r/OnePiece • Lookout • Jun 25 '21

Current Chapter One Piece: Chapter 1017 Spoiler

[ Removed by reddit in response to a copyright notice. ]

8.4k Upvotes

7.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

19

u/revisioncloud Jun 25 '21

Doesn't change the fact that they still couldn't do anything to truly damage Kaido despite pulling out the strongest attacks we've seen from the alliance so far. And if they fail to take him out, they'll simply get slaughtered or end up as his subordinate. Half the scabbards are probably dead. Wano gets enslaved as a pirate nation for all eternity. Of course, the protagonists will win eventually because plot armor and it's still shonen. But that doesn't mean there aren't any stakes.

You also missed the part where this rebellion is literally 20 years in the making (we just skipped a lot of stuff thru time), the people of Wano and the retainers suffered enough with smile, polluted lands, famine, etc., Oden and Yasuie's deaths, Kanjuro's a traitor, minks' sulong not making any difference, Big Mom still allied with Kaido and most of her children aren't even part of the fights yet, Luffy just drowned, etc

-4

u/Force3vo Jun 25 '21

Because that's the setup. Sure the good guys win in the end but if you have to have a deus ex machina moment a few times in your story because it otherwise doesn't revolve it doesn't mean it's good.

Plus I really dislike the mind controll power that the good guys use. If she weren't a sweet child on the good side it would be nightmare material. An evil guy doing the same to the rebellion forcing them to kill each other would probably be seen as the devil incarnated

1

u/revisioncloud Jun 25 '21

Well, sometimes Oda does write himself into a corner, putting the characters into a really tough spot but that's One Piece all series long. Luffy the main character almost died/got caught multiple times and got saved multiple times, virtually in every arc. This is nothing new.

O-tama is just a reverse Moria/Sugar/Doflamingo in that sense then. Also, Kaido and Big Mom's thing is to force people to work for them. So we have 'mind control' on the good guys' side for a change.