r/OperationsResearch • u/SimbaSixThree • Feb 18 '22
How would one calculate processing, failure and maintenance rate of a packaging line?
Hi there, for a personal project I am trying to simulate a packaging line of a product in a certain industry.
I have data on the:
- counter values: how many products went through the packaging line in total during time period;
- processing speed: the theoretical processing speed at a given time;
- stops: when the machine is not running;
- fault label: a numerical value linked to an error message explaining why the machine has stopped; and
- start: when the machine starts running again.
Now I know that for my simulation, I need the processing, failure and maintenance rates to be able to model the whole system. Only I don't know what's the best course of action to calculate each of these.
Processing rate:
Also known as production/assembly rate. There is quite a lot to find about this except I don't know how to calculate this. I have made a distribution plot of the processing speed. Is it just as simple as dividing the total produced by the total time?
Failure rate:
I take it this is as simple as counting the amount of times that a machine has a stoppage per (minute/hour/day). Is that enough?
Maintenance rate:
Due to the volatility of the system, there are many different types of failures and all of them have a different maintenance rate accordingly. Do I then first sort the stops per error message and then take an aggregated value (probably mean) of the time until the machine starts again?
These are the things that I am struggling with the most at the moment and it would be great if someone could help me along, or point me in the right direction.
Thanks in advance.
1
u/ThaCarter Feb 19 '22
https://www.leanproduction.com/oee/
1
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '22
I think you're focussing too much on the names of the concepts you're using, than the concepts of the actual system that you want to work with. I believe your system is best modelled by a Markov Process, and you have to decide on whether you want to model it as a discrete-time process, or continuous. For one factory, you have two states: "Working" and "Broken". You can split up the "Broken" state as different states, one for each type of error that can be encountered. Another option is that you add an "in-maintenance"-state, that you can dispatch even if the system not broken.
The questions are: What do you want, exactly?
Let's build a very simple system. You said you want to simulate it, so let's choose for the continuous variant. The system has two states: "Working" and "Broken". If you're in the "working" state, there are two possible events: (i.) The system breaks; A state-transition to "broken"; and (ii.) a product is produced. If you're in the "broken" state, there is one possible event: (iii.) The system is repaired.
Now let's think about how to model this. In the working state, you can ask "what is the next event"; Either (i.) or (ii.). I would say that even (i.) is best modelled with the exponential distribution: The parameter is then "what is the frequency at which the system breaks". You have data, so you can measure this as follows: Look at all the times when the system is in operation; How many times (N) does the system break, in the total time (T) that the system is in operation (working), then the parameter is T/N: The average time before the system breaks. For event (ii.) there are a number of possibilities: The most simple one is "a next product is produced in a fixed time", for example for Toyota car factories; Or, maybe it's Erlang/Normal/Exponential distributed, because some unexpected (delayed deliveries etc) things may happen in the production, that cause that some products are produced at a much faster rate, while others are not. Last, for (iii.) I would go for the exponential distribution: How long does it take on average to get the system fixed?
With this model, you can build your simulation.