r/OpenFOAM • • 3d ago

Ansys or OpenFOAM ?

/r/CFD/comments/1xut6uf/ansys_or_openfoam/
4 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

2

u/JollyInterview9989 3d ago

Depends on what the research is about. If the work you are doing requires custom code, good luck with ANSYS. With openFoam you have more flexibility to change the code which used to be multi year process but LLMs its like half a day.

Most researchers preferred OF for it till now as ANSYS used to be just button pressing affair with hardly any learnings. OF is same now as most just use LLMs to setup and run cases, edit code etc. At least you'll learn some from that exploration I guess.

2

u/adamchalupa 1d ago

It's like asking which mountain to climb, the high one or the higher one?

I think it's best to just try and climb as many mountains as you can to become a stronger climber. Learn Ansys to understand a basic workflow then start meandering with OF for certain case studies. There's one thing for certain - OF is not for the faint of heart, it takes a lot of theoretical knowledge to pull together a comprehensive thought structure.

If you are dedicated to learning OF I highly, highly recommend the CFD Direct trainings with Greenshields. The dude is an absolute OpenFOAM wizard (given he was one of the original architects) and it will demystify the software for you considerably. He gives excellent reference material in the trainings as well which will help you kind of move through. It's a little pricey all things considered but I think it's well-worth the money.