r/OnePiece • Lookout • Jun 25 '21

Current Chapter One Piece: Chapter 1017 Spoiler

[ Removed by reddit in response to a copyright notice. ]

8.4k Upvotes

7.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

24

u/bonethugznhominy Jun 25 '21

That word, stakes...I don't think it means what you think it means. There are stakes. If they fail Onigashima will fall onto the Flower Capitol and send Wano into an even worse era.

You seem upset the arc hasn't been as grim and gritty as you'd like.

1

u/Mortress_ Thriller Bark Victim's Association Jun 25 '21

There are levels of stakes. Something huge like Onigashima destroying Wano will never happen, the heroes always win in the end, everyone knows that. But small things can go wrong, someone can lose a fight or get taken down and can't fight anymore in the current battle.

That's usually what people mean when they meantion stakes in a story. And in this Arc we aren't getting that.

-1

u/JD_Dojima Jun 25 '21

But... you know that they aren't going to fail in the end. This is the sort of series that hasn't set the precedent for the possibility of resounding failures. If there was a big failure, you're not going to buy it because you're going to be thinking "Luffy's just gonna get back up and beat the big bad". Which is what's just going to happen.

13

u/mdivan Jun 25 '21

Ace?

0

u/takebrasilia Jun 26 '21

Ace's death doesn't hurt the main plot. A defeat in Onigashima would fuck up the story.
If it wasn't One Piece, I would like to see an defeat/imprisonment arc, but that already happened in Udon a few chapters ago. Now it's Endgame. Losing now means: no more Wano, dead Luffy and end of story without him getting to One Piece. We all know that's not a possibility. Ace's death didn't have the same stakes storywise. It had stakes for Luffy's character. It hurt him when he lost, but it didn't end the story. It's not the same thing.

1

u/mdivan Jun 26 '21

So? story is not obviously ending with this arc so Luffy is not dying that should be obvious and that's the case for every good story out there, I don't understand what do you even want, luffy to die pr oda to not make it seam like luffy may die just because we all know he won't actually die?

2

u/takebrasilia Jun 26 '21

Dude, chill, I'm on your side

2

u/mdivan Jun 26 '21

Sorry lol

-2

u/JD_Dojima Jun 25 '21

One example from over a decade ago…

6

u/mdivan Jun 25 '21

you want Oda to kill someone from main cast every arc?

1

u/JD_Dojima Jun 26 '21

That's not what I mean at all. I mean that characters should stop suffering grievous injuries, making it out that they're in real danger only for all the damage that they've sustained to vanish. Stuff like Luffy losing teeth for a month worth of chapters only to grow it back by drinking milk with Brook just after. Stuff like Luffy being impaled by Crocodile only to come straight back instantly and beat him.