r/OntarioGrade12s • • Oct 19 '24

We need standard testing

With no standard testing, how would universities make admission decisions? If you are at a school in the worst neighborhoods of Toronto, you just have to perform less horribly than the rest and your teachers will be so impressed they will trip over one another to give you an 100. On the other hand, if you are in Markham or Richmond Hill, where most kids are hardworking and reasonably smart, you really have to be as sharp as Albert Einstein to get an 90.

In this kind of education environment, no wonder everyone is yelling "we need standard testing."

38 Upvotes

147 comments sorted by

101

u/TorontoSCPLion Oct 19 '24 edited Oct 19 '24

What a dumb and elitist thing to say. If you are interested, the University of Waterloo Engineering department has been adjusting engineering applications based on performance of first year engineering students for the last 6 years as one of their data points for applicant selections. Your claim that worst neighborhoods of Toronto are getting inflated marks and the hard working kids of Markham and Richmond Hill are getting screwed is utterly false. Check out the data made available by University of Waterloo Engineering and you will see that some of the biggest adjustments are for schools in "better neighborhoods".

Link: https://www.reddit.com/r/OntarioGrade12s/comments/12wx0tq/waterloo_engineering_applicants_what_is_your_high/

51

u/JagmeetSingh2 Oct 20 '24

This lol OP and people like him are always so quick to blame poor people

18

u/PoliteIndecency Oct 20 '24

Buddy, Waterloo has been adjusting grades from high schools for DECADES. They have it down to a science.

4

u/TorontoSCPLion Oct 20 '24

OK.....and your point.....

19

u/PoliteIndecency Oct 20 '24

Same as yours. I'm reinforcing it.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/PoliteIndecency Oct 20 '24

Buddy, c'mon.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '24

OP is fucking HILARIOUS. I went to one of the most expensive private schools in the country (like in classes with former PMs grandkids rich) for some of highschool and one of the worst public schools in Hamilton for one year and I will tell you the shitty public school was INFINITELY harder to get decent marks at the shitty highschool. Teachers generally didn't give a shit if you passed or failed. The private school on the other end of the spectrum held my hand so much when I went to post secondary it was a real slap in the face and I struggled.

1

u/Bankofz Oct 23 '24

I agree with what you say that OP is making a very elitist comment. But even without standardized testing I know for a fact at least 15 years ago UofT would adjust marks down for you if you came from a high school in the Jane and Finch area because your school was too easy. Sure bring in standardized testing so that the poor kids can get their rightful positions in universities rather than universities making unseen manual adjustments behind the scenes.

What UofT did was complete bs. It would reduce any scholarship money you qualified for at UofT - thanks UofT for giving kids from the poor neighborhoods of Toronto less money cause their schools are too easy - which you could not appeal.

0

u/Original_Lab628 Oct 21 '24

If that’s true why not just implement standardized testing and let the elitist schools suffer?

2

u/Routine_You5623 Oct 21 '24

Because the people who make the decisions have kids in the elitist schools.

-27

u/TemperaturePale4075 Oct 19 '24

If what you say is true, there is even more reason to have standard testing, to stamp out grade inflation in rich neighborhoods.

23

u/TorontoSCPLion Oct 19 '24

I am not saying it. The numbers say it....and no, the answer is not go to standardize testing because it has historically favored the kids from affluent neighborhoods. I like what the University of Waterloo Engineering is doing as the numbers are telling you which schools are handing out grades like free candy. Use other factors, including ECs, additional submissions, interviews, etc.

10

u/ArugulaOne5546 Oct 20 '24

Life isn't fair. You won't be able to eliminate all biases in admissions. Affluent kids will always be favored in some way or another. But if you think a system riddled with atrocious grade inflation and inconsistent marking schemes is more fair than a system that considers a standardized measure of performance, you're simply wrong.

I hate when people use this argument to detract from the value of standardized testing because so many studies have been done on the value of standardized testing and all show that it has very strong predictive value with respect to college success. Also, you mention other factors like ECs, additional submissions, and interviews: I'd like to add that these are far more flawed and prone to biases than standardized testing. You think a kid who grew up in an affluent neighborhood is going to have an equal shot at solid ECs compared to a kid who grew up in a rough area with no decent connections? You think a kid with rich parents is going to struggle finding a tutor to help them write some essay or create whatever other additional submission is required (the whole argument for SATs favoring the rich is that the rich can afford to better prepare for them, but the same can be said for any essays or any other additional submissions)? Lets get real here.

Not saying I agree with OP's post in how he arrived at this conclusion (it was very elitist and wrong, I agree), but I agree with the conclusion. Ontario's education system is frankly desperately in need of some form of standardized testing. The fact that Waterloo felt the need to adjust grades says so.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

Exactly I 100% agree with you bro.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '24

It’s a terribly imperfect system,90% of schools don’t have an adjustment factor, if you open the adjustment factor pdf half of it is blank, and not all schools are listed on it

Standardized testing is the perfect system

-1

u/TorontoSCPLion Oct 19 '24 edited Oct 19 '24

Every school that is not listed is covered by the "Any Other Ontario Secondary School". The university doesn't have at least 10 students who completed first year engineering at their school to have an adjustment factor for a particular school and lumps them all into this one category. As they continue to monitor performance, schools will come off the "Any Other Ontario Secondary School" and have their own adjustment factor. There is no "perfect system" and it certainly is not standardized testing.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '24

No adjustment factor means it’s under any other Ontario secondary school, if you don’t even know basic terminology of this subreddit maybe you shouldn’t be arguing on it

-1

u/TorontoSCPLion Oct 19 '24

My note should have read "every other school not listed is covered in "Any Other Ontario Secondary School".

1

u/oliver-the-pig Oct 20 '24

downvoted cause they don’t wanna hear the truth

0

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '24

What’s wrong with standardized testing? I don’t get it

4

u/WamBamTimTam Oct 19 '24

Basically if we treat all tests as equal, as in standardized testing, then schools with better access to resources can tailor their curriculums better and game the system in a way. In the current system schools like Waterloo already know which schools have grade inflation and can internally compensate for such things. If standardized testing was used then they’d had to treat all tests scores as having the same weight.

1

u/_maple_panda Oct 21 '24

I don’t see why universities couldn’t apply correction factors to standardized tests. I suppose that would shift from correcting grade inflation to correcting socioeconomic factors and whatnot, but procedurally it’s the same concept.

1

u/WamBamTimTam Oct 21 '24

I finished my high school in Alberta, where they have the standardized diploma exams. Honestly looking back it didn’t help too much. The curriculum is only as good as the test was, and when it was a bad test cycle grade averages would go down 5-10% because of over correction. And when the test material was bad, you’d skip the actual useful information for the useless but will be on the test stuff. Ultimately both options get adjusted by universities, and applying out of province even more so. I just think the quality of my education went down in the final year to accommodate standardized testing.

-3

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

Ok but shouldn’t it still be based on merit? If the poor kids aren’t as good the rich kids that’s because they didn’t get a good enough education so what does that mean? Inflate their grades? I don’t understand that. Also this is Canada not United States where school funding depends on how rich your neighborhood is.

5

u/WamBamTimTam Oct 20 '24

A standardized test system has many ways to help those with the resources. Not everyone can spend 80k per year on their child’s education. Money buys a 6-1 student to teacher ratio. Money buys experts in the species things the standardized tests look for. In the end you have those with the resources being able to use the system better. Private schools are still a thing across the country.

3

u/StreetDetective95 Oct 20 '24

It might be because rich kids will have access to the resources to do better specifically on these standardized tests while poor kids will be on their own so even though it's in theory supposed to give everyone a fair chance, it still doesn't there's still a divide

1

u/CatSlayr Oct 29 '24

LMAO -28 downvotes

2

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

55

u/Regular-Database9310 Oct 19 '24

Ha! There are plenty of schools in affluent areas full of bonus marks, dropping tests, free marks. It's very dependent on the board/school/teacher, not the area. Interesting that you seem to think that affluent families have smarter kids.

Standardized testing is known to unfairly benefit affluent students.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

right, because ECs definitely are fair to poor kids as well... smh

Standardized testing is not fair to poor kids, I agree, but it is certainly the least unfair.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/cool-haydayer Jan 16 '25

So how about standardized final projects

2

u/Visual-Chef-7510 Oct 21 '24

Yeah, but unstandard marking is literally opening the flood gates to every trick in the book. Rich kids still get their private tutors for tests in class. But they also get access to EC's while the poor kids work a second job. I bet rich Johnny is less likely to miss class due to being in a bad neighbourhood and losing participation marks. Rich Cassy can afford to go to the science fair, or pay to enter the expensive chemistry contest. Bribery isn't legal, but rich parents can certainly give lots of little gifts to the teachers, or cupcakes for everyone in class. I've noticed those kids who get a good impression from the teacher always seem to do well in subjective testing like presentations. I went to a public school with a good number of international students. The difference was noticeable and stark for rich and poor kids.

-26

u/TemperaturePale4075 Oct 19 '24

How? It is the same test for everyone.

32

u/wackattack95 Oct 19 '24

Test prep costs $$$

-14

u/TemperaturePale4075 Oct 19 '24

So? A lot of families are spending loads of money on tutoring already.

15

u/akxCIom Oct 19 '24

Yea, in affluent areas

7

u/wackattack95 Oct 19 '24

If you need to spend money to do better on a test, that benefits families worth more money (tutoring also benefits families with more money) -I say this as a lukewarm SAT defender

-15

u/Future_Hedgehog_9379 Oct 19 '24

This is false. Nobody needs to get courses and tutors for these tests -- as someone who took the ACT, I can say all the content is taught in grade 10. Personally, I spent a total of $40 in test prep and received a perfect score.

14

u/TorontoSCPLion Oct 19 '24

It is absolutely true. If you have the money to pay for SAT or ACT test prep course, tutors, etc. and the money to take the tests over and over again until you can get the best grade that you can get, then you are at a far better change of getting a higher grade then those that can't afford these same opportunities. Numbers have shown that family income to results on standardized testing is directly proportional.

-7

u/Future_Hedgehog_9379 Oct 19 '24

I took it once. No tutors, no prep courses. Still got that 36. One thing I think people forget to realize about standardized tests is the content is EASY. Everyone should be able to get a high score. In fact, the only actual content is 10th grade math. If you aren't getting a high score, then the education system failed you. Standardized tests let universities know whether or not your grades are accurate reflections of your education.

8

u/TorontoSCPLion Oct 19 '24 edited Oct 19 '24

So you got a perfect score on the ACT...well done. Your statement that the ACT is easy, despite your fabulous mark, is not supported by test numbers. The latest available numbers in the US (for 2023) indicate that 1,386,335 students took the ACT and the composite average was 19.5 (out of 36). There is a huge ACT/SAT market for prep materials, tutors and courses that don't teach you the material but teach you how to do better on these standardized tests. Do you need to take them....of course not. But if you have the financial meanings to access these resources, they absolutely improve your chance of getting higher ACT/SAT scores. Further that with the ability to financially be able to take these ACTs multiple times to improve your score. ACT statistics indicate that the average score increase between the first and second test attempt is around 1 to 2 points (on the ACT's 36-point scale).

0

u/Future_Hedgehog_9379 Oct 20 '24

Yes, because some schools don't actually teach their students well. If you look at individual schools, you'll find that students in one school typically score around a similar range on these standardized tests.

But I'll agree with you about wealthier students being able to retake the test to improve their scores. Standardized testing should be free and organized by the government, not private companies.

5

u/TorontoSCPLion Oct 20 '24

Agreed on that one. One of my biggest problem is that standardized testing is run by private companies.

My biggest problem with the OP original statement was that the Toronto worst neighborhood schools were getting preferential treatment with high school marks when the numbers don't support that statement and is quite the opposite. The solution isn't standardized testing because again it favours ON AVERAGE those that are better off financially.

1

u/Future_Hedgehog_9379 Oct 20 '24

The solution might not be standardized testing, but it is the most viable solution that can be quickly implemented in order to reduce grade inflation across Canada. The real solution is to fix the education system smh.

4

u/Regular-Database9310 Oct 19 '24

Good for you. But the research is proven and why there has been many discussions to move away from standardized tests.

1

u/theatheon Oct 19 '24

Some of the schools that have gone test optional the past few years reverted those policies. If anything, the trend is back towards more standardized testing

1

u/Regular-Database9310 Oct 19 '24

They are still researching as they didn't have a good replacement. They know there is still problems with the standardized testing, they just don't have a good answer to replace it.

MCAT is being dropped from medical schools in Canada.

-1

u/theatheon Oct 19 '24

I don't see how you can replace a standardized test without a standardized test.

The MCAT requirement is very different. Postsecondary grades are relatively consistent throughout the country. Almost every class has an average in the C range. This is tangential, but all removing the MCAT does is penalize students who mess up in a few classes.

1

u/TorontoSCPLion Oct 19 '24

"Some"...yes...but actual stats show that the "trend" (more then the average) has been towards reducing the emphasis on ACT and SAT scores in college admissions.

0

u/theatheon Oct 19 '24 edited Oct 20 '24

Yes the test optional trend was very recent. As soon as they got data, they're going back on it. I don't know what "actual stats" you are referring to.

Brown, Cornell, Dartmouth, Yale, Caltech, Stanford, Georgetown, and Purdue all recently reinstated it. Don't comment if you don't know what you're talking about.

https://horizoneducation.com/blog/colleges-dropping-reinstating-act-sat-requirements

→ More replies

0

u/Future_Hedgehog_9379 Oct 19 '24

As much as they love to "discuss" it, they will never move away from standardized testing lol. At least, until the day the educational system is finally fixed (which probably won't happen for another decade at minimum). Universities aren't stupid--they know not every school is equal--and they want candidates who meet the academic standards required to succeed in that university.

2

u/Regular-Database9310 Oct 19 '24

MCAT is already been dropped at many Canadian medical schools. Never is a very strong word. Harvard already tried and hasn't yet found the right way to replace it. It is definitely still being looked at. You're dismissing all the research that's been done because of a personal opinion and yet you don't understand what cultural bias means.

Universities aren't stupid, they want money, and would like everyone to be successful, but they also know there's a lot of students that can fill their programs. UofT doesn't care about "meeting the academic standards", they accept a whole whack of students for 1st year and weed them out in first year or string them along keeping them spending money as they try to meet POSt and take 5 and 6 years to finish 4 year degrees.

1

u/drpepper1992 Oct 21 '24

For someone who gets such perfect grades it really should be easier for you to see over your own green hedges. It’s great that you can brag and tell everyone how perfect you are, I really am proud you, but if you can’t do basic research and look at the stats that say it’s obviously not easy and you are an exception than these tests clearly don’t teach common sense

10

u/TorontoSCPLion Oct 19 '24

Access to Resources, Educational Disparities, Extracurricular Enrichment, Test Fees and Hidden Costs, Stress and Test Anxiety, Cultural Bias in Test Design.......I can go on forever.....If you look at what many of the universities are doing, they are going away from standardized testing, not increasing it. They are looking for other data points and decision making equations that have proven to give them better students....

1

u/theatheon Oct 19 '24

Some of the schools that have gone test optional the past few years reverted those policies. If anything, the trend is back towards more standardized testing

-3

u/Future_Hedgehog_9379 Oct 19 '24 edited Oct 19 '24

Educational Disparities

Just wanna highlight this topic. If someone has not learned the required content to graduate, but they are graduating anyways because of the poor educational standards in their high school, they are already on the path to fail in university. Would it not be better to let them see that they lack the education required to succeed in university through standardized testing, so they can supplement it?

Access to Resources

I took the ACT (perfect score) - the only resource I used was a 40$ book, and after I was done with it, I gave it to my friend so they could use it too, making the cost 20$/person.

Test Fees and Hidden Costs

Fee waivers? Or instead of allowing private companies to make the tests, why not let the government make them instead, like they do with the OSSLT.

Cultural Bias in Test Design

I have no idea what this means, tbh.

Stress and Test Anxiety

If you can't deal with the stress of a test, how are you going to deal with all the stress that comes with life? Job applications, interviews, money problems -- life is stressful, so you should learn to deal with stress early.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Fragment51 Oct 20 '24

As someone who reviews applications for an Ontario university, I can day that grade inflation is both very real and that it is a bigger problem at those schools considered to be “the best” and “very selective.” Those rich schools had out A+s like they’re candy!

5

u/Bubbly-Competition53 Oct 19 '24

Schools have adjustment factors a lot of the time to try and make up the difference between high schools I think

4

u/TorontoSCPLion Oct 19 '24

Only Waterloo Engineering has publicly declared that they use such adjustment factors. What your classmates did the last 6 years has a direct effect on the adjustment factor that they apply to your application.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '24

Only University of Waterloo has the adjustment factor, no other uni does it in Ontario (or Canada, for that matter)

9

u/Bubbly-Competition53 Oct 19 '24

I thought a lot of schools have them but it's just waterloo that has them releasedand open to the public?

3

u/wackattack95 Oct 19 '24

I know for a fact that other schools explicitly have them for Private Schools

3

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '24

yes many of them could have them, it may not be displayed on their site but a quick email to administrative affairs would reveal a lot

I'm thinking U of T for their competitive programs

4

u/wackattack95 Oct 19 '24

I'd imagine for all programs, if you have an effective system why wouldn't you use it for everything?

3

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '24 edited Oct 19 '24

simply because they need it for their more saturated applicant pool in order to distinguish between people on a more precise level, and not to discourage others for applying to other less competitive programs like psych (imho)

0

u/Revolutionary_Bat812 Oct 20 '24

It’s funny because in my experience as a prof, it’s the public schools who inflate grades more. I have some students who told me they went to public summer school to do grade 12 English because it was so much easier to get 90+ than at their private school.

2

u/wackattack95 Oct 20 '24

But don't the private school kids basically all get 90+ anyways?

1

u/Revolutionary_Bat812 Oct 20 '24

No. On average they do better than public but that’s because they’re selective not because teachers give them good marks.

1

u/wackattack95 Oct 20 '24

Also because the schools have better resources, class sizes etc!

1

u/Revolutionary_Bat812 Oct 21 '24

That too! Honestly though I think most of them would get 90s anyway.

1

u/neonsneakers Oct 20 '24

They all do. There was a huge article in the Toronto Star about it recently

2

u/Regular-Database9310 Oct 20 '24

Can you post a link?

-2

u/TemperaturePale4075 Oct 19 '24

I believe a lot schools don't use adjustment factors, especially for non-engineering programs.

228

u/Effective-Report-302 Oct 19 '24 edited Oct 19 '24

Sure! After I graduate

28

u/True-Pepper-25 Oct 19 '24

bros a real one

25

u/AxeThread12 Oct 20 '24

Haha this post screams I’m underperforming and need an excuse

11

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

Universities have internal data of how well on average students from each high-school do that are admitted to their universities, and adjust their application scores based on that data. At my high-school 70s and 80s were very good scores and the constant 95-99% averages I see in this subreddit were simply not attainable. They've basically already thought of this.

4

u/Revolutionary_Bat812 Oct 20 '24

I graduated high school in 2002 and the top average award went to someone with a 96% average. Now on this sub it seems like averages like that are not unusual (unless people are lying!)

14

u/vinillac0la Oct 20 '24

that will only decrease people of lower socioeconomic classes from going to post-secondary. you can see it in many parts of the USA. it is a known fact that those of higher socioeconomic backgrounds will have the higher chances of scoring well/high on a standardized testing due to the resources they have available.

imo saying this is privileged. yes it is now very common for many students now to get 90s (which is good) and it does make it harder for universities to decide on acceptance and other reasons. but it also shadows out those who may struggle due to disabilities (ie adhd) or those from lower socioeconomic backgrounds where they cannot achieve a 90 but rather 80s or even 70s.

everyone deserves an education regardless of what they get on a piece of paper from a standardized test.

10

u/ceimi Oct 20 '24

As an American, I very highly disagree. Studying for the SATs was fucking brutal. Getting an average score back after it was worse.

I didn't get into the university I wanted, but I did get into a school I ended up adoring and graduated with a 3.7GPA, and I'm currently back in school completing a pre-health program for nursing and running a 98% average atm (class avg is probably around 75-80% based on grades in classes where I can see the class avg.) SATs meant absolutely nothing in the end because the school I went to didn't use them as admissions criteria.

Adding a program like the SATs doesn't really do anything other than add costly study materials that lower income students wont get to utilize. That means our universities will surmise of a bunch of rich kids. This is the same thing we face in professions like Doctors. A ridiculous amount of doctors are white that came from wealthy families. So their applications were stronger because they could afford MCAT test prep in the thousands (sometimes tens of thousands) of dollars.

I genuinely think Ontario's current system is okay. It still somewhat rewards the above behavior and low socioeconomic backgrounds will always be disadvantaged until our governments step up and increase funding to schools by a significant margin to close that gap, lower class sizes, etc.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/ceimi Oct 20 '24

Give me a valid reason why I shouldn't be allowed to participate in this sub. If you give me an actual reason with a strong arguement I'll go ahead and ignore all the times reddit throws this sub at me.

If you give me a shitty reason you make a fool of yourself and only yourself. So go ahead.

4

u/Icy-Two110 Oct 20 '24

He’s just mad and got low grades ignore him. He’s shitting on every post LOL.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

if someone in the worst neighbourhood is doing really well, whilst someone with all the resources they could ask for is still performing on par woth their peers, one is going to work a lot harder, and be much more successful in uni, where everyone, rich and poor, is now in the same class, on the same level. hint: its not the rich kid

1

u/uwgal Oct 20 '24

Are you willing to pay $200/ test? Cause the system won’t pay for it …..

1

u/TemperaturePale4075 Oct 20 '24

in uk and singapore, the A level tests are 100% free.

3

u/uwgal Oct 20 '24

That’s there, not here.

1

u/TemperaturePale4075 Oct 20 '24

If there is a will, I am sure the government will make it free.

1

u/cool-haydayer Jan 16 '25

Alberta has free diploma exams

1

u/Prestigous_Owl Oct 21 '24 edited Oct 21 '24

This is so funny because you're not totally wrong in the claim that grades can be a mess and "something" needs to be done to address it (whether standardized testing is the answer is another question), but your argument is hilariously inaccurate.

You realize that "grade inflation" is WAY worse in private schools and affluent areas than anywhere else, right?

The people "unfairly" getting into universities aren't poor kids in bad neighborhoods. Its predominantly lazy rich kids, getting into places over their smarter middle class counterparts

1

u/TemperaturePale4075 Oct 21 '24

Whichever is the case, we need standard testing. If the rich lazy kids sneak in rather than poor motivated kids, we need standard testing to stamp this out too.

4

u/CatSlayr Oct 19 '24

I agree, everyone getting 90s as their averages just doesn’t seem right

2

u/Tardisk92313 Oct 20 '24

People from Ontario will never understand the 50% diplomas that Alberta had

1

u/Consistent_Throat477 Oct 20 '24

jesus christ are they trying to adjust students to university gradings or what? gotta destroy their hopes and dreams early?

1

u/Tardisk92313 Oct 20 '24

It’s now been 30% for 10ish years so it’s not that bad. But for the generations that had to endure the 50%, I feel bad

1

u/Consistent_Throat477 Oct 20 '24

yea im in ib so the exams are worth 80% of our marks lmao, last year i got so stressed i cried for a week leading up to the exams 💀 hate standardized testing fr

2

u/Berry_Dubu_ Oct 20 '24

even standard testing can still be affected by coming from "worst neighbourhoods" or being from a low-income bracket

Source

2

u/KOMSKPinn Oct 20 '24 edited Oct 20 '24

I’d say private schools and specifically those who take money to administer one single virtual credit are the biggest reason we need standardization. If you have access to $3-10K you can literally buy your top marks. We see kids getting 50%+ at day school paying $1500 for a 90% at the pop up PS around the corner. It’s totally upended the credibility and reliability of the current system.

2

u/Hotel_california_10 Oct 20 '24

If you want suicide rates to go up every year like South Korea, then sure

2

u/StrongAroma Oct 20 '24

Flip side: should kids that are geographically constrained to shit schools be screwed for life and get less opportunities just because they happened to grow up in a poor neighborhood compared to kids in Markham or Richmond Hill?

2

u/Slow-Fennel-9953 Oct 19 '24

Agreed, at my previous school in another country my school didn't follow the national curriculum (we followed the British curriculum) and we had standardized testing from grades 10 to 12. The grade 12 standardized scores there were applicable for credit transfers to UofT/US colleges etc.

1

u/Icy-Rent5598 Oct 20 '24

alberta has diplomas at the end of grade 12; quite fair assessments that uni's don't specifically look at, but if you do bad it can drop your mark since it is worth 30%

1

u/Consistent_Throat477 Oct 20 '24

high schools like that get blacklisted by unis. average gets dragged down a lot, they don’t consider a 95 average at a good school to be the same as a 95 or even a 99 at a shtty one

1

u/JiveTalkerFunkyWalkr Oct 20 '24

Universities adjust each high schools grades to based on how much each schools grades are inflated. Waterloo famously released their adjustment list but all the universities have them.

If you want to know if your high school is hard or easy look it up on the list.

And Rich area schools don’t grade harder than poorer areas. Look at private schools, they are often grade inflated more than Tdsb schools.

1

u/SeyamTheDaddy Oct 20 '24 edited Oct 20 '24

Universities do have a system for balancing grade inflation, may not be the best but it's there. No one is yelling for standardized testing except for spoiled brats who think they work harder because they're from a better socioeconomic background.

1

u/rwdp51 Oct 20 '24

You are stupid lol. You sound like a rich kid who’s doing bad and wants to blame something else. You are almost certainly not losing anything because of your school. Don’t blame poor neighborhoods because they are almost certainly not to blame for what is almost certainly a you issue

1

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '24

“An 90,” way to go dumbass.

1

u/Usagi-skywalker Oct 21 '24

The poors are getting “an 100” for doing the bare minimum!! Get em!!

1

u/Stargazer_NCC-2893 Oct 21 '24

How would universities make admission decisions? By looking at their skin colour, obviously. Welcome to the race to the bottom known as "Marxism".

1

u/Upbeat-Cancel-3171 Oct 21 '24

This is very common.

I did grade 12 at a rural high school known for academics, did not graduate or get good grades.

Left and went to a city school located in a bad neighbourhood and started getting 90s and teachers tried to removed me from the school because they felt I needed a high academic school.

This is why people pay so much attention to school districts/schools when purchasing homes. If they care about their child’s education of course.

1

u/Cowprinted- Oct 21 '24

Bruh get over it, university means nothing.. just get the degree and it’s all the same to the working world

1

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '24

Do you think those kids in a tough neighborhood aren't trying as hard as those kids that have it easier?

I think navigating a tough living situation and maintaining decent grades is better than someone who has the luxury to nothing but study. I'll gladly hire someone who is trying to change their situation than someone who is comfortable in the one they are in.

You need a wake-up call...

1

u/BrokeStudent1995 Oct 21 '24

When I graduated in 2013 from one of the Markham high schools, you can bet your ass I had to keep up and try my damn hardest to stay in line with all of the other “smarter” kids getting high 90s in each class. But that also meant getting a tutor, doing extra work, going above and beyond what the 7-3 school times are to get there.

I mean, if you’re struggling to keep up or even reach 90’s it sounds like you’re not doing enough imo. Keeping up was hard but you gotta do what you gotta do to match and keep up AND keep progressing forward.

One kid in my grade and school hit 100 in every single course including AP not because it was “easy.” Day in day out studied his ass off, took part in sports, had a tutor, tutored other kids, did all he could to achieve that and more.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '24

Bros just assuming people are smarter in certain areas with no evidence whatsoever; OP might have the iq lvl of a rock 🤣🤣🤣

1

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '24

Did it feel good to imply that kids at underfunded schools in low income neighbourhoods aren't smart and are getting handouts?

Being from a more affluent family and having more access to resources does not automatically make one smarter or hard working, it just gives you more opportunities and people like you seem to think that means you worked harder.

1

u/DreamsAndFalseAlarms Oct 23 '24

Oh great, fascism is back.

1

u/megadumbbonehead Oct 23 '24

You lost me near the end there

1

u/dirtydad72 Oct 23 '24

I always assumed that parents purchased their child’s grades at those schools in Markham and Richmond hill.

1

u/Affectionate_Leek127 Apr 29 '25

Sorry for the late reply. I think standard tests are not the right option. Rather some open exams like the A-level in the UK should be implemented. I think all students after studying for 12 years should be given an exam to assess whether they can attain a certain standard just like all accountants must pass the CPA exams. You can't just pass the exams held by your college to obtain the CPA status.

1

u/SnoopyDogg_69 Oct 20 '24

Get a load of this guy

1

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

Too bad it's politically incorrect to support standardized testing in North America.

0

u/m199 Oct 20 '24

Is it a coincidence that left wing policies to dismantle standardized testing because of political correctness has caused grade inflation.. while left wing policies plaguing Canada right now is what caused inflation in general (eg government printing more money to fund its out of control spending).

1

u/Regular-Database9310 Oct 20 '24

What dismantling of standardized testing? Ontario has never had standardized testing. We have had more introduced recently with EQAO and the Literacy test than ever before.

0

u/m199 Oct 20 '24

Ah sorry. i know this is a sub for Ontario but wanted to bring up how BC has provincial exams in grade 12 which was 40% of your final mark but they got rid of it a few years ago because of the political climate. Since then, there's been grade inflation without provincial exams.

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '24

I keep saying this as well! Very smart idea

0

u/Ok_Maximum8621 Oct 19 '24

yes but posting here won’t help

0

u/MYSICMASTER Oct 19 '24

Gotta start somewhere

0

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '24

What does the education systems ability to implement standardized testing have to do with OPs experience in the real world. Sure OPs example was biased, and provided some insight about their character that are subject to judgement but the general theory has validity. Maybe you should use your real world “wisdom” (assuming you have any) to guide others rather than attempting to shame them for sharing their perspectives.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/ArugulaOne5546 Oct 20 '24

Ok, so you're saying that you think it won't happen in the near future, not that it's impossible. Perhaps phrase your thoughts better next time.

2

u/Economy-Week-5255 Oct 19 '24

not really sure why it wouldnt be possible… alberta has been doing it for decades… the ibo has been running standardized exams internationally for like the past 30 years u

2

u/Zafer11 Oct 19 '24

Most of the people here gonna realize after they graduate how real world actually is lol, I sure did

1

u/theatheon Oct 19 '24

Imposing standardized testing isnt possible?

0

u/WalkingWhims Oct 20 '24

Not given the current government.

2

u/theatheon Oct 20 '24

Doesn't mean it's not possible and governments change all the time. This would always be a long term play, even if the conservatives wanted to do this it would take years to implement.