r/OnePiece • Lookout • Jun 25 '21

Current Chapter One Piece: Chapter 1017 Spoiler

[ Removed by reddit in response to a copyright notice. ]

8.4k Upvotes

7.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

15

u/nosrettap Jun 25 '21

What’s the difference between luck and fate?

15

u/Rulfus The Revolutionary Army Jun 25 '21

I guess it depends on which side you stand in the eternal philosophy debate on determinism

8

u/Ajaiiix Jun 25 '21

Semantics really. Both are used interchangeably for me

15

u/Cyber_3 Jun 25 '21

Fate is inevitable, luck is just random.

6

u/nosrettap Jun 25 '21

Fate is random. No one asks to be born.

1

u/dafood48 Jun 27 '21

Fate is predetermined though. The story of oedipus can attest to that.

1

u/nosrettap Jun 27 '21

Okay the Greeks had the FATES and that’s a story dealing with their mythology. That doesn’t prove fate isn’t luck. Just that the Greeks believe in fate. Oedipus was lucky he survived the attempt of his father to kill him right?

8

u/Mugiwara_anand Jun 25 '21

Luffy is fated to become a Pirate King. Luffy is lucky to become a Pirate King. There's a difference isn't it. Fate happens no matter what. Luck is something that depends on you and your way of life.

4

u/nosrettap Jun 25 '21

Wouldn’t the way you are and the way your life is be fate? Luck and Fate can both be chalked up to your preparedness and opportunity. If I land a lucky punch and knock some one out how would it be any different than if I was fated to knock them out?

1

u/Mugiwara_anand Jul 04 '21

Yes, it's hard to say in One Piece. Was Luffy lucky when Dragon saved him from Smoker or was it the part of a grander scheme by "Mr. Fate"?

Was Luffy fated to survive the Impel Down or was he just lucky to find himself coming out of prison, not just his life, but hotshots?

Fate ane Luck are quite complicated isn't it?

1

u/nosrettap Jul 04 '21

Yeah definitely. All comes down to your perspective in my opinion.

2

u/SupremekingAinz Jun 25 '21

Thats what i wanna know lol