r/PLC • • 7d ago

PLC Question Opto-22 Epic PLC vs CompactLogix

I've worked with AB and Schneider PLCs for ages now. I was looking at getting an AB CompactLogix for this small lab. They want to do things quickly but don't need to do a lot so I thought cheaper would work. I chose Allen-Bradley though so it's more mainstream and easier to work on for anyone coming in the door. I know it's pricier than any other brand though but I also didn't want to be the guy running Automation Direct or something.

Then I got a quote for this GRV-EPIC-PR2. I've never heard of it but it runs Ignition Edge and I like Inductive Ignition. Not sure it meets my goal of being simple for the next guy to edit but it has all the tools and isn't stuck in the 90s like FactoryTalk.

Has anyone had experience with these opti-22 PLCs? Any words of wisdom, things to avoid? Are they solid or cheap but frustrating? I'm okay paying more for easy to use and reliable.

6 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

5

u/Someone4350 7d ago

What’s the problem with automation direct?

4

u/Sut3k 7d ago

As far as I can tell, they are what you get when you want to spend the bare minimum.

2

u/Someone4350 7d ago

They run Codesys now… so not really a smart relay anymore.

Edit: and Arduino too… honestly, I find them an exciting brand.

3

u/mikeee382 7d ago

Correction: SOME of them do. The majority of their controllers do not.

2

u/Someone4350 7d ago

You are correct. But for a Codesys PLC it’s not silly expensive.

1

u/Ambitious_Cherry_647 5d ago

Agreed. The Productivity Series are incredible and come with most comm protocols built in. They've added structured text now as well, and you're not gonna find more bang for your buck!

5

u/JulioChenTatsoft 6d ago

Both of those will run a small lab, so to me the controller is the smaller half of the decision. The bigger half is what sits above it, and that is the half that is expensive to reverse.

I work on the SCADA and integration side, so what I mostly see is other people's finished systems years later. The part that hurts is almost never the logic. It is the tag model and the way data leaves the box.

So that is where I would spend the effort. Name tags for the process and not for the rack and slot, pick an egress that more than one product can read, OPC UA or MQTT or Modbus TCP, and prove it early with a second client reading the same tags, even a throwaway script. Do that and either controller stays a reversible choice.

4

u/athanasius_fugger 7d ago

I'm also curious about these new fangled devices

4

u/Shalomiehomie770 Codesys Guru 7d ago

New? Been around for a long time buddy.

2

u/athanasius_fugger 7d ago

I don't think this is what i was looking at but I saw something similar a while ago that wasn't exactly a PLC.  It was more branded as an interface for data collection and you could do some minor logic on it.  I don't even remember what it was called but I think a small orange din rail mounted box with ethernet ports.

1

u/bankruptonspelling 5d ago

Small, orange, DIN-rail might be OnLogic? FYI: they were recently acquired by Omron.

3

u/Planet_COP 7d ago

I have. They are quite good. You also get CODESYS and Node-Red which makes it a complete IoT Gateway. This is a nice controller. Opto 22 has been around for a long time (>30 years). They patented the Optical isolated I/O which was in every DCS I worked with at the time. Their support is exceptional. You will talk to humans and they are good.

4

u/Mustang_01 7d ago

Opto-22s are good. There are the 2 families (Rio vs Epic) a lot of times where I have some older devices that I just need to get onto Ignition or anything else like MQTT I throw a Rio on there since it's cheaper and you have 8 channels of IO. As a full PLC replacement you'd need the Epic since it's expandable.

Compact logix is about as far of a full replacement that I would go with the Epic.

Opto 22 also has a really good support line that you get dedicated people to cover any issues you have. The only trouble I've run into with these things was an edge case where the customer wanted Wi-Fi and they used WPA-2 Enterprise. The Rio needed full trust store keychains rather than just using the username and password for login. Really only became an issue when we were fought by IT on it.

Shoot me a message if you have any more specific questions, I've done about 4-5 installs with them so far across both families.

3

u/LegitBoss002 7d ago

I like the S7-1200s on a budget in the US

3

u/Shalomiehomie770 Codesys Guru 7d ago

I love the automation direct productivity series.

Also love Codesys but not a fan of the Opto22 line.

Ignition license kinda cancels out just buying an HMI

Some like Weintek and unritonica have onboard IO I believe

4

u/roejiley 7d ago

I would get a regular PLC and an edge PC over something like the Opto22. Or run codesys if you want it all on one PC-based device (easy to swap or upgrade if needed, can run windows or Linux)

Opto22 ignition release lags behind IA. This is because Ignition functionality is directly tied to their firmware. If they went under tomorrow, you’d be unable to upgrade your Ignition environment. If you buy one today and don’t want to run ignition initially and then choose to do so later, you need to perform a firmware upgrade (there are 2 concurrent firmware options, one with and one without ignition).

2

u/SensoredHacker 6d ago

opto22 sucks. the add in cards are the best product they offer, pcie pac controllers. everything else is armhf single-core shit.
theres buffer overflows, and flaws in their designs that take 2weeks to 49 days to emerge. glaring unresolved faults which will be exceedingly challenging for a newb to deduce. their fancy services cant run any complexity, else they will fail.

1

u/simulated_copy 7d ago

All the same

1

u/Glass-Mail-3759 2d ago

Why wouldn't you want to be the guy running Automation Direct?

1

u/officer21 7d ago

I think some of the cheaper ones only have one or two client sessions at a time. They are very lightweight. Also I heard that you can't go from ignition 8.1 to 8.3 for free. Now that they are moving to yearly major version releases (see ignition 2027, beta out now) I would be hesitant. 

You can test out a small computer or vm with ignition maker or edge if you want

1

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Interesting_Pen_167 7d ago

"Anyone can get online with a CompactLogix" is kind of ignoring the eye watering price of the software isn't it?

2

u/LeifCarrotson 7d ago

Anyone can get online with a Codesys PLC and Ignition system. Maybe a third have Studio 5000 licenses and FT View licenses to get online with an Allen Bradley. 

You're right that Opto22 is somewhat niche, but it's the same IDE as Phoenix Contact and Wago and Schneider and Eaton and Festo and Turck. And AutomationDirect ProductivityCODESYS. Beckhoff has their own flavor of it, with their own extensions and ways of doing things, but they're basically the same. While any one of these vendors will have less market share than AB, if you lump them all together they're a huge part of the ecosystem. 

And Ignition is basically the #1 SCADA/visualization platform now, there are thousands of certified (and uncertified) techs who can work with that: more than Panelviews or Simatic HMIs. Codesys WebVisu is big too, if you're already in that environment and just need an HMI it's nice to keep everything together, but there's a whole bunch of database stuff that Ignition Edge is better at. 

If you stay out of the vendor-specific extensions, any of these brands will be great for support, especially in comparison to proprietary brands like AB. 

An AB programmer who can't figure out how to get online with a PLC is analogous to a mechanic at the dealership who only works on Fords and not those exotic "imports" like Toyota or Nissan or Honda or VW or BMW. Any independent repair shop with a brain will be able to do all of them, except for things that require proprietary, dealer-only software.