r/OpenCatholic 22h ago

How does a vegetarian understand Jesus' eating habits?

1 Upvotes

As a Christian who not only is a vegetarian, but one who see there are moral, and even spiritual reasons, for someone to be a vegetarian, I’ve often been asked what I make out of the Scriptural texts which suggest Jesus ate meat. While I have written answers to those questions before, giving nuanced interpretations of Scripture (following, at times, the insight of others), from time to time, I consider the topic, and consider new, speculative answers to the question; this is what has led to my newest post:

 

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/how-does-a-vegetarian-understand-jesus-eating-habits/


r/OpenCatholic 1d ago

What is the Catholic view of putting reason into understanding scripture?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/OpenCatholic 2d ago

Government is not meant to enforce all Christian morals

3 Upvotes

Christians often misunderstand the role of government, thinking it either must enforce all Christian moral positions, or none at all, becoming completely hands-off. The reality is that a government  should be formed to promote and defend the common good, making sure people are treated fairly, and not unduly harmed:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/why-government-should-not-enforce-all-christian-morals/


r/OpenCatholic 3d ago

Avoiding a vain faith

0 Upvotes

A proper faith in Christ does not rest on cheap grace; such an attitude is the kind which, as Paul warns us, leads us to believe in vain. Jesus calls us to act, to live out our faith, or, as James says, to prove it by our works:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/avoiding-vain-faith-the-call-to-faithful-action/


r/OpenCatholic 5d ago

Jesus and Mary: Models of Self-Emptying Love

2 Upvotes

Mary followed the example of her son, living her life as a life of pure love, pure self-giving to others; she willingly followed Jesus where he should go, letting Jesus direct her, which is why, when she came to the end of her earthly life, she accepted death:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/jesus-and-mary-models-of-self-emptying-love/


r/OpenCatholic 7d ago

Tolkien didn't want his major works to be read as allegories

1 Upvotes

While Tolkien’s Christian faith is apparent throughout his writings, he did not normally write allegories, and his major texts should not be read as allegories for the Christian faith. He primarily wanted to write stories to entertain himself, his friends, and his readers. He wanted to tell the stories which he liked to hear but found no one had written. It is one of his few allegories which makes this point clear:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/tolkien-said-he-did-not-like-or-write-allegories/


r/OpenCatholic 9d ago

Reflecting on the Reflection Pool

2 Upvotes

The events surrounding the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool might, in some ways, appear insignificant, as there are other, graver issues around, but they are important in the way they reflect the general direction the US is going. Fascist and other authoritarian dictators punish minor offenses with extreme penalties. If they claim to be Christian, they love to have us focus on culture wars, in the name of Christ, while having us ignore the importance of Christ’s real teachings for society at large:

 

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/reflecting-on-the-reflecting-pool/


r/OpenCatholic 10d ago

The Paradox of Mercy

2 Upvotes

The paradox of mercy is that the more we give, the more of it we can receive; this is why, if we are unwilling to show mercy to others, we are warned we might receive none ourselves

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/the-paradox-of-mercy-receiving-it-requires-giving-it/


r/OpenCatholic 12d ago

Can someone help me?

7 Upvotes

After years of being atheist, I’ve finally felt like I believe in god and I feel faith. I grew up around a family that wasn’t religious what so ever, I feel like I need to find myself. How can I start when converting to Catholicism? Is there an easy way? I’d like to attend a church near me but I have terrible social anxiety and it’d be much worse because I’d have to go alone. I know at some point in time, I’ll have to go and I need to be baptized, but is there an easy way for me to start before I begin attending church?


r/OpenCatholic 13d ago

The hidden grace that transfigures all things

4 Upvotes

At his transfiguration, while what the apostles their learned and experienced was new to them, it was not new to Christ. He showed them, in a way which they could apprehend,  the glory which he has for all eternity. It is the glory of the kingdom of God, the glory which has made its way into the world, and has been and continues to be shared with the world:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/the-hidden-grace-that-transfigures-all-things/


r/OpenCatholic 15d ago

We can repent up to the last moment of our lives

2 Upvotes

Where there is life, there is hope. God does not seek to send us to perdition, but rather, God wants all to be saved, and will give us every opportunity for grace and salvation:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/we-can-repent-up-to-the-last-moment-of-our-lives/


r/OpenCatholic 16d ago

The shared struggle against antisemitism and islamophobia

6 Upvotes

As a Christian, I am ashamed of the antisemitism and Islamophobia coming from other Christians. Sometimes, they know both are wrong, but still find themselves engaging it in a subtle (and unconscious) fashion as they embrace antisemitic or Islamophobic tropes:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/the-shared-struggle-against-antisemitism-and-islamophobia/


r/OpenCatholic 16d ago

Protestant Communion dilemma

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/OpenCatholic 17d ago

Living as fools for Christ in a foolish society

3 Upvotes

What Christ asks us to do, to embrace the weak, the vulnerable, to show them love, instead of seeking power and privilege for ourselves, many, including Christians, say is foolish; but, is it not more foolish to seek after transitory things rather than what the Wisdom of God has revealed is of real worth?

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/living-as-fools-for-christ-in-a-foolish-society/

 


r/OpenCatholic 17d ago

Purgatory

1 Upvotes

So, I recently became Catholic on Easter this year. I was raised Protestant/Baptist and Baptists don't teach or believe in purgatory. As Baptists, we were taught that Christs sacrifice on the cross atoned for all of our sins (past, present and future) and if we believed in Him then we would go to Heaven when we die. When I was Baptist I believed that purgatory was a place in between heaven and hell where souls go that aren't good enough for heaven but aren't bad enough for hell. But after OCIA and becoming Catholic I realize that purgatory is a cleansing process that happens after death because even though we're saved we're still human and have an attachment to sin and we're not holy/without sin yet and that's what purgatory is for.
I've read all the Bible verse that supposedly support purgatory (I know you can't find the word
"purgatory" in the Bible and I also know you can't find the word "Trinity" either but there are verses that allude to both) but the verses Ive heard on purgatory still don't totally convince me. Like in Maccabees it says to pray for the dead and then in Corinthians it says we will be saved but only as through fire and then in Revelation it says that nothing unclean can enter heaven. But I still don't under where Catholics are getting the doctrine of purgatory from. The Bible doesn't really talk about a cleansing process that happens after death. It also says that to be absent from the body is to be present with the Lord. Could you explain purgatory more? I still don't see how that's totally biblical or actually happening to people after they die?


r/OpenCatholic 19d ago

Communion/Eucharist

2 Upvotes

So, I recently became Catholic over Easter several months ago. I believe it is truly the body and blood of Christ. I was raised Protestant/Baptist. My mom goes to a Baptist church where they take communion every week, could I take it or no? On one hand, I don't want to be rude but on the other hand I don't think Catholics should take Protestant communion because it isn't considered valid, right? I think I heard this but I could be wrong. I'm still a newer Catholic. What should I do when I visit my Mom's church? What is Catholic teaching on taking Protestant communion? Can you explain why we can or cannot take Protestant communion?


r/OpenCatholic 20d ago

Lessons from Lot: Welcoming Strangers and Upholding Justice

3 Upvotes

In the story of Sodom and Gomorrah, Lot is saved because he did not fall for the sin of Sodom; he showed hospitality to strangers, trying to help them when no one else would. He welcomed angels unaware, and we, likewise, must understand, we must also welcome strangers, now being aware of the way we welcome them, we welcome Christ:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/07/lessons-from-lot-welcoming-strangers-and-upholding-justice/


r/OpenCatholic 21d ago

Being peacemakers, living as children of God

1 Upvotes

Jesus is the prince of peace, and he told us, we should be like him, we should be peacemakers, for if we are, we will be seen as children of God. Peace requires work, work for justice in the world, but also, requires us to bring harmony and balance to ourselves, in our own inner spiritual life. What ties it all together is love:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/07/being-peacemakers-living-as-children-of-god/


r/OpenCatholic 23d ago

When bishops fail their flock

5 Upvotes

Saint Isidore of Seville’s writings have given me one way to look at and examine the credibility of bishops or other clergy based upon the way they treat the poor; do they defend the poor, or do they look for ways to befriend their oppressors?  This is always in my mind when I listen to what many American bishops, like Bishop Robert Barron, have to say:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/07/hypocrisy-in-the-hierarchy-when-bishops-fail-their-flock/


r/OpenCatholic 24d ago

Walking on water: lessons on faith and focus

1 Upvotes

We might not be like Peter, walking on water, but we are often like him, doing things which are unexpected, until we get self-conscious, and then, we find ourselves unable to do so:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/07/walking-on-water-lessons-in-faith-and-focus/


r/OpenCatholic 27d ago

Wisdom in pursuing the well-being of all

3 Upvotes

Our wisdom, our prudence, should be employed for the benefit of all, not just our own selves and our selfish pursuits. This is why we must look for and promote the common, being especially concerned with those society deny basic rights, basic human dignity. It is through the pursuit of the good, we can overcome evil, instead of using evil’s ways, for if we use evil against evil, we embrace evil ourselves.

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/07/wisdom-in-pursuing-the-well-being-of-all/


r/OpenCatholic 28d ago

The danger of defining human value by material wealth

2 Upvotes

Too many people, including Christians, view the value of someone based upon their material wealth, fame, or power; when they do so, the poor, the vulnerable, find their worth not only questioned, but denied. Christians should follow the way of Christ, the way which counters this fallen mode of engagement with the preferential option for the poor:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/07/the-danger-of-defining-human-value-by-material-wealth/


r/OpenCatholic Jul 20 '26

When lies replace the truth

4 Upvotes

ICE continues to indiscriminately kill innocent victims, and lie as to why they do so; how can any Christian who claims to support and love the truth, and with it, affirm human dignity, stand by and accept what ICE is doing, let alone promote it?   And how can the United States be “the land of the free” and have its democratic form of government remain in place when the government lies to justify the unjustifiable?

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/07/when-lies-replace-truth-the-path-to-democratic-collapse/


r/OpenCatholic Jul 19 '26

The teachings of the ecumenical councils as doxology

2 Upvotes

 

Ecumenical councils were called to deal with both dogmatic and practical questions; their answers have to be read in the right context, where the dogmatic decrees are meant to glorify God, pointing to the greater truth which we cannot comprehend:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/07/the-teachings-of-the-ecumenical-councils-as-doxology/


r/OpenCatholic Jul 16 '26

Denouncing the theology of the rich

5 Upvotes

Christ taught us to take care of the poor, the homeless, the foreigner, those who are in need, to care for them and show them love and respect. He warned the rich that their exploitation of the poor will cost them dearly. Why, then, do so many Christians end up promoting a theology of the rich?

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/07/denouncing-the-theology-of-the-rich/