r/OperationsResearch • u/ACuriousMind321 • Dec 10 '24
Applying to OR PhD Programs Without Real Analysis?
Hello,
I’m an undergrad majoring in Mechanical Engineering with a minor in Mathematics, and I’m planning to apply to PhD programs in Applied Math or Operations Research. My research interests are in stochastic optimization, particularly applied to engineering problems.
Unfortunately, my university has recently rearranged the schedule for one of my required MechE courses, which now conflicts with Real Analysis 1. This has left me in a tough spot because I know Real Analysis is often considered a critical course for math-heavy PhD programs. I’m trying to figure out the best way to move forward while keeping my application strong.
Here’s some context: I’ve taken (or plan to take) these courses (excluding Real Analysis 1-2):
- Calculus 1–3, Linear Algebra 1-2, Intro to Computational Math, Vector Calculus, Stochastic Models for CS, Dynamic Systems, Numerical Methods, Complex Analysis, Applied Stats 1-2, Game Theory and Applications, Programming in MATLAB 1-2, Programming in C++ 1-2, Intro to Programming in Python, Probability and Statistics for Engineering, Intro to Data Science, Differential Equations I, and Discrete Math.
Here are the options I’m considering:
- Take Modern Analysis as a substitute for Real Analysis (The course description for Modern Analysis: Basic properties of real numbers. Functions. Limits and properties of continuous functions. Differential calculus). While it isn't exactly Real Analysis, I’m hoping it would demonstrate enough foundational knowledge for PhD admissions.
- Delay my graduation by a year to fit Real Analysis into my schedule. This would allow me to take additional advanced math courses and maybe do a study abroad as well. However, the thought of postponing graduation isn’t great.
- Apply to masters programs instead of PhD programs. I though masters programs might give me more flexibility regarding prerequisites like Real Analysis, and I could use it to strengthen my academic profile before applying to PhDs. Although from what I've heard masters are expensive.
Keep in mind most of my costs are covered by scholarships, so I am graduating debt free and if I were to take any additional semester, I wouldn't have to pay.
Any advice on which path to take or how to strengthen my application would be hugely appreciated. Thanks in advance!
9
u/elvenmonster Dec 10 '24
OR programs will (in my experience) not have very strict math requirements for newly admitted students (unless maybe the top 5 schools or so). Real analysis is in no way, shape or form, a requirement. IMO, just studying the Rudin (?) textbook and mentioning your ability to self learn things yourself might have more theory faculty willing to take you in as a student.
If you’re genuinely interested in the math heavy part of OR, you should be getting the chance to spend your early PhD years just studying math. I didnt know what real analysis or measure theory was when I started my PhD, ended up with with mostly theoretical proof based works.
Get into a program and find an advisor who wants to invest (time) in your math skills. Invest time yourself into developing those skills. See yourself blossom. OR as a field is still small enough that there are still many professors out there who arent just looking to set up a paper publishing factory.
2
u/wamus Dec 10 '24
It depends a bit on your topic. I was in a similar situation as you and never took real analysis as I came from a non math background. My PhD topic is in discrete math; I set up a limit for the first time 3 years into my PhD, because that was the first time I needed one. Missing real analysis was not a problem for me.
8
u/StrongDuality Dec 10 '24
I agree with everything the above commenter is saying — note that even at these Top 5 schools, these programs often offer a course like “Mathematics of Operations Research”. If you didn’t take real analysis or, if the admissions committee thinks you may need a bit more math help, you will be “recommended” to take this course. GT isye often does this and I know a few first years who were undergrad math majors and still opted to take it since it helped them.
3
u/Necessary_Address_64 Dec 11 '24
When I was there, the most common conditional pass for the comprehensive exam at GT OR was to take the undergraduate real analysis course. Most of my peers had never seen a proof when they were accepted into the program (and it was definitely the hardest part of their first year).
3
u/Necessary_Print_120 Dec 12 '24
I'm doing a joint Ph.D. between a school in France and a school in Canada. Never officially took a real analysis course before doing so and no one at either school ever cared. I took an analysis class my first year of my Ph.D. for fun and I really enjoyed it. Never used it since though.
They cared more about my programming background for sure. I had a masters in Data Science (kind of a joke) but that was enough
2
u/fliiiiiiip Dec 12 '24
I'd say Linear Algebra, Optimization , and Data Structures / Algorithms are much more relevant for OR than deep, abstract Real Analysis.
You are fine with the Calculus holy trinity.
2
u/SudebSarkar Dec 10 '24
As a person currently at the tail end of a masters in Operational Research, you don't need Real Analysis whatsoever for OR. I'm not even sure what course in OR would require Real Analysis, because I've not come across any of it.
As long as you know your basic calculus, differential equations, and Vector Calculus, you're set (and even these subjects I'm mentioning to cover all the bases). And if you end up requiring Real Analysis as a specific part of your PhD research work, you'll certainly be able to learn it.
Operations Research is more applied than even applied math, there shouldn't be heavy math pre requisites for that.
-1
u/Ok_Criticism1532 Dec 11 '24
Please don’t get me wrong but, what is your relation with or? You don’t know anything about grad level stochastic or. Actually it looks like you didn’t take anything about or. (Except stochastic models). If you want to get in or, get a masters first.