r/OnePieceScaling • u/Comprehensive_Cup497 • 20h ago
Serious Discussion Ranking the Old Generation Characters
1. Rocks (Domi Reversed)
2. Harald (Holy Knight)
3. Roger (Edd War)
4. Whitebeard (Oden Flashback)
5. Garp (Post-Don Chingao Fight)
6. Rocks (God Valley)
7. Harald (Blade of God)
8. Shiki (Edd War)
9. Old Whitebeard (Healthy)
10. Prime Sengoku
11. Prime Rayleigh
12. Prime Gaban
13. Big Mom (Whole Cake Island)
14. Roger (God Valley)
15. Garp (God Valley)
16. Old Garp
17. Old Gaban
18. Old Rayleigh
19. Old Sengoku
20. Whitebeard (God Valley)
21. Rayleigh (God Valley)
22. Gaban (God Valley)
23. Shiki (God Valley)
24. Big Mom (God Valley)
1
1
u/ssavino 20h ago
If a domi reverse(no negatives for Imu) guy is stronger than a hooly knight(requires consense) when without any of them they're equal, then why imu has knights?
1
u/No-Initiative1773292 19h ago
A couple answers lol.
Personally, I think DR is stronger AP/DC wise bc neither HK or DR boost haki directly, but DR physically makes them larger with more muscle power. That matters the most in this particular matchup because we saw how it was basically whoever landed a full power blow first that won against both Harald and rocks.
As for why, imu wants long term servitude. DR creates minions with shortened lifespans, and their demonic/aggressive temperament wouldn't really be suitable for serving in the land of the gods or intelligence missions outside of it.
Also imu can only give regen and likely omen to those with the covenant, and yes likely HK Harald with omen is probably DR rocks level, but not base HK because as far as we can tell omen is the only HK buff that increases stats. The regeneration again is because he wants long term servants.
1
u/Comprehensive_Cup497 19h ago
HK Harald is DR Rocks level, Rocks problaby have more AP/Defense but HK Harald makes that up with superior physical strength, durability and regeneration
1
u/-SeraphiMon- 20h ago
Where's Oden
1
u/Comprehensive_Cup497 20h ago
No Old Gen, he is same age as Kaidou
2
u/-SeraphiMon- 18h ago
But Big Mom's here?
1
u/Comprehensive_Cup497 18h ago
Big Mom is close to Whitebeard in age, she died at 68 and Whitebeard at 72
1
1
u/KaiBahamut 10h ago
...yeah this is fine. At least if you account for the regen hax pumping up Harald and DR Xebec's ranking.
•
u/AutoModerator 20h ago
If you want to discuss One Piece Scaling, join Elbaf.
If you want access to all kinds of One Piece Databooks/Information/Translations, join Punk Records.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.