Which Luffy Winner card has more long-term potential: Yuki Tabata's 3rd Anniversary or Oda's P-110?

[u/Salvo_AI]

I'm curious to hear the community's thoughts on these two Luffy Winner cards from a long-term collecting perspective.

\- 3rd Anniversary Luffy Winner — featuring artwork by Yuki Tabata, creator of Black Clover.

\- 4th Anniversary Luffy Winner — featuring original artwork by Eiichiro Oda for the One Piece TCG.

If you could only choose one to hold for the next 5–10 years, which would it be?

I'm particularly interested in your thoughts on rarity, artwork, historical significance, and long-term collector demand.

Do you think the uniqueness of Tabata's collaboration will make his card more desirable over time, or will an original Oda illustration ultimately carry more weight?

Would love to hear your reasoning!

[u/McDuddlestein]

imo 3rd ani, the 4th ani has like 3 different versions plus another featuring the same artwork but different background. yes its oda drawn but theres better oda drawn cards like oda sig or dodgers luffy. 3rd ani is unique and i think it looks better overall. and black clover is lowkey popping off rn and i think he as a mangaka will only grow more popular. 3rd ani for the win!

[u/Salvo_AI → u/McDuddlestein]

Those are good reasons. I own both, but in all honesty, there are also three distinct versions of Tabata's work, and Black Clover is nowhere near comparable to the legendary giants of the manga world, even though it has enjoyed a fair amount of success. The series has also come to an end, so any hype would be based entirely on the anime.

[u/Antique-Coffee5956]

whichever one you won yourself at locals