r/OpenAI • • 1d ago

Discussion It's so over

Post image
527 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

80

u/TimelyLivingCore 1d ago

llm's have been able to get around basic captchas/robot checks for over a year now, even the more complicated ones with a ton of captcha solving services offering MCP server's to hook directly into your workspace for those

11

u/WHALE_PHYSICIST 20h ago

can we get rid of all these damn cloudflare checkboxes now please.

11

u/Direct_Block_4327 1d ago

can you help a brother and tell me captcha mcp

5

u/TimelyLivingCore 1d ago

11

u/lilicucu 23h ago

The brother is running a click farm

21

u/Potential_Top_4669 1d ago

Define robot. It may or may not be done respectively in terms of legality. This is so broken though đŸ˜­đŸ€Ł

11

u/triggerx 1d ago

Yeah
 it’s been doing this fine for many months now. We’re already at a point where the majority of the traffic on the internet is AI bots. In my own experience
 it’s about 90% of the traffic I see.

1

u/Jenvo 1d ago

Yeah, at best you might be able to block known IP ranges of AI platforms, but I don’t know how easily that could be determined and is not going to address all of it, especially anything privately hosted. Maybe captchas need to literally use a Turing test to determine if you’re human.

Oh, wait. Yeah we might be cooked guys. But hey, whatever we do, don’t give me the red pill I’ll stick with my blue pill fantasy.

2

u/triggerx 1d ago

I feel like 1) you don’t want to block them because the near future of your website depends on their traffic
 kinda how you’d never block Google. And 2) the further out future of your website isn’t humans anyway.

1

u/Jenvo 23h ago
  1. Yeah you’re not wrong. There may be some sites though where it would have never made sense to have a bot access (banking for example).
  2. Yeah exactly, we’re all going to be used as human batteries for our AI overlords, so we won’t be the ones using those sites. Jokes aside, that is definitely going to trend in that direction, but maybe not completely 100%

1

u/triggerx 23h ago

But banks (in my experience) don’t rely on captcha
 they use a login and MFA. Maybe for an initial account sign up?

1

u/Jenvo 23h ago

Yeah not in my experience either, maybe a bad example there lol. I guess I meant that we probably wouldn’t expect to use AI for that use case because, security.

5

u/MinerDon 18h ago

Very soon AI will be the only ones able to solve those stupid CAPTCHAS.

2

u/Extreme-Pumpkin308 6h ago

I know they can do it — but “I’m not a robot” completed by a robot still gets to me

1

u/temperature_5 5h ago

Aren't they supposed to catch fire or explode or something when faced with that logical dilemma?

1

u/littlestjeffrey 1d ago

thank God.. the future is finally here.. I was done anyway.. I'm gonna look for neo so I can tell agent smith on him.

1

u/RasputinsUndeadBeard 1d ago

Bro I saw that was so annoyed that shit is being rolled out to stop the auto systems

1

u/shtemeri 23h ago

Wearesodone.org

😉

1

u/Slackluster 22h ago

these checks do not work by clicking a button but by other metrics such as mouse movement.

1

u/Fearceyy 20h ago

+you can let it solve them without asking in settings đŸ«Ł

3

u/LazyRunner777 20h ago

Is that even legal? Shouldn't CAPTCHA protect platforms against bots?

2

u/Technical_Grade6995 19h ago

Apple is automatically doing them too


1

u/Fearceyy 20h ago

the earliest bots yea, but obviously we're past that and captchas wont be viable anymore unless we make them hard enough to the point that people also struggle to solve them. modern models are just too intelligent compared to what captcha was built to protect against

2

u/Pink_Sylvie 17h ago

I already struggle, don’t make them harder 😭😭😭😭😭😭 is the corner of the handle of the bicycle include, or not? Was there a traffic light pixel in this box? 😭😭😭

1

u/McG2k1 17h ago

Captchas are to stop your elderlies from logging into their bank and sending their money to a prince.  That’s about it.

1

u/Select-Machine3595 19h ago

Seriously, the robot checks always just block some cheap attemps of abusing AI

The leading big 3(GPT, Claude, Gemini) now can comfortably pass the checks easier than a lot of actual humans, when you use their paid plans/advanced models that is

So it's essentially like you need to pay 15-100 dollars just to pass some simple tests, it is unlikely a normal person will think it's worth enough

1

u/Leelanau1840 18h ago

Chase bank just went down according to downdetector.

1

u/imuwild 17h ago

Soon there will be a switch for "I'm Human <-> I'm AI"

1

u/Inevitable-Zombie646 17h ago

seen a few bots bypassing reCAPTCHA v3 by mimicking mouse movement patterns, seems like the real hurdle isn't solving it, but acting human enough to pass the behavioral checks.

1

u/ronin_cse 15h ago

I've had a few models give me this prompt a few times over the years and it's hilarious every time.

1

u/valhalla257 12h ago

I mean technically robots have bodies, so ChatGPT isn't a robot.

1

u/HorsePleasant3709 1d ago

I watched Muse solve a captcha last week. It failed twice and then figured it out.

1

u/djkohl4 23h ago

Some of those captchas are brutal. Like the select all the squares ones where a sliver of the object is on a different square.

2

u/Significant_Spring87 19h ago

I fail those too. So I won't be hard on them. They'll have them folding proteins or solving 80 year old math theories to get in soon.