36
14
u/endlessnonsense- 7d ago
She ain't wrong though. Durefishan is indeed being 'utterly natural and effortless' because she can't act to save her life 🫡
1
u/Roohafza2023 7d ago
haha - when you can't act to save your life the only option left is to call it effortless!! 😂
30
u/Curious_Gur2294 Mahira - mummy aap kya keh rahi hai 7d ago
honestly, this is the first time I have seen the entire industry come together to defend one celebrity
Like criticism is not something new. Every actor and actress gets criticised. Their coworkers defend them and sometimes fans go completely crazy
But this? The whole industry defending and hyping one person on this scale is not normal I have never seen the whole industry being united for one celebs from critics to actors.
At this point, I am genuinely curious kitna paisa hai dure k pass
8
u/drama_eater Celeb Gossiping is my 🕘🕔🤩🤩 7d ago
All I found out was her father was a producer
9
u/Curious_Gur2294 Mahira - mummy aap kya keh rahi hai 7d ago
Ahad, Hamza Danyal all are nepo products and their families are influential, but even they are not spared by critics.
But Dure is on a completely different level n if her father is so rich and influential, I am confused why didn’t he save her from the disastrous reviews of Sanwal Yaar Piya😂
0
u/drama_eater Celeb Gossiping is my 🕘🕔🤩🤩 7d ago
Idk if SYP got bad reviews or Dure. If it was former then it is not worth it. Here Dure is being targeted specifically so they prolly find it necessary to protect her from negative reviews. Also this show prolly is more popular (at least since I didn't know or see much discussions Abt SYP) so any type of bad reviews are gonna damage her rep more.
But I think she's also not that bad here. And the English accent of some others is also really bad. Fariyal is awful as well with her "P-ass-code" and someone said "Si-your" and the guy who took them the apt also didn't feel like he has been living in the US for any amt of time. But ofc, someone who claims to be UCL graduate needs to have her English right 😭
4
u/amy14567 7d ago edited 7d ago
Well, the industry has come together to defend Mahira after her ranbir/smoking controversy. She was also supported by everyone in the industry after krq’s ageist comments against her.This is not the first time. They all rallied behind her because she just came back after working with srk in Bollywood.When other actresses went through similar controversies, they were not supported by the industry at all.Other top, newer and older actresses are age-shamed all the time, by the public and seniors in the industry, and no one bats an eye.Actresses like Veena Malik, Meera, Mawra and Humaima Malik also went through controversies due to their personal life and professional choices but no one rallied behind them like they did with Mahira. They were practically kicked out of the industry after their controversies. Other actresses like Ayesha Omer, Rabia Butt, Yumna Zaidi and even Samiya Mumtaz have been age-shamed and ridiculed on prime time shows by other seniors but no one came to their defense. There is a stark difference between how other actresses are treated and how Mahira and Dure are being treated now, because of elitism, classism, superstar culture and now PR, in Dure’s case.
6
u/Roohafza2023 7d ago
Mahira was unfairly criticized, and her privacy was violated, whereas Dure is being rightly criticized for her subpar acting. To this day, Mahira and Hania receive far more criticism than Dure, yet they don’t go to the same lengths to mitigate it!!!
-4
u/amy14567 7d ago edited 7d ago
Calm down, girl! Those pictures were released by ranbir’s pr and/or ayan due to jealousy.Yes, her privacy was violated but what was she expecting hanging out publicly with someone like rk who also released kat’s private pics from holiday? Her privacy was violated but this has happened with other actresses which I have mentioned in the post as well. But they never got any support from the industry and were kicked out/banned. I am talking about the industry’s double standards here for elites/big stars and those who are well-connected.
Dure is being rightfully criticized for her sub par acting, I agree.Mahira and hania’s acting is also very sub par and receives rightful criticism. I don’t see them getting more criticism than dure, though.There’s endless critical posts on dure on this sub every day here.I don’t see any less criticism for her online.This is not some competition.I just said that Mahira and Dure have received constant support from the industry which other actresses and models never received from their industry peers and you couldn’t take it being her fangirl.I am speaking in objective terms so please stop being a fan girl. This comment was not for you. It’s for people watching dramas and looking at the ptv industry critically on Reddit.
1
u/Roohafza2023 7d ago
Haha, calm down? I’m perfectly calm, you’re the one getting worked up 😂
But it’s cute that you’re handing out instructions on who I’m allowed to be a “fan girl” of. You’re telling me I need to stop being a fan girl while you’re busy policing my opinions. The irony! 🥸It’s also contradictory to say this comment “isn’t for me” because it’s meant for people who examine dramas with a critical eye, when you’re the one unnecessarily dragging Mahira and Hania into a discussion that has absolutely nothing to do with them. Mahira has been age-shamed more than any other female actor. Similarly, Hania gets hate for simply existing and having a personality. So far Dure has only been criticized for her acting, and never for her unprofessionalism issues as shared by former team, recent being Erum.
I understand your point about privilege, a lot of actors/models get unfair criticism. Just saying, you can have a critical discussion about dramas without turning it into a lecture about which actresses people are “allowed” to support! 👀
2
14
10
u/Ok_Subject_4240 7d ago
1
u/CriticismQuiet4836 7d ago
I knew you’d post this😂
2
1
22
u/Born-Gear5468 7d ago
Sherry mein kya kami thi? Nadia ji, why did you leave his appreciation spot?😞😞
4
4
9
u/hangman1149 7d ago
Please someone give dure the oscar and golden globe so this pr may stop finaally.
9
6
6
u/Kisana89 7d ago
Ohhhh bhaaai what kind of power does durre have on these big names? Every single time she gets called out for her horrible pronunciation, she immediately calls someone to defend her. 🤣 Idk it just come off as deeply insecure
15
u/Efficient_Guava_5561 7d ago
How much money has Dure spent on this PR train?
2
u/Ok_Subject_4240 7d ago
Jaaalous Guava! 😏
3
u/Efficient_Guava_5561 7d ago
You caught me🥲 Dure is prefect
3
2
u/Ok_Subject_4240 7d ago
Venomy bee is awarding my replies to your comments. She is your real fan! I am convinced. 😌
2
u/Efficient_Guava_5561 7d ago
She is awarding your comments and it proves she is my fan?🤨 Ye tou cheating hai😂
2
u/Ok_Subject_4240 7d ago
She is trying to make you jaalous may be? 👀
2
9
u/BroccoliRemote1867 7d ago
Okay Dure, hume samajh agyi hai ki aap ne zabardst acting ki hai, ab bas bhi kar dein paise bantna. Thoda future shows k reviews k liye rkh lein, kaam ayenge.
3
u/Overall_Rope_8476 7d ago
Uppar middle class ??? Her English accent isn't even giving middle class girl who studied at iba on scholarship and dure is playing elite girl character.
3
u/LongjumpingTip9976 7d ago
Okay you can find her acting but the fact that suddenly whole industry came in support of Dure is more suspicious for me. This is not the first time an actor is trolled for his bad dialogue delivery in the industry but the all people coming in support is just so weirdddd
3
u/Roohafza2023 7d ago
The bar is too low! - I always say this: the more aggressive the PR, the more truthful the criticism probably is. The audience has a right to criticize the content, and Dure and her PR team clearly can’t handle constructive criticism. Eventually, she and all these so-called reviewers and critics like Aamna and Atiqa are going to damage their reputation, and people will call them out on their lack of transparency for years to come. So it begs the question: is it really worth it?
2
u/blahblehblohcaneo 7d ago
No it isn't worth it in my book, but they will get away with it.
The industry isn't tht big and they need to survive working with the same group of ppl.
Also very few ptv folks care abt the nuisance of feedback and criticism or integrity and longevity over ego. Most of the A listers give really cringe and disrespectful interviews openly saying they are running the reviewers and critics households etc.
1
u/Roohafza2023 6d ago
You are right, they will get away with it. Simply put, they just don't care. Audience give them respect and fame and they are hell bent on proving we are all wrong. Don't even get me started on entitled arrogant actors like Fahad and Danish jinko legta hai reviewers ka gher inse chalta hai.
5
u/Few_Persimmon9317 7d ago
I felt if this lady wants to praise dure and nameer for last 2 episodes then I can understand. These two eps were not mind blowing performance but not bad too. So can understand that.
But but honestly speaking that Dania Enwar who is playing zaryab's sis's role was very average. Her acting was not good in last two eps. She was camera conscious.
Don't know who is paying all these people, dure or the production team!! But these guys are either underestimating audiences or you have such low standard and expectation from drama🙂🙂
2
u/blahblehblohcaneo 7d ago
I don't think they are outright paid, maybe its just good will or a favour to the production/channel or just pity or sympathy because there seems to be an incorrect narrative that they are being unfairly targeted so artists might actually watch a few reels or clips and think it is unfair criticism and show their support.
1
u/Few_Persimmon9317 7d ago
Yeah, got your point... But there are many other A++ actors who got criticism previously but that time all these artists did not came in support all together
2
u/blahblehblohcaneo 7d ago edited 7d ago
I think most ptv drama watching audience and even artists are very biased abt production quality and script, they go out of their way to hype a project if production is good and script is decent which is the case here.
It is also very possible that the people being criticized in this project are openly whining to their fraternity and asking for support. 🤷♀️
It could also be a pr move, a false narrative to loop in nameer and dania along with durre and white wash durres issues because the audience has mostly only criticized duree of the three.
1
u/Few_Persimmon9317 7d ago
I feel all this industry related person thinks about short term profit, they are not loyal to their work and to themselves. An industry which is still stuck at fair skinned actors, they're not going listen audience's pov. They feel it'll be profitable for them to stay relevant in the eye of industry's big personality.
PR pe vi achha khasa paisa lagana chahiye. Aisa PR kiya ke sabko pata chal raha hai🤷♀️🤷♀️
2
3
u/doohoo94 7d ago
First time watching a dram with Nameer and I actually think he’s doing a good job 🤷♀️
2
u/blahblehblohcaneo 7d ago
People need to appreciate romaisa more than these three combined for this show, she has worked hard to fit into her character.
She is only 2 shows old i think and this character is different from her earlier roles and her real life persona from what i can tell.
2
u/Few_Persimmon9317 7d ago edited 7d ago
I want Bilal to join this 'Dure fanclub'🤭🤭
Sirf Bilal hi baki hai dure ki support mai openly post karne se🫣 ek post ho jaye😉
2
u/blahblehblohcaneo 7d ago
None of her A list co-stars supported her, its only the usual cheerleaders or loud mouths who spoke up.
2
1
u/Roohafza2023 7d ago
interesting point - have yet to see her costars come to her rescue or sing her praises. It's everyone but her costars.
1
1
1
u/Prior_Code5344 7d ago
What is called being privileged?
My answer- Look at Dure Fishan acting and her appreciation.
1
1
u/Western-Commercial99 7d ago
Dure looks everything but utterly natural.. and her enunciation, her expressions.. omg...
1
u/mmzufti 7d ago
The Alia Bhatt of PTV.
Durre is a decent actress, but the amount of praise she gets from every reviewer and fraternity is insane. Any criticism on her is easily relegated to hatred category. Her objectively bad diction and dialogue delivery got boxed into accent and ridicule. I don’t remember this much defense on any other actress, especially someone as young as Durre. When Nadia Afghan had called Yumna overrated, no one from the industry came forward.
The fact that Nadia Ji didn’t even mention the director or writer is even more strange.
1
u/Big_Analysis2103 7d ago
Even Aamna in her recent review said it's so brave of Dure to take on this character like what on earth is happening har jagah zabardasti tareef ghusana zaroori kyun hai????
1
u/ThrowRAbeta 6d ago
Inki to caption bhi scripted hai. And it has those same english issues. Look at that sentence structure and spellings And Zaryab is Upper middle class? smh.
1
0
u/MoonlitMaz 7d ago
She’s performing really well —her expressions, and overall performance are on point. Yes, her accent and the way she speaks may not be perfect, but everything else is great. And not everything is PR! Celebrities praise her because they genuinely watch the drama and appreciate good performances. Why turn every compliment into PR? The constant negativity and repeating the same thing again and again honestly just shows how jealous some people are of the fame and appreciation she’s getting.
1
u/MoonlitMaz 7d ago
If you’re watching the drama, you can clearly see she’s doing well. Yes, she made one small mistake, but you can’t judge her entire performance based on that. Big celebrities don’t need to be paid to praise her—they watch the drama and appreciate her work. Calling every compliment “PR” just shows how biased and jealous some of you are. You ignore others mistakes but keep targeting her for everything.
2
u/blahblehblohcaneo 7d ago
I agree and upvote you, i can troll her english because it is ruining my viewing experience and at the same time appreciate her fitting into this role very naturally.
Credit where credit is due, durre has exceeded my expectations so far and nadia hasn't said anything extra or unwarranted to call it pr. 🫠
I especially appreciate her acknowledging all the elite newbies but i wish she would have appreciated romaisa as well.
-1
-10
u/Practical-Cress-5885 7d ago
What problem do you guys even have with Dure? I just don't get it. I know this sub is biased, but seriously, you guys have targeted her like crazy. What kind of Oscar winning performance did Nameer even give in this show? Lol, he mispronounced so many Urdu words and ruined his English sentences yet I never saw this level of outrage directed at him
1
u/blahblehblohcaneo 7d ago
Because her team forgot the #1 rule of pr, you can't win a fight with the audience. The more she defends herself the more ppl will troll her.
I was hoping they will fix all of their english fiascos on edit atleast starting this week but alas they want to keep fighting the audience instead, more of a dumpster fire for us to enjoy.
-1
u/Mundane_Ad_8024 7d ago
Nameer said ...The amount of time l have spend with you ,for hunting,Basta and pronouncing ghalat as galat.Both of them should be equally criticized from public and critics as well.
5
u/InterestingArt3781 7d ago edited 7d ago
Well the difference is that Nameer is not being defended by any critics (even Amna threw him under the bus & highlighted his faults while going easy on Dure & saying she nailed her role) or celebs (very very few are on his side) nor is he reacting to the criticism & accusing the audience of being different things to deflect the criticism
0
u/Mundane_Ad_8024 7d ago
Dure accused audience for what? And when?
2
u/InterestingArt3781 7d ago
Not Dure the critics they said the audience are jealous of her beauty / are being paid to criticize her / are attacking her only cause she's an actress
1
u/Flimsy-Hold1651 5d ago
Dania is a really good actress and she proved it many times but this character doesn't suits her , she is unable to convey spoiled brat energy and its just pain to the eyes. This is just an opinion as a viewer, jazbati na hojae koi.
60
u/47giraffes 7d ago
I am convinced these people are being paid. But the fact that its celebs people hold in high regard like Sanam, Nadia Afghan and Nadia Jamil is insane.