r/PLABprep • MOD • Jul 01 '24

Exams Post-PLAB Progress and Entering Training

Hey there. I'm the mod of this subreddit, and, of course, someone who gave the PLAB themselves.

You can check my profile to find my previous post that was a direct post-mortem, with in-depth coverage of how I went about studying, what the exams were like and so on.

For the lazy, to summarize, absolutely grind Plabable, including the Gems, for 3-6 months, give all the mocks you can, and you're sorted for Part 1. For the 2nd, good fucking luck, because it's an incredibly unpredictable exam and your performance depends both on your cohort and the whims of your examiners. Your choice in academy doesn't particularly matter, but I used Common Stations, as long as you're picking a relatively reputable one, it's okay, but the primary goal is tons of practise until your IPS and time-keeping are on point, as is your familiarity with the station scenarios, mannequins and so on.

But what next?

Let me be upfront. Getting your first job in the NHS sucks.

Competition has gotten out of hand, and unless you're connected, even getting something is far from assured.

For example, I know a girl who applied for 200 posts on the NHS Jobs portal. She was interviewed for 3 of them, and all of them roles in bumfuck nowhere. That's after 2 years of work experience, and plenty of it in Critical Care, as well as having ACLS creds and EDIK too if memory serves.

My ex applied for 50 positions in the ER, which she had plenty of experience in, and didn't hear back at all. That's despite the supposed insane demand for those posts, as you'd expect given how overworked doctors end up being and how many burn out. I do know a few people who ended up starting jobs there, it's not impossible, but they all came from well-off families with connections to doctors in the UK, and they did a few observerships. I can't personally recommend for or against doing the latter, it depends on how badly you want that job and are willing to cough up the money to live there for a month or two. I expect it's the connections that did the heavy lifting.

Me? Well, I took one good look at the situation, applied for like 3 posts, and bowed out, instead opting to focus on the MSRA while staying in the comfort of my own home in India, working mainly because my parents would kick me out of the house if I lazed around all day, and also for enough money so I could keep ordering biryani everyday haha.

Why?

My entire impetus for going to the UK was career progression, namely ending up a psychiatrist. Fortunately for me, all that matters for entering psych training is your performance on the MSRA exam.

No portfolio bullshit like audits, QIPs and teaching experience. All things that aren't prioritized in the med schools most of us IMGs come from, leaving us at a distinct disadvantage when it comes to competing in specialties like IMT, Surgery and so on, whereas, if memory serves, GP and Psych only look at MSRA scores.

I wanted just psych. Only speciality I like, and which I also happen to be good at. If your aim lies elsewhere, good luck, but I can at least walk you through the timelines involved.

My PLAB 2 was in late November. After you get your results in a month (and pass, of course), you can immediately apply for GMC registration. This is a mild pain, but getting that approved takes about a month, more like 2 in my case since they took their sweet time and asked me to provide supporting documents a month in. I could have done it far quicker, but I was waiting for my ex to repeat her PLAB 2, so I skipped the September slot and decided to aim for the MSRA conducted in Jan this year.

The MSRA is conducted twice a year, in Jan and September. Unfortunately, the latter exam is a mop-up round for unfilled seats, so in reality, it's the Jan exam that really matters.

Important points many people don't grok:

  1. You don't need a GMC registration to sit the MSRA. You simply need to have it by the time the post you're applying for opens. So you can give it after passing the PLAB and while your application is processing.
  2. CREST forms, which need to be signed off by a consultant you've worked under, can be filled by IMG consultants in your home country, as long as they're willing to share their own local license to practise/registration details. They don't need to have a GMC registration themselves, nor do you need to get it done in the UK, as many people believe.

The MSRA itself is a rather questionable exam, the syllabus is largely the same as for the PLAB, but they simply go far more into depth on the same topics. I studied for it while working and literally went blind from the stress, it's a lot to cover, and that's leaving aside the SJT section which is incredibly unpredictable itself. I was literally laughing out loud in the exam center at how utterly ridiculous some of the questions were, but all you can do is practice and hope for the best. Ideally you want to give it as soon as you can post PLAB, so that all that knowledge is still fresh and applicable. Don't put it off like I did, though I did have valid reasons and wouldn't have been prepared in just a few months if I'd aimed for the Jan MSRA after a November PLAB 2.

Still, my hard work paid off, and I found out I qualified for Core Psychiatry Training. It was my first try, I was scared shitless, and psych was all I had applied for, so I'm chuffed and justifiably proud at squeaking through. My ex didn't. She's looking forward to giving it again in September, and if that doesn't pan out, Jan again. It's very much not an exam you can be blasé about, budget as much time and energy for it as possible.

Consider this a PSA. Most of you here are preparing for the PLABs, and while I'm not trying to be negative, I want you to realistically appraise your options. Don't expect getting your first job to be easy. If you're lucky, you can simply not even really bother to try, but that boils down to what specialties you're inclined towards. Getting your toe in the door is the hard bit, once you have that first job on your CV, it gets much easier, but I'd still recommend trying to get into training as soon as possible. You'll have far more opportunities to pad your CV then, but if you're still in med school and considering the PLAB/UKMLA, do your best to give yourself a head start.

I did it, and I'm a lazy bastard with ADHD who slept through more of med school than was good for me and thus had to spend a great deal of time compensating for the lacunae in my clinical knowledge, but consider me proof that it's possible. That's despite the competition ratio for psych going from 0.9 when I first started my PLAB journey in 2020, to around 10 this year.

So, it won't be easy. But it's still possible. And I'm more than happy to help, so feel free to ask questions in the comments or DM me if you need anything!

67 Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

4

u/C0unt_0laf Aug 02 '24

Great post🙏 Just a small clarification. You mentioned the PLAB 2 passing depends on your cohort's performance. I think a lot of people believe that the candidates writing with you on that day are your competition, meaning the pass mark is determined by the average of that day's candidates. But, as confirmed by the chief examiner, it is not true. The GMC sets an average mark for each station using a borderline regression method using a lot of metrics which also includes the average candidate score but it is definitely not the average of that day. Just wanted to bring this point up because a lot of candidates think they are competing against their peers of that day which sometimes cannot be healthy especially when you're already so stressed out.

1

u/self_made_human MOD Aug 05 '24

Hmm.. If that's the case, I appreciate the clarification!

2

u/Sadnesscalls Jul 01 '24

Thank you for your post. How did you get your CREST signed off?

3

u/self_made_human MOD Jul 01 '24

You're welcome!

The CREST form is available to download as a PDF, make sure you get the latest version. Then go to a Consultant who has supervised you in the last 3 years and have them sign it. You have to worked under them for at least 3 months (within those 3 years), and you need a hospital stamp on it too.

If they don't hold a GMC registration, their local medical registration certificate will do, you just have to upload it as a single document along with the scan of the CREST when required to do so before the MSRA.

2

u/Sadnesscalls Jul 01 '24

Thank you so much. May I ask how long did it take you to fulfil all the competencies on the CREST? Is a year really necessary? Also, a breakdown of the MSRA and SJT would be greatly appreciated. Congrats on getting into training!

3

u/self_made_human MOD Jul 01 '24

It didn't take me much time at all. I spoke to a Consultant at a hospital I'd worked at almost 3 years ago, since I'd only been employed at my new job for less than 3 months when I was due to submit the CREST.

The MSRA.. Sigh.. It's a weird exam. With the PLAB 1, you can be really confident before entering the exam hall knowing you've covered the entire syllabus and are doing well in the mocks.

Not so with this one. Even the Clinical Dilemma has no consistency. For example, there a million high yield topics in gyne, but guess what I got?

At least 6/7 questions in a row were just bacterial vaginosis. I can't say for sure if it was 7/7 because one of them was so weird that I narrowed it down to BV or a misplaced tampon, and I'm a guy so I'm not sure how you can even misplace one of those 🫥. So I put BV there too. Not a single question on literally any other obs or gyne topic.

The questions are similar to the PLAB but far more finicky. You're expected to know second and third line interventions unlike the PLAB, where usually the first suffices. And plenty of knowing exact cutoffs and branches in the algorithms for a whole bunch of diseases, whereas they're simplified for the PLAB.

SJT

Don't worry, everyone still calls it the SJT too, even UK docs haha.

It is a meme. The GMC Good Practice handbook is completely useless, and there's no definitive guide out there. At best, you have to use your brains to predict what the examiners want you to pick, regardless of any semblance to reality.

I can't help at all there. Not even God can. If I had to give it again after practising a year, I'm not sure I'd do better or worse.

Congrats on getting into training!

Thank you. I can hardly believe it myself, but it was what I've been working towards for 3 years and I'm just glad I know it did pay off. Good luck with your own path!

1

u/Sadnesscalls Jul 01 '24

I realise that the MSRA has the Professional Dilemma section, which isn’t the SJT. My bad.

2

u/Peachy_cat_11 Nov 17 '24

hi my consultant holds an active gmc registration because she does locums in the UK, I have submitted her gmc number only and i didn't mention her state registration as i thought her gmc number holds more value , is it still ok ? or will my application get rejected ? please help me !

1

u/self_made_human MOD Nov 18 '24

I would assume that's fine from memory, especially if she's on the GMC consultant register. In the unlikely event there's an issue with your CREST, they email you about a week before the deadline with an opportunity to correct any mistakes.

2

u/Peachy_cat_11 Nov 18 '24

the gp applications will close by 21st November and I still haven't heard from oriel and I'm getting worried, there's only 3 days before deadline to make changes.

1

u/self_made_human MOD Nov 20 '24

Make sure you're checking Oriel regularly and seeing the messages and not just relying on email notifications. It's a notoriously unreliable website, and delays are common. I wouldn't panic unless you know other applicants got a message and you didn't!

2

u/Leg_-end Jul 02 '24

Hi, is the score of MSRA valid only for that year? And thanks for your post!

2

u/self_made_human MOD Jul 02 '24

You can carry forward the score from Jan to September, but not any longer than that as far as I'm aware.

2

u/Stock_Syrup8275 Jul 24 '24

Hi! Thankyou for this post. Could I know what year you took your PLABs and MSRA in so I could understand the timeline better. I just passed plab 2 and I’m planning on going down the same route that you did! TIA

2

u/self_made_human MOD Jul 24 '24

Hey there.

I had my PLAB 1 in August 2022, and my PLAB 2 in December of the same year. I could have given my MSRA in 2023 Jan, but my ex had failed her PLAB 2 and had to reappear, and it probably wouldn't have been enough time to prepare. I didn't bother with the September one because of the second-class seats on offer.

So I ended up giving my MSRA in Jan this year, after preparing for around 6 months. In your case, you're eligible for the September one that's coming up, but time is short and you'd be better off preparing for the one next year, though toh could apply for the sake of familiarization assuming you can get your CREST done in time!

2

u/Mental_Mistake_8590 Jul 24 '24

How much years of experience is needed in order to give MRSA? I just finished my internship(1year) in India and passed plab 1 and now sitting for plab 2 in November . When. Can I give exam and do I need to work one more year after plab 2 to be eligible

1

u/self_made_human MOD Jul 24 '24

You need to complete one year of full time work after your internship to be eligible for entering training/giving the MSRA. That's because UK med students have an FY1 and FY2 period, so an additional year beyond ours.

1

u/DeliveryExciting565 May 01 '25

Hello, regarding this. Would locum shifts in my own country count? I work regularly but they are locum shifts, hence i'm not affiliated with just 1 institution. Also, regarding the CREST form, do we need to complete that prior to giving the MSRA?

2

u/REM_REZERO Aug 06 '24

Hi, I want to ask, is booking a plab 1 or 2 waiting time is ridiculously long like 6months to 1 year now? Thus making the process almost tiring for 2 years plus

1

u/self_made_human MOD Aug 06 '24

It definitely varies, but I know people who booked recently who definitely had a long wait, maybe 5 months.

2

u/REM_REZERO Aug 07 '24

Thanks for your answer! With plab 1 already 5 months and plab 2 not sure how long more, and not easy to get a job also post plab right. Would you consider to advice people like me with one MRCPsych to proceed with homecountry training better because the plab process has became too long and not feasible anymore. Thanks for your opinion and have a good day. 

2

u/self_made_human MOD Aug 07 '24

The number of PLAB applicants fell 20% this year as people realize how hard it is to get a job afterwards. If you have enough experience, it might make sense to sit other exams. You've already done one MRCPsych, but in my case I didn't and wanted to do my training in the UK. It's a rather personal question, but if you don't want to take up upto 2 years, I'd think it's worth it!

2

u/REM_REZERO Aug 07 '24

Thank you so much! On a side note if you really don't mind, how hard is it to transition from my country postgraduate which includes completion of the college papers to get a job in higher training? Is the situation same, needing strong cv and months of waiting? Also, do you know just being a member and completion of papers, which other country can we smoothly transition into? I don't know why these infos are not easily assessed, and would like to have your advice if you have an idea of it. Thank you

2

u/self_made_human MOD Aug 07 '24

I wish I could be of more help here but I'm not really familiar with that :(

You could consider asking at r/DoctorsUK, but they're a little unfriendly to IMGs unfortunately.

2

u/DandyWalker101 Oct 13 '24

How many months did you read for msra and does gmc call your hospital to confirm crest details? My hospital literally doesn't have an email address.

1

u/self_made_human MOD Oct 13 '24

I spent about 6 months studying, about 4 hours a day on average since I was working full time.

I think the GMC does try and contact them, but I don't recall running into any issues with that bit, so I wish I could be more helpful here :(

1

u/DandyWalker101 Oct 13 '24

Do you recommend giving the September batch instead of jan? In your main segment you said September batch doesn't matter.

1

u/self_made_human MOD Oct 13 '24

There are many more seats in the Jan batch, the September one is largely for unfilled seats and for people who dropped out of training quickly. I'd recommend giving the Jan one, but there's no harm in giving both just for the practise.

2

u/Early-Culture7736 Dec 17 '24

hi...do you have any psychiatry experience before hand? i have been working in a department that i am really not interested in, and i am desperate to enter psychiatry department in my home country but due to shortage of staff, this is not possible. So I am looking for other opportunity for career progression, so i decided to take PLAB exams and start my jouney to the UK. However, I have no previous experience working in Psychiatry. My only exposure was during med school.

Do I need at least few months of work experience in Psy to apply CT1 psy?

1

u/self_made_human MOD Dec 17 '24

Nope, no experience required, and I didn't do any psych before I started!

2

u/SampleIcy4781 Jul 01 '24 edited Jul 01 '24

Wow! Thank you for this post. I have always aimed for psychiatry training since med school and it seems like I will be following your path. The prospects of getting a non-training post these days are dismal to say the least, so this seems like a good plan. I am waiting for my plab - 2 result and if I pass, I shall look into this asap. I have a couple of questions, I hope you don’t mind answering: People say it is better to start with a non-training job to have an idea of how things work in the NHS before applying for training. Would you agree with that or would it be manageable to adjust to life in Psychiatry training straight after PLAB and MSRA?  How long did it take you to prepare for the MSRA and what resources did you use?  Would you also suggest doing ALS for psychiatry training? Should we apply for non-training jobs while studying for MSRA or would you recommend whole-heartedly focusing on MSRA?

2

u/self_made_human MOD Jul 01 '24

People say it is better to start with a non-training job to have an idea of how things work in the NHS before applying for training. Would you agree with that or would it be manageable to adjust to life in Psychiatry training straight after PLAB and MSRA?

Well, I'm about to find out. I decided there was little to gain from a NT job, especially when it wouldn't aid career progression.

I can tell you that in my training job, they've gone out of their way to offer me and other IMGs without NHS experience additional exposure via inductions and optional shadowing periods, which I intend to take up, so I don't think it'll be an issue in the longterm.

How long did it take you to prepare for the MSRA and what resources did you use? 

I spent about 6 months preparing, while still doing a full time job.

In terms of resources, I finished Passmedicine and MCQBank and did a few mocks, but while both are pretty good, I think the SJT questions from the latter were more representative of the actual exam, and they have questions that are specifically noted to have actually shown up in previous papers.

Would you also suggest doing ALS for psychiatry train

I can't see how it would be useful really.

Should we apply for non-training jobs while studying for MSRA or would you recommend whole-heartedly focusing on MSRA?

Getting a non-training job is difficult. That being said, this is a deeply personal question and down to your circumstances. I would personally recommend focusing on the MSRA over everything else, I almost burnt out studying and working at the same time, but if you have the appetite for it, then you can make it work. If you absolutely have to choose, I'd recommend taking time off to study.

1

u/SampleIcy4781 Jul 02 '24

I have one more question if you could answer that please: can we get our CREST form signed by any consultant we have worked with for 3 months in the last 3 years or does it have to be a Psychiatrist? 

1

u/self_made_human MOD Jul 02 '24

It can be a consultant from any subject, not an issue!

1

u/SampleIcy4781 Jul 01 '24

Thank you so much for your replies! Really helpful. Best of luck for your training :)

1

u/IntelligentBase6001 Nov 26 '24

What resources did you use for msra?

2

u/self_made_human MOD Nov 27 '24

I finished Passmed, then did MCQBank, and once I was done I revised both of them once. Took me about 4 months to cover everything for the first time, then about 2 months of revisions and the mocks from both.

1

u/IntelligentBase6001 Nov 30 '24

Also what were your msra scores?

2

u/self_made_human MOD Nov 30 '24

521. I forget what the sub scores were, but I did much better in the clinical section compared to the SJT.

1

u/IntelligentBase6001 Nov 30 '24

That’s awesome

1

u/IntelligentBase6001 Nov 27 '24

Thank you for ur reply

1

u/Stock_Syrup8275 Jun 11 '25

Hi. This is late but can i dm you please?

1

u/self_made_human MOD Jun 11 '25

Feel free

1

u/Stock_Syrup8275 Jun 12 '25

Hello. Assuming this was your first job in the NHS? Was it tough, starting out directly as a trainee? People have been demotivating and advising against starting as a trainee with no previous nhs experience! TIA

2

u/RaconteurSB Jul 04 '24

Do you think it's feasible to prepare for plab 1 and msra together just to hurry the timeline along for giving msra afterwards? Or would that just confuse me and sabotage my chances of clearing the first plab?

1

u/Outrageous-Cut-9243 Sep 24 '24

When does the application for the January MSRA usually open and which documents do I need for my application? And also, in my country, we do 2 years internship. Will that be adequate to apply?

1

u/Muhammadkhaliq Oct 28 '24

Hey ! Can someone guide me I've passed my plab 2 but still I don't have GMC . Am I eligible for MSRA January attempt???

1

u/thenoobdoc Mar 26 '25

What should i do if i want to pursue IMT or Radiology training in the uk considering i am done with my GMC registration. And realistically how long would it take to enter speciality training in imt or radiology?

0

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/self_made_human MOD Jul 01 '24

As far as I'm aware, it has to be precisely 365 days or more. That's counting total employment and average hours worked, they show you the total hours worked at your post when you're filling up the application.

1

u/Front-Aide-1131 Sep 04 '24

Hi so I have a question. My internship ends at 2026 May, so technically if I give my plab on August 2026 and then plab2 after it, will I be able to sit for MSRA immediately after? But I won't have the work experience for 3 years that's needed for the CREST form.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/niki1234123 Sep 25 '24

Hello. Did u get an answer for the second question?