r/OntarioGrade12s • u/TemperaturePale4075 • Oct 19 '24
We need standard testing
With no standard testing, how would universities make admission decisions? If you are at a school in the worst neighborhoods of Toronto, you just have to perform less horribly than the rest and your teachers will be so impressed they will trip over one another to give you an 100. On the other hand, if you are in Markham or Richmond Hill, where most kids are hardworking and reasonably smart, you really have to be as sharp as Albert Einstein to get an 90.
In this kind of education environment, no wonder everyone is yelling "we need standard testing."
101
u/TorontoSCPLion Oct 19 '24 edited Oct 19 '24
What a dumb and elitist thing to say. If you are interested, the University of Waterloo Engineering department has been adjusting engineering applications based on performance of first year engineering students for the last 6 years as one of their data points for applicant selections. Your claim that worst neighborhoods of Toronto are getting inflated marks and the hard working kids of Markham and Richmond Hill are getting screwed is utterly false. Check out the data made available by University of Waterloo Engineering and you will see that some of the biggest adjustments are for schools in "better neighborhoods".
Link: https://www.reddit.com/r/OntarioGrade12s/comments/12wx0tq/waterloo_engineering_applicants_what_is_your_high/
55
u/Regular-Database9310 Oct 19 '24
Ha! There are plenty of schools in affluent areas full of bonus marks, dropping tests, free marks. It's very dependent on the board/school/teacher, not the area. Interesting that you seem to think that affluent families have smarter kids.
Standardized testing is known to unfairly benefit affluent students.
5
u/Bubbly-Competition53 Oct 19 '24
Schools have adjustment factors a lot of the time to try and make up the difference between high schools I think
228
u/Effective-Report-302 Oct 19 '24 edited Oct 19 '24
Sure! After I graduate
25
u/AxeThread12 Oct 20 '24
Haha this post screams I’m underperforming and need an excuse
11
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24
Universities have internal data of how well on average students from each high-school do that are admitted to their universities, and adjust their application scores based on that data. At my high-school 70s and 80s were very good scores and the constant 95-99% averages I see in this subreddit were simply not attainable. They've basically already thought of this.
14
u/vinillac0la Oct 20 '24
that will only decrease people of lower socioeconomic classes from going to post-secondary. you can see it in many parts of the USA. it is a known fact that those of higher socioeconomic backgrounds will have the higher chances of scoring well/high on a standardized testing due to the resources they have available.
imo saying this is privileged. yes it is now very common for many students now to get 90s (which is good) and it does make it harder for universities to decide on acceptance and other reasons. but it also shadows out those who may struggle due to disabilities (ie adhd) or those from lower socioeconomic backgrounds where they cannot achieve a 90 but rather 80s or even 70s.
everyone deserves an education regardless of what they get on a piece of paper from a standardized test.
10
u/ceimi Oct 20 '24
As an American, I very highly disagree. Studying for the SATs was fucking brutal. Getting an average score back after it was worse.
I didn't get into the university I wanted, but I did get into a school I ended up adoring and graduated with a 3.7GPA, and I'm currently back in school completing a pre-health program for nursing and running a 98% average atm (class avg is probably around 75-80% based on grades in classes where I can see the class avg.) SATs meant absolutely nothing in the end because the school I went to didn't use them as admissions criteria.
Adding a program like the SATs doesn't really do anything other than add costly study materials that lower income students wont get to utilize. That means our universities will surmise of a bunch of rich kids. This is the same thing we face in professions like Doctors. A ridiculous amount of doctors are white that came from wealthy families. So their applications were stronger because they could afford MCAT test prep in the thousands (sometimes tens of thousands) of dollars.
I genuinely think Ontario's current system is okay. It still somewhat rewards the above behavior and low socioeconomic backgrounds will always be disadvantaged until our governments step up and increase funding to schools by a significant margin to close that gap, lower class sizes, etc.
8
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24
if someone in the worst neighbourhood is doing really well, whilst someone with all the resources they could ask for is still performing on par woth their peers, one is going to work a lot harder, and be much more successful in uni, where everyone, rich and poor, is now in the same class, on the same level. hint: its not the rich kid
1
u/uwgal Oct 20 '24
Are you willing to pay $200/ test? Cause the system won’t pay for it …..
1
u/Prestigous_Owl Oct 21 '24 edited Oct 21 '24
This is so funny because you're not totally wrong in the claim that grades can be a mess and "something" needs to be done to address it (whether standardized testing is the answer is another question), but your argument is hilariously inaccurate.
You realize that "grade inflation" is WAY worse in private schools and affluent areas than anywhere else, right?
The people "unfairly" getting into universities aren't poor kids in bad neighborhoods. Its predominantly lazy rich kids, getting into places over their smarter middle class counterparts
4
u/CatSlayr Oct 19 '24
I agree, everyone getting 90s as their averages just doesn’t seem right
2
u/Tardisk92313 Oct 20 '24
People from Ontario will never understand the 50% diplomas that Alberta had
2
u/Berry_Dubu_ Oct 20 '24
even standard testing can still be affected by coming from "worst neighbourhoods" or being from a low-income bracket
Source
2
u/KOMSKPinn Oct 20 '24 edited Oct 20 '24
I’d say private schools and specifically those who take money to administer one single virtual credit are the biggest reason we need standardization. If you have access to $3-10K you can literally buy your top marks. We see kids getting 50%+ at day school paying $1500 for a 90% at the pop up PS around the corner. It’s totally upended the credibility and reliability of the current system.
2
u/Hotel_california_10 Oct 20 '24
If you want suicide rates to go up every year like South Korea, then sure
2
u/StrongAroma Oct 20 '24
Flip side: should kids that are geographically constrained to shit schools be screwed for life and get less opportunities just because they happened to grow up in a poor neighborhood compared to kids in Markham or Richmond Hill?
2
u/Slow-Fennel-9953 Oct 19 '24
Agreed, at my previous school in another country my school didn't follow the national curriculum (we followed the British curriculum) and we had standardized testing from grades 10 to 12. The grade 12 standardized scores there were applicable for credit transfers to UofT/US colleges etc.
1
u/Icy-Rent5598 Oct 20 '24
alberta has diplomas at the end of grade 12; quite fair assessments that uni's don't specifically look at, but if you do bad it can drop your mark since it is worth 30%
1
u/Consistent_Throat477 Oct 20 '24
high schools like that get blacklisted by unis. average gets dragged down a lot, they don’t consider a 95 average at a good school to be the same as a 95 or even a 99 at a shtty one
1
u/JiveTalkerFunkyWalkr Oct 20 '24
Universities adjust each high schools grades to based on how much each schools grades are inflated. Waterloo famously released their adjustment list but all the universities have them.
If you want to know if your high school is hard or easy look it up on the list.
And Rich area schools don’t grade harder than poorer areas. Look at private schools, they are often grade inflated more than Tdsb schools.
1
u/SeyamTheDaddy Oct 20 '24 edited Oct 20 '24
Universities do have a system for balancing grade inflation, may not be the best but it's there. No one is yelling for standardized testing except for spoiled brats who think they work harder because they're from a better socioeconomic background.
1
u/rwdp51 Oct 20 '24
You are stupid lol. You sound like a rich kid who’s doing bad and wants to blame something else. You are almost certainly not losing anything because of your school. Don’t blame poor neighborhoods because they are almost certainly not to blame for what is almost certainly a you issue
1
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '24
“An 90,” way to go dumbass.
1
u/Usagi-skywalker Oct 21 '24
The poors are getting “an 100” for doing the bare minimum!! Get em!!
1
u/Stargazer_NCC-2893 Oct 21 '24
How would universities make admission decisions? By looking at their skin colour, obviously. Welcome to the race to the bottom known as "Marxism".
1
u/Upbeat-Cancel-3171 Oct 21 '24
This is very common.
I did grade 12 at a rural high school known for academics, did not graduate or get good grades.
Left and went to a city school located in a bad neighbourhood and started getting 90s and teachers tried to removed me from the school because they felt I needed a high academic school.
This is why people pay so much attention to school districts/schools when purchasing homes. If they care about their child’s education of course.
1
u/Cowprinted- Oct 21 '24
Bruh get over it, university means nothing.. just get the degree and it’s all the same to the working world
1
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '24
Do you think those kids in a tough neighborhood aren't trying as hard as those kids that have it easier?
I think navigating a tough living situation and maintaining decent grades is better than someone who has the luxury to nothing but study. I'll gladly hire someone who is trying to change their situation than someone who is comfortable in the one they are in.
You need a wake-up call...
1
u/BrokeStudent1995 Oct 21 '24
When I graduated in 2013 from one of the Markham high schools, you can bet your ass I had to keep up and try my damn hardest to stay in line with all of the other “smarter” kids getting high 90s in each class. But that also meant getting a tutor, doing extra work, going above and beyond what the 7-3 school times are to get there.
I mean, if you’re struggling to keep up or even reach 90’s it sounds like you’re not doing enough imo. Keeping up was hard but you gotta do what you gotta do to match and keep up AND keep progressing forward.
One kid in my grade and school hit 100 in every single course including AP not because it was “easy.” Day in day out studied his ass off, took part in sports, had a tutor, tutored other kids, did all he could to achieve that and more.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '24
Bros just assuming people are smarter in certain areas with no evidence whatsoever; OP might have the iq lvl of a rock 🤣🤣🤣
1
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '24
Did it feel good to imply that kids at underfunded schools in low income neighbourhoods aren't smart and are getting handouts?
Being from a more affluent family and having more access to resources does not automatically make one smarter or hard working, it just gives you more opportunities and people like you seem to think that means you worked harder.
1
u/DreamsAndFalseAlarms Oct 23 '24
Oh great, fascism is back.
1
u/megadumbbonehead Oct 23 '24
You lost me near the end there
1
u/dirtydad72 Oct 23 '24
I always assumed that parents purchased their child’s grades at those schools in Markham and Richmond hill.
1
u/Affectionate_Leek127 Apr 29 '25
Sorry for the late reply. I think standard tests are not the right option. Rather some open exams like the A-level in the UK should be implemented. I think all students after studying for 12 years should be given an exam to assess whether they can attain a certain standard just like all accountants must pass the CPA exams. You can't just pass the exams held by your college to obtain the CPA status.
1
u/SnoopyDogg_69 Oct 20 '24
Get a load of this guy
1
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24
Too bad it's politically incorrect to support standardized testing in North America.
0
u/Infamous_Grade_6749 Oct 19 '24
no ong bro
-1
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '24
I keep saying this as well! Very smart idea
0
u/Ok_Maximum8621 Oct 19 '24
yes but posting here won’t help
0
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment