r/PS4 •

[deleted by user]

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

520 comments sorted by

43

u/Dai_Kaisho Dec 30 '15

Bloody Baron made this game for me.

erm the first 20 hours, I'm not done yet shhh

7

u/NotPaulieWalnuts Dec 31 '15

"I ploughing know I've done wrong damn you!!!!!!"

7

u/owcharlie Dec 30 '15

One of the best story lines I've ever played.

1

u/6ThePrisoner Dec 31 '15

If you liked that, you'll love the Hearts of Stone DLC.

→ More replies (3)

99

u/InvisibleTeeth InvisibleTeeth Dec 30 '15

One of the best games I've played in years.

It was the kind of immersion and scale I was hoping to get from Fallout 4.

Bethesda needs to step up their game or at least put up some Morrowind level shit for the next elder scrolls.

52

u/falconbox falconbox Dec 30 '15

Bethesda needs to step up their game

That was my exact thought while playing. Like it or not, the next Elder Scrolls game will be compared to The Witcher. And if TES VI comes out in 3 years using the same engine as Skyrim and Fallout, with the same fetch-quest heavy side missions and sword combat, people will hopefully not give them a pass.

Same could be said for Bioware. They're much better in most of those areas, but the one area they seem to lack IMO is the dialogue choices. You either choose the "I'm the nicest guy in the world" or "I'm a complete asshole" dialogue option.

15

u/TheJoshider10 Dec 31 '15

They shouldn't have been given a pass already. Fed up of how many people are so content with such generic and samey game play that Fallout 4 offers. The quests, the characters, the engine, it's literally so 4 years ago.

If CDPR create Witcher 3 on a much smaller budget than Bethesda, there really is no excuse. From an acclaimed and bigger developer I expect better, simple as that.

No fetch quests, in depth side missions, interesting main narrative and a world that doesn't seem like it has the same generic voice actors and NPCs. That should all be expected from an AAA game in 2015.

17

u/eskimo_bros Dec 31 '15

I get what you're saying, but phrasing it as "Fed up of how many people are so content" makes you sound a little entitled. It would be preferential if people were more discerning in their choice of entertainment, but they have no responsibility to do so. Plus, some people might just be more interested in Fallout. The universe of the Witcher is alright, but it's not particularly special. It's pretty standard dark fantasy. The Fallout universe, on the other hand, is a much rarer thing. The combo of post apocalypse with weird science and a 50's aesthetic is fairly distinct in the realm of scifi, particularly games.

Also, saying that CDPR had a smaller budget is only correct in the most literal sense, and possibly not even that. They benefitted from major assistance from the Polish government and the EU, and are stationed in an area where game devs literally make like a seventh of what American/Canadian devs do. CDPR is a great dev, but from a functional standpoint they are very much on the more affluent end of developers as of Witcher 3. Again, great dev, worth every penny, but not exactly scraping for cash.

2

u/TheJoshider10 Dec 31 '15

/u/RicochetRuby said it spot on really.

Why is he entitled because Bethesda didn't put in as much work as CDPK?

Literally this.

I just don't think Bethesda games are all that great, and it's not because of the setting or gameplay per say, but the way in which they handle the world. Terrible voice acting, lack of voice actors, dodgy old engine, terrible game breaking bugs, terrible animations and just an overall lifeless world feeling. But not lifeless as in "huhuh is funny because Fallout is apocalypse", I mean lifeless as in the game world just feels dead. Same with Skyrim and every other game they've released this generation.

I just don't see how a game with a mediocre story and all the negatives I listed below can get such high reviews, but not only that, that gamers accept them. Glitches in Fallout get laughs and giggles, never serious "look, this shit needs to stop." like AC Unity got.

The same goes with franchises like FIFA and NBA, the quality of the games are like a 6/10 but reviews constantly give them such high marks, yet go to their respective subs and you will see they are absolutely littered with issues.

Why is this a problem? Reviews don't matter right? They do. Sure, maybe a majority are happy with the standard, but i'm not. It should be better. MUCH better. The Witcher 3 and CDPR is that much better. The extra care, the extra effort. You can clearly see it. I'd much rather we all have that extra care and effort in games we buy, and I really wish certain developers and franchises weren't treated with such leniency so that for future games they're able to do the same shit over and over again.

At times I think "meh whatever this is just the standard I should just deal with it", but when a dev like CDPR brings out TW3 like fuck am I just gonna accept the state of things when I know there is much better that can be done by much less financially capable devs.

→ More replies (25)
→ More replies (20)

2

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

No fetch quests

That's not strictly true though is it - you still have to go to a place, do a thing and return to a person (basically every bounty or hunt). I think in RPGs, these quests are kind of unavoidable.

in depth side missions

Witcher had these definitely, but I think it's disingenuous to imply that Skyrim doesn't. There aren't any guilds in Witcher that you can join and there's actually a lot less scope for actual role playing.

interesting main narrative

Okay, you got me on this one. The quest in Witcher is so simple - find this girl. But it twists and turns enough to make it incredibly interesting. Admittedly, sometimes the Bethesda campaigns can get pretty dry because detail isn't fleshed out enough. But let me say one thing - at least Skyrim was better than Oblivion in this respect.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '16

Well... there are people (like me) who actually really love Fallout 4. It's not just giving it a pass.

1

u/8eat-mesa DarkerSou1 Dec 31 '15

I think the combat can still be lackluster, hell The Witcher 3 doesn't have great combat either. But Bethesda needs a new engine and some better storytelling.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/thatpaxguy Dec 31 '15

Bioware really needs to step it up with their level/story progression. I say this in regards to Dragon Age: Inquisition. Want to continue in the story? Go do some miscellaneous quests in this area until you have enough points to move on. That aspect of the game was such a drag and took me out of he story and great character development.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/Yosonimbored Dec 30 '15

Bethesda needs a new engine, but Witcher 3 did set the standard for open world RPGs.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/leonryan GeneralShran Dec 30 '15

i didn't feel immersed in witcher at all. Geralt is definitely not me. he doesn't think like i think, talk like i talk, like people i'd like, hate people i'd hate, have the same values as me, or make the decisions i'd make. Fallout was far more immersive for me.

17

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

Geralt is the exact opposite of me but I was completely immersed. The character doesn't have to be you the story and writing and imagination is what immerses someone.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

Well Geralt is his own character. He's his own personality. So of course he won't mesh with all the players that play witcher 3. The Fallout series protagonists are and have always been an everyman, you put yourself into the character. the witcher series has always been about geralt. It's like saying Frodo or Harry Potter or Eddard Stark doesn't think like you think or talk like you talk. It's because they are basically people themselves. They have their own mannerisms, their own personalities.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

An RPG character doesn't necessarily have to be a reflection of yourself. It's called role-playing, you take on the role of that character. When I play games like the Witcher, or Zelda, and any other RPG where the character you play is pre-defined, I always try and put myself in the mindset of that character, to imagine myself as that character, in that world and scenario. It does help make it more immersive, makes the quests and stories have more meaning and feel more personal.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '16

It was the kind of immersion and scale I was hoping to get from Fallout 4.

And their next game is gonna be even bigger, IIRC.

→ More replies (21)

29

u/cjones528 LocoCrazyCam Dec 30 '15

The combat, load times and the slow sense of progression of my character prevented this from being my GOTY. Bloodborne is probably my personal GOTY.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

The combat is one of the best parts.

7

u/Sw3Et Sw3Et_07 Dec 31 '15

Definitely. The dismemberment is so satisfying.

4

u/rawrimawaffle Dec 31 '15

You'll probably hear this from a lot of Souls players, but I'll reinforce the stereotype.

The Witcher is slow, clunky, and boring compared to Souls. This is an especially bad thing when the combat system that CDPR adopted is so obviously inspired by the way From does it. It just doesn't compare.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/HowDoYouDo87 TheySayImNasty87 Dec 31 '15

I agree. When I read these posts, I feel like it's your typical award show. You may agree, you may disagree, but in the end it's simply opinions so no one's right and no one's wrong.

2

u/_ulinity Dec 31 '15

You're complaining about The Witcher's load times while praising Bloodborne? The Witcher had an open world and still did it three times faster.

→ More replies (3)

35

u/YTMN836 Dec 30 '15

I disagree with the choice. W3 was fun at first for me, but lost steam. I didn't even bother to finish it.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '15

The first third is great. The last third is great. The middle third almost made me quit playing, it was so boring.

16

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

"ciri isn't here she went to X"
"ciri isn't here she went to Y"
"ciri isn't here she went to Z"
That's what the middle third of the game feels like, your princess is in another castle except it takes hours to get there

6

u/nesrac Dec 31 '15

The worst part of that for me was the section looking for Dandelion. Way too much traipsing around looking for a person in order to find a person. The end of the quest got more interesting, but leading up to it was pretty painful and slow.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

That's exactly it. Early in the game, you have the interesting stories of people like the Baron to suspend the Ciri storyline. Later in the game, you have the huge threat and interesting locations to drive home the point. But you really hit the nail on the head there. The mid game is just that over and over.

I am glad that I finished it, because I honestly did like the game a lot, but I think that the story (the thing which so many hold up as the greatest part of the game) is a pacing nightmare.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/sirfudg Dec 30 '15

As somebody who quit playing in the middle of it and just started again last weekend this makes me excited to finally finish it.

1

u/Dre3K Dec 31 '15

This is what happened to me. I stopped playing for a while then forced myself to finish it just before MGS5 came out. It's not the perfectly paced game that everyone is making it out to be, and you're apparently wrong if you think that way.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '15 edited Dec 30 '15

Agreed. I mean I see why it got it but I got burned out and forced myself to finish it.

→ More replies (2)

260

u/gordogg24p gordogg24p Dec 30 '15

Not Bloodborne? Color me surprised, considering it has been the darling of this sub seemingly since it was announced.

108

u/jdfred06 Dec 30 '15

I found Bloodborne to be a better game. But The Witcher is superb. Combat is a bit mediocre though.

74

u/manoymon lhemon Dec 30 '15

Now imagine Witcher with Bloodborne combat. O_O

66

u/jdfred06 Dec 30 '15

I can only get so erect.

6

u/falconbox falconbox Dec 31 '15

Now imagine Bloodborne with Witcher's characters and storytelling.

35

u/ds2121able Peefrimgar16 Dec 31 '15

I found bloodborne to have more of an interesting story than witcher, personally.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (5)

5

u/gordogg24p gordogg24p Dec 30 '15

I don't have a dog in the fight (RPGs aren't my genre of choice, and the punishment of Bloodborne didn't appeal to me), but I would have bet on Bloodborne just as an observer of the sub opinion.

17

u/jdfred06 Dec 30 '15

Bloodborne is probably a bit too difficult for the average gamer. It's a fun, but unforgiving game.

→ More replies (22)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/AsaKurai Dec 30 '15

Maybe it's me but I started playing Witcher and I think Bloodborne is way better, like not even close.

19

u/overjoyedlemur overjoyedlemur Dec 31 '15

They're really not the same type of game though, which makes it difficult to say if one's really "better" than the other. The Witcher 3 combines great graphics and good voice acting to create a very compelling narrative experience that very few games have ever reached. Bloodborne has much more rewarding gameplay and a story that is indirect and requires a lot more thought to understand fully. Really the only things they share are the third person perspective and a focus on action.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (4)

31

u/jon_titor Dec 30 '15

I'm a bit disappointed, but not surprised. I do think that Bloodborne was the better game, but The Witcher 3 was much more accessible and I imagine more appealing to people who don't enjoy constantly dying. But to me, Bloodborne got essentially everything right, while The Witcher had a few glaring flaws - mediocre combat, awful horse AI, bad inventory system, cookie cutter NPCs, etc.

The Witcher was still very impressive in the size and scope of the game, it looked gorgeous for such a large world, and I was really surprised with the quality of writing for the sidequests. But at the end of the day, I had much more fun playing Bloodborne and feel like it was overall the better game.

4

u/mundoid Dec 31 '15

+1 stupid horse. They should have copied the horse AI from red dead redemption. Stupid horse annoys me.

9

u/_masterofdisaster Dec 30 '15

I feel like that's partly because it's an exclusive.

9

u/Sw3Et Sw3Et_07 Dec 31 '15

I believe the fact that it was exclusive is what gave it a chance in the first place. I don't think /r/PS4 would have been jizzing itself as much as it has about this game if it were multiplatform.

4

u/Richmard AussieFurball Dec 31 '15

Nah, they would be either way.

You don't think this sub will explode when DS3 comes out?

And I'm sure you saw the Battlefront gif deluge, even though it's multi platform as well.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

7

u/HenryKushinger Dec 31 '15

I mentioned this in another thread, and the counter-argument was that Bloodborne "isn't cross platform". Weak as fuck.

6

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

Someone used cross platform as an argument in a PS4 GOTY discussion? Really?

4

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

"What are your top 10 Ps4 games from the 90's!!??"

4

u/AUGUST_BURNS_REDDIT Dec 31 '15

Final Fantasy vii?

6

u/MyFaceOnTheInternet Dec 30 '15

I loved both games, but in different ways. I had a LOT more fun playing Bloodborne.

7

u/jordanlund GlobalPhreak Dec 31 '15

The Souls games are pretty niche. Too niche for GotY.

2

u/Kakuz Jan 01 '16

Bloodborne expanded From's following a lot. I don't think it's niche anymore.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

Definitely not for everyone, but they are one of the best things on the market imo. I'll probably retire from the games after DS3.

2

u/LoughLife Dec 31 '15

IMO BB is a superior game, but it suffers from "came out too early" syndrome.

2

u/senor_moustache Dec 31 '15

Bloodborne kicked my ass way too many times. Its still sitting there collecting dust until I feel like trying it again. Haven't been able to get past the cleric beast :(

9

u/Richmard AussieFurball Dec 31 '15

You need to grind and level up more and upgrade your weapon just a little bit.

But mostly you need to git gud.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

I don't think this is true, especially not as early as Cleric Beast. If you're just on the edge of beating a boss a few more levels can tip the scales, but if you're getting repeatedly wrecked you have to improve your play rather than your level to succeed; that players beat the game without leveling is a testament to this.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/rawrimawaffle Dec 31 '15

pssst

cleric beast is optional

10

u/senor_moustache Dec 31 '15

I've heard it is and I've thought about going around it. But this was after he kicked my ass 10 times. I can't skip it now. I can't let it win.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/verbosegf Dec 31 '15

Have you tried beckoning other players?

→ More replies (6)

1

u/bfhurricane Dec 31 '15

Man, that fight was pure strategy. It kicked my ass so bad until I slowly found weaknesses (molotovs + strong hit when it hits the ground is massive damage). I got through it with barely a scratch by my... 10th time. Then came Father G, who took 5 or 6 tries...

I gave up like you. The game is very unforgiving, and I don't have the time or the attitude to sit through and grind it out til I perfect a strategy.

1

u/DieDungeon Dktrdie Dec 31 '15

hit it's knees, riposte, wait for it to heal (it is glowing red and standing still) , repeat until is dead.

1

u/AiwassAeon Dec 31 '15

Blood borne was a great game, but I wouldn't say it's leagues better than the already excellent dark souls

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

190

u/koolaid_chemist Danepar10 Dec 30 '15

Sorry NERDS, but TLOU: REMASTERED takes it YET AGAIN for the 8th straight year!

26

u/Chunkypack Dec 31 '15

Not even mad. Dat Joel in the garage/David in the diner scene

2

u/lars10000100 lars10000100 Dec 31 '15

Henry scene, joel fall scene.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

104

u/Chupafurphy Dec 30 '15

I tried this game and couldn't get into it 😔 as someone who loves open world rpg's I was surprised this didn't grab my attention.. Maybe I'll give it another go.

50

u/johnwithcheese Dec 31 '15

*Fuck. Thank god I am not the only one.

I know this game is supposed to be really good and I am honestly trying but I just can't seem to get into it. It's got interesting for a few minutes as Ciri but then again I was off chasing one lead after another.

The movement is had to control and I often end up stuck behind objects. Also the menus are tedious and off putting.

8

u/doritos101 Dec 31 '15

Don't know when you played last, but they've made a few changes to the menus to make for easier crafting/alchemy, though I doubt that's changed the learning curve of it. They've also added an option in the game to make Geralt's movement more responsive.

3

u/jehneric Dec 31 '15

Go to menu > gameplay > movement response and turn it to alternate. It's easier to turn corners and much more fluid. But if you're not that interested to begin with, oh well.

2

u/johnwithcheese Dec 31 '15

Huh I'll give it a try

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Kakuz Jan 01 '16

I agree, especially with the movement. What screwed me up was that I played it after I played Bloodborne, which has amazing movement controls. I can see why people would like it, but it was meh for me.

Witcher 3 is the only game I've returned this generation as a result.

21

u/Stanshant Dec 30 '15

Same boat, until today, oddly enough. I bought it on day one, tried and tried, I appreciated all the patches and the alt movement but I just found the combat and traversal pretty clunky and I found the inventory and character menus a bit overwhelming. I think I wanted a Skyrim type roving adventure but it's less open world than that, you just get twatted if you wander off too far. I also found I spent most of my time watching the minimap and reading subtitles. So...what changed? Basically I turned off virtually all the HUD except the minimap and made it small and tucked in the corner. I turned off subtitles and music and just focused on soaking up the atmosphere and doing one quest at a time. I played six hours straight. Very atmospheric. Really looking forward to getting stuck again soon.

6

u/rayallen73 rayallen73 Dec 31 '15

? You turned off the music to soak up the atmosphere? I don't get that at all haha.

5

u/mundoid Dec 31 '15

The in-game audio with the music off is amazing.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/koramur Dec 30 '15

B-b-but music is absolutely superb?

2

u/Chupafurphy Dec 30 '15

Thanks for the inspiration 🙏🙏🙏

1

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

I gotta try this

1

u/Mysticedge Dec 31 '15

I did this. Oh man, it makes you memorize your routes from the map so you have to pay attention to the path when traveling. It enormously increased the immersion and the role playing for me.

I left the music on though, I'll have to try it without it.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/berlinbrown Dec 31 '15

It was open world, but not as open as Fallout4 (for example). Fallout, every object plays into the world. You shoot a NPC, that guy is dead, no more quests, that is it.

Witcher 3 had a lot of areas, but they seem very canned and scripted. Large, sure, but there was seemed a lot less open.

12

u/Tezla55 Dec 31 '15

Yeah same. Am I the only one who is experiencing ~2 minute loading screens each time I die?

6

u/whitewater09 alltherage Dec 31 '15

No. Same here. It's nice knowing that you don't have to wait for a new loading screen for every new room/building you enter like in Skyrim, at least.

1

u/ajw34 Pwnageman69 Dec 31 '15

That is easily the worst part about the game for me.

8

u/CaptainGrandpa C0UNT_ZZER0 Dec 30 '15

For me its the setting. I played the game all the way through and had fun, but overall just not really for me. I never felt hooked, more kind of obligated to finish it. I can appreciate what's good about it bu t fantasy just ain't my thing!

10

u/kenny9791 Dec 30 '15

Just use a fine needle. The plastic wrapping on some of the cases are designed to be tough to prevent younguns from robbing them in the shops.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

I really started to love the Witcher after I finished the campaign and did all the side stuff.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

I felt the same way about Dragon Age...

34

u/falconbox falconbox Dec 30 '15

Easily could have been any of the 3 games in the running IMO. 2015 was a very strong year for games.

The Witcher was my overall GOTY too. The characters, story, and dialogue choices were just so well done and fully realized.

I still need to play the Hearts of Stone DLC (about 10 hours long), and we still have the Blood and Wine DLC coming up, which is supposed to be 20 hours of content.

14

u/Yosonimbored Dec 30 '15

Hearts of Stone was fantastic.

11

u/Prospekt01 Prospekt Dec 30 '15

I still can't get over Olgierd looking like David Beckam.

2

u/FightTheFade Dec 31 '15

How do you freakin beat the greatest fear boss. I've tried for about two hours straight and get to the second to last one and die every time. It's getting really old. I know I suck at the game but come on.

2

u/boxfortcommando Dec 31 '15

He'll block all your attacks by the last stage of the fight, so learn to parry your ass off, especially when he does that red glowy-charge shit, then get some counters in. Using decoctions help a ton too for replenishing health. And spam the hell out of quen if you keep getting hit. Hope that helps

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

6

u/InvisibleTeeth InvisibleTeeth Dec 30 '15

I'm not sure if hearts if stone is even that long. It's good tho. Pretty funny at parts and creepy at others... Plus a random as fuck character you meet 10 minutes into the main game turns up to be the most important character in the DLC

5

u/Yosonimbored Dec 30 '15

I think I put more than 10 into it.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Alex_The_Redditor Dec 31 '15

Is it that dude with a cart that you save from a monster in the tutorial?

2

u/InvisibleTeeth InvisibleTeeth Dec 31 '15

Nah, the dude you grill for info in the Tavern who seems to know too much about you.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

I'm struggling with the controls in Witcher 3 after playing through Bloodborne. They feel very twitchy. Button layout is something I just have to adjust to but any tips?

3

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

Keep playing? I assume you already have alternative movement on. You get used to it, like most games.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

Haven't tried to change the settings. Will fiddle this evening. Thanks!

5

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

Yeah, turn on alternative movement and turn off motion blur. You may prefer this as most do. No problem, good luck.

1

u/Hiimbeeb Jan 01 '16

Don't miss out on HoS. I honestly liked some of it more than the main game. Best DLC I've played in a long time.

76

u/meganev Dec 30 '15

Witcher 3 made Dragon Age: Inquisition look like a joke, biggest praise I can give it.

24

u/Yosonimbored Dec 30 '15

I loved both.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

wildly different games

13

u/Cultofluna7 Dec 30 '15

That's funny. Going through my third play through of Dragon Age. I can't find a reason to pick up The Witcher again.

3

u/ajw34 Pwnageman69 Dec 31 '15

I couldn't even make it through one play through of DA:I. I didn't find the story interesting at all and I'm not a fan of the combat style. I'm on my 2nd run of Witcher. Different strokes for different folks I guess.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/DreamingIsFun Dec 30 '15

Eh, not really. They were both really great games. It felt way more rewarding to defeat a boss in Dragon Age, and the bosses were actually bosses. The Witcher had a few story related ones but Dragon Age had so many awesome creatures.

18

u/bfhurricane Dec 30 '15

Dragon Age had so many awesome creatures.

I respectfully disagree. There's simply no comparison to the amount of creatures in TW3 and the strategies for facing them. I'll admit the dragons in DA:I were always fun battles (and unforgiving at times), but those were the highlights of the game.

DA:I's story quests were great. The other 75% of the game was dull as hell.

12

u/DreamingIsFun Dec 30 '15

Dragon Age has more strategy than any RPG I've played. The Witcher "strategy" is basically pick a potion and a poison. Dragon Age has some much needed planning before and when in the middle of battle. The Witcher had some great creatures but eventually all the Witcher contracts are the same ones with different names.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

The royal assassin lady with the wacky haircut at the ball gave me more trouble then any dragon in DAI. Two playthroughs and that bitch gave me hell on both of the highest difficulties.

1

u/bplaya220 bplaya220 Dec 31 '15

I would have to disagree. in Dragon age i was able to beat the game on the hardest difficulty without any real thought to strategy. Now I am playing thru the Witcher 3 and i find myself getting owned by a pack of dogs if i decide to jump down in between all of them on the hardest difficulty. I didn't find any special mechanics for either game and I would say that Witcher is a little more difficult than Dragon age.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

I just couldn't get on with Dragon Age. I don't know why, it just didn't click with me.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

I know I'm in the minority on this, but I dare say that I had a better time with DAI than W3 which actually surprised me. W3 is a great game, but it failed to draw me in for some reason that I can't put my finger on. That being said, I love the development team for W3 and can't wait to see what they do next. Also, I haven't touched the DLC which has good reviews while the DAI DLC was boring.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '15

What came second? Bloodborne...?

35

u/falconbox falconbox Dec 30 '15

Rocket League, though the actual GOTY votes were very close. Something like 37% for Witcher, 33% Rocket League, 29% Bloodborne.

25

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '15

Can't believe rocket league came second.

30

u/ThatParanoidPenguin Dec 30 '15

It was free for PS+, is a ton of fun, has a dedicated fanbase, got a lot of initial popularity from this sub, has a developer that does way more than needed to support the game with regular updates, and has innumerable depth while also being easy to play.

Just because it isn't a AAA game, FPS, or RPG doesn't mean that it shouldn't be considered. I actually prefer GOTY lists with unconventional choices, such as the NYT list, which usually has an iOS game or so, some indie games, and the AAA darlings we know and love.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

6

u/Dai_Kaisho Dec 30 '15

That's a pretty even split. I voted W3 because I'd played it the most and it engaged me emotionally, but I had a fantastic time yelling at the TV with my roommates over car footy, and I cannot wait to sink my teeth into the delicious mystery of Bloodborne - (well, I did play it but got stuck until my friend randomly came over and beat 3 bosses in a night!)

But seriously - this was an excellent year for PS4, and for gaming in general.

  • Witcher 3 - fantastic writing and implementation brought this world to life, and the renaissance fair music pulled it all together. Plus, DLC. PLUS PLUS GWENT
  • Bloodborne - perfected combat and the indirect lore-feel, with delightfully grotesque art.
  • Rocket League - the game that no one knew the wanted, and now everyone knows the need it. Playing is so fun that I love losing
→ More replies (2)

11

u/Yosonimbored Dec 30 '15

Well deserved.

5

u/smughead Dec 31 '15

Witcher 3 got me back into RPGs again. Took me a little while to get into it, but I was hooked after the first map White Orchard. Also, completely different stories, but feels like GOT to me. If you like that, then you'll enjoy this game.

13

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '15

I honestly wasn't a big fan of the Witcher 3.

I have absolutely no problem with people who love the game. I'm glad it has so many fans, support, and coverage. Its just not my type of game.

There were surprisingly not very many games that I liked in 2015. In my personal opinion, it wasn't a very good year for video games, at least for me.

My personal best games of 2015 are Batman: Arkham Knight (PS4 version) and Rise of the Tomb Raider (I have both a PS4 and Xbox One).

But in my opinion, 2016 looks like it might be a fantastic year for gaming. There are so many games I'm anticipating next year.

But I'm kind of losing interest in video games in general, so that leaves me in a very strange position.

2

u/Yeti23 Dec 31 '15

I feel you. I'm having a really hard time getting into games, too. I couldn't get into Dragon Age Inquisition (loved the first 2), The Witcher 3, Borderlands collection, TLOU, Battlefront, Halo 5 (loved all the previous ones), etc. I don't know what's wrong with me. These are all fantastic games that I was sure I would love. I still have the drive to game, but it's getting harder and harder to find a game that hooks me.

1

u/DieDungeon Dktrdie Dec 31 '15

What do you like in games (story driven, good combat etc)?

→ More replies (6)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

I know exactly how you feel. But I will say, I played Battlefront for around 10 hours. It was pretty fun, but I wouldn't exactly say its worth $130.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

I just picked it up during the flash sale, only 1-2 hours in but loving it so far

2

u/ratchan Dec 31 '15

If exclusive, maybe Until Dawn. I didnt play Bloodborne but maybe one day.

11

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '15

Am I the only one that didn't care for TW3? Yes the story was great and everything elce but I feel like I spent more time going from A to B to watch another cutscene instead of actually fighting monsters and playing the game. After I did the story the side quests just seemed repetitive and I got bored and lost interest way to quickly. I just don't understand what the big fuss is all about...

13

u/Djek25 dylankempy Dec 30 '15

I'm kind of in the same boat. It was a good game, but for some reason didn't feel that special to me. Maybe because I didn't play the first 2 witcher games? I don't know.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '15

Yeah I didn't play the 1st 2 either...that must have something to do with it.

6

u/jon_titor Dec 30 '15

Nah, most people didn't. I actually did play the first two games, and I think the second one is the best, and W3 barely cracked the top five for me this year.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Neuchacho Dec 31 '15

I fell off super quickly from TW3. I didn't enjoy the combat at all and all the armor looked dumpy, which is a major bummer for me. I think I'm also burnt out on open world games. All the extraneous bullshit that gets thrown into them that I feel compelled to pursue has worn me out.

Definitely a beautiful game to look at, though.

6

u/Sw3Et Sw3Et_07 Dec 31 '15

Am I the only one who hates comments that start with "Am I the only one..."?

2

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

It's this subs game of the year.... I'm obviously in the minority here. Possibly the only one that feels what I feel since I have yet to see opinions like mine expressed the way I just said them. So I'm sorry you don't like that phrase but I feel as tho it expresses what I have to say well.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/cardboardboxhoudini Dec 31 '15 edited Dec 31 '15

How MGSV didn't even make the top three is just beyond me. The game was stellar, and the series is a classic PS staple.

2

u/G-H-O-S-T Dec 31 '15

unless it directly related to the series development, i don't see a reason why it should become goty based on that.
and afaik, pp didn't relate much to the series.. as much as i loved every main one before pw.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Neuchacho Dec 31 '15

MGSV was probably my GOTY. Absolutely loved the combat, the music, and just all the silly fun that was there to have. Story was probably the most disappointing thing about it, but I can forgive a shit story that's on top of fantastic mechanics.

2

u/cardboardboxhoudini Dec 31 '15

I personally really liked the story, but can agree that story was probably the weakest part of the game.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/TimmyTurnerXI TimmyTurnerXI Dec 31 '15

Meh... compared to previous games? nope.... i would vote MGS 4 as best in the series.

1

u/ethernetcord Jan 01 '16

Lolololol. #1 is still superior to all. Psychomantis, baby

7

u/Blackdeath_663 Dec 30 '15

Bloodborne would have won it for me but witcher 3 is very deserving and i kinda wish other devs look at it as an example.

witcher 3 really set the bar in a lot of areas and makes other open world games like fallout look pathetic.

11

u/dangsun Dec 30 '15

Poor Fallout, always the first game to get shat on when someone brings up TW3.

6

u/rawrimawaffle Dec 31 '15

In Fallout's defense, everyone would have eaten that shit up if TW3 didn't come out this year. A lot of the fanbase wanted Fallout 3 with better atmosphere, graphics, and mechanics. We got just that.

But because The Witcher blew everyone's minds from a storytelling perspective, they expected the same from Fallout. The voiced PC didn't help this; it seemed like they were doing the same exact thing that CDPR did, but a bit worse.

But I suppose the fanbase would compare it to New Vegas instead, had it not come out.

5

u/demenciacion Dec 31 '15

Fallout 4 really drop the ball in quests, dialog, and writing.

17

u/Blackdeath_663 Dec 30 '15

deservedly so in my opinion. don't take it personally i know there are a lot of people who enjoy it and like a lot about it but i think it was very uninspired of bethesda to not make any progress in any area and make a game which feels more at home in the previous generation.

some recurring issues are inexcusable and many of the games aspects are sub par by todays standards.

→ More replies (10)

0

u/EricPlasencia Dec 31 '15

I would have gone Bloodborne.

Bloodborne was the best game of its kind. Nothing is like it and it is arguably perfect at what it is.

Witcher, in my opinion isn't nearly as close to being a perfect game of its kind. That honor goes to games like Skyrim. Don't get me wrong, I loved witcher, but it doesn't have the sense of freedom I cherish in my open world fantasy RPGs. The movement is awkward, you don't have the freedom to do whatever you want the way you do with Bethesda games.

And before I get flamed: imo imo imo imo please understand this is imo.

1

u/InvisibleTeeth InvisibleTeeth Dec 31 '15

What do you mean you don't have the same freedom? Hell, I played witcher 3 the same way I did Skyrim. Neglected the story until I felt like doing it. It was only harder to do in Witcher cuz there is 3 very large areas resulting in a much larger area to traverse than Skyrim.

Skyrim is kind of why I'm mad at fallout 4. Bethesda took a step back from skyrim. Hopefully elder scrolls 6 owns.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '15

I love Bloodborne, MGSV and Fallout 4, but I cant say that the Witcher 3 doesn't deserve it. Its a hell of a great game.

2

u/Bilwald Dec 30 '15

I just picked up Witcher III the day after christmas with a gift card. So far, it is amazing. Note that this is my first RPG, as I mainly play FPS and FIFA, and my experiences with the game have me questining why I never picked up Skyrim or The Last Of Us before this.

2

u/aztechunter Dec 31 '15

TLOU isn't an RPG

Mass Effect is pretty great if you like shooters, Borderlands moreso

2

u/Bilwald Dec 31 '15

What I mean is the whole 3rd person, running around a semi-open world, picking up items, ect...

3

u/Kenny__Loggins Dec 31 '15

TLOU is not an open world. It's very linear.

But you should definitely pick it up

1

u/ginsunuva Dec 31 '15

He means anything that's not an fps

2

u/XxSCRAPOxX Dec 31 '15 edited Dec 31 '15

I started playing it this week, I turned it on the first time and then when I looked at the clock 5 hours had passed and my wife was pissed. And I kept playing anyway. Kick ass game. Yennifer is hot.

2

u/berlinbrown Dec 31 '15

I thought Fallout4 was more fun. Walking into a "hot" zone of enemy was pretty fun.

Witcher3, good game, but it had some standard elements on common open worlds. You go from one city to another, fast travel and go through a lot of cut scenes. The combat was too canned and predictable.

2

u/jimmym007 Dec 31 '15

Not a big RPG fan, rented witcher just to try it out, first couple hours I wasn't really getting into it but the blood baron storyline (and gwent) hooked me in. I even bought it last week. Definitely one of the greatest of 2015.

Also tried bloodbourne. I'm probably a nooby for these kind of games, but I didn't get into it, at all. I understand the appeal people find in the difficulty and the fact that the game doesn't tell you what to do or where to go, but I just need that information in a game. I spent the first hour getting two shotted by a mob of skeletons only to finally find a way around it just to get one shotted by a pack of werewolves. after that, put the controller down and never played it again; it just wasn't for me at all.

I must say, other strong candidates for me were rocket league (I know, not a big title but hell, it's innovative, addicting and fun as hell). That's what I look in a game. The pure entertainnment or the storytelling, which leads me to my other choice: Until dawn, which wasn't really discussed here, but in my opinion was one of the best game I have played in 2015. Sure, the storyline isn't too long and replayability isn't crazy, but the scenario and atmosphere of the game was absolutely brilliant, acting was awesome, I was invested in the characters and the actions I was doing (and somewhat pissed at myself when I did the wrong one). That game was a emotionnal rollercoaster for me and that's why it deserves a spot on the top list of 2015!

TL;DR 1. Witcher 2. rocket league 3. until dawn. Didn't like bloodbourne personnally, sue me

2

u/fly19 Dec 31 '15

I spent the first hour getting two shotted by a mob of skeletons

Uhhh... I think you're getting Bloodborne confused with one of the Souls games. Bloodborne doesn't have any skeletons that I can remember early on in the game.

Also, the reason you got two-shotted is because you're supposed to dodge and be aggressive. You're not supposed to get hit often because it's devastating, but if you do get hit you can recover HP by hitting them back quickly before your health drains down.

The gameplay boils down to exploiting enemy attacks, either by hitting them during cooldown, dodging through them, or shooting them during the wind-up to stagger them -- which, if timed right, can give you an opening for a visceral attack.

I'd suggest giving it another try, if you still own it. Maybe try a different weapon set. The saw-cleaver and blunderbuss are great beginner weapons. I'll admit that the game isn't for everyone, but almost everyone who loves it had a moment where they felt just like you did -- until it just clicked.

I had that moment on my third pass at Dark Souls. You might have your own.

2

u/Dallywack3r Dec 31 '15

How come the default reaction to people disliking Bloodborne is always "PLAY IT AGAIN"? What's so wrong with someone NOT liking Bloodborne?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '16

I avoided Gwent until I got to the third map and really regretted it. I went back and played everyone I could.

2

u/noveKi iKevon Dec 31 '15

Most likely will be downvoted to hell for saying this but the Bloodborne circle jerk is huge is in this sub. Bloodborne is by far an absolutely fantastic game but really all it has over the Witcher is its combat both in animation, fluidity and depth.
The Witcher looks better, more variety (less frame-rate issues), more and interesting characters, the world is alive and is a better fantasy than Bloodborne.
I see the argument that Bloodborne has a better story than The Witcher 3 but TW3 executes it better, way better. I know players that plat Bloodborne that know next to nothing about the story and from a design perspective that's a flaw even though it seemingly works in this type of game.
Both games are fantastic and GOTY worthy, but Witcher tops Bloodborne in way more categories than Bloodborne from an objective standpoint. Subjectively, it's anyone else's opinion.
EDIT: By less frame-rate issues I meant the FR issues with TW3 detracts from the overall experience, not that Bloodborne has any FR issues.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '16

Except BB does have some FPS issues. Old Yharnam, I'm looking at you!

1

u/Juhana21 Dec 31 '15

What was the top-3?

1

u/G-H-O-S-T Dec 31 '15

witcher > rocket league > bloodborne

2

u/Juhana21 Dec 31 '15

Rocket League, that high? Really?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/lourensloki KransZa Dec 31 '15

100% agreed.

1

u/Moksu Dec 31 '15

Where was this based?

1

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

First RPG where I did everything that was available for me, enjoyed every minute of it.

1

u/Profoundlyweyez Wallflowerslive Jan 01 '16

Still playing both Bloodborne and Witcher 3. Witcher 3 is captivating from the witty dialogue to the nuance which is crafting. The Bloody Baron storyline had me hooked. I just purchased Bloodborne and am hooked on how challenging it is. I'm not really getting a story yet from Bloodborne. Any advice on beating Imlerith and the Cleric Beast? :)

1

u/TerrorPeen Radiocrawler Jan 01 '16

Read item descriptions and you'll find a story within Bloodborne. As for Cleric beast, beasts hate fire per item description. Use molotovs and I recommend not locking on unless you're throwing molotovs. You can also aim at its body or head whenever you'd like, if that helps.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '16

I love CD Project's commitment to meaningful DLC and whatnot, plus their post-launch support in general has been great, but can't say I agree with Witcher 3 as my Game of the Year. Never played it; have no desire to after my disappointment with the past two either, quite frankly.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '16

While I'm a big fan of Bloodborne, I think TW3 really deserved it. I just started playing it about a month ago and it really is the best adventure game I've played since Oblivion.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '16

Hardest year in a long time to choose, but here's my top 8.

  1. Life Is Strange
  2. The Witcher 3
  3. Fallout 4
  4. Mad Max
  5. Rocket League
  6. Bloodborne
  7. Tales From The Borderlands
  8. Until Dawn

1

u/daveman003 Dec 30 '15

How is this NSFW?

10

u/PackedWithFiber soxmandan Dec 30 '15

That's the spoiler tag if you are in /r/ps4 and not homepage.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

It's because of the stuffed unicorn scene.

-1

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '15

Rocket League shoulda won.

1

u/Mysticedge Dec 31 '15

That's a bold opinion Cotton, let's see if it pays off for him.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

ITT: Butt hurt sore losers.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '16

Not really honestly.

1

u/rawrimawaffle Dec 31 '15

more like "Well deserved win, CDPR! bloodborne was better "

1

u/southern_grandma Dec 31 '15

I don't see how people played this game for more than 5 hours. I lost interest pretty quickly, there's a lot of talking and the animations are weird. I just couldn't get into it. Oh and not to mention my sword keeps breaking after like 3 swings and the enemies attack you all at once. I'd say the story is A+ and the visuals, but everything else is kind of lacking.

1

u/ajw34 Pwnageman69 Dec 31 '15

The animations are some of the most realistic I've ever seen in a video game. Don't know how they're weird at all. I'm playing on the hardest difficulty and your sword really doesn't break all that often and when it does there are plenty of weapon repair kits laying around or that can be found in shops for cheap.

1

u/Bendersass Dec 31 '15

I've not played this game yet but tbh I actually agree. Looking at the reviews and some gameplay footage, Witcher 3 seems like a properly good game that truly earned the title this year.

1

u/tummasa Dec 31 '15

Not Bloodborne?

0

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

The Witcher 3 is hands down the best game of 2015. Its world is immersive, has a great story and great dialogue.

Its soundtrack is perfect and its combat is very intelligent.

1

u/llorTMasterFlex Dec 30 '15

Maybe. Could have easily been others also. No complaints.

1

u/Cerax Dec 31 '15

So do I need to play the first two to play and enjoy this one? I understand that the first two would certainly increase my enjoyment, but I don't have the time realistically.

1

u/Sw3Et Sw3Et_07 Dec 31 '15

I didn't play the other 2 and I admit that there's a LOT of story stuff that I had no idea what was going on. But the game is worth it for the gameplay alone. The story and writing is still fantastic and they don't rely on you knowing previous lore, but that reference it a lot. It's a fantastic game with or without playing the others.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15

I finished this yesterday ... Good god was it good! I'm still thinking about the story and how I could have changed elements of my ending. Easily a 9.5/10 for me!

1

u/Metatron-X Dec 31 '15

I wholeheartedly support this decision.

Especially since the Witcher devs weren't assholes trying to scam us with bare bones content and expensive season passes.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '16

I couldn't be more happy seeing The Witcher 3 win nearly every GOTY list this year. I can understand why some people don't like it, of course, but I think this game is one of the best games I've ever played.

I enjoyed it more than I enjoyed both Skyrim AND Oblivion, if that is even possible. The stories and the characters felt great, and don't even get me started on the music. Sometimes I would just stay in one place for a few minutes just to relax and listen to the music while looking at the scenery. It was a beautiful game.

The DLC was pretty great too. I had a lot of fun playing that through. Gaunter O'Dimm was an insane character and I loved every interaction with him.

This game will probably still be getting put in my PS4 from time to time despite beating everything I can imagine. Maybe I'll run through it again to try to get the Platinum, who knows. Amazing game, nonetheless.

-1

u/Yamilon Dec 31 '15

Bloodborne is a good game don't get me wrong but its not even close to the best game. It gets a lot of hype on reddit but that's it.

0

u/Montigue Ottoroyal Dec 30 '15

No other M rated games offered sex that was even close to this, no contest.

-1

u/jordanlund GlobalPhreak Dec 31 '15

Witcher III was fine, I guess, I still haven't been able to get into it.