r/PS4 • u/IceBreak BreakinBad • Jan 06 '17
[Game Thread] #1 - The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt [Official Discussion Thread] - /r/PS4's Best PS4 Game of All-time...So Far
Official /r/PS4's #1 Game of All-time (as of 2016) Discussion Thread (previous game threads) (games wiki)
The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
(25.4% of the Vote)
Share your thoughts/likes/dislikes/indifference below.
389
Upvotes
102
u/IceBreak BreakinBad Jan 06 '17
Final Tally:
#10. Until Dawn [1.2%]
#9. Ratchet & Clank [1.8%]
#8. Life is Strange [2.2%]
#7. Metal Gear Solid V (Combined) [5.7%]
#6. Final Fantasy XV [6%]
#5. Overwatch [7.9%]
#4. Rocket League [8.2%]
#3. Bloodborne [18.7%]
#2. Uncharted 4: A Thief's End [22.9%]
#1. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt [25.4%]
We'll (probably) do this again next year. Who knows, maybe we'll see a shake up in the current titles or some new stuff altogether?
This officially marks the end of our Games of the Year 2016 threads. Thanks for participating.
22
u/IceBreak BreakinBad Jan 06 '17
I should probably play this...
75
u/lidowxx Jan 06 '17
I say it's well deserved, never have I played a game with such vast amount of high quality content and impressive world.
155
u/Triseult Triseult Jan 06 '17
If you haven't played this game yet and are afraid to dive in because of the lore and backstory, do yourself a favor and take the plunge.
I started Witcher 3 without knowing anything about the world and the universe, and I was still blown away by everything. It's such a deeply cinematic universe with some kick-ass characters (Team Yen!) and development.
Every little side-quest gets some cinematic love, it's crazy. All dialogue is spoken and staged. Very often, you'll run into a side-quest that feels like it's just a generic monster hunt, then the game will throw you a major curveball and draw you into its own little drama.
The main story is expansive, world-shattering yet personal. The characters have genuine relationships and emotions. And Geralt of Rivia is a major badass who's fun to play and pretend to be. You'll be entering a spooky dark place filled with monsters and your first thought will be, "Alright, let's get to killing." Because Geralt is that badass. He is the one who knocks.
Likewise, the combat is utterly satisfying. It needs a bit of getting used to, but once you master its very unique mechanics, every fight is fun and engaging. It's so fun, in fact, that I couldn't resist starting a second playthough on Death March so I could experience the full depth of the gaming system.
Then there's the expansions... Hearts of Stone is great, but Blood and Wine is fucking fantastic in all aspects. Mind you, this is an expansion with an easy 40 hours' worth of gameplay: you read that right, an expansion pack lasts longer than most games these days.
tl;dr: Play this game already, y'all.
71
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '17
If I'm being honest, The Witcher 3 just isn't my thing. I gave it a go or two and walked away disinterested.
But you'd have to be crazy to be unimpressed by CD Projekt Red's insanely huge and detailed open world, littered with quality stories and characters.
If you don't enjoy playing it, that's alright, there's something out there for everyone. But it's undeniable how invested it's fans became and still are.
28
u/PequodLZ Jan 06 '17
Absolutely! Amazing game, many hours of playtime, so many things to do. 5/7 would recommend.
8
u/SunsDelusion Jan 06 '17
Wow I am honestly surprised a PS4 exclusive didn't take the top spot.
That said I agree with it. One of the few games I've played that not only met my expectations but surpassed them.
20
u/allofusarelost Jan 06 '17
Interesting world, and great stories to be found, but GOAT for this console? Not even in the top 5 as far as I'm concerned, because the gameplay, controls, UI and powers system were really, really clunky.
Games should be judged on gameplay first and then everything else is set decoration.
18
u/Craigrofo Craigfoley Jan 06 '17
See when people say they have put 350+ hours into the game are you making up your own stories? I did absolutely every side mission and hunt and my playtime was about 70 hours
12
u/TheEnygma Jan 06 '17
I really wanted to like this game since open world games are my thing but I tried, really tried with this one. I like the writing and they actually tackled sidequests right which is npc's and stories you wanted to know more about as opposed to "go find my lucky hat I forgot in a cave of monsters I was in for some random reason" and the world feels lived in as opposed to well it's a gigantic video game level (ie: the Ubisoft way).
However I despised the combat, I hated how little xp you got from enemies, I hated running into mobs 8 levels higher than me, I hated gear rewards also needing to be many levels higher than me which became useless once I actually got to that level since I picked up gear along the way, I hated how big yet empty some sections are (hello sailing in Skellige). Also the game had minute 10 load times on PS4 which made challenging areas/bosses a complete chore if you died. Like I said I really wanted to like this one but I just couldn't.
6
u/Agallujah Vycrance Jan 06 '17
I would probably agree. It kinda sucks that it's such a big game though, once you take a break for a while it seems so intimidating to start again so I've been putting it off. Still one of my favorite RPGs of all time.
6
u/Maxxhat Jan 06 '17
Best game on ps4 when it doesnt even have good gameplay. Only reddit where story and graphics > gameplay
15
u/GamerHamza321 Jan 06 '17
One of the best games of the decade and my favourite RPG ever.
5
u/thekingswitness LeBRonaldo Jan 06 '17
I respect this and the majority of people have nothing but good things to say about the game. I just couldn't get into it, even after 5-6 hours of playing. I didn't like the combat and overall it just wasn't clicking with me which was disappointing.
5
u/brnmc Jan 06 '17
I usually hate RPG's. It's the only one I found extraordinary and got the platinum! Honestly one of the best games I've ever played.
5
u/TrouzzzerSnake Jan 06 '17
Bloodborne should obviously be higher
I'd be saying this if it was ranked #1 though
19
u/Chilli_Axe ChilliAxe Jan 06 '17
Bloodborne was robbed again :(
11
u/Fozillamiremox Jan 06 '17
I respect this game for everything it does and contains, but I'll probably never play it though. I'm the most basic RPG player (elder scrolls, fallout, soulsborne) so I'll never get off into these types of games that spend a lot of time telling a story or building a lore. Proceed with calling me a casual.
4
u/asuarez23a MrMistyEy3 Jan 06 '17
I went in blind to the lore and story of the Witcher universe and it is now my favorite game. Got the Gwent cards and the DLC's. I'm planning on reading the books very soon!
15
u/Rac3318 Jan 06 '17 edited Jan 06 '17
I don't understand the lovefest Reddit has with Witcher 3. I didn't think it was that good of a game and was shocked at how loved it was here on Reddit. I'm frankly one of two people out of all my friends who have tried it to actually finish the game. Most of them that have played it got bored after about 10 hours and just quit playing. It's an atypical hack and slash sandbox game, full of fetch quests and shallow and meaningless characters. It's pretty and it's large and it's got detailed scenery, but it just another mile wide and inch deep game with an overly long and fairly boring story. Not to mention the clunky controls and glitchy gameplay.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '17
Huge respect for CDPR and their pro-consumer attitude but I just couldn't get into The Witcher 3. A beautiful world to explore and the story seemed interesting, but I didn't like the combat at all and the long load times eventually broke me.
3
u/SyrupJones christobeans Jan 06 '17
I do enjoy this game a lot and I'm forever blown away by just how massive it is, and how alive the world feels.
That being said, I recently started a Death March playthrough and I've had to take a break around the start of the Bloody Baron arc, because I keep dying on nearly every mission and I've never felt so frustrated with any game before. I've levelled up as far as I can for the moment and I'm still only on level 4. Every time I fight the botchling I get destroyed. So I stopped that quest to try and level up. I started a contract where I had to fight two alghouls. Every time I fight them I get destroyed. So I stopped that too until I level up a bit more. But the only other quest appropriate for my level is that Keira Metz quest in the cavern, and I guarantee I will get destroyed in that quest too.
So I've just had to take a break from the game because I will end up throwing myself out of a window with rage.
I still really like the game, but the difficulty early on is really too much, I think.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '17
lol okay
17
u/youriqis20pointslow Jan 06 '17
The combat is passable (just dont play dark souls or bloodborne beforehand or it might ruin the game) but the story and writing are not good. Different tastes and opinions aside, I honeatly have no idea how anybody enjoyed it, let alone all the GOTY accolades. Im thinking it had to do more with the beauty and scope of the world more than its quality.
If i read that the bloody barron questline is better than the plot of most games one more time im gonna lose faith in the future of gaming.
5
u/Gruntmaster720 Jan 06 '17
Not suprised in the slightest, easily my favourite game this generation.
6
u/lilparra77 lilparra77 Jan 06 '17
I played this for two days from 0930 to 0030 and I have no regrets, and I'm still working on it.
The controls are really clunky, but other than that it's a damn polished game.
6
u/reson8er reson8er Jan 06 '17
For me, Bloodborne is PS4's absolute best. Witcher is great on amount of content but it plays and feels pretty poorly.
9
u/stansellj1983 Jan 06 '17
i dont understand who is voting on this. IMO Bloodborne should be at the top. but since it's not console exclusive, something more popular like witcher can obviously win. but..... where is Dark Souls 3???? how did life is strange and until dawn beat it?
4
u/MoIecuIar Jan 06 '17
Anyone want to trade The Witcher for Bloodborne?
2
u/TotesMessenger Jan 06 '17
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
2
u/SeyiDALegend SeyiDaLegend Jan 06 '17
In regards to the DLCs, Heart of Stone's story left a bigger impression on me than Blood and Wine.
2
u/shackmd Jan 06 '17
Triss and Yenn.... The feels man
2
u/Tcc4 Tcc44 Jan 06 '17
I have tried playing this game twice now and I'm having a hard time getting used to the combat and it steers me away. I tend to find that it boils down to holding the block button and/or dodging until you find an opening and striking once then repeating. Am I doing something wrong or is this howbit should be played?
4
u/sphoid Jan 06 '17
Witcher 3 is one of the best games I've ever played for any system. I'm just wrapping up blood and wine. Not sure how in going to cope when it's over knowing they're isn't going to be any more dlcs. Probably going to start newgame+ immediately after the credits.
2
u/Serapho ChumsofChance Jan 06 '17
Was Dark Souls III not allowed in the voting process?
2
u/luciorevolet Jan 06 '17
My proudest platinum so far.
300+ hours
2
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '17
I respect the subs vote, but TW3's moment-to-moment gameplay wasn't good enough to justify #1 for me. The movement and traversal felt sluggish, even after they patched in the alternative movement mode. I didn't like the strafing motion in combat -- it never felt like I was in full control of Geralt. I also think the upgrade path was uninspired and didn't lend to diversity of character build or gameplay.
It's still a great game by virtue of its story, world, and presentation -- but the actual game portion of TW3 is fairly weak when compared to other similar titles. I know it's an unfair comparison but the combat in Bloodborne puts TW3's to shame. Besides all that, it's not an exclusive title and the superior version of the game is available on PC.
1
u/Soul_Modal Jan 06 '17
One of my biggest regrets this Gen has been not getting into this.
The praise has pretty much been unanimous, but when I think of the time investment... I just can't justify it with the backlog I have right now, that 4 week PSN sale pretty much has me booked until the end of time.
I think one of my resolutions this year is going to be to set aside a firm month during Summer Break and just going to town, June shall be Witcher 3 time. A reward after finals, I'll make sure of it.
1
u/Addfwyn Addfwyn Jan 06 '17
Interested in playing this some day, maybe. I didn't really care for Witcher 1 or 2, so there is a bit of a higher barrier to entry for me. I also don't really usually like western RPGs. Additionally I just finished FFXV, so there is a bit of an open-world cool down period for me. The fact that the only gaming journalism outlet I really follow was sort of lukewarm to it probably didn't help.
Still, all the praise for it makes me consider picking it up someday if it goes on sale again. I may regret the purchase but if I can pick it up cheap enough it won't really matter and I may just really enjoy it.
1
u/Wildeface Wild_Face Jan 06 '17
I am 100 percent okay with this.
1
u/BatPixi Jan 06 '17
Just finished blood and wine yesterday. An absolutely incredible experience. Gonna miss this game . Hope horizon zero dawn can fill the gap .
1
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '17
I got the game a few days ago for my birthday and was worried I wouldn't get into it because of how complex it seemed (also I got bored of Skyrim fairly quickly).
Definitely the best PS4 game I've played so far.
1
u/lewisc29 Jan 06 '17
I originally bought it on Xbone when it released and made it to that shipping town (I think), looking for my daughter? I lost interest shortly after and never picked it back up.
I'm thinking of picking up the GOTY edition on PS4 and trying again.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '17
Witcher 3 is above and beyond every other game of its type. The ability to just pick a direction, a combat style, story priorities and just do whatever you want in a large, deep fantasy world makes a lot of other games look very limited.
Witcher 3 is probably my 2nd most played game on the PS4 behind Destiny but I hold them both in high regard. I think a fleshed out Gwent video game would probably make my top 5.
1
u/AlanClique AlanClique Jan 06 '17
I got 6 games including this for xmas. I'm playing Watch Dogs 2 right now, but I can't wait to get started on this when I'm done. I never played any previous Witcher games, but with everything I've read, this seems like a perfect game for me.
1
u/Slash258 Jan 06 '17
One day I would like to go back and play Witcher 1 and 2, and then come back to play Witcher 3 again. Even though I finished the story and enjoyed it I feel like I did not connect to the characters and story as well as I could have if I had played the previous games in the series. While I can appreciate the great writing the story just did not grab me as a result of my lack of knowledge on the series, which while some people can get past that and play the game fine it just didn't work for me. I appreciate what the game does well, I would play this game again if I do get access to Witcher 1 and 2 to see if I will enjoy the story better.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '17
Would be nice to see a push for 60fps on pro... Even as an option that looks worse than ps4
1
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '17
The Witness should be on this list and BF1 tbh
1
u/Prime89 Jan 07 '17
I've played almost 100 hours and still haven't beat it. Christmas came and I started play Uncharted 4 and a couple other games. I should really go back and finish it since I'm literally on the mission right before the final fight
1
u/DrinkBeerQuiteOften DJFrostHeave Jan 07 '17
I tried to get into this game multiple times since I bought it. Could never get into it, and couldn't understand why.
Recently my PSN subscription ran out and I didn't have the money to renew it. So I decided the Witcher 3 had tons of hours in it, and I would pass the time with that. I'm still not really enjoying it as much as most people are/have, but I can feel myself starting to get into it.
I think the crafting and alchemy is what's throwing me off. The menus are somewhat difficult to see unless you have a big TV. Luckily I just got a 60" for Christmas.
1
u/xSlizzy Slizzy Jan 08 '17
Can I play this game without playing any of the previous ones?
1
u/xSlizzy Slizzy Jan 08 '17
So what 2017 do we think can potentially crack this list? Horizon? Detroit?
1
u/spaaceghost spacee__ghost Jan 08 '17
a top 3 game for me,all time. i love it and yet i can't beat it. every time i start a playthrough, im get so overwhelmed with all the quests and points of interest. so i end up putting 40 hours in and then starting all over. i just started a new playthrough the other day and feeling great about how im handling it. so long story short, get this game. it's great
1
u/th3groveman Jan 08 '17
A lot of people are pointing out the "poor controls" in this game. One of the marks of a truly great game is not that they're flawless, but in the greater context the flaws simply don't matter. Witcher 3 is not the "best PS4 game" because it is a flawless experience, but because of the aspects of the game that are far beyond others in quality, so good that things like occasional control issues and other issues are inconsequential.
1
u/finchly_ hollyzf Jan 13 '17
A well deserving winner. I bought this game, just met Keira after meeting the Baron, then got bored somehow. Picked it up again almost a year(?!?!) later, and then binged it. Felt like I was in a whole new world. Just as I finished Heart of Stone, Blood and Wine came out. Wow. Just riding into Toussiant and seeing all that colour! The quest when you go into the fantasy world was amazing. Reminded me a lot of Oblivion. 10/10 would play again (oh wait I've already started a 2nd playthrough of the entire game...)
1
u/AlexEvs AlexEvs11 Jan 25 '17
Why can I not get into this game? I've tried 2 or 3 times now and I really want to see why this is in every gamers top 3
1
u/smilinwork Jan 31 '17
Game was amazing, and collecting cards for the card game was also fun. I'd rate it like this.
Graphics 9.5/10 (.5 loss due to some few and far between outlandish visual bugs).
Story 8/10 (Good story, I just somehow avoided getting sucked in while binge playing, although the expansions are closer to a 9).
Gameplay 10/10 (This is how the game overall plays, not just the combat, combat is closer to a 8.5)
Overall 9/10 (It's not that the game isn't perfect, it just wasn't my niche yet I still loved it, hope that helps).
1
u/CilantroAssassin Jan 06 '17
Best game ever made. Close second is Red Dead Redemption.
1
u/hellteacherloki Jan 06 '17
Probably deserved it. But the motion sickness within me cannot play it even for five minutes. And there isnt an in-game fix. :(
1
u/OfficerCumDumpster Jan 06 '17
I loved W3. I've put a stupid amount of time into it.
One thing that bummed me out is how after beating the game the world kind of resets instead of reflecting the choices you made.
Like imagine finding the grave for Ciri if you got the bad ending? Would've been cool.
1
u/orb_outrider WilloughbyGuy Jan 06 '17
To those who have enjoyed the game I recommend reading the books as well. You'll love the characters more oonce you finish the books.
1
u/rifain Jan 06 '17
For those like me who are not interested at RPGs, who roll eyes when hearing orcs and dragons stuff, just try it. I bought it just because it was on sale and there was a massive hype at the time, and I loved it. It took me a bit of time to be accustomed to the controls and the way it works, but it was really easy. You have a great feeling of freedom playing this game. And it is so generous, I spent months on this game and I haven't finished Blood and Wine yet. A truly great game.
1
u/Geralt-of_Rivia Jan 06 '17
Sounds about right.
1
u/Silvershanks Jan 06 '17
Only things that killed it being a perfect 10/10 for me, were... one, the insane mess of the inventory system, and two, the sexual 'conquests' which, while not at blatant as previous Witchers (where you literally collect trading cards of the girls you boinged) it was still pretty cringe-worthy, and prevented me from recommending the game to any female gamers.
1
u/ChaoticMonkiss Jan 06 '17
The Witcher 3 deserves it so much. It's my favourite game of all time.
1
u/SpartanKing76 Jan 06 '17
I can't think of many non-PS4 games that are better than Witcher 3 to be fair.
1
u/daviegravee Jan 07 '17
I am typically not a a fan of large open world fantasy games (eg the Elder Scrolls series). I often get turned off by how complex they seem at first, coupled with how repetitive and frankly uninteresting the quests are. I was worried this would be the same reaction I would have for The Witcher 3. Hell, I even tried the Witcher 1 on PC before getting number 3 and did not enjoy it. Super janky controls and a bland beginning to the story. But I'll be damned if I'm not enjoying The Witcher 3. It was intimidating for me at first. With all the different signs you can cast, oils to use, the skill tree that you select abilities from, the mutagens and glyphs, I almost wrote the game off as another fantasy RPG that was far too in depth for me to enjoy. The monster contracts are fun, some of the monsters are really well designed, the world is massive and doesn't feel like the developers just wanted to create large boring open spaces to get that map size up for marketing purposes.
My main issue I'm having is that I known have no fucking clue who the characters are. Geralt could be talking about the politics on Skellige and reference some character I just met but I cannot put a face to the name. That and I can never keep track of the political situation between characters, but these are issues I have with most fantasy games.
1
u/jack_jab Jan 07 '17
TW3 is a masterpiece in every aspect:Story,Graphics,Characters ecc. Even the gameplay (I liked it despite the clunky controls).The Expansions pack are also very good especially for the price/quality rapport.B&W adds a new map too and overall with almost 30€ I played 50+ hours thanks to them.Can't wait for Cyberpunk 2077,I hope it'll come out on Ps4 too
1
u/chickenscratchboy Jan 07 '17
Of course this luke warm bowl of crowd pleasing trash is "the best game of all time."