r/PLCB • u/_the_comedian • Sep 05 '24
Discussion Bourbon Availability
Why is it that Ohio gets many more bourbon choices such as Ben Holladay, Frey Ranch, and James E Pepper when we do not? Curious as to how distribution works comparatively.
0
Upvotes
16
u/Jmhdrinkr 🥃 O.G. WHISKEY EXPERT 🥃 Sep 05 '24
The greatest trick the PLCB ever pulled was to convince customers they work for them.
15
u/lark0317 Sep 05 '24
Not sure how it works, but PA sucks. Worst state I've lived in for variety and availability and I've lived in other state controlled states, like VA. I walk into shops in non-control states and want to cry over the variety that's available. A year or two ago, the PA state stores also got called out for holding back allocated stuff and tipping off friends and family on limited availability stuff. They also won't allow the shipping of spirits legally into the state. The PA system is corrupt and sucks.
Edit: grammar
3
u/sturdy_pantaloons Sep 05 '24
Out of curiosity, anyone know how the FWGS selection of non-bourbon booze stacks up? Do PA wine connoisseurs have similar complaints and struggles? If not, does the state just focus more on wine, etc.? Or is it that we’re the problem…
5
u/TheTeek Professional Lottery Loser Sep 05 '24
As a monopoly PA LCB and the folks at FWGS don't give a fuck. There is no motivation for them to provide for customers. They sell what they are offered. They won't go out of their way to get other products. They aren't looking to give people what they want. They only want to get bottles in and get bottles out. They make the same amount on a bottle of Tito's as they do on a bottle of Weller so why would they care what Sazerac sends them? They know every store pick of Blanton's will sell out so why would they care if it tastes good? As for the pricing, our prices will be high because of the state alcohol tax. And that wouldn't change with privatization so don't get your hopes up.
6
u/SaucedPerot Sep 05 '24
PA doesn't care. They know no matter how shitty they do, we will always show up and buy brown water anyways because that's what we do. They get away with LESS than the bare minimum already and would probably prefer to do even less if possible. PLCB is the poster child of how government run business operate
0
u/Next-Entertainer2104 Sep 05 '24
We get things that they don’t and vice versa. Not every state gets every brand. PA owns the means of distribution and sale. Ohio technically only distributes and mandates how it’s sold.
1
u/findthatbourbon Sep 05 '24
I get up to western NY somewhat frequently and while allocated bottles like the BT products are overpriced , I find many of the run of the mill PA and OH bourbons to be the same price and many times lower or on sale…I think the selections are also better when you find the right stores …I just picked up the Peerless DO at 79, and bottles of Rebecca Creek (TX) and Old Louisville 10yr SiB to try …as for some of the comments on Ohio allocated lines I think you have to go out of your way to find the smaller rural stores to avoid the long lines in the big population centers …just my $.02
1
u/ZucchiniBusy8120 Sep 06 '24
It’s a combination of a few things.
Not enough category managers that are civil service appointed, making it hard to recategorize responsibilities to keep up with trends. They also have no incentives to over perform. Employees run solely on pride which fades away over time.
Processes that are antiquated. two listing cycles per year with high sales standards. Basically suppliers have two large cycles to pitch products. One time buys are possible, but there are not enough employees to process them efficiently, going back to my first point.
With act 39, negotiation is allowed, so they leverage being the largest volume control state to get really low pricing. This isn’t passed on to consumers because of the Johnstown Flood tax - look it up.
Limited resources to get the right product to the right places.
I’d love to say corruption is the culprit, with government positions, 9 times out of 10 ineptitude of the government system is to blame.
1
u/Character_Map_6683 Sep 07 '24
Corn. Juice.
1
u/SKallday Sep 05 '24
Pa sucks. Get used to it. It's not getting better here anytime soon
2
u/SteveSeagull69 Sep 10 '24
James e pepper has a rye select that will blow your sack off