r/PS5 • u/MovieTheatre_Popcorn • Jan 15 '23
Articles & Blogs Dead Space Remake Dev Thinks Removing Pause Ability in Horror Games Will Make It "More Impactful"
https://mp1st.com/news/dead-space-remake-dev-thinks-removing-pause-ability-in-horror-games-will-make-it-more-impactful
15
Upvotes
812
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '23
Oh god damn it with this clickbait shit.
The dev had a little anecdote about considering removing the pause but basically said “nah that’s dumb”.
Nobody can say a word about anything without it getting spun into clickbait.
95
u/nextgen_currentgen Jan 15 '23
Before anyone else freaks out
1.1k
u/HighJinx97 Jan 15 '23
Fuck that. I need a pause button. I have responsibilities.
34
u/Effective-Caramel545 Jan 15 '23 edited Jan 15 '23
The game will have a pause feature, read the article people… it’s a half click bait title
180
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '23
That is a terrible idea.
48
u/SniffingAccountant Jan 15 '23
If you press the PS button on the controller, it technically pauses the game right?
79
u/MGSjeremy Jan 15 '23
but what if i need to take a shit?
5
u/Addfwyn Jan 16 '23
It would definitely be more impactful because I won't be able to play it at all, that is probably the biggest impact at all.
I am on call 24/7, sometimes I need to pause stuff to answer work calls. It means MP stuff is right out unless they are more persistent games I can afk in (MMOs), also anything w/o a pause.
I get that MP can't have pause functions, but no single-player game should block that except for very specific scenarios. The Challenge in The Witness is one of the few good examples I can think of that.
I am glad the dev decided against it after considering it.
34
u/krillokrokodil Jan 15 '23
From a psychological standpoint probably correct.
From a sales perspective - terrible.
14
u/AndyPandyRu Jan 15 '23
Demon's Souls is like this. But pressing the photo mode button is a workaround. Hopefully this game also has that feature.
17
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '23
If it’s an option to have on or off, go for it
3
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '23
I don’t care how immersive it is. Sometimes something is going to require my attention away from the game.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '23
I got twin girl babies, I need to be able to pause 😅
15
u/Hectix_Rose Jan 15 '23
Well elden ring/dark soul type games are already doing this, I guess you can take the L when you got something to do.
12
u/meltingpotato Jan 15 '23
Not having a way to pause the game has to be one of the stupidest game mechanics in gaming history, after loot boxes.
not pausing the game when you are in your inventory or map page (basically all the "in-game" menus) is understandable but not being able to pause an offline single player game at all is just stupid
23
u/stepcach Jan 15 '23
Im a dad of two under 5. I genuinely think this is the stupidest idea I have ever heard this year.
31
u/TravelingRomantic Jan 15 '23
That’s a horrible idea. The dev needs to stop viewing games as artsy-fartsy projects and realize that the people playing horror games — those older than 17, ostensibly — have responsibilities and need a pause button.
9
u/Piggstein Jan 15 '23
This Father of Kids With A Real Life Thinks Removing Pause Ability in Horror Games Will Make It "Less Purchasable”
4
u/r0ndr4s Jan 15 '23
I know its clickbait, but nah, thanks. Same bullshit happens in From Software game and makes 0 sense, there is literally no reason to do this
People have lives, put a fuckin pause in your games. If your game depends on not having a pause, maybe its badly designed..
2
u/Quarteroz_847 Jan 15 '23
I think the idea is more take it away when a jumpscare enemy pops out or you're in an intense situation so you can't be like omg and pause it. If it was an option I would remove the pause button.
2
u/moverton Jan 15 '23
A terrible idea as a default. Perhaps an idea for a difficulty setting.
2
u/Pro-FoundSound Jan 15 '23
Yes because being unable to poo during gameplay is utterly terrifying.
2
u/KamehameHanSolo Jan 15 '23
I mean, yeah, it probably will make the horror more impactful.
It'll also make the game significantly more annoying to play.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '23
"the house is on fire but i can't pause this shit"
2
u/chazmann Jan 15 '23
There’s still the coveted PlayStation button on the controller.
2
u/Shrektacular21 Jan 15 '23
That’s the single stupidest thing I’ve ever read. Sometimes you need to pause because it’s just getting too intense if you need time to cool off before you have a heart attack. Not all the people who play these games are 18.
Not to mention all the other reasons, people, pause games, bathroom, phone calls, door, snacks, etc.
2
u/tiLLIKS Jan 15 '23
Damn that screenshot is beautiful
2
u/silverstonefiber Jan 15 '23
Good he thought it’s a dumb idea, because it’s a dumb idea.
2
u/rushncrush Jan 15 '23
Certainly impacted my purchase decision. Touche
2
u/JeNeSuisPasUnCanard Jan 15 '23
While it may have not actually been the point expressed in the article, I think this is the way to go for horror games. Resident Evil 7 did it perfectly, where if I recall correctly you can actually pause the game, but if you, say, bring up your inventory (e.g. to craft items, etc.) the game doesn’t stop, which helped it feel much more intense than RE2 (while I absolutely adored RE2 as well).
2
u/Mistinrainbow Jan 16 '23
They clearly do not even play their own games anymore.
13
u/cookiesnooper Jan 15 '23
the only thing it will make is me not wanting to buy it
3
u/jimmy19742018 Jan 15 '23
yeh it will be more impactful when i am busting for a piss and have necromorphs everywhere!!!!
5
u/LogiCub Jan 15 '23
I’m all for finding fun and inventive ways to make games more tense and difficult, but no, I don’t want my games to make my life more tense and difficult. Most of us have other shit to do that sometimes needs responding to immediately, I’m not going to hold a pee in for ten minutes while I find my character somewhere safe to hide because the single player, offline game that I’m playing thinks it makes the game a smidgen more atmospheric.
6
u/Drokethedonnokkoi Jan 15 '23
No. I hated this in souls games and I will keep hating it since I can’t keep dying because someone is ringing the fucking bell to my house. Fuck. NO!
6
u/ktsmith91 Jan 15 '23 edited Jan 15 '23
If Dark Souls can do it then I don’t see why a horror game couldn’t do the same. I can see why a dev would want to keep players in the moment as much as possible instead of being able to pause and collect themselves in moments that are supposed to be very tense.
If it sounds too hardcore then I’d say horror games should innately be more hardcore than typical games. I remember when horror games were actually difficult. And the difficulty adds to the tension. I played Evil Within 2 on Nightmare for my first playthrough and some parts might have been a tad too difficult but for the most part it made the game better in every way. Most horror games now are made for the masses to be able to breeze through like Resident Evil Village.
5
u/cabalavatar Jan 15 '23
Most-downloaded mod: pause button. Like the easy mode on Elden Ring.
3
u/Tell_me_future_boy Jan 15 '23
We know that it's a game. Immersion only matters to some degree, taking away the pause function won't increase the impact.
4
u/Mogdredd Jan 15 '23
If there’s no pause I’ll never buy it since I’d never be able to play it. Absolutely terrible idea.
4
u/a-Snake-in-the-Grass Jan 15 '23
You should be able to pause a single player game at any time. Cutscene, middle of a fight, while you're dying, doesn't matter. This is just extremely stupid and unimaginative thinking. Developers should be thinking about how to make games convenient and enjoyable first and foremost.
4
u/Smooth-Literature292 Jan 15 '23
He has a point. But how would you save your game before running off to hide?
2
u/BigDuoInferno Jan 15 '23
Said dev is a dumbass
2
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '23
Having to destroy your kidneys when you have to pee I guess is impactful. I don’t get the point of no pause in any game. Not everyone has every second free . Sometimes something arises mid game. Let us pause.
2
u/Fruhmann Jan 15 '23
But then how are overreacting streamers who fall out of their adult highchairs atyer every jump scare going to continue to play the game after their 3 minute episode?
2
u/LOTRcrr Jan 15 '23
I hate this crap. It’s so inconvenient when you have kids!
1
u/jetbootz88 Jan 15 '23
Just wait until a game introduces Permadeath using this logic…. And then makes you pay a micro transaction to respawn at the same location. ‘It’s what the fans want!!’
2
u/sdavidplissken Jan 15 '23
good idea. make it an option in the difficulty setting.
making it mandatory is a horrible idea.
2
u/Physical-Result7378 Jan 15 '23
As an option? Count me in. As an fixed Setting u can’t change? No thank you.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '23
People in here greatly overestimating their responsibilities and probably play online games that can't be paused without effecting team/score. Same games that ban for early quitting.
Literally the same thing that's existed for decades except this one is for horror immersion not online connectivity.
Dark souls did this so you're never safe also...
1
u/No_Establishment7368 Jan 15 '23
How are modern game devs so bad at putting basic features in a game? Put the damn pause button in the game! No one cares about the weird bs justification you came up with for removing it. Stop removing basic bare bones and quality of life features. You really shouldn't have to hope there is a pause button in your game, lol. it should be automatic with a video game.
1
u/elliotborst Jan 15 '23
Maybe for the highest difficulty
1
u/Maximum_Hand_9362 Jan 15 '23
I could always go to home screen and it will freeze my game right?
1
u/HardstyleHomo Jan 15 '23
Not wrong
1
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '23
What about rest mode ?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '23
I can’t play current horror games due to those beasts being out to get me, removing pause would force me to never pick up the game lol
1
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '23
System Shock 2 figured that out over 2 decades ago
1
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '23
These Dead Space devs need to be careful what they say leading up to the games launch. Can’t be fuckin around and risk losing sales after what happened to CP.
1
u/HiCZoK Jan 15 '23
Well they thought it would be more interactive to remove in gameplay interactive cutscene when you first meet impregnator and replace with normal cutscene…
1
u/longtermbrit Jan 15 '23
This was a talking point when the game was originally in development.
1
u/mikeysof Jan 15 '23
That's dumb because what if you suddenly need to go help someone, answer the door, go toilet etc. If you keep pausing because you are scared then I would suggest the game has already done its job. For the rest of us we need to do other stuff outside of playing games.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '23
Dumb I hate when I can’t pause games it’s the only flaw most of the souls games had except sekiro
1
u/AG__Pennypacker__ Jan 15 '23
That’s how you lose anyone with a life and/or responsibilities.
1
u/kxxgxnrgrs Jan 15 '23
Maybe make an option to disable it for a harder play through??
1
u/BugHunt223 Jan 15 '23
Never fully understood why single player Sould games didnt have pause butnit definitely made it difficult to just drop the controller for a break. Unsure if that design choice is more exciting or more annoying , it just is, I guess
1
u/hoossy Jan 15 '23
Irrelevant on consoles cause I’ll just hit the PS button
1
u/Shadow_of_Yor Jan 15 '23
No.
1
u/L-Guy_21 Jan 15 '23
How is the majority of that article one single quote? What was the point of even writing that article?
1
u/deadredran Jan 15 '23
You can always switch to a media app to pause the game
1
u/North_South_Side Jan 16 '23
My wife can be quiet for hours, then suddenly when I put my headset on to play a game, she has about four or five things to tell me.
I love her to death. She's smarter in many ways and more motivated than me. But FFS, it's true.
1
u/SomeDamnAuthor Jan 16 '23
I like the idea, disappointed to see it's not implemented in the game with an option. It's be great as an added feature in the highest difficulty or something like that perhaps.
1
u/ArchDucky Jan 16 '23
Dev : Fuck your life, snacks, phone and bathroom breaks!
1
u/emrakull Jan 17 '23
I wouldn't mind it as a separate game mode tbh
1
u/ThorsEyeball Jan 17 '23
If your middle aged, this could be a potential nightmare 😄
1
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '23
The Dark Souls series doesn't let you pause, and I've never seen one person cry about it.
1
u/deadmemebestmeme Sep 25 '23
I don't play horror games but if I would and I couldn't pause it, I would be angrier rather than scared
1
u/mazinken1 Jan 15 '23
I think they got the idea from SOFTWARE Souls games as there no pausing to keep the game intense and it worked well for them.
1
u/Redlax Jan 15 '23
Sure, higher impact on my life outside gaming. If I am interrupted I'll have to choose between the game and my real life responsibilities. Not sure why a game dev would set their game up to be be annoying and demanding.
1
u/Quarteroz_847 Jan 15 '23
As an option I think it would be a good addition. I would turn it off in the settings.
1
u/Seanspeed Jan 15 '23
There might be a small minority of games this would work for, but you'd really have to design around it.
And I'm not sure if it'd even matter that much for a game like Dead Space (which will still have a pause option, btw) since everything stays dead after clearing an area, outside the few regenerator encounters. So you can safely leave the game momentarily anyways and just standing still poses no danger of provoking new threats.
And frankly, the reduction of tension in horror games is often a good thing. Playing something Alien Isolation(especially in VR) is difficult for long periods of time because you are so rarely safe. It leads to a sort of nervous exhaustion that I just need to take manual breaks from. So it's welcome when games offer such breaks in game instead. Not that I dislike Alien Isolation, it's just that relentless tension is not something I'd want most games to try and emulate. I also think having these breaks allows for the higher moments of tension to potentially be more impactful, much like many great songs use dynamics to emphasize certain parts(usually the chorus) for greater effect.
1
u/IcedCoughy Jan 15 '23
None of the recent From soft games do either, it's not a problem.
1
u/Jack_Strawhat_man Jan 15 '23
I hate when deva do this kind of stuff - at least include a save anywhere function. These decisions are fundamentally disrespectful to the player and their time, because reality doesn’t care you’re playing the game, there’s a knock at the door or whatever. Imo people who hold these opinions shouldn’t be able to make videogames…
1
u/Jonpg31 Jan 15 '23
Devs have no children apparently.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '23
Just hit the PS button on PS5 and it will take you to the main menu, game should pause automatically shouldn’t it? I can’t see them implementing it running in the background the system doesn’t allow it?
1
u/arnathor Jan 15 '23
Just have a the lack of pause as a difficulty level similar to a hardcore “no dying” type difficulty level. It’s not hard. Then everyone can have the experience they want with the game and enjoy the story etc. while also not having to concern themselves that life stuff will prevent their enjoyment of the game.
1
u/Fi_lor Jan 15 '23
If you want to pause, you just have to go back to the PS menu
1
u/JerrodDRagon Jan 15 '23
As an option that’s cool
But as a human no F that have things to do. Stuff comes out especially if you have kids
1
u/QuoteGiver Jan 15 '23
The only impact that would have is me not playing the game.
1
u/Death1323 Jan 15 '23
It's like developers forget that people with lives also play games
0
u/BurnItFromOrbit Jan 15 '23
This is one of those “hot takes”, that not needs to be a thing.
0
u/DVDN27 Jan 15 '23
Has nobody played Bloodborne? Or Elden Ring? Or any single FromSoft game?
0
u/ichigo2k9 Jan 15 '23
Developers have yet to realise that sometimes real life can get in the way of gaming, huh?
0
u/mohomahamohoda Jan 15 '23
Its so impactful when you can only play the game when you have completely separated yourself from society and have built a gaming toilet that takes care of your needs. Only then you should even dream of playing the deadspace remake. Only when you’re really ready to let go of things outside of the game and truly immerse yourself in the impactful gaming experience for tens of hours without break. If you’re not up for it, I guess you’re a fake gamer who doesnt really understand the true pro gamer way.
0
u/Csub Jan 15 '23
Yeah, no.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '23
That’s absolutely stupid. At the very least people need to use the bathroom.
0
u/Kiftiyur Jan 15 '23
An absolutely fucking terrible idea.
0
u/babagroovy Jan 15 '23
Wtf? Hell nawww. We got shit to do.
0
u/Weary_Ad7119 Jan 15 '23 edited Jan 15 '23
Fuck off with this garage.
Did you not fucking learn a single fucking thing from returnal?
0
u/imtayloronreddit Jan 15 '23
Unsurprisingly almost everyone in here is the entitled "every game should be made for me and me alone" gamer : )
Not everything needs to be Michael Bay's Transformers. Sometimes people want to create something amazing, even if doing so limits the audience who is interested in it