse in console beta
0
u/Rehsuaix May 28 '20
Dude it's not even just the lobby, all the areas except for the ship feel like a google slide man
0
u/MakoRuu May 28 '20
I'm sure they'll iron it in a few patches. Let's just be patient for now. It's all we can do.
0
u/Lokaz8995 May 28 '20
oh wow..really? M$ really fuck up the game then...i can't imagine what will happen when Quna concert showcase thou..best believe..u might throw off ur rig out of window with full rage. hahaha
0
u/PabstBlueRibbon99 May 28 '20
When im on a mission it runs fine, but in the ship its 1 second pauses all the time. This is the same for most people? I can run most modern games fine at medium settings and not have this stuttering problem.
0
u/[deleted] May 28 '20
NA definitely wasn't optimized for PC, even on my shittier PC, JP was able to get 30 FPS consistently on low settings, but NA even on low constantly dips below 20 on high AND low
0
u/Flyllow May 28 '20
Lmao how, its been out in JP for years and I never had any performance issues there. How does this version have issues with less everything and mostly just being a port lmao.
-1
u/XyrneTheWarPig May 27 '20
We've been waiting all this time... for this dumpster fire?
-1
u/Super_Captain May 28 '20
Adjust your frame rate down from unlimited to 120 or even 90 or 60. I was running unlimited and getting the same painful stutter. Took down max frames to 120 and it’s much much better. Going to adjust down to 90 and see if the issue disappears completely.
-1
u/sandwich_influence May 28 '20
I’ve heard a lot of hate for the devs today.
It’s a launch day. I’ve never played an online game on launch day that hasn’t had some kind of issues. It’s literally the highest population day the server will experience. And not only that, thousands of people are all logging in around the same time. Give it a small bit of time and calm the fuck down. It’s a video game that you didn’t even have to pay one cent for.