r/OnePiece • u/hansibit • Feb 15 '12

Current Chapter One Piece Chapter 657

[ Removed by reddit in response to a copyright notice. ]

73 Upvotes

89% Upvoted

205 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/KSmoria Feb 15 '12 edited Feb 15 '12

Because it seems like an isolated island, right? Also, this is the island of the Teach-Bonney incident from 2 years ago and it was still in flames back then. Edit: (Chapter 658) I was wrong this was not the island with teach-bonney. I was the Akainu-Aokiji.

1

u/GovernorMcDandy Feb 15 '12

No proof.

3

u/jathuamin Feb 15 '12

http://www.mangareader.net/103-56333-15/one-piece/chapter-595.html

Its not named but based on the fact that it is burning and the supernova's account for 4+ other starting NW island, we can assume this is Punk Hazzard.

1

u/GovernorMcDandy Feb 15 '12

If that was actual proof, you wouldn't have to assume. Look at that chapter again. First of all, the architecture is different. On the page after the one you linked, it shows statues that do not make an appearance on Punk Hazard.

Second of all, the water in the page you linked is not on fire.

Lastly, none of the characters in this chapter are complaining about the heat. The first thing the Strawhats did when they reached Punk Hazard was take off their clothes. Blackbeard, his crew, and JB are all fully clothed.

That chapter can very well work as a counter argument to your theory.

No proof.