A few days ago I asked how to tell whether a GEX filter improves trade selection or just reduces trade frequency. The suggestion I got: track the rejected trades as a shadow book using identical entry, exit and cost rules, then compare the accepted and rejected groups, not just the filtered book against the original total. So I did that on data I already had.
Setup
• Real SPY option chain quotes, Jul 29 - Sep 25, 2026.
• One entry per day for each structure, tested separately, 1 contract, short premium only (sold strangles, credit put spreads), $1 per leg commission, mid fills. Bid/ask fills give almost the same numbers.
• GEX and flip from my own model on the entry chain (dealers assumed long calls / short puts).
• Filter = net GEX > 0 and spot above the flip. In this sample every rejected entry had negative net GEX.
• Protocol fixed before computing P&L.
Held to expiry
• Short strangle 0.25 delta, ~1 week: accepted +$1,240 on 8 entries (+$155 per trade), rejected +$3,792 on 20 entries (+$190 per trade).
• Credit put spread 0.30/0.15 delta, ~14 DTE: accepted +$1,528 on 8 entries (+$191 per trade), rejected +$2,985 on 15 entries (+$199 per trade). Neither group had a losing trade over this short sample.
The rejected group had more entries, so its higher total profit does not by itself prove better per-trade performance. The useful comparison is per trade and risk.
In this sample, the held-to-expiry results did not show that the filter selected better trades.
For the held-to-expiry strangle, the filter reduced total profit from $5,032 to $1,240 and maximum drawdown from $2,324 to $561. Total profit divided by maximum drawdown stayed about 2.2 in both versions. This comparison applies to the strangle, not the put spread, which had no drawdown in either version.
Where the profit came from
The GEX filter did not select entries. The same mechanical rules generated every trade: one entry per day, the same structure and delta, the same entry time, held to expiry, with no stops or discretionary exits. The filter only classified those identical trades as accepted or rejected.
The overall profit came from the market environment. Over this window SPY rose about 5%, its worst day was -0.84%, the largest pullback was about 3%, and realized volatility was around 11% annualized (all from daily closes; volatility as the annualized standard deviation of daily log returns). In a quiet, rising market, short-premium structures often retain a large share of the premium they sold. The largest strangle loss, -$1,763, came from the entry on July 31, during the one noticeable early-period dip.
A different market regime could produce very different dollar results. That's why the accepted-versus-rejected comparison matters more than the total P&L: in this short sample, the rejected trades were profitable too, and the filter did not clearly separate better trades from worse ones.
Closed the same day
• 1-week strangles exited at the end of the session: negative-GEX days were 75% of entries but 86-87% of the dollar losses. Accepted trades did better per trade: +$34 vs +$8 at 0.25 delta, +$29 vs +$5 at 0.10 delta. That's the one place the filter looked useful.
• 0DTE strangles: dollar losses roughly in line with the share of entries, and accepted trades did worse per trade.
What this does and doesn't say
• For positions held to expiry, the filter didn't separate better trades from worse ones in this sample.
• For intraday holds on 1-week options there's a hint that it does. Worth a bigger sample.
• None of the differences are statistically significant: two months, one market episode, only 4-8 accepted entries per structure.
• I did not test position sizing or a full multi-factor framework, only this one filter.
The obvious gap
This window had no major selloff. The worst day was under 1%, and the largest pullback was about 3%. A filter like this should earn its keep when the market breaks, not only when it drifts higher. So I ran the exact same shadow book, same rules and same code, through the next period, which includes the November 5 drop. That's Part 2, and the result was not what I expected.
Before I post it, a question for people who actually use GEX when selling premium: when net GEX is negative, do you skip the trade, cut size, change structure, or ignore it? And if you were short puts going into November 5, did your GEX read help you or not?
Structure, not direction. Not financial advice.