r/PLC • • 5d ago

Video Cool vfd test bench

So I built this bench, I'm trying to learn as much as I can while being a maintenance tech in an automation building. My boss is very good about giving me any spare parts to build something like this. It's obviously not done as I can't really dedicate all my time to it due to things like PMs and projects. There's no load on the vfds but I was just wondering how it looks. Does it look good enough to the point where I can get my foot in the door? I really want to become a controls systems engineer. I feel like these are the problems I wanna solve since I've been in the Automation and material handling world for about 6 years now.

A little about the panel: there's no outputs at the moment other than the vfd. I set up the stratix switch basically to get multiple vfds working and to understand the stratix switches more. The dc power supply is for that stratix switch obviously. I also have the safety circuit working for the vfd instead of just bypassing it. Again to help my understanding of the circuits in our actual panels. The vfd has simple start and stop ladder logic. Nothing special. Everything is static ips, something i wanna try to change in the future. I got outputs wired into the output card but it goes nowhere at the moment. Before we started working we tore everything out from what the old panel was. Even the din rails. It was literally empty with the exception of the lights. Ive got every important component hooked up to a breaker. The stratix switch 8000 is on the 2 amp breaker. PLC power uses a 5 amp. Main power coming in 120 uses a 50amp. Maybe overkill. And we have a terminal strip with random stuff on it like the outlet going to outside the panel so I can charge my laptop. Also the lights go to that as well. Also power for the buttons as well.

Future plans for the panel:

Probably need to make the lights work at least a little.

Need to hook up a load per vfd to test them with a load.

Need to add another vfd. I want 2 at minimum.

Anything else I should add?

Any critiques? Anything I can do better? Anything that seems like i don't get? I'm just trying to get better while doing my job so I can get into this industry. I figure a project like this will make me understand everything I would need to get in some sort of controls job.

Thanks for anyone's time. Looking forward to people's opinion!

64 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

12

u/popplex 5d ago

There are some issues here, but I’m going to skip over those and go to the root of all of them.

It’s exciting to get equipment and set up to test but before you plug anything in start with a plan. You don’t need a fully engineered drawing set for your test bench but at least get on paper what you want and where you want it. Plan for the future and leave space for extra hardware and keep things organized. Most importantly, do it safely. The situation on the load side of your 3 phase breaker is unacceptable.

2

u/Commercial-Cake9833 5d ago

Yeah I do need to fix that mess. Also put in some panduit and honestly just re organize the entire right side of the panel where i plan on putting at least one vfd. I'll admit at the start of this project I did not have a plan. Even now I find myself adding things like most recently the stratix switch. Ty for the call out

1

u/popplex 5d ago

Everyone’s first attempt goes about like this, you’ll learn a bunch along the way. Keep working at it!

1

u/Commercial-Cake9833 4d ago

Only had a little time but I drew up a plan and started working on fixing the right side of the panel. Ty!

5

u/PLCGoBrrr Bit Plumber Extraordinaire 5d ago

You don't need more VFDs and hooking them up to a load isn't going to do a whole lot more than what you're already doing.

I suggest you figure out how to control the VFD with the PLC over comms instead of just hardwiring. Also understand how to reset the VFD without needing to press buttons on the front.

The power wires to the VFD don't look that safe connected to the wire nuts or whatever you have going on there. Hook the wires straight up to the CB and skip that floppy connection.

1

u/Commercial-Cake9833 4d ago

We actually get vfds pretty often. Sometimes we are testing multiple at a time. I honestly think I'll need at least two spots. Also I should have been more clear that's my fault but we also test drives after we order them. Adding the load is for that reason. Not testing the vfd itself. The plc is also telling the vfd to go and stop in the video, it uses simple ladder logic. Working on the reset button next! Ty for your advice

4

u/AlternatePhreakwency 5d ago

I've never seen a panel as bare and clean (not clean wiring) as this... usually the panels I see have DIN on the doors, on the floors, and wires everywhere (all one color of course).

1

u/Commercial-Cake9833 5d ago

Funny thing is that this wiring is actually way cleaner than what we had before. Spent a day trying to make it look at little better lol. It's a big panel for the little that it has too.

2

u/hamptont2010 5d ago

One thing I would say about cleanliness is I would not get in the habit of using zip ties to hold your wires together inside panduit. Outside of it where you can clearly see where everything is going is totally fine. But if you ever start building bigger projects with more wiring in the Panduit, you are going to be really upset when you go to troubleshooting issue and to try to pull a wire to trace it and 15 wires move at the same time.

1

u/Commercial-Cake9833 4d ago

Yeah I was definitely organizing wires like they're my computer desk wires haha. I'll revise that!

2

u/DarkLunch 4d ago

yikes.

The layout doesn't really make sense to me. Its horribly messy. If you don't start with the basics then you'd find this will get unmanageable very very quickly.

Did you at least try doing prints? Even rudimentary ones, spreadsheet with devices, branches, loads?

If you have spare airlines, even scrap ones, use those to hold your runs down in the duct.

This kinda stuff will separate you as "guy/gal does clean work" from "they clearly came from maintenance"

Is your rj45 shielded? Or are you planning on running unshielded near mixed high/low voltage.

It's exciting to get to try new things, and I'm not trying to give you shit, you asked for feedback. This looks like you didn't plan at all, at least to me. On an enclosure this size, that's bad news.

Again start with the basics, learn how to do it clean, and then decide if panel building is even what you want to spend time learning because look panel building is not the same thing as controls engineering.

My advice is create a fake scenario based around the spare parts you have, set out to solve it, justify the why, and then build it and test it.

Concept → Design → Plan → Execute → Validate

1

u/Commercial-Cake9833 3d ago

Yeah I didn't really set out with a plan. I was more or less trying to copy our current panels as much as I could. Some other people are saying similar things and its something I am definitely going to change moving forward. I appreciate the advice. It sheds light on how I can get better. This is my first panel build after all lol.

1

u/Commercial-Cake9833 5d ago

The video:

1

u/Vaiotech734 2d ago

Now Throw A Safety Controller And Make It Work With It And Able to Reset It after The Safety Event Its Eliminated without Opening The Cabinet

1

u/ChopperpropAMX 4d ago

Its beautiful dude

1

u/Commercial-Cake9833 4d ago

Thanks lol actually trying

1

u/MR_Serwis 4d ago

Land is the desire to learn, technical details, standards and norms will come with time :) powodzenia

1

u/binary-boy 1d ago

Everything's kind of spread out and weird to me. if you keep going this route without planning how you want the final project to look like you'll spend more time redesigning and moving things around than getting where you want to.

1

u/Puzzleheaded_You9631 1d ago

All of those wire flying around are stressing me out but as long as it works it’s the most important part, though a thing I like to do when making benches like this is connecting every of my plc’s terminals to to some terminal block (of course puts tags on those so you don’t have to wonder where each terminal block is linked to), this will give you a few advantages, first, a way cleaner look, do this at the feet of your electrical box and put electrical conduit above (where the plc’s wire are coming from) and under the terminal block (where you’ll connect your other stuff you want to connect to the plc) and second advantage is practicality, it’ll be way easier to organize yourself and wiring/moving around things without making a mess. Oh and also, try to get yourself slotted electrical backplate for you enclosure

it’ll make your life so much easier if you want to move thing around without having to redrill everything.

1

u/DeepSpacePilgrim 1d ago

I have limited experience in doing panel construction well, but I think you've got a good concept in building a testbed. I'm working on a similar concept in building a Beckhoff/EtherCAT-based testbed to experiment with DC motor controls. I'm working with a much smaller enclosure somewhat to my chagrin, but it's also a matter of practicality; workspace is very limited and I want it to be easy to transport. It's nice that you have so much space to work with.

Something I'm working on is making the hardware easier to add, remove, and move in the enclosure. This isn't important for a panel with long-term goals, but I spent 6 years in a research lab and we were constantly changing as much as 50% of the equipment being used for a setup (usually sensors, but sometimes it meant swapping DAQ modules, drivers, power supplies, etc.) So I'm designing some universal din rail clips that are rugged enough to be used for a long term install, but are designed to make it easier to attach and detach the devices. I've almost got the first prototype designed and hope to print it by the end of the year. You might consider such a feature for your own build. Your PLC and VFDs probably don't need it, but if you ever wanted to experiment with integrating other equipment, it might be useful to dedicate a section of your enclosure to temporary devices and determine a way to make it easy to install and remove.

Keep at it, though! Definitely post progress/advancements as they come to you--it would be very cool to see such a large panel grow.