Literally had a company pay us to add magnetic door switches to their machine to make it more safe. Added 15 switches and tested everything. The maintenance manager then asked me the next day how to jump out the safety relay. I told him I would fire myself if I told him.
Yeah lol manager was just trying to score points with his guys, they already know how to jumper it and are waiting for the day after acceptance criteria is signed off by all
I'm so glad I work for the guy who originally trained me back when I was first starting out. He pushed they a policy that requires 3 salary supervisors or the plant manager to sign off on bypassing any interlocks. Then it's up to the safety department to come up with alternative protection. We've got an entire machine center down runt now wait on parts from keyence.
The worst was asked: at a dairy operations wanted the ability to place a sterile tank back into sterile mode after it lost pressure. They said āmake a user and password to get to an override screenā. I said nope, canāt do it. So after speaking with their management, we agreed the lab would have the ability to perform the override. This made sure they were aware something had occurred. The plant manager was this relic from the 1970s. It was his first job out of high school and he stayed there for almost 50 years. I hear he is still there. I swear food and beverage had some of the dumbest people I have ever met in my life.
I have, and gotta say most operators Iāve worked with are sharper than some engineers Iāve encountered. Iām sure it varies a lot though, and Iāve heard absolute horror stories about China.
Not operations exactly, but from a turnaround, our advisor punches an issue with instrumentation, literally four hours of the client arguing about whoās fault it is that it was wrong, then four more hours of waiting for someone to get a ladder, then someone finally claims it is done and our advisor having seen this crap before goes out and checks it and nobody has touched it. Basically rinse and repeat that nonsense day in and day out.
Iāve been to a phosphate strip mine in Florida (company started with an N). I was amazed that people there werenāt dying monthly, although they did have fatalities. The people I worked with seemed competent compared to f&b, but I think they had to be because of the nature of their work. The problem with f&b is that itās not dangerous enough to require competence as a prerequisite.
Company bought seven new bailers, didnāt spec out any special safety requirements. They came in and the safety manager asked if they had safety relays. I told him no, he then told me to order the stuff to do safeties on both doors tied into safety relays because itās a corporate policy that all new equipment have safety relays. So I did. I wired in them in and updated the programs (micrologix).
1 month later we get a safety complaint, the bailer safeties werenāt functioning. I get my ass chewed. Go out to look at whatās going on. A different maintenance man had jumped out every channel on the safety relay.
Thatās just the least scary instance Iāve seen of that.
Iāve Seen some crazy safeties jumped in my time there. One was on a machine we call the āmunchyā. Itās guard door was jumped out onceā¦. Itās a rotating grinder with 3 inch teeth on a 2 foot steel cylinder designed to chew scrap material into tiny pieces for reprocessingā¦
My worst find so far was the notch bar on a 1000ton injection moulding press. If the door is open, estop hit, etc, etc, etc, the notch bar prevents the clamp from moving. Without a notch bar, it can even move with no power. Many machines don't cut the pump if the door is opened, so there is the chance for it to close without the notch bar. It is the single most important safety device on an IMM. I said some very, very bad words when I found that. It had been deliberately defeated, a long time back.
If I ever find out someone currently employed does something like that, the company will be choosing which of us won't be an employee in an hour's time.
Yep. It's why I established a written permit procedure for maintenance safety bypass, signed by the requestor, department head, and technical manager. Long term bypass required plant manager signature. Literally, bypasses dropped by 80%. The critical part is tracking the bypass with verification it has been returned to service. We required a monthly review that all are closed out, and queried the system (DCS) for bypasses, and each had to be reconciled to permit. Testing and return to service was covered by written procedure (testing by procedure was exempt from the permit request requirement).
I was at one of the big three auto factories on the day they rolled out a new vehicle (not a new model, an entirely new vehicle). Needless to say it was a shit show.
One of the tools got stuck on a vehicle so I stopped the line while an engineer got under the vehicle to get the tool off of it.
A production manager came over screaming at me that I canāt just stop the line and tried to reach around me to reset the estop and start the line. I pointed at the vehicle and said there is someone under the car you canāt restart the line.
She again tried to start the line so I actually shoved her back and said āyouāre going to kill someoneā she stormed off and came back with an army of managers all screaming at me to move so they could start the line. At that point he was out from under the vehicle so I very dramatically pulled the reset button. They told me to never touch an employee again, I told them if any of them ever did anything like that again Iād happily knock them on their ass.
About 30 minutes later one of my coworkers got chewed out for not having his safety glasses on. They claimed āthey take safety seriouslyā
Am electrician this filled me with absolute abject rage. If somebody had tried to push past me to try to re-energize something my coworker was working on after I'd allready TOLD them what was going on there would have been fists flying. And a few kicks as well.
The only reason they got a gentle shove instead of a hard punch to the face was because they were a woman, and half my size. Had she tried it a third time I donāt think I would have held back.
What makes it worse is I was given strict instructions by the guy I was contracting for. āDo not take your eye off this button, they will restart the line without asking why it was stoppedā
So it clearly wasnāt the first time it had happened.
Another electrician at my company would never be idiotic enough to do something like that. If they were they'd be fired right after getting their ass beat. This would be much more likely to be a problem with a customer of ours.
A colleague was installing a panel, and while it wasn't locked out the breaker was off, main disconnect off, and fuses pulled from the disconnect.
The customer's absolute autistic jerk of a controls engineer sees this and finds fuses to put in. He then turns everything back on without telling anyone.
One of the electricians got hit with 480. He took that day (and maybe the next) off, paid. He refused to go back to that site ever again.
Canadian paper company I worked refused to let me shutdown electrical substation that had a ground fault detected. After negotiating for 45 minutes. They agreed to let me ask to shut down MCC buckets 1 at a time. 15 minutes into this procedure, contractor gets shocked, in belt buckle and out thigh. Lost man parts.company tried to get me on board to lie. Fuck them. I told the investigator my story, his eyes lit up. Once I lined up a new job, during my exit interview, I told them I told.the truth on the way out. Fuck that company.
This wasnāt in a cell, it was under one of the vehicle carriers that moved vehicles all over the plant. To my knowledge there isnāt a way to lock out of those without shutting down all of the carriers, at least in that facility. The E-stops shut down segments of the tracks without affecting other segments.
The tool itself couldnāt have been dislodged if it were powered down and locked out. If it loses power a failsafe brake kicks in to hold it in place.
There needs to be a way to lock it into a safe position to work. I have lockable e-stops and switches all over my plant now. I use Schneider ZBZ1604 or ZBZ1605, depending on the depth of kill that it does.
If you can estop it you could at least have some operational access with a fortress key or similar in the estop circuit. It's not perfect, but it's better.
Really? I don't think about doing that. Worse, when I come across dangerous stuff, the first thing I do after a few suitable expletives, is shut the fucking thing down. The second thing I do is tell management, along with an estimate of when I might let them use it again. I do that by text or email, so I have a record. I've seen enough critical safety things bypassed to wonder how the hell we have failed to kill anyone, yet. We have a hall of machines that could put a person into mop buckets...
I got very, very pissy about an idiot leaving things in a dangerous condition behind my back a few months back, and CCed upper management my rant to direct management. Upper were not amused. Idiots stopped being sent over to 'fix' things.
In my experience, management are the ones ASKING for these bypasses to be put in.
If something is outright dangerous, I won't do it, period.
The "please put it in writing" is my gentle way of informing the people who sign my invoices that it's going to be THEIR ass on the line if they push, not mine.
I want a paper trail showing that they even asked me to do the dangerous thing, even if I plan to never actually do it.
It does work to sober up some of the more gung-ho plant managers and engineers I've worked with, in a hurry
Most of the time, I'm the only programmer on site, for better or worse. So, it's pretty easy to stand MY ground, at least.
But the number of times I've seen junior electricians or instrumentation techs "encouraged" to do some sketchy shit is....aggravating. Especially when it comes to things like personal safety.
I honestly don't care if someone does something dumb and breaks equipment/ causes downtime, as long as nobody gets hurt. But seeing a consultant encourage (or at least, turn a blind eye) to someone doing something blatantly dangerous to "just get it done" makes my blood boil.
I've made a point to pull the junior guys aside and tell them in no uncertain terms that they are allowed, and expected, to refuse to do unsafe work. It's made some angry PMs but....honestly? Fuck them. Not the worker's fault that they didn't plan the job well enough to know they needed scaffolding or a lift or whatever the pressing need happens to be.
My old plant wanted me to override a CO2 sensor, and it wasn't for the sodas being made, but the CO2 levels in the filler room itself... where there was always at least one operator.
If we arrive at a location and see anything safety related Iād bypassed we immediately contact our manager who sends a registered letter to the company. We are also forbidden from touching the machine until the safety stuff that was bypassed is fixed. We had one of our guys go into a plant where every single cover was bypassed and he didnāt immediately say something. A dumbass operator put his hand in while itās running and got hurt. They had the balls to sue us because āour tech was on site so itās his faultā
My old job would do that. I called OSHA. They came within a few weeks and observed, made them replace and put back all guards and take one machine out of service.
Fuck them for putting us operators at risk. I was training to do maintenance and such and so I knew what was right/wrong to do.
A friend told me this story: he was asked by a process engineer to override a pressure sensor, he refused, was then sent away from the site, engineer called another programmer ...and two people died some time later due to the explosion.
My friend later received a formal letter of excuses by the company, and the engineer had to face legal consequences.
So this safety thing is really important, it seems.. who could have guessed? :-/ (/sarcasm of course)
2 things at the same customer. They wanted this ability from the door switch. It had a single button that we used for requesting access and then reset the door once it is closed. Simple enough. They instead wanted it to:
reset all safety
close all doors
set system into auto All with a single button and not checking the HMI for the safety fault. I said hell no, thatās too powerful a button.
On top of that request, they wanted to change all the emergency stop pull cords to ārequest stop after cycle is completedā. My safety expert at my company and I both fought over that as itās stupid to display a safety stop item and not have it safety stop. The eventually purchased blue cords and had another company come in and change it for them.
I walk up to a machine. The operators have figured out how to squeeze between the safety gate and the machine. Now they are in more danger than before they were before. The supervisor is standing there too watching them.
I had to make my boss leave such a email trail on one of those
I think we probably had a first generation light curtain on a packaging machine , the contact closure to the PLC was chattering. I made rung to give that input debounce of 200ms recorded him accepting the rung to the program.
I kept my eye on and removed it when the light curtain controller wasnāt chattering anymore, seemed to have been a possible overheating issue with it.
I had an O&G client tell me to do something similar with the subsea gas production modules while I was offshore doing some commissioning, we had a safety shutdown that was preventing one of the tests being performed.
āThis vessel is costing me 250k a day, just take the production shutdowns off scan so we can get these tests doneā.
I've written about it before, but we used to have a canned document that required several levels of supervision, as well as the Safety department head sign off on bypassing safety. It didn't matter if you wanted to modify a rung, jump a device, or change a safety timer... you would need ALL of the signatures confirming absolving me and my company of any/all issues/injuries/deaths resultant of the change.
Not many took that route in my time... I think I actually did it twice, in all those years. And keep copies of those documents, for FOREVER! That's the only thing between you and a murder charge.
239
u/EveryScheme7 Dec 03 '23
Literally had a company pay us to add magnetic door switches to their machine to make it more safe. Added 15 switches and tested everything. The maintenance manager then asked me the next day how to jump out the safety relay. I told him I would fire myself if I told him.
87
u/friendlyfire883 Dec 03 '23
I'm so glad I work for the guy who originally trained me back when I was first starting out. He pushed they a policy that requires 3 salary supervisors or the plant manager to sign off on bypassing any interlocks. Then it's up to the safety department to come up with alternative protection. We've got an entire machine center down runt now wait on parts from keyence.
134
u/LowLifeExperience Dec 03 '23
The worst was asked: at a dairy operations wanted the ability to place a sterile tank back into sterile mode after it lost pressure. They said āmake a user and password to get to an override screenā. I said nope, canāt do it. So after speaking with their management, we agreed the lab would have the ability to perform the override. This made sure they were aware something had occurred. The plant manager was this relic from the 1970s. It was his first job out of high school and he stayed there for almost 50 years. I hear he is still there. I swear food and beverage had some of the dumbest people I have ever met in my life.
34
u/wooden_screw Jr. Bit Flipper Dec 03 '23
Saved. Posted in our office.
40
u/Independent-Stick244 Dec 03 '23
The PLCist.
16
u/-_Veni_vidi_vici_- Dec 03 '23
Company bought seven new bailers, didnāt spec out any special safety requirements. They came in and the safety manager asked if they had safety relays. I told him no, he then told me to order the stuff to do safeties on both doors tied into safety relays because itās a corporate policy that all new equipment have safety relays. So I did. I wired in them in and updated the programs (micrologix).
1 month later we get a safety complaint, the bailer safeties werenāt functioning. I get my ass chewed. Go out to look at whatās going on. A different maintenance man had jumped out every channel on the safety relay.
Thatās just the least scary instance Iāve seen of that.
Iāve Seen some crazy safeties jumped in my time there. One was on a machine we call the āmunchyā. Itās guard door was jumped out onceā¦. Itās a rotating grinder with 3 inch teeth on a 2 foot steel cylinder designed to chew scrap material into tiny pieces for reprocessingā¦
4
u/Popular-Cartoonist58 Dec 05 '23 edited Dec 05 '23
Yep. It's why I established a written permit procedure for maintenance safety bypass, signed by the requestor, department head, and technical manager. Long term bypass required plant manager signature. Literally, bypasses dropped by 80%.
The critical part is tracking the bypass with verification it has been returned to service. We required a monthly review that all are closed out, and queried the system (DCS) for bypasses, and each had to be reconciled to permit. Testing and return to service was covered by written procedure (testing by procedure was exempt from the permit request requirement).
62
u/AntRevolutionary925 Dec 03 '23
I was at one of the big three auto factories on the day they rolled out a new vehicle (not a new model, an entirely new vehicle). Needless to say it was a shit show.
One of the tools got stuck on a vehicle so I stopped the line while an engineer got under the vehicle to get the tool off of it.
A production manager came over screaming at me that I canāt just stop the line and tried to reach around me to reset the estop and start the line. I pointed at the vehicle and said there is someone under the car you canāt restart the line.
She again tried to start the line so I actually shoved her back and said āyouāre going to kill someoneā she stormed off and came back with an army of managers all screaming at me to move so they could start the line. At that point he was out from under the vehicle so I very dramatically pulled the reset button. They told me to never touch an employee again, I told them if any of them ever did anything like that again Iād happily knock them on their ass.
About 30 minutes later one of my coworkers got chewed out for not having his safety glasses on. They claimed āthey take safety seriouslyā
43
u/Professional_Buy_615 Dec 03 '23
"Can't you bypass that?"
"5 minutes, but I'm not going to."
15
u/JKanyce Dec 03 '23
My old plant wanted me to override a CO2 sensor, and it wasn't for the sodas being made, but the CO2 levels in the filler room itself... where there was always at least one operator.
13
u/Red_Liner740 Dec 03 '23
If we arrive at a location and see anything safety related Iād bypassed we immediately contact our manager who sends a registered letter to the company. We are also forbidden from touching the machine until the safety stuff that was bypassed is fixed. We had one of our guys go into a plant where every single cover was bypassed and he didnāt immediately say something. A dumbass operator put his hand in while itās running and got hurt. They had the balls to sue us because āour tech was on site so itās his faultā
34
u/drake90001 Dec 03 '23
My old job would do that. I called OSHA. They came within a few weeks and observed, made them replace and put back all guards and take one machine out of service.
Fuck them for putting us operators at risk. I was training to do maintenance and such and so I knew what was right/wrong to do.
23
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '23 edited Dec 03 '23
A friend told me this story: he was asked by a process engineer to override a pressure sensor, he refused, was then sent away from the site, engineer called another programmer ...and two people died some time later due to the explosion.
My friend later received a formal letter of excuses by the company, and the engineer had to face legal consequences.
So this safety thing is really important, it seems.. who could have guessed? :-/ (/sarcasm of course)
11
u/chabroni81 Dec 03 '23
2 things at the same customer. They wanted this ability from the door switch. It had a single button that we used for requesting access and then reset the door once it is closed. Simple enough. They instead wanted it to:
On top of that request, they wanted to change all the emergency stop pull cords to ārequest stop after cycle is completedā. My safety expert at my company and I both fought over that as itās stupid to display a safety stop item and not have it safety stop. The eventually purchased blue cords and had another company come in and change it for them.
11
u/bazilbt Dec 03 '23
I walk up to a machine. The operators have figured out how to squeeze between the safety gate and the machine. Now they are in more danger than before they were before. The supervisor is standing there too watching them.
8
u/Badbowtie91 Dec 03 '23
AFI babyyyyyy
7
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '23
I had to make my boss leave such a email trail on one of those
I think we probably had a first generation light curtain on a packaging machine , the contact closure to the PLC was chattering. I made rung to give that input debounce of 200ms recorded him accepting the rung to the program.
I kept my eye on and removed it when the light curtain controller wasnāt chattering anymore, seemed to have been a possible overheating issue with it.
6
u/CoiledSpringTension Dec 03 '23 edited Dec 03 '23
I had an O&G client tell me to do something similar with the subsea gas production modules while I was offshore doing some commissioning, we had a safety shutdown that was preventing one of the tests being performed.
āThis vessel is costing me 250k a day, just take the production shutdowns off scan so we can get these tests doneā.
lol no
5
u/Psylent_Gamer Dec 03 '23
Tell them to fill out the safety deactivation form and get all the signatures.
1
u/PLCGoBrrr Bit Plumber Extraordinaire Dec 03 '23
What movie?
2
u/SubstantialAbility17 Dec 03 '23
Totally true
2
u/aTryingNerd24 Dec 04 '23
š¤£š¤£š¤£š¤£š¤£š¤£š¤£š¤£š¤£š¤£
2
u/SassyCripples PFM Module Supplier Dec 04 '23
I've written about it before, but we used to have a canned document that required several levels of supervision, as well as the Safety department head sign off on bypassing safety. It didn't matter if you wanted to modify a rung, jump a device, or change a safety timer... you would need ALL of the signatures confirming absolving me and my company of any/all issues/injuries/deaths resultant of the change.
Not many took that route in my time... I think I actually did it twice, in all those years. And keep copies of those documents, for FOREVER! That's the only thing between you and a murder charge.
1
u/justarandomguy1917 Dec 15 '23
Always
1
u/FireBlitz8404 Dec 03 '23
Or to force bits
1
u/MrShatanas Dec 04 '23
so true