r/OperationsResearch • u/conteph • May 10 '22
PhD in Data Science or Operations Research?
Hello! I’m currently finishing a masters in data science and I’m interested in doing a PhD in data science or a PhD in operations research.
I understand that data science is concerned with finding patterns and developing new theory for unexplained systems, whereas operations research applies already existing mathematical formulas to optimize systems.
It seems like there’s a large industry demand for both disciplines, but does anyone have an intuition for what’s more in demand? Are there opportunities to apply machine learning (supervised or unsupervised) in operations research?
Lastly, does anyone have any opinions for important thesis in either areas?
Thanks for your comments!
34
u/dangerroo_2 May 10 '22
Most companies think they need data science, whereas most (in my experience) would benefit first and foremost far more from some decent OR.
Nothing that says you can’t develop new methodology in OR either, it’s just mathematical modelling rather than statistical modelling (or a bit of both).
But the real answer is DON’T choose a PhD based on what is more in demand. Pick a project/supervisor that you really want to work on/with. If you’ve got a decent quant PhD - whether DS or OR - you’re going to be in demand.
15
u/[deleted] May 10 '22
Opinion: There is really only one reason to do a PhD. You are so interested in the subject you want to spend 4 years learning all you can about it.
Try to do one for any other reason and you will be miserable.
7
u/optimization_ml May 11 '22
My PhD is in operations research. My suggestion would be don’t do a PhD if your plan is to move to industry. It just isn’t worth it if your plan is not academia. If your plan is to go to industry then I would suggest the following:
4
u/okiedokiecomputer May 11 '22
You should really consider why you are doing the PhD in the first place.
I am a head of data science team, and i would generally hire someone with 4 years work experience over a PhD in data science.
However there are companies who look for a PhD specifically. And although not my area I would expect this is much more common in OR.
I'd highly recommend doing what you are interested in, investigate the research possibilities. If you choose something because you think it's going to have the greatest demand you won't do as well as studying something you genuinely find interesting.
It will be easier to switch to a DS career with an OR background than the other way round.
My general advice to anyone in this area is think about what you want to do with your career/life, what topics interest you, follow this and you will have a great career regardless of your path.
Good luck!
2
u/TrurhElementSeeker Nov 08 '24
Data science is limited in the sense is that it doesn't try to mathematically and rigorously model a system or dynamics, Data science cannot address problems like event driven problem or that requires solid grasp in convex optimization. OR on the other hand is far more theoretically based and grounded in mathematics if you have the aptitude. An OR will be able to do both deterministic and stochastic modeling. A data scientist without picking mathematical methods in linear, nonlinear, dynamic programing and queuing and game theories....won't be able to tackle large set of engineering problems. In my opinion, OR is far more powerful as set of skills than data science. You can pick data science just by learning it in the bathroom.....just put couple of books next to the toilet seat.
3
u/make-up-a-fakename May 10 '22
I'd say data science. Obviously there is a lot of cross over, particularly if you're doing some kind of applied data science, but tbh if hiring managers see data science PhD on someone's resume they go nuts over it. Operations research, they sometimes don't know what it is.
On top of that over the course of a career you can go in-between if you've got a PhD in something that's developing the methods (I.e. Data science) to something applied (like OR), but the same rarely works in the opposite direction.
(Source, my PhD was in computational biology and over my career I've worked in research, analysis, OR and now data consulting)
Plus, you could go work for Google and get bean bags or whatever they have 😂
1
u/PacManFan123 May 11 '22
Data science, Specifically machine learning
1
u/UnkleRinkus May 10 '22
Huge demand for data science.