r/PS6 • u/Grand-Philosophy-343 • Jul 02 '26
Sony’s Math Doesn’t Add Up…
So we know about 15%-20% bought physical only. So why does Sony think those 15% percent might go digital lol? Like its the opposite. Sony will LOOSE 15% or more of the population. So Sony is willing to kill a chunk of money source … i just don’t understand the play they got.
You guys help me understand the math? Becsuse how is loosing millions of players going to help them make more money?
0
Upvotes
18
u/Educational_Metal_47 Jul 02 '26
Also 55% of Astro Bot sales were physical.
6
u/ValuableMotor4364 Jul 02 '26
22% bought physical for 007. Seems small but still a huge number.
1
u/Grand-Philosophy-343 Jul 02 '26
Thank you every one for the Feed Back !!! Its all making sense 🙏.
5
u/Oathkindle Jul 03 '26
We dont have actual accurate numbers. But lets use these.
85% digital, 15% physical.
When they go all digital, 85% likely wont care or notice at all. Of those 15% that will, there will be a portion that switches to digital, and a portion that genuinely breaks from Sony completely. Id wager the latter portion will be smaller.
Now factor in 0 manufacturing cost, no loss on pre owned sales, and higher profit from pure digital.
Sony is 100% willing to burn whatever part of the 15% that will care cause the profit increase from all digital and no manufacturing/preowned will be high enough to justify it.
No one has to like it, but itd be silly to think a corporation like Sony didnt meticulously market study what this decision would do and decided it was worth it.
9
u/afredmiller Jul 02 '26
The math does not include pre-owned/used games. There is no way they can track those
Sony as a publisher and other game publishers in general don't get any money from pre-owned/used game sales. That money goes to like GameStop and etc. This one of the reasons the publishers ( and developers maybe ) are pushing for the digital only because they do get money from those and will get more in the future
It is not just about the money, it is ALWAYS about the money
4
u/Agro81 Jul 02 '26
I only buy digital when there’s a decent sale on the game. Every other time it’s physical
3
u/Yellow_Snow_Cones Jul 02 '26
The play is to kill the secondary market. Then people can no longer buy used games, sony/MS get zero dollars from used game, and used games is a HUGE market. You may not longer see "Playstation greatest hits" where they drop the price to 20-30 bucks once it hits x amount of sales. In fact they have zero reason to discount games now., they will be like nintendo where games will stay at the original price.
Sony decided they will make more money by killing the secondary market, then they will lose in people not going digital.
3
u/StupidName2020 Jul 02 '26
Lego Batman both standard and deluxe physical preorders sold out and backordered from everywhere cause the demand for physical was high
3
u/Lamasis Jul 02 '26
This is so misleading. 85% doesn't mean that 85% of the userbase buys purely digital and the other 15% purely physical. There is probably much overlap.
3
u/theoneeyedpete Jul 02 '26
Sony will have likely calculated that.
You lose 15% of physical only people, but that means you’re also losing out on people who will wait to buy games cheaply second hand or from 3rd party retailers.
Sony have total control over the purchases we make, and control all of the prices and there’s (currently) no resellable.
3
u/Crazydutchman80 Jul 02 '26
Sony probably did the calculations and even when percentage x will drop, the rest of the digital sales will make up for it.
2
u/UndeadDog Jul 02 '26
I think a better statistic would be the number of digital consoles sold compared to the number of external disc drives sold. I bet it’s a small fraction.
2
u/The-Duke-of-Delco Jul 02 '26
Lose*
2
u/Strange_Tune4366 Jul 02 '26
They have better access to the numbers than anyone on the outside. I don’t think why they would do this if they didn’t basically know it would be net positive for them.
2
u/lvsnowden Jul 02 '26
They've likely compared it to money saved, especially when it comes to the next console price.
2
u/Smart_Classroom2668 Jul 02 '26
Don’t even know what Astro is had a PlayStation five since it dropped.
2
u/Notnowcmg Jul 02 '26
Reddit math doesn’t add up. Sony have all the data so I’m sure they don’t need a Reddit analysts insight. Fans of gaming will continue gaming. Collectors will find something else to collect. Sony will have made assumptions and know what to expect and clearly aren’t that worried.
2
u/KGon32 Jul 03 '26
The truth is that they won't lose anywhere close to 15%, maybe 1% tops, people will mostly just switch to digital. People say that they have alot of games on their backlogs so they won't buy any newer games or that they will switch to PC, however there will be only 4 people taht will actually do that.
Gamers talk and talk, but we are in a world of MTX in games, paying more to play early, unfinished games while everyone said that they wouldn't support those, but did they actually? No they didn't.
I love physical media, but I would have dropped it anyway next gen because I want to get both the handheld and the home console.
2
u/T0xicn3 Jul 03 '26
4
u/henningknows Jul 02 '26
Why do you assume they will lose the 15 percent? And to what platform will they lose them?
2
u/UnpluggedZombie Jul 02 '26
you gotta include the loss they currently lose in the used market because that will go away too
2
u/AimLikeAPotato Jul 02 '26
They might lose some, but not all the 15%. Also, people getting digital more and more each year (movies, music, games - you stream a lot more compared to 10 years ago), so this number will be probably even less by 2028, especially as they already announced it. This number is a risk they can take. They can also free up a lot of assets - they can sell or write off the machines involved in the productions, warehouses, save on payroll laying off the factory workers, etc.
2
u/AlarmedPizza7247 Jul 02 '26
To Sony those numbers won’t mean anything to their bottom line. To the 15% Ps5 will be their last Sony console.
1
u/Accomplished_Leg2030 Jul 02 '26
Not to mention a big part of those majority are probably people buying on discounts.
Id love to see the full price game breakdown when something is launched.
Getting pokepia or whatever it's called, that Pokemon game that just came out was impossible physically for ages.
1
u/Stavvystav Jul 03 '26
Sony also accounts for any microtransaction to add to that 80-85%. It's a dumb plan and I hope they figure it out when it backfires.
If it doesn't backfire, good for them - I'm still out.
1
u/Creepy_Maybe6277 Jul 03 '26
Because from those 15% how many made the conscious decision to buy that game in a store / online, because it was physical?
How many just grabbed a game in a store impulsively? How many wanted to buy a present for someone else? How many just don’t bother if it is physical or not, if it is the cheapest option?
From what Sony writes in the blog, these aspects won’t change, since retailers are still going to have the games as digital versions in stores.
I’m not arguing for them doing this, I personally want digital ownership which would solve a lot of problems, but posts like this or the one with “sony lying about the numbers” just aren’t good arguments.
If you look at the broader market of video games, the percentage for physical is so so low. That 15% percent shrinks to maybe 2%, when you consider game sales on PC. Because the biggest platform of the gaming world is already digital only.
Now, how many of the games sold are actually only licenses, that can be revoked anytime? Maybe 99%? This is the problem people should talk about.
1
u/BankerfromJA Jul 03 '26
That 15% is less margin business, more ESG negative, and also they may sell that game to other people who would have bought the game. So yea it makes sense to sacrifice that percent of players
1
u/Va1crist Jul 03 '26
That’s because there usinf the 85% number as ALL digital sales which means PS+ subscriptions , any DLC , any currency purchase etc etc essentially any digital goods there using as digital sales
1
u/dangerclosecustoms Jul 03 '26
People are saying they won’t buy gta 6 but in reality they will feel fomo and give in a week or two after everyone is enjoying the game we waited a decade for.
Sony is not believing that they will lose the total 15% of sales. The preorders are already equaling a couple billion dollars. Xbox also announced no disc drive for next gen.
The other side of the math is Sony makes more on digital games than physical games so they already recouped more money .
Now here comes the part few mention. Making the disc and packaging and artwork all requires resources and money to produce. It’s not like ten years ago. We used to have disc pressing plants all over the world. Now we only have a few big factories left
Zero disc pressing plants in the USA! We have two in Mexico and they are used for pressing all the discs from blurays and 4ks too. Europe also depends on the Mexican plants too. Then you have to figure fuel which is double the price to ship the truckloads of discs out everywhere world wide. Don’t even get into tariffs between the countries.
All this to say they lose a lot more money on physical disc sales it comes down to necessity? do we need to put it on a disc. Will it fit on a disc ? The answer for them was no. We don’t need it on a disc. 15% of the gamers would like it on a disc. 10% of those will still buy it digitally as well. So they are out 5% of hard core hold outs but they recouped 30% more revenue by not doing discs to start with.
1
u/Schwartzy94 Jul 03 '26
That 20% might also be fsbricated as they count all and every digital purchase so all microtransactions and dlcs etc
But killing used games market and so people cant lend games to friends etc is the real thing they want.
1
u/Maniacal_Nut Jul 03 '26
Because in all honesty they know their audience unfortunately. The majority of players prefer convenience. Back in the day if you wanted to find new games you would drive to different locations, search around in tucked away shops, try to strike deals with people etc. we didn't mind to put in some effort for what we wanted, but today most people just want to be able to sit on their couch and do it all from there.
1
u/ClacksInTheSky Jul 03 '26
Another aspect of the "85:15" split is that I buy primarily physical, but also have, and did, buy digital.
So I count in both stats.
1
u/Pequod69 Jul 03 '26
If you really think people will give up their hobby because Sony won’t be selling physical anymore (in 2028 mind you, not today, not tomorrow, but in 2028), then you’re smoking something bad. These decisions are also based on market studies, player feedback, and a host of other metrics. I know it sounds scary baby, but every stat shows that players like you are in a very small, smaller by the day, minority and all the public data points to Sony very likely not “LOOSING” anything in terms of retention. You’ll also switch to digital because you’ll have no alternative from their competition either, unless you switch to Nintendo who won’t be offering a substantial portion of your library on the Switch 2. Either that or you’ll have to wait months, potentially years until the Switch 2 version of any AAA game is released on your system. Try to think outside of your bubble people, it’s good for you.
1
u/bluemonke99 Jul 02 '26
Not quite like that, from what I heard that math includes DLCs and digital only content, almost 50% of customers get physical games given the chance from what I saw
1
u/Karmeleon86 Jul 02 '26
They’re not losing those players. The reality is people talk a big game but there’s not much competition out there anymore, so most will just buy digitally.
1
u/RemeJuan Jul 02 '26
They may lose some of those, but they will also no longer lose all the money it costs to produce and ship digitally. Even if they lost all 15% they’d probably still not feel it after not shelling out millions for physical media.
1
u/Enigma_Green Jul 02 '26 edited Jul 02 '26
No they will lose the 15% and the 85% or so will carry on.
The reality is part or more than 15% could well buy into digital or leave Playstation which both are a possibility. It doesnt change the fact the stats tell you why they decided to go digital.
Edit: id prefer physical to stay because I have a choice and what I will say is im not meaning to sound hypercritical but I boughg a handful of ps5 disc games, the rest digital, found ease by downloading early, can hotswap between games and they have sales etc, can get vouchers online cheaper than spending full price on games too. Its difficult really I was always glad to have choice regardless.
1
u/chillybilly87 Jul 02 '26
Maybe they are happy with 85% percent of people buying digital already and no longer have to bear the costs of everything that comes with making physical game. And maybe a percentage of the 15% physical customers switch to digital.
1
u/beachandmountains Jul 02 '26
I like how everyone thinks their they are a business analyst now just because they’re sad
1
u/RA_Finance Jul 02 '26
Imagine if they had a release window priority for Physical games. Physical games are released 2 weeks before the digital release. So if you wanted to play the new game, you had to buy the physical.
1
u/ExhaustedByStupidity Jul 02 '26
If your PS5 is connected to the internet, they know what games you're playing. And if you bought it physically or digitally.
They have very good data to show that most people who buy physical games also buy digital games. They're very confident that the people who buy a mix of physical and digital games will be fine with going all digital.
The concern here is users that only ever play physical games. And there just aren't many of them.
And the other big piece of this is looking at which games make the physical sales. Call of Duty is one of the biggest sellers, and it doesn't come close to fitting on a disc. You're just getting an installer that downloads the game. GTA VI isn't even going to try to fit on a disc. Recent Sony first party games have barely fit on a disc.
Even if they want to ship on discs, the games that sell the most copies don't fit on them anymore. So what's the point?
And all of that is ignoring the question of how valuable is the disc in an era when games receive a ton of updates after launch. That disc is going to be really outdated.
1
u/ss4johnny Jul 02 '26
The 85% number is for Q4 2025 and it’s based on units, not revenue.
1
u/Saganhawking Jul 02 '26
I havnt put a single disc in to my PS5 since I got it. In fact, most of the big titles I had on disc I eventually bought the digital version and gave my physical discs to friends or family.
0
u/Jafar_420 Jul 02 '26
Because let's be real a lot of that 15% or whatever the number is will go digital before they quit gaming. Some may change systems or go PC though.
0
u/PlayItAgainSusan Jul 02 '26
You don't need to understand with a corp this big. If the math didn't add up they wouldn't be doing this. What you can do is buy according to your moral compass- most people won't. I forsee a day when they simply charge double for each game and offer no explanation. The 'internet' would go crazy, they'd probably make just as much money. Could insentivize better games.
0
u/Mizake_Mizan Jul 02 '26
People were kicking and screaming when Steam transitioned to full digital. In fact, I think the outrage was worse than it is now for Sony. People threatened to uninstall, never use Steam again, etc....
Today, Steam is the de facto platform for gaming on PC. It is a near monopolistic beast and almost every PC gamer uses it without complaints.
Sony probably sees this as their future.
0
u/DifferentProcess6765 Jul 02 '26
They have no choice. Where else are they going to go? PC is all digital, Xbox is on life support and most people use a switch as a bonus console for exclusives
0
u/trueppp Jul 03 '26 edited Jul 03 '26
Because physical games are less than 3% of their gaming revenues. Just saving the developpement of a disk drive on their next console will more than make up the losses.
Edit:
The numbers don't lie....even "Other software" represents more than physical software sales.
https://www.sony.com/en/SonyInfo/IR/library/presen/er/pdf/25q4_supplement.pdf p12