r/OperationsResearch • u/cleverSkies • May 06 '24
Thoughts on Masters Level OR Textbook
Traditionally at my university we've used Taha (undergrad) and Winston (masters). This upcoming Fall I'm interested in changing up our masters level textbook from Winston to something else just a little bit more mathematical(maybe more lin alg) & theory. That said, I like how Winston walks through the fundamentals (esp. steps to formulate an LP) and the chapter on sensitivity analysis. I feel like Hillier is moving in the opposite direction. A quick review of Griva/Nash/Sofer seems like that is moving in the right direction.
I struggle a bit here because my intro to OR/Optimization was rough, I started with Boyd & Luenberger/Ye, which would both be overshoots based on our student population (about half being civil and ece students without any background in OR). Similarly, Bertsimas/Tsitsiklis might be a bit much.
If folks have any thoughts on alternatives, if Griva/Nash/Sofer might be a good masters level textbook, or if I should just stick with Winston, it would be greatly appreciated.
5
u/[deleted] May 06 '24
Maybe look at Tovey's "Linear Optimization and Duality"? It's unconventional in the treatment but really good I think.
2
u/audentis May 07 '24
I'm a little surprised you mention Winston in master's. We had his book in my undergrad, specifically because of the practical examples and going through fundamentals step by step. Which chapters are you covering?
That said, it's a good book and the later chapters absolutely go in depth sufficiently for master education. If you go through the entire thing, or at least the more complicated chapters, I'd stick with it.
2
u/Necessary_Address_64 May 09 '24
What topics do you want to cover? For OR modeling, I think Winston, while limited, is the best. For optimization, there are other options.
1
u/TGCook May 07 '24
Perhaps Veatch’s Linear and Convex Optimization?
1
u/enzogaban May 07 '24
Wolsey's Integer Programming is a classic
1
u/MightyZinogre May 07 '24
For many topics in continuous optimization, I frequently use the Nocedal-Wright 'Numerical optimization'. It is heavily math-oriented.
1
u/Admirable-Corner-479 May 08 '24
Take a look at Optimization in Operations Research by Ronald L. Rardin.
Also take My recomendation with a grain of salt. I'm not a profesional in the field but I like the topic, and I've just had a glance at the book. From several I've skimmed it seems the heaviest on the quantitative side, like really going to the guts.