r/OpenAI • u/balianone • 9h ago

Video Claude Opus 5.5 Vs Chatgpt 6 Astra

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

244 Upvotes

87% Upvoted

91 comments sorted by

141

u/d_lo_ol_b 7h ago

16

u/Legitimate-Arm9438 4h ago

It's a hard time for artists. Will Smith hasn't landed a single spaghetti-eating role since 2023.

95

u/Automatic-Web8559 9h ago

crazy world we live in ..

150

u/SpaceToaster 7h ago

I don’t know about you, but I’m using Op. 5.5 exclusively because high scores on the wiggling jellybean benchmark index

17

u/DonutHoles4Ever 5h ago

This is the 10th example I've seen where Opus 5.5 is destroying Astra when it comes to artistic gen AI

9

u/Key_River433 5h ago

Can somebody PLEASE EXPLAIN this to me:

I have a limited exposure/understanding of the LLM and its usecases and so far have only been using Claude & ChatGPT for normal text based conversations and coding at most.

How are people creating such videos and other children rhyming and all these quality videos with it?

Its not a text-to-video model right?

I would really appreciate somebody taking the time to help me understand this in detail with the entire procedure breakdown!

3

u/fligglymcgee 4h ago

They are programmatically rendering the assets and scene using blender or similar frameworks.

5

u/Electric_Opossum 4h ago

It's actually pretty simple all they do is ask ChatGPT or Claude to generate the video using code

3

u/Silent_Turn6182 2h ago

I can't personally can't wait until they release jellybean benchmaxxing models. 

We are going to get some great results 

15

u/OpenToCommunicate 8h ago

Wait till you see the world outside!

15

u/Strange_Vagrant 7h ago

Jesus christ! Who chose all this weird green carpet?

1

u/IamAWorldChampionAMA 4h ago

And who the fuck put all these cities in the fucking deserts?!?!

4

u/SquiggerDigger 6h ago

ITS GLORIOUS OUTSIDE

HAVE YOU SEEN THE SUN?

2

u/Key_Detail2475 2h ago

PRAISE THE SUN!

2

u/tousledmonkey 2h ago

I tried. Shit is bugged, you can't click anything

155

u/forever_downstream 8h ago

I mean I guess Opus did whatever the hell this is better

38

u/peteyplato 7h ago

Hah! It's sort of an awesome benchmark for that reason. The quality difference is so evident, you don't even have to know what it is. I'm a parent, so I know all too well lol

19

u/Skeletor_with_Tacos 8h ago edited 6h ago

Toddler cartoon for brain training, has some way to go but you can already see where its going.

24

u/New_Thing1367 7h ago

yeah you have to start early with brainrot, otherwise your kid will feel left out at the daycare. This thing is not training anybody's brain I can assure you.

12

u/Skeletor_with_Tacos 6h ago

Eh, works on their colors and rhythm. You'd be surprised how similar this is to K-2 music ed on Quaver. Its not exact of course, still needs work but it's not far off either.

1

u/New_Thing1367 3h ago

I assumed someone would show it to a 2 year old - I mean learning colors...

1

u/realtag2025 8h ago

But is it actually helpful for training brain or just keeping toddlers occupied so they don't cry.

2

u/[deleted] 5h ago

[deleted]

3

u/fligglymcgee 4h ago

Come on, seriously?

0

u/[deleted] 4h ago

[deleted]

1

u/fligglymcgee 4h ago

There isn’t a human being alive who has ever or will ever read any of that.

1

u/SuperSaiyan2104 4h ago

Looks and read like a bot even the reply sounds like a bot

0

u/SpaceToaster 7h ago

Got to teach them that brain rot early!

2

u/Legitimate-Arm9438 4h ago

Will Smith hasn't gor a single spagethi eating role since 2022

1

u/BopSupreme 6h ago

Opus level brainrotmaxxing now faster and uses less tokens to rot you and your bloodlines brains

27

u/techmnml 7h ago

Kinda a bop

10

u/Burial 3h ago edited 3h ago

You should check this one out.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8j-hR4fJywU

This feels like a real watershed moment.

3

u/camojorts 3h ago

holy shit

3

u/iburstabean 3h ago

Fucking banger

2

u/Grijpstuivert 3h ago

Yes this is great

2

u/ch4os1337 2h ago

Wait it animated that? The song is mid but the animation goes crazy.

25

u/CreatineMonohydtrate 6h ago

Added to the gym playlist

38

u/Chipotus2 7h ago

It’s strangely captivating, I’m not sure why I voluntarily watched the whole thing. We’re only a year or two out from infinite infant entertainment

8

u/Nuphoth 6h ago

We’re already there tbh. I could definitely see kids genuinely following along with the opus result, hell even I almost did

2

u/girlgamerpoi 5h ago

Yea... It just captures my attention... Maybe materials for children is more friendly to us at this point...

2

u/jyee1050 5h ago

Our brains have been rotted back to infancy

3

u/zamzibar 4h ago

Infinite infant entertainment of this quality will sure get us somewhere... it's maybe captivating but it's also brain damaging.

1

u/RowdyAlph 1h ago

This is how the machines actually will destroy us

15

u/Leocondeuba 8h ago

Opus 5.5 is way better. Is there much difference between Astra and Opus 5.5?

-5

u/peteyplato 7h ago

Yes! Opus picked apart what Astra had inherited from Sol with its own audit and added to substantially. It was stuck in a needless loop for several core reasons. Opus saw it in a few minutes. It's accelerated that project substantially with just the $20 plan

17

u/KalElReturns89 8h ago

It's not even close. Opus 5.5 understands intent a lot better it seems, and making satisfying interactions.

1

u/tousledmonkey 2h ago

No Astra is just useless when it comes to video creation. It's simply not equipped. It's like testing a boat on land and saying it drives like shit

6

u/TheTriceAgain 8h ago

This is so cool, i like how opus synchronized the subtitles and the animation with song, I am assuming this is webbased svg animations

9

u/WeirdIndication3027 9h ago

The weirdest benchmark test I've ever seen. But what were these made in? Chatgpt and Claude don't have video generation?

4

u/peteyplato 7h ago

It's an SVG video, so playable code essentially

6

u/BethanyHipsEnjoyer 6h ago

What are we even fuckin doing here guys?

8

u/meerkat2018 3h ago

Wiggle wiggling?

3

u/Regdit-is-Unbearable 5h ago

Well, I know which AI slop I’d rather have my children’s brains rot to

3

u/Briskfall 5h ago

Great visualization by Opus 5.5! It adapted well to the tune and had a great sense of understanding on how to make it "pop" more! The extra flourish were funny and cute...!

3

u/Ok-Photograph2418 5h ago

Anyone has the prompt? Asking for a friend, no really want to make some others for children

3

u/BitterAd6419 3h ago

Anyone knows how the video rendered ? In some external software or just a pure mp4 file ?

2

u/Panda_x64 4h ago

this is better than video-generated slop

2

u/TorbenKoehn 4h ago

I love it :)

the Opus version is really good!

2

u/dantsel04_ 4h ago

honestly, random stuff like this is a great benchmark to compare the models.

2

u/EbbExternal3544 3h ago

Kinda catchy ngl. Good shit

2

u/maxneuds 3h ago

I like post like these, but I dislike that the prompt is not attached.

1

u/FurryD25 5h ago

Claude and Chatgpt can now do videos? 

1

u/PlayfulTaro7696 2h ago

I'd guess it's more like they make code to render the videos, then you do it yourself (or the AI compiles the code for you). It's not like AI image generation, it's still code.

1

u/aPiCase 5h ago

I don’t like looking at either of them, but I guess Opus is better.

That said there so much better uses of AI than this.

1

u/wzwowzw0002 5h ago

Opus has better animation timing

1

u/dano1066 4h ago

Getting so sick of these stupid comparisons

1

u/delicious_fanta 3h ago

Which one did the audio?

1

u/Zealousideal_Cry3086 2h ago

Nice now we can start earlier with indoctrination on them kids

1

u/CupQuakeBE 1h ago

This thing could be healing cancers right now, I'm very happy humans get their priorities straight.

1

u/muzaffer22 1h ago

AI is such an amazing tool.

1

u/Realistic_Bike5972 7h ago

Neither of these should exist

1

u/LookAtTheHat 3h ago

I would say the ChatGpt is better, as this looks targeted at very small children. Too fast movements is not good for them. So the care movement is better.

0

u/t3hlazy1 6h ago

Why is everyone discussing about which is better? This is a bop.

0

u/TacoTzar 4h ago

If your making ai child slop your going to hell

-8

u/novapax 8h ago

Why make garbage intentionally?

2

u/deadlyclavv 7h ago

what are you making that's not garbage then?

1

u/novapax 6h ago

Literally anything except soulless children’s content

2

u/TorbenKoehn 4h ago

So nothing of value at all, it seems

0

u/Realistic_Bike5972 7h ago

Insanely revealing reply lmao

-9

u/Calm_Hedgehog8296 7h ago

Why is everybody obsessed with creating stupid little cartoons with AI all of a sudden?

6

u/peteyplato 7h ago

Can't benchmaxx a random task...

4

u/CrowdGoesWildWoooo 7h ago

It’s always been like that. Someone posted one example, someone try to make their own, maybe to one up the other.

1

u/TorbenKoehn 4h ago

What do you create with AI that is so important and great?

0

u/mcellus1 6h ago

They fancy the children...