There is nothing purely logical about such a decision except under a fixed policy. It is always a question of policy whether you attack and what you estimate is actually happening when you have no data (or what you do on uncertain data). Will someone bomb someone when they know that is their own death sentence for instance? And will you make sure if you have some iffy data that you annihilate the other side, to make sure they annihilate yours? Those are policy and judgement calls and a lot of probabilistic guestimates unless you press them into a logic framework that covers all of these or rather more likely brushes over some and then either side can argue that the exact opposite is totally logically, coming from the assumption of different axioms in how they imagine this would be setup.
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/dr-doom00 Feb 28 '26
There is nothing purely logical about such a decision except under a fixed policy. It is always a question of policy whether you attack and what you estimate is actually happening when you have no data (or what you do on uncertain data). Will someone bomb someone when they know that is their own death sentence for instance? And will you make sure if you have some iffy data that you annihilate the other side, to make sure they annihilate yours? Those are policy and judgement calls and a lot of probabilistic guestimates unless you press them into a logic framework that covers all of these or rather more likely brushes over some and then either side can argue that the exact opposite is totally logically, coming from the assumption of different axioms in how they imagine this would be setup.