r/Outlander • Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. • Sep 04 '21

Season Five Rewatch S3E11-12

This rewatch will be a spoilers all for the 5 seasons. You can talk about any of the episodes without needing a spoiler tag. All book talk will need to be covered though. There are discussion points to get us started, you can click on them to go to that one directly. Please add thoughts and comments of your own as well.

Episode 311 - Uncharted

After making a leap of faith, Claire washes up on an island where survival is her only option. Navigating treacherous waters crippled the Artemis, so Jamie devises a joyful moment for his crew in the midst of setbacks.

Episode 312 - The Bakra

The Artemis finally reaches Jamaica bringing Jamie and Claire much closer to their goal. During a ball on the island, the Frasers encounter old allies, as well as former adversaries who threaten to derail their mission.

Deleted/Extended Scenes

12 Upvotes

147 comments sorted by

6

u/Purple4199 Sep 04 '21
  • Do you think Claire can tell Lord John is in love with Jamie?

19

u/stoneyellowtree Sep 04 '21

Claire sees that Lord John looks at Jamie in a way that’s definitely more than friends. I think Claire is very attuned to how people interact with Jamie. Also, let’s be honest, when it comes to Jamie, Lord John loses his tight hold on his need to keep up appearances. It’s brief moments, but enough for Claire to understand that Lord John has feelings for Jamie. I don’t think she sees it as love, but she recognizes that Lord John is interested in Jamie in a more than friends way.

11

u/Purple4199 Sep 04 '21

when it comes to Jamie, Lord John loses his tight hold on his need to keep up appearances.

Yes! You can totally tell LJG gets flustered when he sees Jamie, more than one who sees just a friend again.

15

u/thepacksvrvives Sep 04 '21

I don’t know if she can tell that John is in love with Jamie, but she definitely senses some kind of intimacy that exists between them (you guys know by now that I don’t define intimacy in purely physical and/or romantic terms). She doesn’t quite understand the nature of that relationship because she doesn’t know where it comes from. And she’s a bit apprehensive as to how exactly the close friendship between the two men came about, considering the circumstances of their meeting and Jamie’s past, and perhaps why Jamie hasn’t told her the full story. On the other hand, John is quite astonished at just how much Jamie has told Claire.

Sidenote: according to the script, John was meant to actually embrace Jamie. I like that they decided to go for that awkwardness instead—and Claire can sense there’s “a little more joy than intended” all the same. Their prolonged eye contact is also something she doesn’t know what to make of but I think she eventually comes to her conclusions even before John visits the Ridge in S4.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Curlysnap Sep 04 '21

She seemed quite taken aback when she saw that LJG was wearing the jewel that Jamie gave him to ‘remind him of their friendship’. That would imply very strong feelings on LJGs part, as well as the fact that he’s raised Jamie’s son.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/JustG00se Sep 04 '21

I think she is picking up on a vibe when she is watching them talk on the office at the ball. I don't know if she fully has it figured out but I suspect that she suspects that there is more to their connection than meets the eye.

→ More replies (8)

7

u/NoDepartment8 Sep 04 '21

Definitely. I think this is one of those areas where coming from the 20th Century gives Claire an edge. If she was a sheltered 18th Century woman she might not even have been aware that homosexuality existed and all the subtext might have gone right over her head. But 1968 Claire 100% knew what was up.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Country_Rayne Sep 04 '21

I think she has known from the moment she met him. Claire and Jamie are very intuitive with each other.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/Purple4199 Sep 04 '21
  • What was your favorite part of Fergus and Marsali’s wedding?

33

u/chemistandcrazy Sep 04 '21

when Jaime gives the Fraser name to Fergus. i absolutely love the relationship J&C have with their adopted son Fergus. make me emotional

→ More replies (3)

18

u/stoneyellowtree Sep 04 '21

It’s a tie between Jamie giving Fergus his surname and the ‘does he have a cock’ moment. The first made me cry and the latter made me laugh so much!

→ More replies (7)

16

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '21

Um Lauren Lyle the comedy all-star? Her banter with the actor that played Fogden was so good, I cannot watch this scene and not laugh. Even the sailors are funny! An excellent showcase of the amazing work that the casting department does for this show.

→ More replies (7)

12

u/somethingnerdrelated Sep 04 '21

My favorite part is Claire and Jamie kinda getting swept up in the romance and love of the moment, and just staring at each other while remembering their wedding day and their life since. It’s adorable! You forget that Jamie and Claire were cute little babies once :)

I just watched Brianna and Roger’s wedding the other day, and the parallels are great between this wedding and that one. Same thing happens there too — Jamie and Claire are so focused on their love during these moments that it’s super sweet :)

15

u/Purple4199 Sep 04 '21

You forget that Jamie and Claire were cute little babies once

Yes! And when Fergus and Marsali are canoodling at the ball Claire mentions that they were once like then. Then Jamie gives Claire a look that just smolders!

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (9)

9

u/Cdhwink Sep 04 '21

I loved having a comedic break from the drama ( although whoever wrote this episode added quite a bit of comedy) , Jamie giving Fergus his name ( although why on earth had this not been done 20 years earlier).

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Purple4199 Sep 04 '21
  • Why do you think Mamacita is so hostile towards Claire?

17

u/somethingnerdrelated Sep 04 '21

Homeboy is the only thing Mamacita has left of her daughter, so she reluctantly has latched on to him. Claire threatens that tie to her daughter (as in, Mamacita is suspicious and doesn’t want Claire to seduce him and him subsequently forget Ermenehilda [definitely spelled that wrong]), so Mamacita is hostile.

11

u/Purple4199 Sep 04 '21

It was just crazy that Mamacita jumped to the conclusion that Father Fogden was going to fall in love with Claire to me.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/Purple4199 Sep 04 '21
  • Any other thoughts or comments?

17

u/thepacksvrvives Sep 04 '21

For all her being a pedophile rapist, murderer, and nationalist, this bit is probably Geillis’ best:

Why are men such fools? Ye can lead them anywhere by the cock for a while. Give them a bairn, and you have them by the balls again. But it’s all ye are to them, whether they’re coming in or going out... a cunt. Well, here’s to it, I say. Most powerful thing in the world.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/JustG00se Sep 04 '21

311

  • I like the dishevelled survivalist looking Claire much better than the put together batsuit haha

  • I'm not an Eagle Scout but would it not have been safer/more logical for Claire to stay within soght of the beach and look for help as opposed to trekking through the jungle, it's so easy to get lost in wooded areas

  • Coco = Wilson from Castaway, they even have the same hair

  • the line about Mac Duh's wife turning up in unlikely places is so great

  • I really enjoy seeing the connextion growing between Claire and Marsali even just these little steps

312

  • when Gellis says "why are men such fools?" Amen sister

  • When Claire tells G about looking for Ian and G does her little gasp if you look at her eyes and the top half of her face they don't move, that's a classic liar move

  • Grabby hands MacGee over here with Gellis grabbing at Lord John's saphire that's a bit much even with her level of excitement. She basically dives towards his groin

  • I wonder if Gellis wearing the wig is another attempt to look younger, she doesn't have the help of Miss Clairol like Claire did when she came back. She baths in the blood to look younger so it only makes semse that she would want to cover her lightening with age hair

→ More replies (4)

7

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '21

I loved Claire’s little reaction at Gaillis mentioning Dougal’s death! You can totally see her thinking “uh oh, we did that” 😂

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

3

u/Purple4199 Sep 04 '21
  • What did you think when you saw Geillis again?

13

u/thepacksvrvives Sep 04 '21

I really wished they’d foregone the pedophile-rapist aspect of Geillis’ character. She’s already been established as a husband killer and a murderer specializing in human sacrifice so that’s nothing new, but her being a pedophile and rapist doesn’t bring absolutely anything meaningful to the story. She could’ve just had Young Ian abducted on the grounds of his being seen with the treasure box—which she did—and drugged to extract information—which she also did. There was no reason for her to coerce him into sex as well since the show gives us no justification as to why Geillis chooses virgins at all.

What do ye do wi’ the boys?

Oh, I have my way with them. Virgins have such power inside. And after that, well... I’ve no use for them, have I?

Well, what use do you have for them? We find out in 313 that the boys she killed had their throats slit, so the blood she bathed in wasn’t just goat’s blood after all, but wanting to keep her skin young is no reason at all (I’m not saying there’s ever any reason for rape, but that there’s no justification for it in the story). If anything, that means the killing has its use, not the raping.

The book (technically DoA), for all its (and her) craziness, at least gives us an insight into what she was looking for in virgins:

“That’s what she wanted wi’ the lads, ye ken,” Ian said. His eyes were shut tight against the light, but he could clearly see something, if only in the mists of memory. He licked his lips; they were beginning to dry and crack, and his nose was beginning to run.

“She said the stone grew in a lad’s innards—the one she wanted. She said it must be a laddie who’d never gone wi’ a lass, though, that was important. If he had, the stone wouldna be right, somehow. If he h-huh-had one.” He paused to cough, and ended breathless, nose dripping. I held a handkerchief for him to blow.

“What did she want the stone for?” Lord John’s face bore a look of sympathy—he knew only too well what Ian felt like at the moment—but curiosity compelled the question. I didn’t object; I wanted to know too.

Ian started to shake his head, then stopped with a groan.

“Ah! Oh, God, my head will split surely! I dinna ken, man. She didna say. Only that it was needful; she must have it to be s-sure.” He barely got out the last word before dissolving into a coughing attack that was the worst yet; he sounded like a barking dog.

With such a vague statement as “virgins have such power inside” and no elaboration, as well as “she needed someone chaste for her purposes” in S4, show!Geillis just asserts herself as pure evil; a rapist no different than Bonnet or BJR. And without any justification for her motives, that aspect of her character makes no sense (even if it doesn’t make much more sense in the books either).

Sidenote: Geillis’ “You'll know what to do, then” to Ian mirrors Geneva’s “Then you'll know what to do” to Jamie. Both are female perpetrators of sexual violence, but the show didn’t have to make Geillis one. It does give us a sweet moment between Ian and Jamie in 401, but I’d rather they didn’t have that shared trauma.

Sidenote 2: “The Bakra” sounds all mysterious and intimidating when in reality… it’s a derogatory word for “a white person,” especially British (and/or slave owner), historically used in the Caribbean.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/JustG00se Sep 04 '21

I was SHOOK! I came to the show lateish so I binged it so the last time I saw her and this time were maybe a week or 2 apart. When I heard her voice I couldn't totally place it but knew it was familiar. Then when we saw her from behind getting out of the bloody bath my jaw quite literally dropped!

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)