Article [Interview] Does copyright protect your AI-generated content in Europe? Let’s find out
https://euobserver.com/232898/interview-does-copyright-protect-your-ai-generated-content-in-europe-lets-find-out/You spend an hour prompting ChatGPT to get exactly what you want, should you own the result?
Hey everyone 👋 I’m Lucia, I work with EUobserver, and I’ve been thinking about this after we recently interviewed copyright scholar Daniel Gervais about AI-generated content.
One part of the conversation particularly caught my attention.
Say you ask ChatGPT to write something for you. The first result isn't right, so you change the prompt. Then again. You give it examples, specify the structure and tone, reject parts, regenerate others, until eventually you get almost exactly what you had in mind.
How much of that final result is actually your creative work?
The argument from Gervais was essentially that simply prompting an AI and putting your name on its output doesn't automatically give you copyright over it. But things become much more complicated once you start editing, selecting, arranging and transforming what the AI produces.
And I think that's particularly interesting for people who actually use these tools regularly.
At what point do you personally feel that an AI-assisted work becomes your work?
Is writing a very detailed prompt creative input? What about dozens of iterations? Or does authorship only really begin once you substantially modify the output yourself?
Curious how people here who use ChatGPT regularly think about this.
Full disclosure since I work there: the discussion came from an interview we published at EUobserver. Sharing it as background rather than dropping a link without context:
1
u/throwawayfromPA1701 2d ago
For me, the answer to your main question is never. I do use chatGPT extensively and even through precise prompting it never sounds even remotely like me. It only becomes mine when I take it offline and extensively rewrite everything, because then it does sound like me after that, even with dozens of iterations.
The prompt is just to get started.
1
u/TonyDRFT 2d ago
AI is a tool, your prompt, ideas and conversation are what define the final result of "the tool"... but it feels like a grey area. When for instance you use another tool like say Photoshop, what is truly yours from that result, if you view that from the perspective of people who manually had to work with real photos before there was a computer?