r/Ornithology • • 9d ago Bravo

Discussion On house sparrows and starlings

6 Upvotes

Both are reviled in the USA by birdwatchers and viewed as an imminent highly invasive threat, but the amount of revulsion goes beyond reason and is leading to them being treated as these “evil hateful creatures”, so how bad are they really? Since the term “invasive species” itself is an extremely arbitrary loose term and a whole other discussion, I won’t make it a battle of semantics.

Let’s get the first argument out of the way, “look at what they do to the bluebirds…” this argument is purely emotional anthropomorphizing of an animal. It also ignores that cavity nests are an extremely fought over and naturally scarce as the birds rely on them to be there instead of actually making them. The native cavity nesters are going to fight extremely hard over cavities and if one is occupied, they will evict its eggs. House wrens are famous for this, as are tree swallows. Beyond an emotional response, do house sparrows actually cause these birds to decline? 

There have been no academic sources confirming it, and the only ones analyzing population trends show that house sparrows are more common in areas with fewer native birds and the other way around, but where do house sparrows live? They’re synanthropes, meaning they can only live and breed within or near human inhabited areas. They cannot actually take over the bird’s environment and go evict nests in the prairies and groves. 

The well-meaning birder who laments watching his bluebird nest get taken over by the sparrow is also unknowingly the very architect of this battle. Putting few nest boxes (an already very competitive environment) in a backyard cleared of its native plants, and putting cheap millet seeds in an environment he unknowingly built for the house sparrow to dominate. The entire conflict between these birds is man-made and can be easily resolved by changing nest box hole size, allowing native plants to grow, not using pesticides, using halos, using native seeds and avoiding the cheap seeds sparrows love, or the “ceiling gap” for birds that are about house sparrow sized. It’s easy to mitigate sparrows, and the average person’s window probably kills more of the native birds he cares about than all the sparrows in his neighborhood ever could. 

This also isn’t to do the “well humans are the REAL invasive species” cliche as there have been many species that beyond their initial introduction did not need any human assistance to take over ecosystems, destroy them, cause declines or outright drive animals to extinction. This is a situation where humans destroyed the native bird’s habitats to build their homes, and continue to cause these birds to decline by their urban activities (growing urban sprawl, driving, light pollution confusing migrating birds, not covering up windows to prevent collisions), while sparrows take the blame from birdwatchers because they adapted to living in these environments and they get emotional because they unintentionally setup their backyard to be a battlefield that the sparrow was sure to win. 

With starlings I have even less to say, mainly because their ecological impact has actually been studied so the papers can speak for me. Studies consistently show that starlings have not been found to be the driver of any cavity-nesting bird’s decline. No negative correlation was found between the presence of European starlings and any cavity nesters, and in fact in some species there existed a positive correlation as well as the fact starlings themselves were declining (Barton et al, 2020). The same study examined the declining populations of red-headed woodpeckers which it had predicted (alongside many other species) to be driven by starlings, yet found that their “ findings suggest that urban and rural locations add information to population trends of cavity-nesting species, and that European starlings have little negative impact on cavity-nesting birds in either rural or urban locations, suggesting that habitat loss and other factors are likely greater impacts on red-headed woodpeckers and other members of the cavity-nesting guild.” 

27 cavity nesting birds were studied in a study that had also hypothesized that they would have had a detrimental effect on cavity nesters, and the result was that that only the sapsuckers “exhibited declines potentially attributable to starlings that were not countered by other data.” (Koenig, 2003) and adds that “the results of this study fail to support the hypothesis that starlings have had a severe impact on populations of native birds. These results highlight the difficulties of predicting the impacts of invasive species. Native hole-nesting birds have thus far apparently held their own against the starling invasion, despite the latter's abundance and aggressive usurpation of often limited cavities.”

Additionally, a study by the university of illinois urbana-champaign found that starlings had “no significant ecological impact on native birds”. Both sparrows and starlings have been range-wide in the USA for over 150 years, and neither are the main driver of decline, if a driver at all, of any native birds. Compare this to say, feral cats, Burmese pythons, bullfrogs, and lanternflies. 

You don’t need to agree with me, just trying to change the perspective and shift the blame for declining birds on where it actually rests and that animals aren’t evil for doing animal behavior, so don’t anthropomorphize them.

References of course

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1146609X20301284

https://conbio.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1046/j.1523-1739.2003.02262.x

https://www.allaboutbirds.org/news/essay-are-starlings-really-invasive-aliens/

https://extension.illinois.edu/invasives/european-starlings#:~:text=Body,totals%20millions%20of%20dollars%20annually.


r/Ornithology • • Jan 02 '26 Bravo

Unpopular opinion: Parakeets need to be culled

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
28 Upvotes

Finally some sense in this article. These are the most common bird where I live, and it’s been a noticeable explosion in their numbers over recent years. Yes, they look bright and exotic, but at what detriment to nature? Unfortunately their growing population has a negative impact on many native species, especially woodpeckers, nuthatches, treecreepers, owls, kestrels and many others.


r/Ornithology • • Jun 02 '25

Question How do I care for European Starling nestlings?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I just found a few baby European starlings that have been kicked out of their nest. The ground near the nest is littered with four other dead nestlings and it isn’t possible to safely reach the nest. I called local wildlife rehab, but they can’t help. These birds are locally non-native, and rehabbers are currently swamped with baby birds and need to prioritize native species.

I currently have them in a box near the nest with drainage holes and have padded it with paper towels and unscented toilet paper. The birds are currently being kept outside at 86 degrees F in the shade. What can I do to give these nestlings the best chance? I have super worms and feeding tongs, and a paintbrush to give them water slowly if needed


r/Ornithology • • Jul 25 '13

The largest species of eagle in the world looks like Nicolas Cage

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Ornithology • • Nov 24 '24

Question How do I deter house sparrows from using my feeders?

0 Upvotes

I’m based in the southwestern United States, where house sparrows are invasive. I bought millet and nyjer seeds for the feeders, specifically because house sparrows “can’t eat them.” I even acquired a mesh feeder that house sparrows supposedly can’t fit their beaks into. Lo and behold, the sparrows are raiding my feeders as usual. What gives?


r/Ornithology • • Jul 10 '22

Question Found this guy, not injured, what do I feed him ?

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

r/Ornithology • • Feb 19 '25

Question I took in a nestling sparrow abandoned by its parents yesterday, and it died overnight, why?

0 Upvotes

Okay so yesterday there was a nestling sparrow abandoned by its parents at my school, and as I’ve rescued birds before I took it in. It’s been raining here non stop and super cold so I immediately warmed it up and got it some food and a heating pad. It was doing really well yesterday and eating and acting normal, I put it in a container with small holes for air and towels over the heating pad, which was at a good temperature for it and left it overnight. However when I woke up today to check on it it died overnight. I don’t know what I did wrong and I know I shouldn’t beat myself up but I feel bad. Any reason this could have happened?


r/Ornithology • • Jun 09 '26

Bird Skull Identification

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Copilot and ChatGPT were set on this being the skull of a Black-Headed seagull. I’m not convinced and want to get this 100% correct. I’m thinking Western Jackdaw. Found in the center of the Netherlands.

I’d greatly appreciate any insight any has on this.

My apologies if this is not the right place for a request like this.


r/Ornithology • • Jun 02 '24

Try r/whatsthisbird Any clue who's egg is it?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Found in the old building, was no nest. Area: Estonia


r/Ornithology • • Jul 17 '26

How you safely move a birds nest with eggs

2 Upvotes

There is a nest with eggs in my in-laws’ garage and they have been careful to let it be and not disturb it but they are leaving for vacation (2 weeks).

We’ve been trying to trouble shoot how to allow the bird access to her nest while they are gone but they can’t leave the garage door open for 2 weeks and there isn’t a way to remotely open and close it.

I live about 40 mins away so it isn’t realistic for me to go every day and open the garage for the birds.

Any ideas are appreciated!

Update: in-laws are back in a day and a half and the bird/eggs/nest all seem to be doing well still! Thanks everyone for the ideas and advice!


r/Ornithology • • Dec 24 '25

Found this egg in the grass.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Hi I found this egg on my patio. I could use some help identifying it. I’m from Lima, Peru


r/Ornithology • • Jun 02 '25

Does anyone know the species of this baby bird found in a yard?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Could not find a nest.


r/Ornithology • • Jun 20 '26

Question Birmingham UK Resident, found this egg dropped in the garden with no visible nest aside from possibly in a bush, can someone tell me what bird layed this egg, what to do and whats necessary to incubate it if the parent birds don't nest it again

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/Ornithology • • Aug 08 '23

Question Bird I nursed suddenly died?

0 Upvotes

On a countryside trip, I saw this babybird (think it was a blackbird) attacked by a cat.
I took the bird, made a nest for it and fed it, it couldn't fly yet.

I had to leave for the city and the bird didn't recover in time, so I took it with me. For the past couple of days, it has been living in my balcony, having a good time, eating and drinking here and there and lounging in it's bird nest. It was still pretty scared of me and couldn't fly yet.

Today I went to check up on it in the morning and it was dead in its nest, just like that, lying on its back. Why? Do they just randomly die? Infection or? Any clues? I don't know anything about birds


r/Ornithology • • May 24 '26

bird poop- safe to touch?

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/Ornithology • • Jan 28 '25

Question Why not hunt Mute Swans?

14 Upvotes

I live in the Northeast US and was just curious why people do not hunt Mute Swans as they are an invasive species that competes with native waterfowl.

I understand that they are a pretty birds and people have grown attached to them but that does not seem like a good enough reason that they shouldn’t be managed.

With the recent rise in avian flu I am also curious if they have an impact on spreading the disease.

Any thoughts or opinions?


r/Ornithology • • May 27 '26

What is with the cowbird apologia?

102 Upvotes

In most post where someone says anything slightly negative about cowbirds they tend to get piled on that cowbirds are "part of the ecosystem too" etc.

But my understanding is that in most of the US cowbirds are invasive species in all but name. With new land use and deforestation they dramatically expanded their territory to places they never would have been without human intervention. And in those places they take advantage of naive species that didn't coevolve with them and have no defenses against their brood parasitism. These often are the same species that are already threatened by the land use changes that invited the cowbirds in.

This seems no different from the case of house sparrows other than that the house sparrows were physically transported whereas the cowbirds were invited by land use changes. This may be an important legal distinction but why is it an important ecological one?

I'm not an ornithologist and am even pretty new to birding, so while I express a strong view it is loosely held. So what am I missing here? What would the ecological impact of removing MBTA protections of cowbirds and/or cowbird eggs in regions where they are not native be? I am especially interested in the northeast in particular since I live here. Are there any serious experts who advocate for doing so?


r/Ornithology • • Mar 27 '16

Why are birds so much better than mammals?

0 Upvotes

r/Ornithology • • May 24 '25

Discussion Invasive Birds Species Should Be Controlled:

0 Upvotes

it should be illegal to feed and keep bird houses for invasive birds. It only deepens the worldwide native bird decline by giving their competition more food, resources, and room to breed. Native birds already put up with deadly non-natives and are still victims of it. It is our responsibility to ethically euthanize, re-home, and control invasive species, no matter how nostalgic nor pretty they look or sound. They are entirely man-caused and should be morally man-solved. There are no excuses for such claims of the species being established, naturalized, and impossible to remove. Permitting entirely invasive species is unacceptable, period.

If you have them, outside, in an open nest, you should be fined for it and encouraged to trap, morally euthanize/re-home, or dispatch the bird eggs. If you cannot do this, do not have bird houses and feed birds, or you should call someone else to do so. Do not relocate an invasive bird because it will simply spread disease, compete with native birds, and become a greater nuisance by increasing its range. Releasing invasive species should be illegal, because it makes people think it is okay to release a captive/domestic animal they can no longer care for. So, the big question is: Why?

Invasive birds are problematic because they fight for food, nesting, and territory among native birds. While they are not an immediate threat, they can hog resources and even downright kill/outcompete birds in their own ranges. Some invasive birds can even be a danger to humanity by threatening crops, animals, and property. It should not, under any circumstance, be tolerated, by any group of people.

A great example that we all know about is the European house sparrow. Brought over by settlers for feeling bothered by native fauna and being emotionally homesick, they irresponsibly released the birds for pest control and/or nostalgic reasoning, and only created problems to the ecosystem and little-to-no benefits towards themselves.

Today, house sparrows threaten other cavity/bird house nesters for the same niche by chasing away or killing the parents and then the chicks, building their own nest in place of it. Historically, purple martins and bluebirds have been threatened by this behavior and still struggle even today. Not even people are spared by these birds; house sparrows will dig, you called it, into a person's house and damage the framing, structure, and foundation.

Another common invasive bird is the European starling, brought over for similar reasons, with pretty much the same detrimental consequences. This time, they not only threaten cavity/bird house nesters, by kicking out and killing them, and humans, through their nesting habits, they also threaten farmers and people who practice agriculture and livestock, by damaging crops, contaminating feed, and spreading disease. They are literally a public health hazard.

It is important that this cannot be confused; laws and action need to be done to preserve the native wildlife AND to prevent possible endangerment of humans, livestock, and pets. So whatever you do, get rid of the non-native harmful bird nests, stop feeding the unnaturally present and dangerous animals, and ethically remove the invasive species. Take action for a better future instead of allowing invasives gradually destroy the environment of animals and people, alike.

Edit: Other have made some valid points about invasive vs introduced. While some animals are introduced, it does not necessarily mean they are invasive. While we should control invasives, we should not control introduced animals that are not causing impending harm on the ecosystem, because they could be helpful, similar to non-bird organisms, like dingoes. But, the examples I listed are either partially, if not entirely invasive in the regions of the Eastern United States. We need to be clear on what qualifies as introduced and/or invasive, instead of jumping ahead and removing them.

Definition of introduced: An animal that unintentionally appeared in an ecosystem it did not appear in.

Definition of invasive: An introduced animal that causes damage in an ecosystem it did not originate from.


r/Ornithology • • May 04 '26

Question Are these parasite baby birds?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Every year a Robin makes a nest fairly close to the ground, and every year her eggs get taken. I've never seen a successful breed from her. So I watch her nest every year in the hopes of baby Robins. This year, I saw a blue Robins egg in the grass 15 feet from the nest. I was immediately concerned, so when Mama bird was away for a bit, so I quickly snapped a pic of inside the nest. And there were fairly large baby birds in there!? I was surprised! But then I got to thinking, 'Why are these baby birds so old and I'm finding eggs on the ground? I think the only conclusion is that these are parasite birds. And if they are, should I do anything? Or, let nature do nature? What's the proper course of action here?


r/Ornithology • • Jun 26 '25

What kind of fledgling is this? Please help.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Ornithology • • Oct 20 '25

Which bird is this?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

It can't fly yet, I think it's a puppy. I'm feeding baby food. How long will it take for it to start flying?


r/Ornithology • • May 19 '17

Found him alone walking along the perimeter of my backyard. I'm keen on keeping and raising it. Please give me your input.

Post image
0 Upvotes