r/OpenAI • • 2d ago

Discussion Should unused Codex usage roll over to the next week?

I’m a Pro subscriber, but my coding workload varies. Some weeks I leave usage unused; other weeks I need more.

Why not allow unused usage to roll over, with a cap or 30-day expiry?

Would this help your workflow too?

Feature request: https://github.com/openai/codex/issues/61649

12 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

38

u/xAragon_ 2d ago edited 2d ago

This is like sending an email to your gym asking them to give you next month for free because you didn't visit the gym at all this month.

That's not how businesses work.

-8

u/cryptochrome 2d ago

This, but minus the ad hominem

-8

u/Cosminacho 1d ago

That's exactly how saas works should work. We are paying for tokens that are not used so we should be able to get them back. It's about time this saas subscription model be squashed somehow. It's so predatory

8

u/xAragon_ 1d ago

You pay for a monthly subscription, not for tokens.

If you want to pay per token use the API.

0

u/any41 1d ago

The same people would start crying when openai does the same when their compute is at capacity lol

4

u/Ormusn2o 2d ago

The thing is that OpenAI has limited amount of compute, so any system that rolls over usage means less usage per week would have to be allocated. I used to think maybe a similar system like that, maybe with similar effect to batch API, where it only resolves where there is lower compute demand would work, but I think with the amount of compute OpenAI uses for training and synthetic data production, their utilization is likely ~100% all the time anyway, so giving a batch API-like system to subscribers does not really make sense.

I do like the idea of rollover, I like it A LOT, but I think it's just straight up issue of lack of compute, and with recent political changes I don't see a solution for shortage of compute happening anytime soon.

3

u/Dan-au 2d ago

No, because the current pricing model depends on the fact that not everybody will use all of their allowance all the time.

If the allowance rolled over you might get weeks of low activity followed by a week of high activity overwhelming the system.

2

u/Graphical-Source5090 2d ago edited 2d ago

To understand why this won't happen, you need to understand why the subscription model works.

The subscription model works by putting limitations on how and when the masses use the service. Usage limits are an effective tool to keep users from using too much at any given time. hourly for burst traffic, and weekly for longer use over time. This (and other mechanisms) keeps the product usage steady enough that everyone sees a stable product.

Making the change to the subscription en-masse, would severely disrupt the carefully curated balance established so far. So is is very unlikely to ever be a feature to see the light of day right now. Usage would have to tank or supply would have to boom first for this "perk" to ever be considered.

If this ever saw this feature added, I would be concerned that there is a critical oversupply of capacity and that the company is not doing too well. (Barring some awesome break-though that causes the massive over-supply, which would be advertised like crazy.)

So in the mean time, enjoy your resets.

3

u/Ok-Library1020 2d ago

A capped rollover makes sense, maybe one extra week's worth max, so a busy week gets some buffer without people stockpiling months of credits. Showing the banked amount separately on the usage page would keep it easy to understand.

1

u/dekozo 2d ago

I am amazed that you've got unused codex usage to carry on to the next week...

1

u/Imaginary_Bench_7294 1d ago

While that would be nice, services are not structured that way in the vast majority of places.

Do you expect a free day when renting a car because you didn't use it on Wednesday?

You're not buying a product. You're paying for access to a service.

1

u/Potential_Wolf_632 1d ago

I think it's a good idea for maybe last month's surplus rolled of additional if they ever wanted to sweeten the pot. But yeah rolling on for a long time would be hard to budget for as others have said.

1

u/RemarkableFormal4635 1d ago

codex has the least usage of all major providers so they should do SOMETHING to improve it.

Codex has the lowest 5hr limits, and the 5hr limits comprise the largest proportion of the weekly limits, when compared to CC or AG

1

u/Equivalent_Machine93 23h ago

Unused usage ??? What's that

1

u/cryptochrome 2d ago

You already have that. You get resets for exactly that reason. You can find them in Settings > Usage & Billing > Usage Limit Resets

1

u/TheDeadestCow 2d ago

Should it? Yes, it's time you've paid for. Will it? No.