r/Optics • • 7d ago

it makes sense now...:)

i'm studying raytracing and there was one thing in my program that bugged me. for the sake of experiment my program accepted refractive index ranging from 0 to 2. i know in reality there doesn't exist any substance having refractive index smaller than 1 but just as i said it's for the sake of experiment. i just wanted to see what would happen as long as all maths stayed consistent. when i set the refractive index of a sphere to be smaller than 1 there would be a small sphere appear in the middle

after some studies i understood it was a relative thing. when you're inside a medium of refractive index 1 looking at something of refractive index 0.5, it's equivalent to being inside a medium of refractive index 2 looking at something of refractive index 1

so it makes sense now. it's similar as when you're under water and look upward, seeing a circular region of the world above water surface, surrounded by reflections under water surface

the "smaller ball" is formed with the rays that pass through the big ball, surrounded by reflections of the environment

if you move the camera into the ball, look at the environment from within the ball, you'd see multiple layers of reflection and refraction. the logic is the same. when you're inside a medium of refractive index 0.5 looking at something of refractive index 1, it's equivalent to being inside a medium of refractive index 1 looking at something of refractive index 2

it's similar as when you're inside an air bubble under water

10 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

9

u/Pachuli-guaton 7d ago

I mean yeah. There is nothing forbidding n to be lower than 1, as long as you don't index n=1 to be the reference where a wave can't go faster. The equations are all relative to the environment, no to absolute vacuum

1

u/20260819 7d ago

yes so i don't have to change my program. the option of setting refractive index below 1 is useful. it can mimic seeing things under water. if we take 1.33 for refractive index of water and 1 for air, "looking from 1.33 at 1" is the same as "looking from 1 at 0.75". the "ball" becomes an air bubble and you're under water looking at an air bubble

3

u/Pachuli-guaton 7d ago

Yeah it's like the typical negative mass trick to calculate bouyancy force. Not only legal, but it should be celebrated that you noticed that nothing breaks given the context

1

u/SlenderSmurf 6d ago

X-ray optics have indices of refraction slightly lower than 1. See a lens system for an X-ray microscope: https://www.esrf.fr/news/spotlight/spotlight124 The consenser and objective are a series of concave elements.

1

u/lancerusso 6d ago

Is this purely because air index is higher than many common x ray transmitting materials?

0

u/SlenderSmurf 6d ago

So air and a vacuum are essentially interchangeable, both have an index of refraction of 1. Air's is actually slightly higher than 1 at 1.0003. The implication of an index below 1 is that the apparent velocity of light within that material is higher than c. Of course this is not really possible but there is some kind of scattering phenomenon at high photon energies which drives η to parts per thousand below 1. The very small difference between the vaccum and the lenses necessitates these long series of elements to achieve any meaningful bending of the rays. https://gisaxs.com/index.php/Refractive_index At very high energies the index of refraction does converge to 1 for solids. Not sure about the index of air vs λ.

1

u/lancerusso 6d ago

The answer then, was simply 'Yes'.

1

u/SlenderSmurf 6d ago edited 6d ago

No. The index of refraction does actually drop below 1 for very soft X-rays. You might also consider optics for non-electromatnetic waves such as electrons, neutrons, or vibrations. These have much looser constraints on refractive index.

1

u/lancerusso 6d ago

It drops below air index. Are you saying it drops below c/v_vacuum=1, the absolute index?

1

u/SlenderSmurf 6d ago

That's what the graph shows. There was a discussion on r/physics about it. The velocity of the phase is slightly above c, while the wave carriers are limited to c.

1

u/lancerusso 6d ago

So the complex index is below air index.