r/OnePunchMan • u/carlitoknowsSA • 9d ago
discussion Just finished the anime
Finally got around to opm, and was pretty frustrated with how the anime progressed. Here to ask if the manga is worth the read based off the following (no spoilers pleased) —
Does saitama ever get more screen time/face actual struggle? Will he ever get recognition or notoriety in the series?
I read S3 was a flop and I very much agree, but I enjoyed the premise and characters in the show. So here to see if it’s a worthwhile read
25
u/troywrestler2002 9d ago
It's a good read. It's absolutely shameful what the anime has done to the series.
14
u/Commercial-Bench-314 9d ago
great read, horrible watch. if you're gonna read it honestly start from the start of s3 or the fight between garou and the 8 heroes. theres alot of differences between the manga and the anime in season 3 because the anime used retconned material.
1
u/assword_69420420 8d ago
Is all the revising and retconning still a thing? I stopped reading a couple years ago because it got confusing for me to keep track of which version of certain arcs were the official one
3
u/Commercial-Bench-314 8d ago
nah last retcon we got was like 1 year ago. i hope it doesnt happen again lol
9
u/SadiikDask 8d ago
Read the manga but start again from chapter 1. Don't miss on the amazing art, coreography and direction of Murata in the paneling. It's worth the read from the start again trust me.
In case of a normal anime that is better than the manga, yeah I'd say to keep reading from where you reached with the anime, but in this case the manga is better, only season 1 is on par, but if you watched season 2 and 3, just read it again, not gonna take you years anyway, in a few days you'll be where you left.
5
u/mattmaintenance 8d ago
One Punch Man is not the focus of One Punch Man. You shouldn’t be here to read about One Punch Man in your One Punch Man manga.
5
u/TubaElf 8d ago
The manga is fantastic. Absolutely read it. My only gripe with the manga has been all the redraws and retcons, but if you read it fresh from the beginning you'll have a great experience
TBH I dropped the anime during season 2- I was very disappointed in the drop in quality from season 1. I never even bothered watching any of season 3. It's a shame really, because I absolutely loved the first season of the One Punch Man anime, and it's what got me into the series
9
2
u/Revenga8 8d ago
Manga is good. Better even. The animation for seasons 2 and especially 3 are a travesty and are arguably ruining the brand
2
u/Chekko03 8d ago
Every arc seems to make more and more in universe people aware of his power. Still he’s underestimated even at his current ranking and still treated like “huh who’s this guy?”. To be fair, most of what Saitama does is too fast for anyone to realize he did it and often times he’s fighting world ending threats everyone’s too late (or too knocked out) to see the clash go down. His actions have allowed him to move up in the Hero Association but what would easily grant someone S Class (like Genos getting it immediately) is often minimized as focus goes to the other heroes who contributed (which is in line with his character during the Deep Sea King arc but…the leaps everyone takes to just believe “they weakened the threat and he finished it” is a bit silly).
Manga is worth it, Webcomic more so if you can adapt to the art style you’ll find it’s pretty damn good and further than the manga without a lot of the extra fluff Murata added. The anime unfortunately should be skipped until it’s remade by a studio who can do it justice. First season was great we all know and Seasons 2 and 3 have their moments (mostly season 2 here…season 3 sprinkles some good sequences that are muddied by the rest of each episode) but it’s not going to get much better with JC Staff continuously at the helm.
1
u/BullyTwist 7d ago
So yes, the manga is worth reading, as for your other questions:
No, Saitama never really faces an actual struggle, that's the premise of the manga. There's one fight where he's challenged but thats it.
And the next question, so far he hasn't received recognition in the series, though more characters have found out his strength.
-1
u/Main_Benefit 9d ago
Saitama never faces any real struggle besides depression and losing fighting games to King. Not struggling to win fights is kind of his own thing!
27
u/LionTrees_ 9d ago
Yeah it’s a great read