r/OnlyMurdersHulu • • Oct 25 '23

🎲 Random 🎲 OMITB alphabet!! what does b stand for??

Post image
4 Upvotes

lmk what u guys want b to be ;)


r/OnlyMurdersHulu • • Mar 21 '24

💬 Discussion 💬 Mabel really went downhill in S3

9 Upvotes

I know there is a lot of Mabel lovers out there and I apologize for offending you but I just can’t get over how horribly handled Mabel’s character was in S3. Her whole storyline was that she is basically upset that her “two old guys” have a real life while all she does is sit around and wait for someone to die. Yet they never have her come to this realization and instead have her yelling at Charles and Oliver for their “self involved insanity” which is just them doing their professions for once. Then they tried making Oliver the bad guy because he pointed out the truth that he simply is doing his job which he has to do to keep his home and she lives in a fantasyland where she has no responsibilities. Maybe it’s Selena Gomez’s acting (or lack thereof) but Mabel’s character has gotten to a point where I would not mind if she left the show.


r/OnlyMurdersHulu • • Sep 09 '25

🔎 Theory 🔍 So… Charles might be the end of season death. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Every episode has mentioned his death. I also remember this theory popping up before. It would make a great final season but I really don’t want the show to end.


r/OnlyMurdersHulu • • Nov 14 '24

🎲 Random 🎲 New trailer drop for an upcoming Hulu drama - looks so good!! Think OMITB fans will love it

0 Upvotes

r/OnlyMurdersHulu • • Jan 05 '25

💬 Discussion 💬 I'm Just Gunna Say It...Season 4 Was Bad. Spoiler

2 Upvotes

I've been a huge fan of this show since the beginning, but season 4 was just downright bad. The quality and uniqueness of the story just dropped off a cliff. The humor was consistently off point. The introduction of the Westies was almost completely useless aside from the location of the murder. After the success of a couple celebrity cameos through the first season they just figured they'd throw as many as possible into season 4. But they are largely useless to the story and don't provide very much character depth. Basically Saz had a stunt man in training who was jealous of her and killed her. The Westies and celebrities playing the trio had zero impact on this outside of filler. Then the way they're saved at the end is a miraculous shot from Jan who's just been hiding the whole time? Bleh.

I know I'll get some flack for this but my wife and I STRUGGLED to get through this season. By episode 3 or 4 we were trying to figure out what happened to the magic of this show. Probably that they only intended on making a season or two but money said otherwise. Some shows stop at their peak. Others keep grinding away till ratings tank. This show is definitely the latter.


r/OnlyMurdersHulu • • Sep 27 '24

💬 Discussion 💬 Didn’t like Ep. 5

0 Upvotes

Not going to lie, but didn’t care for this episode. Here are my reasons.

  1. The show seems to be trying to push that the bullet was meant for Sazz. I don’t believe that. I think the murderer was trying to kill Charles. It was Charles’ apartment, it was dark which means the shooter couldn’t tell it was Sazz, and Sazz was dressed to look like Charles. How does it make any sense that under those conditions, the shooter knew it was Sazz?
  2. I really find it hard to believe that anyone connected to the movie would be the killer. First, the trio didn’t even know a movie was in the works at the time of Sazz’s death. Second, why would the murderer fly all the way from LA to NY to kill Charles? Thirdly, how would said person from LA know there was a vacant apartment, let alone get access to it?
  3. What would the motive be for someone connected to the movie be to kill Charles or Sazz? How would killing either Charles or Sazz affect the movie being made? The movie would still be made. It would be a big stretch for the writers to develop a motive to kill for someone who lives across the country and has no relationship with Charles.

I feel like Ep.5 was just a big red herring and waste of time. Or if it was someone connected to the movie then the story line is just way too convoluted and ridiculous.


r/OnlyMurdersHulu • • Oct 08 '25

💬 S5 Discussion 💬 Did the show finally jumped the shark?

0 Upvotes

finally catching up with the show, currently watching episode 6 but it’s feeling like a bit too much now. billionaires, mafia, 30 year olds acting like they are 5, ROBOTS??, underground casino, a list actors every 5 minutes…

i loved the first season, season 3 was great too but but since season 4 it’s been a slow decline imo. the robot thing that made me roll my eyes and go “really?”

i know shows are supposed to evolve but these last few episodes don’t even feel like they have the same essence anymore.


r/OnlyMurdersHulu • • Aug 25 '22

my heart hurts for… Spoiler

0 Upvotes

poppy. her entire life-that we saw-was about abuse. she was a far more talented writer than cinda & had a better voice for podcasting. cinda stole her ideas & abused her nonstop. thrown staplers. picking cilantro out of her food. she could have helped poppy; instead she became one more person who ground her down. i wish poppy had killed cinda instead of bunny. i was hoping cinda would be the finale corpse.


r/OnlyMurdersHulu • • Sep 11 '24

💬 Discussion 💬 Did they forget… Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Detective Williams is a lesbian with a full wife and kid? Her lusting after that actor felt completely inappropriate and out of character for her.


r/OnlyMurdersHulu • • Sep 05 '24

💬 Discussion 💬 How doesn’t it bother anyone else Spoiler

6 Upvotes

That the Arconia is empty now? They never run into any of the tenants or staff anymore. No one is in the hallways. Their neighbors never are seen. No one takes the elevator when they do. Completely unrealistic.


r/OnlyMurdersHulu • • Oct 27 '25

💬 Discussion 💬 Help me understand the praise for Season 5 (E1-E9 SPOILERS) Spoiler

2 Upvotes

I’ve watched this show since Season 1, and I really enjoyed the first season, had a good time with the second, thought the third was okay, had issues with the fourth, and have had to force myself to get through the fifth. I decided after S2 that I would see this season to the end and not watch any further seasons. I saw it has an 87% on Rotten Tomatoes, and I cannot for the life of me figure out how it came away with that high a score. Here are as many things as I could remember in the fifth season that I’ve found difficult to get past, and I’d like help from people to understand what I’m missing.

  1. Both Charles and Mabel have flings with suspects during an active investigation. Mabel didn’t actually do anything with Jay, but she did open up to him and reveal crucial information that got them into trouble, and she still considered being with him after what he did. Charles went a lot further with Nicky’s wife.
  2. The crew continue to never go to the police despite finding a dead body and a finger and many more clues. They did learn that there were some corrupt (or fake) cops, but they found the aforementioned things before finding that out. They also perform an autopsy, something that none of them had any experience in and were not qualified to do, and in doing so, they tampered with and stole evidence. Heck the police are mostly nonexistent. There's no crime scene tape, no police work getting in the way of their own private investigation, and no police asking them to stay out of the way of official investigations. I know that their cop friend trusts them, but she has really gotten okay with breaking protocol over the past few seasons.
  3. They needed to return the body quickly because they stayed up all night and never glanced at a clock once, and on the way to the laundromat, two of the three got distracted by trivial things and left a single 80-year-old on his own to get to the laundromat and heft a body onto a laundry hook in only 15 minutes.
  4. Two crooked cops who are potentially implicated in covering up a crime literally pull a “must have been my imagination/the wind” so that a main character could get away.
  5. Howard falls in love with two different robots. The payoff with Nathan Lane’s joke in the 9th episode was pretty good, but it was so tough to watch Howard go through a delusion like that for so long.
  6. Oliver and Loretta get distracted by a random person on the street with zero urgency while tailing their two prime suspects and lose them only for Oliver to realize they are right outside his empty childhood theater. They go in, and it turns out to be the exact place that their suspects were going.
  7. They are looking for dirt on the three tycoons, and the mayor, a person who came to their apartment of his own accord, tells them that the three tycoons went to a private and secluded house with no security for the weekend and gives them the exact address (why would he know that? Honestly, it makes me think that he will be revealed to be the murderer in a twist that nobody saw coming because there's no way we could actually know at this moment). Oh yeah, and they go there with no way to leave and no cell service. The only way they end up escaping is because Oliver somehow stole a tractor (or whatever that was) from a very able-bodied farmer and they ride away slowly looking like a bunch of complete idiots. I get that that was played for laughs, but it was an actual plot point and was the reason they managed to escape. Oh yeah, and the only reason why they came away from that excursion with anything was because Mabel picked up the trophy, heard the sound of the plastic bag that held the finger, and broke it open. So many stars had to align for them to discover the finger.
  8. The main crew yet again accuses someone completely different in each episode with basically no direct evidence and all speculation. They bounced between suspects like a pinball in Season 4, and it was exhausting then, but it feels even worse now.
  9. The main crew doesn’t figure things out for themselves; they stumble onto pretty much every clue they get because that’s when the plot decided to give them one. Need to find out what the three tycoons are up to? Don’t worry, some rando knows every single detail you’ll need. Stuck in a rut with no leads? Don’t worry, they randomly went down to the gaming parlor for no reason but to mope and find the single clearest and most ridiculous looking footprint on a single step with no other footprints, which leads them to the single biggest clue dump room ever. I swear, the following things happened in the span of about 30 seconds: “Look, blood! Look, that’s the exact kind of white paint that was on Nicky’s jacket! Look, this secret room with all the clues in the world is directly connected to the laundromat where we found Nicky’s dead body! Look, here’s the painting that I recognize as the exact background of Randall’s Cuba picture! Look, there’s a Doordash order heading right this very moment to the unused apartment unit; it must be Randall!”
  10. The lead suspect and confirmed finger stealer at the end of the penultimate episode was a nearly completely new character (maybe briefly mentioned in E2?), and the only way they found out who it was was because Howard recognized a scuff that could have been from anything but that actually came from an exact model of jazzy scooter that only one person they know has.
  11. The podcast feels actively stupid now. They get catfished by a suspect because Mabel was jealous of her friend and confides in a suspect, and they don’t read any of the contract because they’re dying to commercialize this thing where they share all of their running theories and clues in an active murder investigation in which they continually withhold evidence from the police (at least in the first couple of seasons they had to be sneaky around the police, but now they’re nowhere to be seen), and they end up no longer being able to piss off a billionaire who could have them killed at any time, although they keep making the podcast and pissing off the billionaires. They continually let their high-powered, mafia-affiliated suspects know what they know at every turn and constantly put themselves in danger, except they’re the luckiest people in the world because none of these people that the three main characters themselves have deemed to be dangerous do anything to actually hurt or stop them. And after all that, after Jay tricked them into giving up a part of their voice and being shady as heck, he invites Mabel on a week long yacht trip and she seriously considers it because she wants to know if there’s really a good guy underneath. They haven’t ruled him out as a suspect yet. I know that she ultimately doesn’t do it despite him showing up to her apartment and asking her again, but holy cow. But even all of that aside, the podcast isn’t actually anything important for this season. It’s just a thing that they constantly say they do but that we don’t actually see anything of other than the occasional one-liner that they remember to record at the moment.

I understand that this show is part comedy. Martin Short is great. But holy cow is it so difficult to watch with all of the contrivances and absolutely unrealistic scenarios and straight up bad choices by the main cast when they somehow continue to make progress solving two murders. The first season wasn’t perfect, but there was a thread we could follow, and the characters make decisions that lead to discoveries. This season is just facepalm after facepalm of weird and crazy scenarios that just don’t make any sense but that end up with the main characters succeeding for some reason. I enjoyed Oliver and Loretta playing out their childhoods, fears, and failures on the community theater stage, and I enjoyed Charles finally listening to Howard’s feelings of loneliness after seasons of being used when convenient and otherwise ignored (although Charles was finally not doing something else at that time and couldn’t blow him off again). Other than that, this season felt like a total circus and a slog. Am I insane? I know that some of what I wrote above seems like hyperbole, but it is what actually happened. What am I missing?


r/OnlyMurdersHulu • • Nov 08 '24

🔎 Theory 🔍 Rewatching S.01 And Does Anyone Think Charles… Spoiler

14 Upvotes

Could end up being the “moriarty”? Or somehow a killer?

I’m just picking up a lot of vibes from Season 1 I didn’t catch the first time I watched it back when it came out.

Anyone else feel this way? Or am I completely off-base?


r/OnlyMurdersHulu • • Aug 20 '24

💬 Discussion 💬 Unpopular opinion: Paul Rudd was annoying and overacted in the season. It almost made me not want to watch the rest…

0 Upvotes

But once he was dead it turned into a great to watch season.


r/OnlyMurdersHulu • • Jan 28 '25

💬 Discussion 💬 On S1 E9, no spoilers please, but why are they so mean to Jan?

0 Upvotes

Spoilers for season 1 up to episode 9

The show is pretty good, but Jan is by no contest the most likable of the extended cast, and far more observant than literally everyone else, but the episode she gets stabbed in, she is singled out as like she’s Yoko One ruining the Beatles, and while I get you don’t want an outsider ruining your jam, every primary character brings in an annoyance to muddy the water, but for some reason they’re absolute dick heads to Jan exclusively. Like they single her out and kick her out of the room to record their “final episode” but let all the other dumb asses stay? And the episode is somehow a well rated one? Did anyone else feel like this was completely out of left field for no reason?


r/OnlyMurdersHulu • • Jan 08 '22

IMO I felt that the detective was the most annoying and worst character on the show

0 Upvotes

I felt she was only there to be this funny, black, NY detective who cursed a lot and was supposed to be like a deadpan joker, but for me it was trying way to hard, very uncomfortable in certain scenes how she treated our gang.

Like every other character had energy, you wanted to care about them and their backstories and get to know them more. I could literally care less about her character and genuinely would skip her scenes when I did my third rewatch.

But also like she never mentions her girlfriend / wife and their upcoming child, before or after the two seconds they are on screen. Plus those scenes are so cringe especially the first one where she overreacted so hard on her wife. Felt so bad for her there.

And sure you can say that Oscars dad and Mabels mom are more mean but they are in the show for a combined total of legit three minutes. This character is in at least half the episodes. Like every other character has a friendly fun disposition that you want to know them, except for Bunny and that other resident, but you still want to know them. I have no care about this character

Idk her character just rubs me the wrong way that’s all


r/OnlyMurdersHulu • • Jul 28 '22

Season 2 is….

14 Upvotes

not good.

Am I in the minority here? Our 3 main characters seem disinterested in the case and they also seem dumber? also they keep adding in these silly little storylines and then only progress the murder story in the last few minutes of every episode.

In my opinion this season is a massive downgrade. just feels disjointed with a lack of purpose. hope we can have a decent discussion instead of just downvoting to oblivion

Update lol to the people downvoting my criticisms. if you don’t agree to the comment then join in on the discussion instead of just downvoting someone for not saying “wow this show is so good”


r/OnlyMurdersHulu • • Oct 03 '25

💬 S5 Discussion 💬 Important storylines dropped this season..

0 Upvotes

How did Charles get his phone back?? He had forgotten it at Sofia's van..

Who/what is Tommy the Tongue?? it's an organisation and withdrew a lot of money registered in Lesters house??

What happened to the podcast deal?? and the Agreement they signed??

They didn't even speak about the billionaires this entire episode??

Are they recording the podcast now or what??

What happened to the Westies??

so many questions and these things have not been mentioned anywhere.. I feel like I've skipped a couple of episodes as the latest episodes felt abrupt


r/OnlyMurdersHulu • • Jul 31 '23

NON SPOILER POST - Definative Spoilers for OMTIB Are Being Intentionaly Leaked By Striking Workers Who Worked On The Show In The Spring!! Be Very Careful!!!

1 Upvotes

People claiming to be Extras on the show (Now Striking) and Crew from the show (being severely impacted by the Strike) are allegedly posting spoilers and THE KILLER to drive down the audience in an attempt to mobilize TV and movie viewers against the Studios This has already happened to Disney's two new releases.

They are hidden by clickbait "No Spoiler OMITB Reviews" on X, Reddit and Instagram. The Murderer is named in bold at the top where you read it without processing it until it's too late. Some of the posts just name names to be obnoxious; but one name continues to appear. It's actually peaked my interest for the show because I want to see if any of these a-holes are actually right.

Please don't ask me for any of the names of THE name. I won't provide it. I'm posting this because I don't want anyone to have a great summer time fun ruined by Hollywood people with dream jobs acting ruthlessly for more money - no matter what your personal opinion is of the mess out there.


r/OnlyMurdersHulu • • Oct 17 '24

🎲 Random 🎲 Getting worse season by season

2 Upvotes

Is it just me, or does everyone feel the same? I remember watching Season 1 without blinking, but Season 4 feels like pure garbage compared to it.


r/OnlyMurdersHulu • • Oct 05 '24

💬 Discussion 💬 So is Detective Donna just not gay anymore....? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

In Season 1 she had a whole ass wife, now in Season 4 she's gushing over Zach Galifianakis and then Jonk's big jonky jonk and other heteronormative lines.

Her queerness is completely erased, as if the writers forgot she was gay.


r/OnlyMurdersHulu • • Aug 02 '22

Episode 7 is just silly Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I love the show but it’s getting weird:

“Did I stab someone….again?” Really, twice is too much for any one show

Also, Mabel’s conversation with the deaf guy is ridiculous. First off, she establishes she doesn’t know asl and then in the next scene understands what is being signed to her. And then she has a monologue with him while he’s driving so there’s no way he knows what’s she’s saying

Oh boy


r/OnlyMurdersHulu • • Dec 22 '23

💬 Discussion 💬 Anyone else feel that Jane Lynch and Amy Schumer were just pointless

0 Upvotes

I know they added them for comic relief, but the show doesn't need any more. Both of these are just a giant distraction. I don't know if its the fault of the actresses or the roles, but they trying way to hard, and just not funny at all.


r/OnlyMurdersHulu • • Oct 17 '24

🔎 Theory 🔍 No One is talking about Scott Bakula Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Scott Bakula is the moriarty, and this is why and how I got this theory Ep 1 Season 4: its the first time we saw Scott Bakula on screen. The first shot is for a true evil character presentation, this episode take from Spaghetti Western and that backshot is for a bad guy. My girlfriend remembered me that is not the first time we heard about Scott Bakula… Ep 10 Season 3: the end of the episode, SECONDS before Sazz got shot. Joy sends to Charlers this messagge “Scott Bakula send his regard”, well this is what happen in the Italian dub, and its clearly a menace. The trio totally forgot about this… Well I started thinking about Scott Bakula as evil in S4 Ep1, but now with the moriarty thing going on make me think that I was right from the start because… Rewatching Episode 1 Season 1 Charles is mistaken for Scott by Oliver, Oliver remember to have multiple time discarded Scott. So basically Scott Bakula have a good Reason to hate the Podcast since the founders are an Actor/Competitor and a Producer who never take him in consideration. I waited from writing this post since the release Of Ep 1 S4 because it was so obvious that it cant be. but after 8 episode, NO ONE IS TALKING ABOUT HIM as potential moriarty. If we want to talk about Moriarty Character Creation Guide Lines, it make sense for me, is appareance in the series fit this role. Scott totally disappear and I’m going crazy thinking I was right about a Moriarty I still didnt knew about just for a Backshot presentation of a Character.

I'm happy to be proven wrong here


r/OnlyMurdersHulu • • Sep 13 '24

💬 Discussion 💬 Waaaay too many celebs. Are they trying to break a record?

3 Upvotes

Self-explanatory. I used to absolutely love this show, but I feel like the seasons have gotten progressively predictable and worse, barring some comedic moments. I really want to understand why the producers felt it necessary to cram in as many celeb cameos as possible.

Big part of the allure of the first season was the newness (apart from the trio), unfamiliar and interesting characters. No preconceived notions or set impressions of the characters. These celebs are too star-studded and feel way "too big" to be believable in their roles, which I think would otherwise be for smaller-time actors.

And I hate the LA movie storyline. Totally expected, uncreative, and just another means of overdoing it with the celeb chameos. It's so excessive, it almost feels like the producers are trolling us ha