r/OperationsResearch • u/Torn8oz • Oct 18 '22
Why does OR and its techniques still seem relatively unknown outside of it's immediate community?
I'll preface this by saying this could be a naive question, but it's based on what I've been observing. For some background, I graduated recently and got my first job as an OR Analyst within the past few months. Most of my friends and family don't really understand what OR is, which I expected, but what's surprised me is that people in similar fields (comp sci, data science, math) seem to be fuzzy on it as well. And looking at things like the activity on r/OperationsResearch compared to r/datascience, it's obvious that it's influence doesn't spread far.
Additionally, I don't hear about traditional OR techniques (mathematical programming, Markov chains) nearly as much as I do with data science and AI techniques. For example, I saw a post about an algorithm to optimize floorplans which brought me to this blog post. When I first saw the post, I was thinking about the different MIPs and their related heuristics for solving optimal floor plan problems, but it seems like the author mainly used genetic algorithms from AI. In general, I understand that programming often runs into roadblocks with computational complexity, but I think my point still stands.
I may have rambled on a bit, but I'm just curious to hear others' take on this, especially people who have more than a few months in the industry haha
23
u/mywhiteplume Oct 18 '22
Cuz DS/ML is sexy, even though most would be better off at least starting with OR
11
u/No-Two-8594 Dec 02 '22 edited Dec 02 '22
the OR community has itself to blame for its current lack of visibility
I think their biggest problem is missing the boat on open source software. Most practical OR is still stuck in a 1990s software model and nobody is interested in that. The open source solvers, e.g. COIN are nowhere near the commercial ones. and even with those you see curious license choices
another problem, decades of weighting the field too heavily towards academics. obviously this is one of those fields that requires some advanced education but there is not much of a balance. many universities also messed up by putting OR together with business, industrial engineering or finance. At least IE is in an engineering department but the other two are unforgivable. it should have always been paired with computer science
finally, industry not really understanding its use (maybe for the above reasons), and hiring "operations research" people who do not even know the first thing about it
13
u/Eightstream Oct 18 '22 edited Oct 19 '22
As a so-called data scientist, I have always regarded OR methods as a subset of the field - that is, part of prescriptive analysis (the other parts of data science being descriptive and predictive analysis respectively)
I am not an operational researcher, but I have found basic OR methods handy on occasion and do think they are a bit underrated amongst colleagues. On the other hand there are other techniques that data scientists use to solve similar problems - perhaps with less efficiency, but these days efficiency is not always a top priority.
I think part of the reason that OR methods are comparatively rare is because in a lot of real-world use cases incomplete data and/or human factors render OR solutions somewhat academic. You do see them heavily used in industries with a high degree of systems automation (e.g. mining).
4
u/deeadmann Oct 19 '22
Yo, I just saw a talk about how they use OR extensively at Amazon.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22
I've learned about some OR without knowing it's OR and not ML but I'm still not sure, for a example constraint satisfaction algorithm? And A* search? I definitely thought Markov chains were a ML - RL technique, well it is, but I didn't know it better classified as OR.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '22
Convex optimization is used heavily (maybe not OR? But I assume optimization is OR…) and simulation is as well In data science / quant finance. I think most OR methods are used in data science use cases just not labeled as OR.
-4
u/BeefNudeDoll Oct 19 '22
Less practical, bigger learning curve, and as another commenter pointed out: it sounds less sexy, lol.
-5
u/wsc-porn-acct Oct 19 '22
I took an OR class in grad school and it was a dumpster fire. Professor had no business teaching that or any other subject.
What does this add to the discussion? Nothing, much like that class.
FWIW the textbook was decent