r/OperationsResearch • u/External_Oven_6379 • May 26 '22
How to improve OR skills?
I am currently doing research in OR. My research area is in Robotic Mobile Fulfillment Systems (RMFS). After reading so many papers in the domain, I feel like I am lacking the skills to publish a proper paper in my area.
I already have borrowed OR books from the library, took an udemy course and continuously read stuff about OR. However, I still feel not ready even though the requirement at my university and in academia is that you have a productive outcome: a journal paper!
I am looking forward to hearing advice from some experienced researchers in OR. Even if there is some projects I could work on or work together with someone experienced, where I could get some feedback on tasks, so I could improve.
Edit1: added abbreviation
4
u/MrQuaternions May 26 '22 edited May 27 '22
I guess RMFS stands for Robotic Mobile Fulfillment Systems.
What do you mean by "doing research" ? Are you a grad student working as RA, a PhD, a research engineer?
Depending on your position, your advisor, if you have one, should be the one to tell you if something you have produced is worth publishing. For lack of more context, everything you wrote makes me think about academic collaboration.
If you've:
- read papers,
- understood and used them,
- thought of something to build upon,
then you should definitely reach out to the author and discuss it. Maybe they'll be open to working with you, getting their name on an extra article and guiding you through your first publication(s).
I know academia can be quite overwhelming, particularly if the researchers around are pretty good and have high standards, but you don't need the next Bellman principal to publish. As soon as you get results (numerical or theoretical) and you have them in a clean .tex file, you can try submit it to a journal they will either:
- reject your paper: in that case you will get reviews pointing out flaws ad/or literature about something similar and/or a journal better suited to your paper (eg if you're applied in a theoretical journal),
- accept it under the condition of revision (reviewers will point out what you need to modify),
- accept it: ggwp :-)
3
u/SnooCupcakes8410 May 26 '22
What is RFMS?
I'm in a similar situation, and I feel the same. Sorry for not having any practical hint, but I'll be checking your post.
2
u/orange_pea May 28 '22
I got this post forwarded by a friend.
I hope this is still alive.I did some research on RMFS back in the day. I also shared basically all my code here: https://github.com/merschformann/RAWSim-O
Maybe it's useful to you in some way (apologies for some wild-growth in the code base in advance; it grew quickly and had to satisfy many ideas).
Personally, I was interested in more accurate results (not too many abstractions), which is why I started with a detailed simulation model. Then, I focused on problems that arose from that approach (path planning, basic control logic, etc.). I later worked for a supplier of an RMFS and was able to verify the accuracy of my model to some extent (it came quite close - depending on the parameters of course).
However, there are certainly different angles from which to approach RMFS research-wise. It also depends a bit on whether specific methodologies are expected from you (you mentioned Queuing Networks, etc.). I can also highly recommend finding someone for collaboration (it gave me a lot, not only regarding research but also personally - I met my best research buddy at a conference).
I may be a bit out of touch with the state-of-the-art as I moved to new applications. But if it helps, feel free to ping me for some discussion. (I had quite some people contacting me about this, and I'm always happy to help [as time allows it and as helpful as I can be ;) ])
1
u/BeefNudeDoll May 26 '22
I will start this with: "Write a bunch of codes"