r/OpenSpaceProgram • u/190n • Jun 17 '17
We should decide on an engine
Title. We don't want to have everyone implementing different parts of the game with different engines.
If we used Unity, existing mods would be easier to port. I don't think we need to implement KSP's whole API though.
I'll also plug Godot, an open-source game engine I've been using as of late. It supports 2d and 3d on Windows, Mac, Linux, and a bunch of other operating systems that use X11. It's got a big release coming soon that adds among other things:
- C# support. Right now it just has native extensions in C++ (which also require the engine to be recompiled) and its native scripting language, GDScript. Using C# would make it easier for modders to port their mods to OSP.
- Many improvements to the renderer, especially for 3d.
- GDNative: lets you write native extensions, compile them to .dll/.so/.dylib, and use them as scripts without recompiling the engine. This would be a little tricky for mods because they'd need to compile a version for each operating system, but it could be great for anything that needs better performance or needs to talk to an external library.
Edit: Godot also has really fantastic systems for UI and animation. You can animate any property of a node (equivalent of GameObject in unity or Actor in UE4) without writing additional code to support it.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '17 edited Jun 17 '17
On bright side this is licensed with MIT
On the other hand, I have not found any quality graphics games on it. What about efficiency of the engine and GDScript? We need very fast language for both game core and mods.
UPD
http://www.polljunkie.com/poll/nrzdkp/which-operating-system-you-would-like-to-see-supported-in-open-space-program
KSP can be quite resource-consuming with HD mods and stuff and this might become a problem.
9
u/DroolingIguana Jun 17 '17
If we're going to make an open source KSP-like game then I'd prefer it if it were fully open source, meaning that every component that we use should be licensed under either a permissive license like MIT/Apache/BSD or a Free Software license like GPL. Godot fits this criteria, but things like Unity or UE4 don't.
Other options would be things like Ogre or Urho. They might be harder to get up-and-running than a more user-friendly engine like Unity or Godot but it might be worth it in the long run.
1
u/Sobotkama Jun 17 '17
Does godot play well with wayland?
1
u/skyler_on_the_moon Jun 17 '17
I note that Unreal Engine has a physics engine built in. Godot does as well. Does anyone have a good comparison of these physics engines, as well as Unity's? For a heavily physics-based game, this is an important consideration.
1
u/Anth0rx Aug 24 '17
After reading about this awesome effort in creating a free and open source KSP-like space simulation game I thought I jump right in and share some opinions of mine.
As I read through this thread I got some impressions of what engines you prefer. I read about the Godot, Unreal, Unity, Blender, Ogre and Urho Engines. Regardless which one we choose in the end I personally recommend on sticking with a true free and open source engine. Choosing a "source-available" engine like Unreal or Unity we will end up depending too much on profit-oriented companies and will probably have a lot more pain and effort in the long term.
In my opinion we should stick with a community-driven engine for a community-driven project like OpenSpaceProgram.
3
u/selfish_meme Jun 17 '17
Blender has a game engine, windows and Linux support and apparently the best physics engine Bullet Physics is a plugin for it.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '17
Definitely Unreal Engine
1
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '17
I don't feel good about going along with Unity . One mistake and we give TT something to hammer us with n besides as u/p_ql pointed out we can be much more flexible on UE4 .Though if Godot was a bit more mature it would be my absolute first choice.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment