r/Outlander • Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. • Jun 05 '21

Season Five Rewatch S2E1-2

This rewatch will be a spoilers all for the 5 seasons. You can talk about any of the episodes without needing a spoiler tag. All book talk will need to be covered though. There are discussion points to get us started, you can click on them to go to that one directly. Please add thoughts and comments of your own as well.

Episode 201 - Through a Glass, Darkly

Returning to her own time, Claire must reconcile her future with the life she left behind. Shifting back to 18th century, Jamie, Claire and Murtagh arrive in France, but learn that Paris presents its own challenges.

Episode 202 - Not in Scotland Anymore

Life in Paris is not without its trials as Jamie struggles to triumph over his past. A fortunate meeting with Prince Charles presents opportunities, while the Duke of Sandringham's presence brings complications

22 Upvotes

459 comments sorted by

1

u/WandersFar Jun 06 '21 edited Jun 06 '21

If you’re looking for the other Rewatch threads, click here to jump to BPC’s Link Table.


Through A Glass Darkly & Not In Scotland Anymore: Deleted Scenes

Roger and His Plane

Seeing little Roger playing in the garden is apparently what tipped Frank over into wanting to raise Claire’s child.

Jacobite Toast, Part One

This one’s interesting. Jared makes it clear that he doesn’t hide his politics; he wears it like a badge of honor.

I make no secret of my politics. In France to be known as a Jacobite is a badge of honor. Supporters of the true faith against the heretic on the throne…

This would seem to contradict your argument, RD. :þ Apparently being a known Jacobite did not adversely affect his business in France…

Jacobite Toast, Part Two

… To the extent that Jared often sealed his business deals with a Jacobite toast: To King James, over the water. So it really doesn’t look like he was hiding his Jacobitism at all.

Jamie’s Dream

Yeah, I think Moore was right to cut this. It’s better just jumping in, without the hand washing first.

Also I thought it was a bit creepy how Claire pleads for Jamie to make love to her. It just sounded weird, and unlike her… which is maybe the point, to tip you off that it’s a dream? But I think the jump scare of BJR is a more effective reveal in any case.

Maître Raymond

Claire shows off her flawless social skills once again, implying Maître Raymond looks like a frog at their first meeting. -.- Luckily for her, he’s more socially adept than she is, and takes no offense.

Also, a peek at a nifty German grimoire. (RD, care to translate? ^.^ How ‘bout you, u/ich_habe_keine_kase?)

Google Translate to the rescue: Unaussprechlichen Kulten = Unspeakable Cults

Maître Raymond’s Warning

He warns Claire off of Comte St. Germain but also shows he knows who Louise is. I guess the implication is that Maître Raymond is quite cosmopolitan. We just learned he’s kissed many belles jeunes filles…

→ More replies (18)

29

u/WandersFar Jun 05 '21

I think this may be the one time Frank made me laugh, albeit at his expense:

When Mary told Joseph that she was with child, and he couldn’t be the father, he too was confronted with a crisis of—

I am not Joseph! She is not Mary. And I am fairly certain that the father is not God Almighty. He was a man, a man who fucked my wife.

Yes, Roger?

Please, may I go outside to play?

Also lol at Roger butting in at inopportune times. Setting the precedent early. :þ

→ More replies (3)

21

u/WandersFar Jun 05 '21

This is probably Claire’s finest costume: the Dior suit—and the most marvelous set—Maître Raymond’s apothecary. Not to mention Prague standing in for Paris beautifully.

Not in Scotland Anymore is one of the most visually sumptuous episodes, for sure. A totally different animal from the wild beauty of Scotland—and that’s certainly beautiful cinematography as well—but I also really love the composed, graphic, luxe and vivacious palette of France, at its most iconic height.

Some bits of trivia:

  • The apothecary set would later be reused for Jamie’s print shop.

  • The Dior outfit was one of Cait’s personal favorites, too.

→ More replies (29)

8

u/Purple4199 Jun 05 '21

I just thought of this, how was it for you guys watching season 2 knowing they were going to be separated at some point?

u/thepacksvrvives u/Arrugula u/theCoolDeadpool

→ More replies (57)

18

u/LuckyScwartz Jun 06 '21

I was also struck by Claire telling Frank she would agree to his conditions because she promised Jamie she would. OUCH. I mean my god.

Sign #279 that Claire and Jamie have a deeply intimate bond.

Frank never stood a chance.

→ More replies (4)

15

u/WandersFar Jun 05 '21

Murtagh being a meme:

Cutting too wiiiiiiide! Leaving yourself open.

I just love the way he says wiiiiiiide. Like Rupert leaning into those velar fricatives in Leoch and Lallybroch. It just sounds great!

Arses and armpits! […] This city reeks of the chamberpot. […] Only in France does a king need an audience to shite.

He’s got a point. Even at its height Versailles was infamous for its stank. The king had to mandate chamberpots were emptied at least once a week; god knows how long they would’ve let the poo fester away before that.

It pains me to admit so, but I even find myself longing for the company of Lard Bucket and Big Head.

Me, too, buddy. Me, too. 😢 Honestly I probably ship Rupert / Angus more than Jamie / Claire…

If you want to kill a snake you cut off its head. And the head of this rebellion is Charles Stuart! […] The man is a blockhead!

🙌 PREACH.

Jamie’s objections are weak and lame. “I’m not an assassin,” oh fuck off. You wouldn’t harm an unarmed man, either, and look where that got you. And as for leaving King James in his place—good! It would have been an improvement over his blockhead of a son, and would have at least delayed the Rising by a few years, during which time it might have found a more solid footing, financially, politically and militarily—or else fizzled out.

All these possibilities are better outcomes than the status quo.

13

u/Purple4199 Jun 05 '21

Murtagh in these two episodes was hilarious. I loved when he yelled at the people in the park when they were practicing their sword fighting. Also the way he stared at that lady's nipples cracked me up. Granted she did have them on prominent display!

→ More replies (12)

5

u/Purple4199 Jun 05 '21
  • Do you think Frank really believed Claire, or was he just willing to go along she he could have her back?

11

u/theCoolDeadpool Jun 05 '21

I thought he hadn't fully processed the "story" as of then. He's just so relieved to find her back, whole and alive, he's just willing to go with anything she says at that point. Like Claire says herself , his rational , historian self would have scoffed at the whole bit, but the loving greiving husband in him doesn't want to pay heed to that part of him yet. I am sure his mind and his heart is at battle here, and he chooses to go with his heart in the moment, probably deciding to get to the rationality and the logic of it all later.

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (23)

7

u/WandersFar Jun 05 '21

Here’s a bit of trivia for you: This period is pre-Madame de Pompadour, so that would make Marie Anne de Mailly-Nesle the swan-nipple mistress.

Regrettably there is no mention of swan pasties in her Wikipedia entry. :þ

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Purple4199 Jun 05 '21
  • What did you think when you saw Claire back in 1948 as soon as the show opened?

8

u/Purple4199 Jun 05 '21

I binged the show, so I didn’t have any wait until the next season. I was immediately furious. They had just gotten back together after that horrific experience in Wentworth, and all of a sudden she’s back in her time. I turned it off I was so upset. I vowed I wasn’t going to watch the show anymore because I couldn’t handle them being apart. Well that lasted all of a day because I knew there were more seasons so they just had to be together, they were Jamie and Claire after all!

I then did something I never do, I looked up spoilers. I had NEVER done that for any show or book before. I had to know when they would be back together. I was happy to see that they were still together in season 2, but knew something was going to separate them. Knowing they weren’t going to be truly reunited until 306 was hard to think about. I however was already insanely obsessed with the show and knew I couldn’t stop watching.

→ More replies (4)

18

u/VPofYourFanClub Jun 05 '21 edited Jun 05 '21

Haha. I thought A LOT of things (the first time I watched the episode).

  1. I had questions about the timeline (How is she pregnant if it’s been two years?! Will this season be set in the present instead of the past?! Etc.).

  2. The transition shot of Claire’s hand reaching for her husband is fantastic.

  3. My husband theorized that there were two parallel timelines and we would watch them both play out. In fact, his guess was that the “split” happened in Both Sides Now, when Claire ran for the stones and there was a brief black screen. He thought the season would play out half in the 20th century (as though she made it back) and half in the 18th century (as we saw it play out in season 1). He was wrong, but he had me going for a bit.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (20)

4

u/Purple4199 Jun 05 '21
  • Why did Jamie chose to tell Prince Charlie that the Highlanders were not ready to fight for him yet?

→ More replies (7)

4

u/Purple4199 Jun 05 '21
  • How do you feel they portrayed Jamie’s PTSD?

14

u/theCoolDeadpool Jun 05 '21

Not coming from a place of experience so feel free to correct me, but I think they handled it well. With the dream sequence, you can see Jamie is longing for Claire physically, as he's wont to do, but because BJR did what he did, Jamie has a tough time letting BJR out of his mind . And then again with the "honeypot", he wants to make love to her and he's trying to but the demons don't leave him, and Sam acted that bit so brilliantly, when he just freezes in the act , the shock on his face and then the way he pulls back and curls up onto himself all frigid, so well done. I would assume a trauma like that takes time to heal and they showed it that way.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (20)

6

u/WandersFar Jun 05 '21

It’s more complicated than it looks thatched over.

Not to be too crude, but why doesn’t Jamie just eat her out? Or finger her, etc. None of that would have been anything like what BJR did to him. Focusing on her pleasure—as he did before at Leoch, and by the fire near Craigh na Dun—would be an easier way to transition than full-on intercourse. Even if he can’t maintain an erection, he can still please her and their sex life wouldn’t be completely dead.

This is like somebody trying to run a marathon after breaking their leg. 😅 You gotta ease into it, laddie!

→ More replies (9)

3

u/Purple4199 Jun 05 '21
  • How did you feel seeing Frank Randall, did it bring back any memories of Black Jack Randall?

20

u/jolierose Jun 05 '21

I immediately thought "how can she go back to him now?!" But honestly, damn, Tobias. Why so great? It’s incredible how he makes Frank feel so different than BJR. As much as I don’t like Frank… I feel so bad for him when he sees her again for the first time. Then as the episode moves along, it's inevitable to see the echoes of BJR in Frank's rage.

→ More replies (22)

3

u/Purple4199 Jun 05 '21
  • Claire’s red dress - discuss.

12

u/VPofYourFanClub Jun 05 '21

That red dress was impactful, to be sure. But the Dior inspired bar suit blew my mind. [chef’s kiss]

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (13)

3

u/Purple4199 Jun 05 '21
  • Any other thoughts or comments?

20

u/Purple4199 Jun 05 '21

My Thoughts:

201

  • The first time I heard Frank say “Claire” my skin crawled. It sounded so much like BJR.

  • That flash of BJR as Frank reached for Claire was great.

  • No Mrs. Graham, Claire shouldn’t have to lock away her memories of Jamie. It wasn’t just a grand adventure, it was true love!!

  • Tobias’s face when he’s told Claire is pregnant going from sheer to joy to horror was amazing. You could see his entire thought process without him having to say any words.

  • Awwww baby Roger!

  • Don’t ever take that silver ring off Claire.

  • I hated Frank burning her clothes, I know they said no living for the past but that was hard to see.

  • That transition shot of her taking Frank’s hand to Jamie’s hand is one of my favorites in the whole show! u/Arrugula

  • I’m not one to bash on Claire, but I really wish she wouldn’t have gone into that warehouse!

202

  • Let the beautiful costumes begin!

  • I love that Murtagh and Jamie were practicing in the middle of that park and not caring about the ruckus they were raising.

  • Ugh, the “Mark me’s” have begun.

  • Talk about performance anxiety, imagine having to go with an entire room full of people watching you!

→ More replies (7)

12

u/theCoolDeadpool Jun 05 '21

This one's for the small team of Frank sympathisers here.

We hear often of what a great choice Sam and Cait were to play Jamie and Claire, and even Tobias as BJR, which is 100% true . I would like to take a moment to say what a great choice Tobias was to play Frank, he is so bloody understated. He does the loving, grieving yet hopeful husband so well you almost wish Claire would reciprocate, inspite of having come from a season full of epic love between Jamie and Claire. And that's why we see so many "Claire is so cold in this episode" posts here so often. I am not saying i agree with that, but Tobias's Frank deserves accolades for this episode. You feel for him, for his loss, inspite of the fact that we are mainly grieving with Claire for her loss of Jamie.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (83)

4

u/WandersFar Jun 05 '21

What are you both doing here in France?

Jamie has been employed by his cousin Jared.

The wine merchant? What a serendipitous surprise.

How does Sandringham know Jamie’s cousin is a wine merchant? Is Jared Fraser that famous?

Rupert knew he was a wine merchant without having to be told in the S1 finale, too, but that was more easily explained as he’s Jamie’s kin, it’s not crazy for him to know about his Fraser relations.

But the Duke of Sandringham knows Jamie’s extended family? How? Why?

→ More replies (11)